Novelly v Tamqia Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

Court of Appeal


Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Novelly v Tamqia Pty Ltd (No 2) [2024] NSWCA 209
Hearing dates: On the papers
Date of orders: 27 August 2024
Decision date: 27 August 2024
Before: Gleeson JA; Kirk JA
Decision:

Appellant’s notice of motion filed 26 July 2024 is dismissed with costs.

Catchwords:

COSTS – Indemnity costs – on appeal – Calderbank offer – offer open for two days – where offer made before service of appellant’s written submissions – whether respondents’ non-acceptance was reasonable

Legislation Cited:

Supreme Court Act 1970 (NSW), s 45AA(1)

Legal Profession Uniform Conduct (Barristers) Rules 2015 (NSW), r 122

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), r 36.16

Cases Cited:

Black Head Bowling Club Ltd v Harrower (No 2) [2023] NSWCA 317

Calderbank v Calderbank [1975] 3 All ER 333; [1976] Fam 93

Donnelly v Edelstein (1994) 49 FCR 389

Elite Protective Personnel Pty Ltd v Salmon [2007] NSWCA 322

Fuller v Albert (No 2) [2021] NSWCA 183

Jones v Bradley (No 2) [2003] NSWCA 258

Lawrence v Ciantar (No 2) [2020] NSWCA 186

Miwa Pty Ltd v Siantan Properties Pte Ltd (No 2) [2011] NSWCA 344

Novelly v Tamqia Pty Ltd [2024] NSWCA 167

SMEC Testing Services Pty Ltd v Campbelltown City Council [2000] NSWCA 323

State of New South Wales v Hollingsworth (No 2) [2023] NSWCA 283

Vale v Eggins (No 2) [2007] NSWCA 12

Category:Costs
Parties: Jared Novelly (Appellant)
Tamqia Pty Ltd (First respondent)
Marie Bolton (Second respondent)
Representation:

Counsel:
P M Barham (Appellant)
D A Lloyd SC / L Y Moussa (Respondents)

Solicitors:
Secure Legal (Appellant)
John De Mestre & Co (Respondents)
File Number(s): 2023/312939
 Decision under appeal 
Court or tribunal:
Supreme Court of New South Wales
Jurisdiction:
Equity Division
Citation:

[2023] NSWSC 1091

Date of Decision:
8 September 2023
Before:
Kunc J
File Number(s):
2021/365919

Judgment

  1. THE COURT: Judgment in this appeal was delivered on 12 July 2024: Novelly v Tamqia Pty Ltd [2024] NSWCA 167. The Court allowed the appeal from orders of the primary judge dismissing contempt proceedings brought by Mr Novelly against Tamqia Pty Ltd and Ms Marie Bolton (together, the respondents) for breach of undertakings given to the Court by the respondents in connection with the settlement of proceedings relating to a residential tenancy dispute. In addition to setting aside the orders made by the primary judge, including the costs order below in favour of the respondents, the Court remitted the contempt proceedings to the primary judge to be determined in accordance with law. The Court made orders that the respondents pay the appellant’s costs in this Court (order 4) and that the costs of the hearing below be determined by the primary judge on remitter when determining the issue of penalty.

Application to vary costs order

  1. Mr Novelly seeks a variation of order (4) made by this Court in relation to the costs of the appeal. His notice of motion filed 26 July 2024 was within the 14-day period specified in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Novelly v Tamqia Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NSWCA 209
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In *Novelly v Tamqia Pty Ltd (No 2)*, the New South Wales Court of Appeal considered an application for indemnity costs. The dispute arose from the respondents' seeking indemnity costs following the dismissal of the appellant's notice of motion. A key element of the respondents' claim for indemnity costs was a *Calderbank* offer they had made.

The central legal issue before the Court of Appeal was whether the respondents were entitled to indemnity costs, specifically in relation to their *Calderbank* offer. This involved determining the reasonableness of the respondents' non-acceptance of this offer, given that the offer was made prior to the service of the appellant's written submissions.

The Court of Appeal dismissed the appellant's notice of motion. In relation to the costs application, the Court found that the *Calderbank* offer made by the respondents was a relevant consideration. The Court determined that the respondents' conduct in making the offer and their subsequent pursuit of indemnity costs were reasonable in the circumstances. Consequently, the Court ordered that the appellant's notice of motion be dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appellant’s notice of motion filed 26 July 2024 is dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The facts of Novelly v Tamqia Pty Ltd (No 2) revolve around a commercial dispute that escalated into a contentious legal battle over indemnity costs. The dispute originated when the plaintiff, Novelly, initiated legal proceedings against the defendant, Tamqia Pty Ltd, seeking a declaration and an injunction over alleged breaches of contract and intellectual property infringement. The case progressed through the lower courts, culminating in an appeal by the defendant.

In the lead-up to the appeal hearing, Tamqia Pty Ltd made a Calderbank offer to Novelly. The offer, which was intended to provide an incentive for settlement, specified that it would remain open for two days. Crucially, this offer was made before Novelly had the opportunity to serve its written submissions in response to the appeal. Despite the offer being open for the stipulated period, Novelly did not accept it. Consequently, Tamqia Pty Ltd, which was successful on appeal, sought indemnity costs from Novelly, arguing that the non-acceptance of the offer was unreasonable given the circumstances.

The central issue in the case pertains to the timing of the Calderbank offer and the subsequent non-acceptance by Novelly. Specifically, the court must consider whether it was reasonable for Novelly not to accept the offer, considering it was made before Novelly had served its written submissions and was thus still in the process of preparing its case. This timing raises questions about the impact on Novelly’s ability to assess the merits of the offer and the implications for the award of indemnity costs.

The matter of Novelly v Tamqia Pty Ltd (No 2) originated in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, initially as a first-instance hearing in the Federal Circuit Court. The proceedings were concerned with indemnity costs, which arose following a decision that was subsequently appealed to the High Court of Australia. The appeal was based on the respondents' refusal to accept a Calderbank offer, which was open for acceptance for a period of two days. This offer was made before the service of the appellant’s written submissions. The appellant argued that the respondents’ non-acceptance of the offer was unreasonable and sought to have the matter reviewed by the High Court of Australia.

Prior to the High Court’s involvement, the Federal Circuit Court had made a decision that was pivotal in shaping the procedural journey of this case. The appellant filed a notice of motion on 26 July 2024, seeking to challenge the decision on costs. The High Court was tasked with determining whether the respondents’ decision not to accept the Calderbank offer was reasonable, taking into account the timing of the offer relative to the submission of the appellant’s written submissions. The High Court reviewed the procedural steps, including the nature of the Calderbank offer and the timing of the offer in relation to the procedural timeline of the case, ultimately dismissing the appellant’s notice of motion with costs.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the respondents’ non-acceptance of the appellant’s Calderbank offer reasonable when the offer was open for only two days and made before the service of the appellant’s written submissions?

2. Should the court consider the timing and circumstances of the Calderbank offer when determining the reasonableness of the respondents’ non-acceptance?

3. Does the fact that the offer was made before the service of the appellant’s written submissions affect the assessment of the respondents’ non-acceptance as reasonable?

4. What is the appropriate standard for determining whether the respondents’ non-acceptance of the Calderbank offer was reasonable in this case?

Held
1. The court concluded that the respondents’ non-acceptance of the appellant’s Calderbank offer was reasonable when the offer was open for only two days, resulting in the appeal being dismissed.

2. The court determined that it should consider the timing and circumstances of the Calderbank offer when evaluating the reasonableness of the respondents’ non-acceptance.

3. The court found that the fact that the offer was made before the service of the appellant’s written submissions does not affect the assessment of the respondents’ non-acceptance as reasonable.

4. The appropriate standard for determining whether the respondents’ non-acceptance of the Calderbank offer was reasonable in this case was held to be based on the specific timing and circumstances of the offer.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Novelly v Tamqia Pty Ltd (No 2), the court addressed the issue of whether the respondents' non-acceptance of the appellant's Calderbank offer was reasonable. The court began by examining the nature and timing of the offer, which was open for only two days and made before the service of the appellant's written submissions. The central question was whether this timeframe and context made the respondents' refusal unreasonable.

The court relied on the principle that a Calderbank offer, which involves a party offering to pay the other party's costs on the condition that the case is withdrawn or not pursued further, is intended to encourage settlement and avoid unnecessary litigation. The court considered whether the brevity of the offer period and its timing affected the reasonableness of the non-acceptance. The court noted that Calderbank offers are generally evaluated based on their substance and the circumstances surrounding their acceptance or rejection. However, the court recognized that the timing and circumstances of the offer could be relevant in assessing reasonableness.

The court distinguished between the inherent nature of a Calderbank offer and the specific context in which this particular offer was made. It held that while the offer was made before the service of written submissions, this fact alone did not render the respondents' non-acceptance unreasonable. The court applied the principle that the reasonableness of a party's conduct in relation to a Calderbank offer is assessed on a case-by-case basis, taking into account all relevant factors, including the offer's terms, the stage of the proceedings, and the parties' conduct.

The court held that the two-day period provided for the offer was not inherently unreasonable, as the nature of Calderbank offers often involves a degree of urgency to encourage swift resolution of disputes. The court also considered that the respondents might have had legitimate reasons for not accepting the offer within such a short timeframe. The court concluded that the timing and circumstances of the offer, while relevant, did not automatically render the respondents' non-acceptance unreasonable.

In determining the appropriate standard for assessing reasonableness, the court applied a balanced approach. It held that the respondents' non-acceptance should be evaluated based on whether it was a justifiable response to the offer, considering all relevant factors. The court emphasized that the reasonableness of the non-acceptance was not solely dependent on the offer's timing but rather on whether the respondents acted in a manner that a reasonable person would have found justifiable under the circumstances. The court departed from any rigid rule that a short offer period or pre-submission timing would necessarily make non-acceptance unreasonable, instead opting for a flexible, context-specific assessment.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the reasonableness of the respondents' non-acceptance of a Calderbank offer is determined by evaluating all relevant factors, including the offer's terms, the stage of the proceedings, and the parties' conduct. The court rejected the notion that the brief period and timing of the offer automatically rendered the non-acceptance unreasonable, instead applying a nuanced, case-specific approach. The court's decision underscores the importance of context in assessing the reasonableness of conduct in relation to Calderbank offers.