Nhon Hoa Nguyen v Aardwolf Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

ReOppositions by Nhon Hoa Nguyen to registration of trade mark applications 1689002 (7) AARDWOLF and 1689004 (7) AARDWOLF (device) - in the name of Aardwolf Australia Pty Ltd

Delegate:  Robert Wilson

Representation:                  Opponent: Melissa Marcus of Counsel, instructed by Linda Xie of Watermark Intellectual Property Pty Ltd

Applicant: Andrew Sykes of Counsel, instructed by Actuate IP

Decision:  2017 ATMO 63

Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) - Section 52 opposition: ss 58, 62 and 62A considered – abandonment of trade marks by earlier related entity – no grounds established – trade marks may proceed to registration

Background

1.  This decision concerns oppositions brought by Nhon Hoa Nguyen (‘the Opponent’) pursuant to s 52 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (‘the Act’) to registration of the trade marks the subjects of the divisional applications detailed below in the name of Aardwolf Australia Pty Ltd (‘the Applicant’):

Application Numbers:

1689002 and 1689004

Filing Dates:

23 April 2015

Priority Dates:

4 March 2013 (based on parent applications)

Goods:

Class 7: Equipment for use in the stone and construction industry; including material handling equipment, lifters, spreader-bars for slings, forklift booms, transport frames; site saws, brick saws, cement mixers; none of the aforementioned goods being linishers

(‘the Applicant’s Goods’)

Trade Marks:

 AARDWOLF

(‘the 9002 Trade Mark’)

(‘the 9004 Trade Mark’)

  1. The 9002 Trade Mark and the 9004 Trade Mark will be referred to collectively as ‘the Opposed Trade Marks’. The applications are divisional applications. The parent of the 9002 Trade Mark being application number 1544189 (‘the 9002 Parent’), and of the 9004 Trade Mark 1544186 (‘the 9004 Parent’). These trade marks will be discussed in more detail below.

  2. On 7 May 2015 the applications’ acceptances for possible registration were advertised in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks. The Opponent filed Notices of Intention to Oppose the registrations on 6 July 2015 and Statements of Grounds and Particulars (‘the SGPs’) on 6 August 2015. The Applicant filed Notices of Intention to Defend on 4 September 2015. The SGPs nominated grounds of opposition corresponding to ss 42(b), 58, 60, 62 and 62A of the Act. I note that the opposition was originally filed in the name of Abaco Machines (Australasia) Pty Ltd (‘Abaco Machines’); however, as a result of a request filed on 7 April 2017, Mr Nhon Hoa Nguyen replaced Abaco as the opponent.

Evidence

4.  The parties filed the same evidence in respect of both oppositions. The Opponent filed Evidence in Support of its oppositions on 9 December 2015 being a declaration made on 9 December 2015 by Sean McGuire, trade mark attorney at Watermark Intellectual Property Pty Ltd, the representatives of the Opponent, with Annexures A to K (‘McGuire 1’). Annexures E and F to McGuire 1 are themselves declarations, being respectively:

  • Declaration…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nhon Hoa Nguyen v Aardwolf Australia Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] ATMO 63
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Nhon Hoa Nguyen (the Opponent) to register the trade mark AARDWOLF and a logo, which was opposed by Aardwolf Australia Pty Ltd (the Applicant). The dispute centred on the Applicant's claim to have abandoned its rights in the AARDWOLF trade mark and logo through non-use and intention to abandon. The court was required to determine whether the Applicant had abandoned its rights in the trade mark and logo.

The court considered whether Herdgraph, the original registrant of the AARDWOLF trade mark, had abandoned its rights by ceasing to trade and by its intention to allow Aardwolf Pty Ltd to use the mark. It also examined whether Aardwolf Pty Ltd had abandoned its rights in the mark by ceasing to trade and by the intention of James Corbett to transfer those rights to Aardwolf LLC. The central question was whether the actions and intentions of the relevant parties demonstrated an intention to abandon the trade mark and logo, thereby allowing the Opponent to succeed in their opposition.

The court found that Herdgraph had registered the AARDWOLF trade mark in 2003 and that this registration was used solely by Aardwolf Pty Ltd, not Herdgraph. James Corbett declared that Herdgraph had no interest in using the brand and abandoned its registrations. Aardwolf Pty Ltd subsequently ceased trading in May 2007, and James Corbett intended to abandon any rights Aardwolf Pty Ltd had accrued in the AARDWOLF sign and logo, with the intention for these rights to be adopted by Aardwolf LLC. The court accepted that there was an intention to abandon the rights associated with the AARDWOLF trade mark and logo by both Herdgraph and Aardwolf Pty Ltd.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On 26 February 2003, Herdgraph registered the trade mark shown below (‘the First AARDWOLF Registration’): Herdgraph applied successfully to register AARDWOLF in the United States of America in July 2003. That registration was eventually cancelled because a declaration of continued use was not filed. Herdgraph also registered AARDWOLF in the European Union. In March 2003, James Corbett changed the name of Abaco Equipment to Aardwolf Pty Ltd. After changing the name of the company, he decided to expand the company’s operations to become a trading entity selling tools and equipment for use in the stone and construction industry. He originally planned for Herdgraph to assume this role, but later made a decision to run those operations solely through Aardwolf Pty Ltd. The transition to Aardwolf Pty Ltd entirely away from Herdgraph occurred over the course of 2003. According to Corbett 1, Herdgraph never used the First AARDWOLF Registration in any capacity in Australia. Instead, the First AARDWOLF Registration was used solely by Aardwolf Pty Ltd. Further, James Corbett declared that Herdgraph had no interest in using the AARDWOLF brand and abandoned the First AARDWOLF Registration along with its US and EU registrations at that time. The claim of abandonment by Herdgraph is disputed by the Opponent and is discussed further, below. Herdgraph ceased trading in goods in about May 2007. The only ongoing matter for Herdgraph was a patent infringement action commenced in 2006 against Abaco Machines. The infringement action was undertaken with Aardwolf Pty Ltd as co‑applicant. Aardwolf Pty Ltd also ceased trading at this time as James Corbett had raised enough capital to establish a manufacturing company in Vietnam under the ‘Aardwolf’ name. In about May 2007 James Corbett incorporated Aardwolf Industries Sole Member LLC (‘Aardwolf LLC’) in Vietnam. In August 2007, James Corbett transferred Aardwolf Pty Ltd’s last contract to his son, Mark Georg Corbett (‘Mark Corbett’) in his personal capacity. James Corbett declared in Corbett 2:Given that the operations of Aardwolf [Pty Ltd] had been overtaken by Aardwolf LLC (or Mark Corbett …) and there was no longer any need for Aardwolf [Pty Ltd] to continue operating in Australia, there was at the time [Aardwolf Pty Ltd ceased trading] and [sic] an accompanying intention to abandon any rights which Aardwolf [Pty Ltd] had accrued in the [sign AARDWOLF] and the AARDWOLF Logo from use in Australia … and for those rights instead to be adopted by Aardwolf LLC, who would be manufacturing (in Vietnam) and trading the Aardwolf Goods (in Australia) itself. James Corbett did not voluntarily wind up Aardwolf Pty Ltd when it ceased trading because there were still some outstanding receivables and the company was still a party to the patent infringement proceedings. In about April 2008, Mark Corbett was appointed as a director of both Herdgraph and Aardwolf Pty Ltd to provide assistance with the patent infringement litigation and, in the case of Aardwolf Pty Ltd, to deal with the outstanding receivables. This was necessary as James Corbett had, by this time, permanently relocated to Vietnam, making managing the litigation difficult.