CITATION: New South Wales Crime Commission v Lee and Ors [2010] NSWSC 1012 HEARING DATE(S): 31 August 2010
JUDGMENT DATE :
9 September 2010JUDGMENT OF: Schmidt J CATCHWORDS: STATUTES - acts of parliament - operation and effect of statutes - construction and interaction of Criminal Assets Recovery Act 1990 and the Real Property Act 1900 - whether caveat may be lodged pursuant to s 15(3) of the Criminal Assets Recovery Act when plaintiff has no right to lodge caveat under s 74F of the Real Property Act - effect of s 10A restraining order - construction of s 15(3) of the Criminal Assets Recovery Act - caveat may be lodged when NSW Crime Commission has no legal or equitable interest in Real Property Act land - caveat may be challenged under s 10C of the Criminal Assets Recovery Act, not s 74J of the Real Property Act - assets forfeiture order under s 22 of the Criminal Assets Recovery Act incompatible with indefeasible title under Real Property Act - purpose of Criminal Assets Recovery Act must be given effect - REAL PROPERTY - torrens title - caveats - whether caveat should be extended - s 10A restraining order under Criminal Assets Recovery Act - interests in property - whether plaintiff has any legal or equitable interest in the land - whether Real Property Act a code as to caveats - caveats under s 15(3) of the Criminal Assets Recovery Act - whether order sought under s 12 of the Criminal Assets Recovery Act should be made - caveat to be extended - costs LEGISLATION CITED: Real Property Act 1900
Criminal Assets Recovery Act 1990CATEGORY: Principal judgment CASES CITED: Black v Garnock [2007] HCA 31; (2007) 230 CLR 438 PARTIES: New South Wales Crime Commission - Plaintiff
Jason Lee (also known as Do Young Lee) - First Defendant
Elizabeth Park - Second Defendant
J & Lee Property Investment Group Pty Limited - Third Defendant
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 2010/118966 COUNSEL: Mr I Temby QC - Plaintiff
Mr C Newlinds SC with Mr G Jones - Third DefendantSOLICITORS: New South Wales Crime Commission (John M Giorgiutti) - Plaintiff
Nyman Gibson Stewart - Third Defendant
- 23 -
- IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COMMON LAW DIVISION
SCHMIDT J
THURSDAY, 9 SEPTEMBER 2010
JUDGMENT2010/118966 NSW CRIME COMMISSION v JASON LEE AND ORS
: By motion filed in August 2010, the plaintiff seeks an order that:
- "1. Pursuant to section 12(1) of the Criminal Assets Recovery Act 1990 ("the Act") the caveats registered by the Plaintiff in respect of the interests in property of the First Defendant in the properties specified in Schedules One and Two hereto be extended to such time as the restraining order made in these proceedings on 13 May 2010 in respect of the interests in property of the First Defendant ceases to remain in force."
2 The application is opposed by the third defendant, J & Lee Property Investment Group Pty Limited (‘the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read New South Wales Crime Commission v Lee and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
Details
- Case
- [2010] NSWSC 1012
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The case of New South Wales Crime Commission v Lee involved the New South Wales Crime Commission (the plaintiff) and Lee (the defendant). The dispute centred on whether the plaintiff could lodge a caveat over the defendant’s property under section 15(3) of the Criminal Assets Recovery Act 1990, given that the plaintiff did not have a right to lodge a caveat under section 74F of the Real Property Act 1900. Additionally, the court considered the effect of a section 10A restraining order and the interaction between the two Acts.
The primary legal issue was whether the plaintiff could lodge a caveat when it had no legal or equitable interest in the property under the Real Property Act. The court also examined whether the plaintiff’s right to lodge a caveat under the Criminal Assets Recovery Act was constrained by the provisions of the Real Property Act, particularly in light of the indefeasible title principle. Furthermore, the court had to decide whether a section 10A restraining order could be used to challenge a caveat and whether the assets forfeiture order under section 22 of the Criminal Assets Recovery Act was compatible with the indefeasible title under the Real Property Act.
The court found that the Criminal Assets Recovery Act allows the plaintiff to lodge a caveat even if it does not have a legal or equitable interest in the property under the Real Property Act. The court held that the Real Property Act is not a code as to caveats under the Criminal Assets Recovery Act and that a caveat may be challenged under section 10C of the Criminal Assets Recovery Act, not section 74J of the Real Property Act. The court also determined that an assets forfeiture order under the Criminal Assets Recovery Act is incompatible with the indefeasible title under the Real Property Act, but the purpose of the Criminal Assets Recovery Act must be given effect. Consequently, the court ordered that the caveat be extended and granted the plaintiff’s application under section 12 of the Criminal Assets Recovery Act. The court also ordered that costs be paid by the defendant.
The primary legal issue was whether the plaintiff could lodge a caveat when it had no legal or equitable interest in the property under the Real Property Act. The court also examined whether the plaintiff’s right to lodge a caveat under the Criminal Assets Recovery Act was constrained by the provisions of the Real Property Act, particularly in light of the indefeasible title principle. Furthermore, the court had to decide whether a section 10A restraining order could be used to challenge a caveat and whether the assets forfeiture order under section 22 of the Criminal Assets Recovery Act was compatible with the indefeasible title under the Real Property Act.
The court found that the Criminal Assets Recovery Act allows the plaintiff to lodge a caveat even if it does not have a legal or equitable interest in the property under the Real Property Act. The court held that the Real Property Act is not a code as to caveats under the Criminal Assets Recovery Act and that a caveat may be challenged under section 10C of the Criminal Assets Recovery Act, not section 74J of the Real Property Act. The court also determined that an assets forfeiture order under the Criminal Assets Recovery Act is incompatible with the indefeasible title under the Real Property Act, but the purpose of the Criminal Assets Recovery Act must be given effect. Consequently, the court ordered that the caveat be extended and granted the plaintiff’s application under section 12 of the Criminal Assets Recovery Act. The court also ordered that costs be paid by the defendant.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi