NCL Corporation Ltd. v Norwegian Brand Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by NCL Corporation Ltd. to extension of protection to Australia of International Registration Designating Australia 1273316 (classes 16, 35, 38, 39, 43) - NORWEGIAN.COM (figurative) (Australian Trade Mark Application No. 1847335) and International Registration Designating Australia 1273904 (classes 16, 35, 38, 39, 43) - NORWEGIAN.COM (figurative) (Australian Trade Mark Application No. 1847336) – both in the name of Norwegian Brand Ltd.

– and –

Application by NCL Corporation Ltd. for an extension of time to file evidence in support and request to have regard to late-filed evidence under regulation 21.19.

Delegate: Nicholas Smith
Representation: Opponent: Clive Elliot QC of Counsel instructed by Kate Duckworth Intellectual Property Limited
Holder: Did not appear in respect of the extension of time application
Decision: 2020 ATMO 131
Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) – application for extension of time to file evidence under regulation 17A.34K – grounds for extension of time under regulation 17A.34K(a) and (b) considered – no grounds established – application for extension of time refused – request to have regard to late filed evidence under regulation 21.19 – discretion applied

Background

  1. Extension of protection in Australia for International Registrations Designating Australia 1273316 and 1273904 (trade mark application numbers 1847335 and 1847335) in the name of Norwegian Brand Ltd (‘Holder’) are opposed by NCL Corporation Ltd. (‘Opponent’).

  2. Regulation 17A.34J(3) of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995 (Cth) (‘Regulations’), provides that evidence in support of this opposition was to be filed by the Opponent by 11 September 2019. On 4 September 2019, the Opponent sought an extension of time of three months within which to file its evidence in support (‘Request’).[1]

    [1] The Opponent’s Evidence in Support, being a declaration of Daniel Farkas (‘Farkas declaration’), was filed on 10 December 2019.  The request was technically made under reg 5.15 however as the application is for the extension of protection of an International Registration Designating Australia the proper provision is 17A.34K, which is substantively identical and this decision treats the request as being made under reg 17A.34K.

  3. A delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks (‘Registrar’) wrote to the Opponent on 9 October intending to refuse the Request.  A copy of the Request and the Registrar’s letter were sent to the Holder at the same time.

  4. The Opponent responded on 21 October 2019 with a letter providing further information in support of the Request.  The Registrar wrote again to the Opponent on 8 November 2019 expressing an intention to refuse the Request, but also offering the Opponent the opportunity for an oral hearing.  The Opponent’s further reasons and the Registrar’s second letter were also forwarded to the Holder at that time.

  5. The Opponent applied to be heard in relation to the Request on 20 November 2018.  This office issued formal hearing notices to both parties setting the Request to be heard initially on 14 April 2020, however…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read NCL Corporation Ltd. v Norwegian Brand Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] ATMO 131
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by NCL Corporation Ltd. (the Opponent) for an extension of time to file evidence in support of its opposition to a trade mark application by Norwegian Brand Ltd. (the Holder). The decision was made by Nicholas Smith, a Hearing Officer in the Trade Marks and Designs section. The core of the dispute revolved around the Opponent's delay in filing its evidence and whether the Registrar should exercise discretion to consider this evidence despite the missed deadline.

The legal issues before the court were whether to grant the Opponent's request for an extension of time to file its evidence in support of the opposition, and, in the alternative, whether to exercise discretion under Regulation 21.19 of the relevant Regulations to have regard to the Opponent's evidence despite the failure to meet the original deadline. The court was required to assess the reasons provided for the delay and the potential prejudice to the parties.

The Hearing Officer noted that while the Opponent's representative had acted promptly, the Opponent itself had not provided sufficient explanation for the significant delay in preparing its evidence between May and September 2019, despite being involved in numerous similar disputes globally. However, the Hearing Officer ultimately exercised discretion under Regulation 21.19. This decision was based on the public interest in avoiding further unnecessary hearings and delaying the final resolution of the substantive opposition. The Hearing Officer considered that allowing the Opponent's evidence would cause little inconvenience to the Holder, who would be given an opportunity to respond.

Consequently, the request for an extension of time under Regulation 17A.34K was refused. However, the Hearing Officer allowed the material comprising the Opponent's Evidence in Support, specifically the Farkas declaration, to be considered by the Registrar in making her decision on the substantive opposition. The Holder was ordered to be provided with a copy of this declaration, and its evidence in answer was to be filed within three months of the decision date.

Background

Background to the litigation

NCL Corporation Ltd. and Norwegian Brand Ltd are parties embroiled in a series of intellectual property disputes worldwide. The case at hand, NCL Corporation Ltd. v Norwegian Brand Ltd, centres around a trade mark opposition proceeding. NCL Corporation Ltd, a prominent cruise company, is the Opponent in this case, while Norwegian Brand Ltd, an airline, is the Holder of the contested trade mark. The two companies are engaged in approximately 25 such disputes globally. The Opponent's representative, Kate Duckworth of Kate Duckworth Intellectual Property Pty Ltd, and the Opponent's US attorney began discussions in March or April 2019 to prepare evidence for the opposition. A draft statutory declaration was sent on 17 April 2019, and further information was exchanged between 15 May and 18 May 2019. The Opponent was notified of the evidence filing deadline on 11 June 2019, which was 11 September 2019.

The Opponent claims to have gathered the necessary information to complete the evidence during July and August 2019. However, it is unclear what work the Opponent conducted during these months, as no additional evidence is presented to explain their conduct. The Opponent's representative sent follow-up emails in July and August 2019, with a final reminder on 27 August 2019, expressing concerns about missing the deadline. The Request was filed on 4 September 2019, and a draft statutory declaration was prepared by 21 October 2019, which was eventually filed on 10 December 2019. It is apparent that the Opponent's representative was diligent in preparing the draft declaration and sending regular reminders to the Opponent. However, it remains unexplained what work the Opponent undertook on the draft declaration between 18 May 2019 and the deadline of 11 September 2019.

The matter of NCL Corporation Ltd. v Norwegian Brand Ltd. before the Australian court involves an application for the consideration of late filed evidence in a trade mark opposition proceeding. The Opponent, NCL Corporation Ltd., a large and well-known cruise company, and the Holder, Norwegian Brand Ltd., an airline, are engaged in multiple disputes globally, with approximately 25 such disputes in different jurisdictions. The timeline of events leading up to the application reveals that the parties were in communication as early as March/April 2019 to prepare evidence for this matter. Despite the efforts of the Opponent's representative, Kate Duckworth of Kate Duckworth Intellectual Property Pty Ltd, and the Opponent's US attorney, the Opponent missed the deadline for filing evidence in support on 11 September 2019. Subsequently, the Opponent filed a Request on 4 September 2019 seeking an extension of time to file its evidence. The case proceeded with the Opponent filing a declaration on 8 May 2020, followed by written submissions on 30 June 2020, which included a chronology, list of facts, and relevant case law. The Opponent's representative maintains that they were diligent in their efforts to meet the deadline and had no blame for the missed deadline. The court was tasked with deciding whether to exercise its discretion under Regulation 21.19 to consider the late filed evidence and whether to grant an extension of time under Regulation 17A.34K.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Opponent also filed written submissions as directed, and Clive Elliot QC instructed by Kate Duckworth of Kate Duckworth Intellectual Property Limited appeared on its behalf by video conference at the hearing on 14 July 2020. The written and oral submissions sought, in the event that the Registrar refused the Request, that the Registrar have regard to the Farkas declaration pursuant to Regulation 21.19 of the Regulations. This decision shall also consider whether discretion should be exercised pursuant to r 21.19. The Opponent’s Evidence and Submissions In support of the Request the Opponent filed, on 8 May 2020, a declaration dated 7 May 2020 by Nicole Meyer, Equity Partner of Dickinson Wright PLLC, the Opponent’s representative (globally) (‘Meyer Declaration’). On June 30, 2020 the Opponent filed written submissions (‘Opponent’s Submissions’). These submissions included a chronology, list of facts and relevant case law. The Opponent’s timeline The Opponent has set out a timeline of its work in preparing the Farkas declaration. The Meyer declaration notes that the Opponent and Holder are engaged in range of disputes around the world. The Opponent is a large and well-known cruise company and the Holder is an airline. There are approximately 25 such disputes in different jurisdictions. It is not necessary to set out the chronology in full but in summary the Opponent’s representative Kate Duckworth of Kate Duckworth Intellectual Property Pty Ltd and the Opponent’s US attorney were in communication as early as March/April 2019 regarding the preparation of evidence in this matter. A draft statutory declaration was sent to the Opponent’s US attorney on 17 April 2019. On 15 May 2019 the US attorney sent further information to the Opponent’s representative and a revised declaration was sent back 3 days later. On 11 June 2019 the Opponent was advised that the deadline for filing evidence in support was 11 September 2019. The Meyer Declaration states that ‘during July and August 2019, the opponent kept gathering the information required to complete the evidence’. No other evidence is presented to explain the Opponent’s conduct during these months, nor is there any explanation of how this process could have taken two months, notwithstanding that the parties were involved in a number of (presumably similar) trade mark disputes around the world. The Opponent’s representative sent follow up e-mails to the Opponent’s US attorney in July and August and on 27 August 2019 sent a further follow-up e-mail raising concerns about missing the filing deadline, following which the Request was filed on 4 September 2019. A draft statutory declaration was prepared by 21 October 2019 and filed on 10 December 2019. It is apparent from the timeline that the Opponent’s representative bears no blame for the failure of the Opponent to file its Evidence in Support; it prepared the draft declaration well before the deadline, and was prompt in turning around draft declarations and sent regular reminders to the Opponent. What is not apparent is what work the Opponent conducted on the draft declaration between 18 May 2019 and the deadline of 11 September 2019.

Decision

Reasons for decision

There is a considerable public interest in avoiding an additional and unnecessary court hearing in order to hear all the grounds of opposition particularised by the Opponent, which would also delay the final resolution of the matter. Furthermore consideration of the Opponent’s Evidence in Support would involve little inconvenience to the Holder (as the Holder will be provided time to file Evidence in Answer and may avoid the additional costs of an appeal of the decision of the Registrar). As such, I consider it appropriate to exercise the discretion under reg 21.19 and have regard to the Opponent’s Evidence in Support in this proceeding Decisions35. The Request for an extension of time under regulation 17A.34K has been refused. Under Regulation 21.19 I allow the material comprising the Opponent’s Evidence in Support being the Farkas declaration to be considered by the Registrar in making her decision on the substantive opposition. If not already provided, the Holder must be provided with a copy of the Farkas declaration so it will have a reasonable opportunity to respond (by means of filing its evidence in answer). Accordingly, the Holder’s evidence in answer is due three months from the date of this decision.Nicholas SmithHearing OfficerOppositions and HearingsTrade Marks and Designs3 August 2020

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In support of the Request the Opponent filed, on 8 May 2020, a declaration dated 7 May 2020 by Nicole Meyer, Equity Partner of Dickinson Wright PLLC, the Opponent’s representative (globally) (‘Meyer Declaration’). On June 30, 2020 the Opponent filed written submissions (‘Opponent’s Submissions’). These submissions included a chronology, list of facts and relevant case law. The Opponent’s timeline The Opponent has set out a timeline of its work in preparing the Farkas declaration. The Meyer declaration notes that the Opponent and Holder are engaged in range of disputes around the world. The Opponent is a large and well-known cruise company and the Holder is an airline. There are approximately 25 such disputes in different jurisdictions. It is not necessary to set out the chronology in full but in summary the Opponent’s representative Kate Duckworth of Kate Duckworth Intellectual Property Pty Ltd and the Opponent’s US attorney were in communication as early as March/April 2019 regarding the preparation of evidence in this matter. A draft statutory declaration was sent to the Opponent’s US attorney on 17 April 2019. On 15 May 2019 the US attorney sent further information to the Opponent’s representative and a revised declaration was sent back 3 days later. On 11 June 2019 the Opponent was advised that the deadline for filing evidence in support was 11 September 2019. The Meyer Declaration states that ‘during July and August 2019, the opponent kept gathering the information required to complete the evidence’. No other evidence is presented to explain the Opponent’s conduct during these months, nor is there any explanation of how this process could have taken two months, notwithstanding that the parties were involved in a number of (presumably similar) trade mark disputes around the world. The Opponent’s representative sent follow up e-mails to the Opponent’s US attorney in July and August and on 27 August 2019 sent a further follow-up e-mail raising concerns about missing the filing deadline, following which the Request was filed on 4 September 2019. A draft statutory declaration was prepared by 21 October 2019 and filed on 10 December 2019. It is apparent from the timeline that the Opponent’s representative bears no blame for the failure of the Opponent to file its Evidence in Support; it prepared the draft declaration well before the deadline, and was prompt in turning around draft declarations and sent regular reminders to the Opponent. What is not apparent is what work the Opponent conducted on the draft declaration between 18 May 2019 and the deadline of 11 September 2019. The Meyer declaration notes that the Opponent has a large global trade mark portfolio and the Deponent deals directly with one attorney and one paralegal in-house. Given the size of the Opponent, this presumably does not represent the entire in house legal team of the Opponent, rather it simply illustrates the individuals with whom the deponent worked. The Meyer declaration states that the Opponent had a number of other opposition deadlines in various jurisdictions around the world between June and September 2019 that were taking up significant time for the Opponent and its legal representatives and despite working diligently they were unable to satisfy the original deadline of September 11, 2019. The extension of time provision