Lodestar Anstalt v Austin, Nichols & Co Inc

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS, WITH REASONS

Re:Oppositions by Lodestar Anstalt to applications under section 92 of the Act by Austin, Nichols & Co Inc to remove trade mark number 839740 - WILD GEESE - in the name of Lodestar Anstalt

Delegate: Terrence Williams
Representation: Opponent: Ben Fitzpatrick of counsel, Joanne Dunn, trade mark attorney, of Pizzeys attorneys
Applicant: Michael Hall of counsel, Nicholas Smith, solicitor, of Mallesons Stephen Jaques
Decision: S 92 removal application. Standing, relevance of documents produced under s 202, relevance of material supporting removal application, exercise of discretion, trade mark to be partially removed.

Background

  1. Trade mark registration 839740 is in the name of Lodestar Anstalt (“Lodestar”).  The trade mark is the words WILD GEESE.  It is registered in classes 32 and 33 for goods listed as:

    Class 32:  Beers, mineral and aerated waters and other non-alcoholic drinks, fruit drinks and fruit juices; syrups and other preparations for making beverages

    Class 33:  Alcoholic beverages (except beers)

  2. Section 92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (“the Act”) relevantly allows for making of a removal application seeking the removal, from the register, of a trade mark that has not been used within a period of three years ending one month before the date on which the removal application was filed.  The relevant ground for removal reads:

    (b) that the trade mark has remained registered for a continuous period of 3 years ending one month before the day on which the non-use application is filed, and, at no time during that period, the person who was then the registered owner:

    (i) used the trade mark in Australia; or
    (ii) used the trade mark in good faith in Australia;

    in relation to the goods and/or services to which the application relates.

  3. Two such removal applications have been filed in respect of the registration in question.

    First removal application

  4. This was filed by Austin, Nichols and Co, Inc (“Austin”) on 27 June 2005. It seeks removal, in terms of s 92(4)(b), of the trade mark for all of the goods for which it is registered.

    Second removal application.

  5. This was filed by Wild Geese Wines Pty Ltd (“Geese”), a South Australian company, on 6 September 2005. However, it proceeds now in the name of Austin, reliant on the terms of s 92(5), which reads:

    (5) If the right or interest on which a person relied to make an application (under subsection (1) or (3)) to obtain the removal of a trade mark from the Register becomes vested in another person, the other person may, on giving notice of the relevant facts to the Registrar or the court (as the case requires), be substituted for the first-mentioned person as the applicant.

  6. The second removal application sought removal in terms of s 92(4)(a) as well as (b). However, for reasons which are not relevant, Mr Hall formally abandoned the 92(4)(a) ground and only the subsequent provision, which I have set out, was pursued at…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lodestar Anstalt v Austin, Nichols & Co Inc and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] ATMO 38
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Lodestar Anstalt (Lodestar) and Austin, Nichols & Co Inc (Austin) were parties to proceedings before the Trade Marks Hearings Officer. The dispute concerned an application by Austin to remove Lodestar's registered trade mark from the register.

The primary legal issue before the Hearings Officer was whether Lodestar's trade mark had been used in good faith in Australia, or whether it had been registered without any bona fide intention to use it, or without any bona fide use, in respect of the goods for which it was registered. This involved considering the extent of use and the circumstances surrounding that use.

The Hearings Officer reasoned that while Austin's initial removal application was unsuccessful, Lodestar's subsequent concession regarding the use of its trade mark in relation to certain alcoholic beverages indicated a limited success for Austin's second application. Balancing the interests of both parties, particularly considering the initial obstruction experienced by Austin, the Hearings Officer determined that a proper exercise of discretion required the trade mark to be partially removed from the register. Specifically, the registration was to be removed in respect of "wine, fortified wine and wine-based spirits, namely brandy, grappa and cognac" within class 33.

The Hearings Officer refused Austin's first removal application but directed the partial removal of the trade mark as described above. Neither party was awarded costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The facts of Lodestar Anstalt v Austin, Nichols & Co Inc centre around a dispute over the registration and use of a trade mark in Australia. Lodestar Anstalt, the applicant, registered a trade mark for certain goods and services, including alcoholic beverages under class 33 of the International Classification of Goods and Services. Austin, Nichols & Co Inc, the respondent, filed an application to remove the trade mark from the register, alleging non-use and other grounds. The proceedings involved detailed submissions from both parties regarding the use and scope of the trade mark.

Initially, Lodestar had registered the trade mark for a wide range of alcoholic beverages, including wine, fortified wine, and wine-based spirits such as brandy, grappa, and cognac. Austin contested this registration, arguing that Lodestar had not used the mark in relation to these products. Austin further contended that the registration should be limited to exclude these specific wine-related products. As the dispute progressed, Lodestar made a concession that it would not oppose the removal of the trade mark in respect of wine, fortified wine, and the specified wine-based spirits. This concession came after Austin had already filed a removal application.

The case involved a complex interplay of submissions and evidence concerning the use of the trade mark, the market for the products, and the impact of the trade mark registration on both parties. The Hearing Officer, T.E. Williams, was tasked with determining the appropriate scope of the trade mark registration, balancing the interests of both Lodestar and Austin. The officer ultimately decided to partially remove the trade mark from the register to reflect the concession made by Lodestar, while rejecting Austin’s earlier, broader removal application.

The matter of Lodestar Anstalt v Austin, Nichols & Co Inc originated as a removal application filed by Austin, Nichols & Co Inc seeking the cancellation of Lodestar Anstalt's trade mark registration for certain goods. The proceedings initially came before the Trade Marks Hearings as a first-instance removal application. In this application, Austin sought to have the trade mark removed from the register entirely for certain classes of goods, specifically "wine, fortified wine and wine-based spirits, namely brandy, grappa and cognac". This application was filed following an earlier concession made by Lodestar that certain goods should be excluded from its registration. Following the filing of the initial removal application, Lodestar filed a partial removal application, which sought a less extensive removal of the trade mark registration. The Hearing Officer considered both applications and the concessions made by Lodestar, ultimately deciding that the trade mark should be partially removed to reflect the limited success of Austin's removal application. The Hearing Officer balanced the interests of both parties, taking into account the initial obstruction experienced by Austin, and made an interlocutory order directing the partial removal of the trade mark from the register. This order left the trade mark registration intact for certain alcoholic beverages, excluding wine, fortified wine, and the specified wine-based spirits.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Accordingly, balancing the interest of Lodestar against that of Austin insofar as it results from the initial obstruction experienced by Geese, I think a proper application of the discretion would see the trade mark removed from the register in respect of “wine, fortified wine and wine-based spirits, namely brandy, grappa and cognac”. This would leave a specification reading as follows in respect of class 33: Alcoholic beverages (except beers) but excluding wine, fortified wine and wine-based spirits, namely brandy, grappa and cognac.Conclusion and costs I have refused the first removal application filed by Austin. I have, in contrast, directed that the trade mark be partially removed, reflecting the limited success of the other removal application now being prosecuted by Austin when balanced against the last-minute concession made by Lodestar. I do not believe that either side is entitled to an award of costs.T. E. WilliamsHearing OfficerTrade Marks Hearings13 May 2009

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining the competing interests of Lodestar, the trade mark owner, and Austin, the applicant seeking removal of the trade mark. In Lodestar Anstalt v Austin, Nichols & Co Inc, the Hearing Officer considered the balance of these interests. The court found that the interest of Lodestar in retaining the trade mark was not absolute, and that Austin's interest in removing it from the register should be considered. The court concluded that Austin's interest was sufficient to warrant the removal of the trade mark from the register for certain classes of goods, as will be discussed below.

Regarding the second issue, the court examined whether the trade mark should be removed from the register for "wine, fortified wine and wine-based spirits, namely brandy, grappa and cognac". The Hearing Officer found that Austin's interest in removing the trade mark for these classes outweighed Lodestar's interest in retaining it. The court considered that Austin had demonstrated a genuine use of the trade mark in relation to these goods and that the removal of the trade mark for these classes would not significantly affect Lodestar's interest in retaining the trade mark for other classes of goods. The court therefore directed that the trade mark be removed from the register for these specific classes.

The third issue involved determining the appropriate specification of the trade mark in respect of class 33: Alcoholic beverages (except beers) when the removal application was granted in part. The court considered that the trade mark should be retained for some alcoholic beverages, but removed for others, specifically wine, fortified wine and wine-based spirits, namely brandy, grappa and cognac. The court concluded that the trade mark should be specified to exclude these goods in class 33, while retaining it for other alcoholic beverages.

The fourth issue addressed whether Austin was entitled to an award of costs for the first removal application filed. The court refused to grant Austin an award of costs for the first removal application, as the application was ultimately unsuccessful. The court noted that the refusal of the application did not necessarily mean that the application was frivolous or vexatious, but rather that the court's discretion was exercised in a manner that balanced the interests of both parties.

The final issue considered whether Lodestar was entitled to an award of costs for the second removal application filed. The court also declined to award costs in relation to the second removal application, as the application was only partially successful. The court found that neither party was entitled to an award of costs, as the exercise of the court's discretion did not result in a clear success or failure for either party.

In conclusion, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the court will exercise its discretion to balance the interests of the trade mark owner and the applicant seeking removal, and will consider the specific circumstances of each case when determining the appropriate specification of the trade mark. The court distinguished its decision from prior authority in that it did not award costs to either party, as the exercise of the court's discretion did not result in a clear success or failure for either party.