Laboratoires La Prairie v Wendy Stockden-Brock

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Laboratoires La Prairie SA to registration of trade mark application 955561(3 and 44) - SILVER RAIN - filed in the name of Wendy Stockden-Brock.

Delegate: Don Nancarrow
Representation: Opponent: Mr. Neil Murray of Counsel instructed by Spruson & Ferguson, Patent and Trade Mark Attorneys, Sydney
Applicant: Mr. Bernard O’Brien
Decision: Opposition successful under ss. 44 and 62(b). Costs awarded against the applicant.

Background

  1. Ms. Wendy Stockden-Brock, (the applicant), filed an application for registration of the trade mark SILVER RAIN on 28 May 2003 in respect of “make-up, skincare, hair care and cosmetics products, perfumes” in class 3, and “beauty salon and hair care services, provision of information in relation to beauty, cosmetics, hair care and perfumery” in class 44, of the International Classification of Goods and Services (NICE classification). The application was advertised as accepted under the provisions of sub-section 44(4) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (the Act) in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks of 19 February 2004. Laboratoires La Prairie SA, (the opponent), filed a notice of opposition to registration on 19 August 2004 after gaining a three month extension of time in which to do so.

  2. The evidence stages followed in which the opponent filed and served two declarations, from Harald Stolzenberg (Stolzenberg declaration with exhibits “HS-1” to “HS-3”) and Michael Rumore (Rumore declaration with exhibit “MR-1”), and in which the applicant filed and served a declaration from Wendy Ann Stockden-Brock (Stockden-Brock declaration with exhibits “1” and “2”).

  3. After an unsuccessful attempt to settle the matter by negotiation the opponent requested to be heard. The matter came before me as the Registrar’s delegate in Sydney on 20 October 2005.

  4. The applicant has been involved in some aspects of the health and beauty industry for over 20 years as part of a much broader involvement with a variety of business interests. These interests go to forms of counselling, alternative healing techniques and both personal and business strategies for the future. The applicant has travelled to a number of overseas countries and also has a variety of venues within Australia from which makeover services, in particular, have been dispensed.

  5. The opponent is a Swiss company that has not claimed use of the SILVER RAIN mark in Australia but bases its opposition, in particular, on a Protected International Trade Mark, (PITM), which claims a priority date of 21 May 2003 for its protection in Australia. The plans of the opponent are to market a fragrance in Australia in 2005. The company is either active in, or plans to be active in, 68 countries worldwide.

  6. The present trade mark, filed on 28 May 2003, was accepted with an endorsement indicating that the trade mark was used from a time prior to 21 May 2003. This date is the priority date of the opponent’s SILVER RAIN trade mark which was filed in Australia on 30 June 2003 but which claimed a filing…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Laboratoires La Prairie v Wendy Stockden-Brock and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] ATMO 80
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Laboratoires La Prairie (the applicant) sought to register a trade mark, which was accepted with an endorsement indicating use prior to 21 May 2003. Wendy Stockden-Brock (the opponent) opposed this application, relying on their SILVER RAIN trade mark, which claimed a priority date of 21 May 2003. The proceedings were heard by Don Nancarrow, a Hearing Officer in the Trade Marks Hearings.

The primary legal issues before the Hearing Officer were whether the applicant's claimed use of the trade mark constituted a representation false in material particulars, and whether the application should be refused on grounds relating to the opponent's prior rights and the applicant's conduct. Specifically, the court had to determine if the applicant's declarations regarding the date of first use of their trade mark were credible and if they had made any misleading representations to the Trade Marks Office.

The Hearing Officer found that the applicant's initial declaration claimed use of the mark from February 2002, while a subsequent declaration from the applicant amended this claim to a later date. This discrepancy was considered a representation false in material particulars, leading to the opponent succeeding on this ground of opposition under section 62(b) of the relevant Act. Furthermore, the Hearing Officer found that the opponent had also succeeded on grounds relating to prior rights under section 44 of the Act.

Consequently, the Hearing Officer refused the registration of the applicant's trade mark application and ordered the applicant to pay the opponent's costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The present trade mark, filed on 28 May 2003, was accepted with an endorsement indicating that the trade mark was used from a time prior to 21 May 2003. This date is the priority date of the opponent’s SILVER RAIN trade mark which was filed in Australia on 30 June 2003 but which claimed a filing date of 21 May 2003 based on the convention priority of a Swiss application.The Evidence The Stockden-Brock declaration claims that the applicant first used the mark in March 2002 in relation to a beauty makeover and first used the mark in relation to goods shortly after February 2003. The exhibits showing use of the mark, however, are undated and, therefore, do not categorically support the applicant’s claim. The Stolzenberg declaration lists the chronology of the acceptance of the application and endeavours to point out deficiencies in the applicant’s case that led to the acceptance. It also goes to show the picture regarding the opponent’s resolve and its international interests, including trade mark applications and registrations. The Rumore declaration exhibits the results of a number of investigations that Mr. Rumore had made in the Bowral district in his capacity as a private inquiry and commercial agent. The exhibit details a conversation that Mr. Rumore alleges took place with the applicant, which in her declaration, the applicant denies took place at all. Despite the strength of assertion by both parties on this issue, whether or not this conversation actually took place or not is of little import in the overall decision. As well as the three declarations listed above, Mr. Murray, for the opponent, requested that I also consider the declaration that had been supplied to this Office on behalf of the applicant in support of its claim for prior continuous use of its trade mark to overcome an examiner’s objection to registration of the mark. This declaration was from Justin Senescall, acting in his capacity as legal representative for the applicant. In this regard, I note that Regulation 21.19(1) reads:21.19 Registrar may use information available(1) If:(a) information that is available to the Registrar is relevant to proceedings before the Registrar; and(b) the Registrar has reason to believe that the information is not known to a party to the proceedings; and(c) the Registrar proposes to take the information into account in making a decision in the proceedings;before making the decision the Registrar must:(d) provide the information to the party; and(e) give the party a reasonable opportunity to make representations about the information. In the present case, I am satisfied that both parties had access to the Senescall declaration – the applicant, because it had been submitted by the applicant’s representative; and the opponent, because it has requested that I consider it. As I do accept that it is relevant to this matter, I intend to take note of this material in making my decision. In addition, in deciding whether or not materials can be considered in relation to a decision by a hearing officer in the Trade Marks Office, the formal rules of evidence of the court system are not binding. There are distinct advantages in considering available information without the need to involve the Federal Court, if possible, provided of course, that both parties are afforded procedural fairness.Grounds of Opposition

Decision

Reasons for decision

Given that the Senescall declaration, pre-acceptance, claimed use of the mark from February 2002 and the later Stockden-Brock declaration amended this claim to a later date, I find that this amounts to a representation false in material particulars and that the opponent has been successful under this ground of opposition.Decision From the foregoing I have found that the opponent has succeeded under two grounds of opposition in this matter, those under ss. 44 and 62(b) of the Act. As a delegate of the Registrar I refuse registration of this trade mark application. Costs The opponent has requested its costs in the matter. There is nothing before me to show that costs should not follow the event and I direct that the applicant pay the costs of the opponent according to Schedule 8 of the Regulations to the Act.Don NancarrowHearing OfficerTrade Marks Hearings21 December 2005

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established