National Australia Bank Limited v Stern

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – joinder – Mareva Injunction - transfer of property – whether serious question to be tried - whether reasonably arguable that assets of respondents and prospective respondents could be diminished or dissipated – balance of convenience.

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976, (Cth) s 23

Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth), s 121

LED Builders Pty Limited v Eagle Homes Pty Limited (1997) 78 FCR 65, applied
Jackson v Sterling Industries Pty Limited (1987) 162 CLR 612, followed

NATIONAL AUSTRALIA BANK LIMITED V
ILANA ELENKA STERN AND JOSEPH POLLAK

NG 936 OF 1996

TAMBERLIN J
SYDNEY
21 DECEMBER 1998

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NG 936 of 1996

BETWEEN:

NATIONAL AUSTRALIA BANK LIMITED
APPLICANT

AND:

ILANA ELENKA STERN
FIRST RESPONDENT

JOSEPH POLLAK
SECOND RESPONDENT

HARRY STERN
THIRD RESPONDENT

AANA POLLAK
FOURTH RESPONDENT

STERN NOMINEES PTY LIMITED
FIFTH RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

TAMBERLIN J

DATE OF ORDER:

21 DECEMBER 1998

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

ORDERS IN RESPECT OF HARRY STERN, AANA POLLAK AND STERN NOMINEES PTY LIMITED

Upon the Applicant giving to the Court:

(a)       the usual undertakings as to damages; and

(b)an undertaking to keep the terms of the following orders confidential and, in particular, not to communicate the terms of such order to any other financial institution or financial reporting agency.

The Court orders that:

  1. Harry Stern, Aana Pollak and Stern Nominees Pty limited be joined as third, fourth and fifth respondents in proceedings NG 149 of 1996, NG 936 of 1996 and NG 81 of 1998.

  1. Until further order, each of the third, fourth and fifth respondents be restrained from selling, disposing of or dealing with any interest in any assets whatsoever and wherever situated in which they have had any interest transferred to them either directly or indirectly by the first two respondents after 1 January 1994 without giving the solicitor for the Applicant at least twenty-eight days prior written notice.

  1. Within fourteen days from the date hereof, the third, fourth and fifth respondents file and serve on the Applicant, affidavits giving details of their interests in any property whatsoever and wherever situated, transferred to them either directly or indirectly by the first two respondents, after 1 January 1994 and giving full details as to any sale, disposition or dealing by either of them of any interest in any such property.

  1. The third, fourth and fifth respondents pay the costs of the Applicant on this application in relation to the orders made against them.

  1. Liberty to apply on 24 hours notice.

ORDERS IN RESPECT OF JOSEPH POLLAK AND ILANA STERN

Upon the Applicant giving to the Court:

(a)       the usual undertakings as to damages; and

(b)an undertaking to keep the terms of the following orders confidential and, in particular, not to communicate the terms of such orders to any other financial institution or financial reporting agency.

The Court orders that:

  1. Until further order, the first and second respondent be restrained from selling, disposing of or dealing…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read National Australia Bank Limited v Stern and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] FCA 1665
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In National Australia Bank Limited v Stern, the Federal Court of Australia was called upon to decide on an application for joinder of additional parties and the issuance of a Mareva injunction to prevent the dissipation of assets. The application was brought by the National Australia Bank Limited against Ilana Elenka Stern, Joseph Pollak, Harry Stern, Aana Pollak, and Stern Nominees Pty Limited. The Bank sought to join Harry Stern, Aana Pollak, and Stern Nominees Pty Limited as respondents and to obtain a Mareva injunction against them to prevent the disposal of any assets transferred by the first and second respondents, Ilana Stern and Joseph Pollak, after 1 January 1994.

The legal issues before the Court included whether there was sufficient evidence to support the conclusion that there was a real risk of the assets in the hands of the prospective respondents being diminished or dissipated and whether there was a reasonably arguable case that the assets could be recovered by a trustee in bankruptcy. Additionally, the Court had to consider the balance of convenience in deciding whether to grant the Mareva injunction.

Justice Tamberlin found that there was a real risk of the assets being diminished or dissipated due to the timing of the transfers and the dramatic reduction in the assets of the original respondents. The Court also concluded that there was a reasonably arguable case that the dispositions of property could be set aside by a trustee in bankruptcy if the Bank was ultimately successful. Furthermore, the balance of convenience favoured the grant of the Mareva injunction given the Bank's undertakings as to damages.

Consequently, the Court ordered that Harry Stern, Aana Pollak, and Stern Nominees Pty Limited be joined as third, fourth, and fifth respondents and restrained them from disposing of any assets transferred to them by Ilana Stern and Joseph Pollak after 1 January 1994. The first and second respondents were similarly restrained from disposing of any of their assets. All respondents were required to provide detailed affidavits of their interests in any property transferred since 1 January 1994 and to pay the costs of the application.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 25 March 1995, the National Australia Bank Limited (the Bank) obtained a judgment against Ilana Stern and Joseph Pollak for approximately USD 3.58 million from the Superior Court for the State of California. On 23 October 1995, Joseph Pollak transferred his interest in three home units at Point Piper to his wife, Aana Pollak, for AUD 1.125 million. On 6 June 1996, Ilana Stern transferred her interest in various properties to her husband, Harry Stern, and to Stern Nominees Pty Limited for AUD 549,000. This company is a trustee for a Stern family trust. On 26 June 1996, a deficiency judgment was obtained from the Superior Court of California, requiring Joseph Pollak and Ilana Stern to pay USD 3.813 million plus costs to the Bank. The Bank filed proceedings in the Supreme Court of New South Wales seeking judgment against the defendants for USD 3.799 million plus costs and interest. Joseph Pollak testified that his only remaining assets comprised personal property and that he had no real estate. Ilana Stern also testified that she did not have any substantial assets available.

The matter came before the Federal Court of Australia, New South Wales District Registry, as an interlocutory application for a Mareva injunction and to join additional respondents. The application was filed on 10 December 1998, and the reasons for judgment were given on 21 December 1998. Prior to this, Joseph Pollak and Ilana Stern had commenced proceedings to restrain the Bank from enforcing the Californian judgment, which was dismissed by the Full Court. The Bank had also filed proceedings in the Supreme Court of New South Wales seeking judgment against the defendants.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Court has jurisdiction to join Harry Stern, Aana Pollak, and Stern Nominees Pty Limited as third, fourth, and fifth respondents in the proceedings.
2. Whether there is a serious question to be tried as to whether assets of the respondents and prospective respondents could be diminished or dissipated, rendering a judgment in favour of the Bank fruitless.
3. Whether there is a reasonably arguable case that the assets were disposed of in such a way that they could be recovered by a trustee in bankruptcy if the Bank is ultimately successful.
4. Whether the balance of convenience favours the grant of Mareva relief against all respondents.

Held
1. The Court has jurisdiction to join Harry Stern, Aana Pollak, and Stern Nominees Pty Limited as third, fourth, and fifth respondents in the proceedings.
2. There is a serious question to be tried as to whether assets of the respondents and prospective respondents could be diminished or dissipated, rendering a judgment in favour of the Bank fruitless.
3. There is a reasonably arguable case that the assets were disposed of in such a way that they could be recovered by a trustee in bankruptcy if the Bank is ultimately successful.
4. The balance of convenience favours the grant of Mareva relief against all respondents.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Federal Court of Australia considered an application by the National Australia Bank Limited (the Bank) to join Harry Stern, Aana Pollak, and Stern Nominees Pty Limited (the prospective respondents) as third, fourth, and fifth respondents and to grant Mareva injunctions against them. The primary respondents were Ilana Elenka Stern and Joseph Pollak, who had been judgment debtors of the Bank. The Bank sought to prevent the prospective respondents from disposing of any assets transferred to them by the primary respondents after 1 January 1994. The court held that it had jurisdiction to join the prospective respondents based on the principles established in LED Builders Pty Limited v Eagle Homes Pty Limited and the authority of Jackson v Sterling Industries Limited. The court found that there was a serious question to be tried as to whether the assets could be diminished or dissipated, which could render a judgment in favour of the Bank fruitless. The court also found that there was a reasonably arguable case that the dispositions of property by the primary respondents to the prospective respondents could be set aside by a trustee in bankruptcy if the Bank was ultimately successful. Finally, the court found that the balance of convenience favoured the grant of Mareva relief against all respondents, as the Bank had provided undertakings as to damages, and there was no significant inconvenience to the prospective respondents that could not be compensated. The court granted the joinder and the Mareva injunctions as requested by the Bank.