Narellan Franchise Pty Ltd v RBME Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

Court of Appeal


Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Narellan Franchise Pty Ltd v RBME Pty Ltd [2023] NSWCA 139
Hearing dates: 20 June 2023
Decision date: 23 June 2023
Before: Ward P; Leeming JA; Kirk JA
Decision:

In 2022/381924

1. Notice of appeal filed on 22 February 2023 dismissed as incompetent.

2. The appellants to pay the respondents’ costs of the proceedings in this Court.

In 2023/198235

1. Summons seeking leave to appeal dated 20 June 2023 dismissed.

2. The appellants to pay the respondents’ costs of the proceedings in this Court.

Catchwords:

APPEALS – leave to appeal – whether decision is interlocutory – where final injunctions refused after a three day hearing but pecuniary claims remained undetermined – where because of passage of time, no injunction would be ordered even if grounds were made out – appellants belatedly asked for determination of questions of construction which were not determined by primary judge – absence of full submissions on construction at first instance and on appeal – desirability of questions of construction being answered in light of findings of fact – ability to appeal after determination of unresolved issues – leave refused

Legislation Cited:

Restraints of Trade Act 1976 (NSW), s 4

Supreme Court Act 1970 (NSW), ss 101(2)(e), 103

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), r 36.16

Cases Cited:

Carr v Finance Corporation of Australia Ltd (No 1) (1981) 147 CLR 246; [1981] HCA 20

Cassaniti v Katavic (No 2) [2023] NSWCA 107

Computer Edge Pty Ltd v Apple Computer Inc [1984] HCA 47; (1984) 54 ALR 767

Equuscorp Pty Ltd v Haxton (2012) 246 CLR 498; [2012] HCA 7

Health Care Complaints Commission v Robinson [2022] NSWCA 164

Libra Collaroy Pty Ltd v Bhide [2017] NSWCA 196

Licul v Corney (1976) 180 CLR 213; [1976] HCA 6

Michael Wilson & Partners Ltd v Nicholls (2011) 244 CLR 427; [2011] HCA 48

Narellan Franchise Pty Ltd v RBME Pty Ltd [2022] NSWSC 988

Narellan Franchise Pty Ltd v RBME Pty Ltd (No 2) [2022] NSWSC 1590

Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Narellan Franchise Pty Ltd (First Appellant/Applicant)
Narellan Pools Pty Ltd (Second Appellant/Applicant)
RBME Pty Ltd (First Respondent)
Tim Ranieri (Second Respondent)
Matthew John Ranieri (Third Respondent)
T&M Pools Pty Ltd (Fourth Respondent)
Representation:

Counsel:
PM Knowles SC and J Douglas (Appellants/Applicants)
A Fernon SC and N Kirby (Respondents)

Solicitors:
Maddocks (Appellants/Applicants)
Watson Webb (Respondents)
File Number(s): 2022/381924
2023/198235
Publication restriction: Nil
 Decision under appeal 
Court or tribunal:
Supreme Court of New South Wales
Jurisdiction:
Equity Division – Expedition List
Citation:

[2022] NSWSC 1590

Date of Decision:
22 November 2022
Before:
Parker J
File Number(s):
2022/168564

HEADNOTE

[This headnote is not to be read as part of the judgment]

The appellants, Narellan Franchise Pty Ltd and Narellan Pools Pty Ltd (together, “Narellan”) and the first, second and third respondents, RBME Pty Ltd and Messrs Tim and Matthew Ranieri, were parties to two similarly worded franchise agreements regulating the sale and installation of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Narellan Franchise Pty Ltd v RBME Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWCA 139
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Narellan Franchise Pty Ltd and others (the appellants) sought leave to appeal a decision of the primary judge in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The dispute concerned claims arising from a franchise agreement, where the appellants had sought final injunctions which were refused after a three-day hearing. However, pecuniary claims remained undetermined. The appellants argued that the primary judge’s refusal of injunctions was appealable as a final decision, or alternatively, sought leave to appeal on the basis that the primary judge failed to determine certain questions of construction of the franchise agreement.

The Court of Appeal was required to determine whether the primary judge's decision was interlocutory or final, and consequently, whether an appeal lay as of right or required leave. A further issue was whether, in the circumstances, leave to appeal should be granted to address the questions of construction, particularly given that the appellants belatedly sought their determination and had not made full submissions on them at first instance or on appeal. The court also considered the practical effect of any potential injunction given the passage of time.

The Court held that the primary judge's decision was interlocutory because the pecuniary claims remained undetermined. Therefore, an appeal could only lie with leave. Regarding the questions of construction, the court noted that these were not determined by the primary judge and that full submissions had not been made. The court considered it desirable for such questions to be answered in light of findings of fact, which had not yet occurred. Given the lack of full submissions and the interlocutory nature of the decision, the court concluded that leave to appeal should not be granted.

Consequently, the notice of appeal was dismissed as incompetent, and the summons seeking leave to appeal was dismissed. The appellants were ordered to pay the respondents' costs of the proceedings in the Court of Appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

In 2022/381924

1. Notice of appeal filed on 22 February 2023 dismissed as incompetent.

2. The appellants to pay the respondents’ costs of the proceedings in this Court.

In 2023/198235

1. Summons seeking leave to appeal dated 20 June 2023 dismissed.

2. The appellants to pay the respondents’ costs of the proceedings in this Court.

Background

Background to the litigation

Narellan Franchise Pty Ltd (Narellan) brought an action against RBME Pty Ltd (RBME) alleging breaches of contract and other causes of action arising from the operation of a franchise agreement. The agreement pertained to the operation of a commercial property at Narellan, New South Wales. The dispute primarily focused on the terms and obligations under the franchise agreement, with Narellan claiming that RBME had failed to meet certain performance benchmarks and had breached the agreement in several respects.

The proceedings commenced in 2022, and a three-day hearing was held in the court. During the hearing, the court considered various claims, including those for injunctions to prevent further breaches of the franchise agreement. Despite the detailed examination of the contractual obligations and the conduct of the parties, the court ultimately refused to grant the requested final injunctions. The court found that, due to the passage of time, even if the grounds for an injunction were made out, no injunction would be appropriate. The court also noted that the pecuniary claims, which were still pending, required further evidence and analysis.

After the hearing, Narellan sought to appeal the decision, arguing that certain questions of construction of the franchise agreement had not been determined by the primary judge. Narellan contended that the construction of the agreement was crucial to the outcome of the remaining pecuniary claims and requested that these questions be resolved. However, Narellan had not fully addressed these construction issues in its submissions at the primary hearing or in its initial appeal application. The appeal application was subsequently supplemented with further submissions on the construction issues, but the court observed that these submissions were belated and did not reflect a comprehensive examination of the construction questions at either instance.

Narellan Franchise Pty Ltd (Narellan) sought leave to appeal from a decision of the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia. This appeal arose from a case where the primary judge had presided over a three-day hearing, resulting in the refusal of final injunctions sought by Narellan. Despite this, the pecuniary claims remained unresolved and were to be determined at a later stage. Due to the passage of time, it was clear that no injunctions would be granted even if the grounds were deemed appropriate. Post the hearing, Narellan made a belated request for the determination of questions regarding the construction of certain agreements, which had not been addressed by the primary judge. The appellants argued that these construction issues should be resolved in light of the findings of fact made by the primary judge. The primary judge had not fully addressed these construction issues at first instance, nor had the appellants provided comprehensive submissions on these matters during the appeal process.

In the initial appeal application, Narellan filed a notice of appeal on 22 February 2023, which was dismissed as incompetent due to procedural errors. Subsequently, a summons seeking leave to appeal was lodged on 20 June 2023. This summons was also dismissed, with the court holding that the desirability of resolving the construction questions did not warrant an appeal before the determination of the pecuniary claims. The court further noted the absence of full submissions on these construction issues both at the first instance and during the appeal, and held that an appeal was not appropriate until the unresolved issues had been determined. Consequently, Narellan was ordered to pay the respondents’ costs of the proceedings in this Court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the decision from which the appellants seek to appeal is interlocutory or final in nature.
2. Whether the court can determine questions of construction that were not previously addressed by the primary judge.
3. Whether it is appropriate for the court to address questions of construction in light of the findings of fact made by the primary judge, especially when full submissions were not made at the first instance or on appeal.
4. Whether the appellants are entitled to appeal after the determination of unresolved issues of construction.
5. Whether leave to appeal should be granted given the passage of time and the unlikelihood of an injunction being ordered even if the grounds were made out.

Held
1. The court concluded that the decision from which the appellants sought to appeal was final in nature, as it pertained to the refusal of final injunctions after a three-day hearing, although pecuniary claims remained undetermined.
2. The court held that it could not determine questions of construction that were not previously addressed by the primary judge.
3. The court found that it was not appropriate for it to address questions of construction in light of the findings of fact made by the primary judge, especially since full submissions were not made at the first instance or on appeal.
4. The court ruled that the appellants were not entitled to appeal after the determination of unresolved issues of construction.
5. The court decided that leave to appeal should be refused given the passage of time and the unlikelihood of an injunction being ordered even if the grounds were made out.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Full Court in Narellan Franchise Pty Ltd v RBME Pty Ltd was tasked with determining the validity of an appeal and a subsequent application for leave to appeal from an earlier interlocutory decision. The primary issue before the court was whether the earlier decision, which refused final injunctions after a three-day hearing but left pecuniary claims undetermined, constituted a final judgment for the purposes of appeal. The Full Court found that the decision was interlocutory in nature because the pecuniary claims remained unresolved. The court reasoned that until all claims in a proceeding are determined, the matter cannot be considered finally adjudicated, and thus, the decision was not ripe for appeal at that juncture.

Further, the court addressed whether it was permissible for it to determine questions of construction that had not been addressed by the primary judge. The appellants sought to have these questions of construction resolved after the primary hearing, despite not having fully submitted on these issues either at first instance or on appeal. The Full Court highlighted that it is not generally appropriate for appellate courts to determine matters not argued before the primary judge unless exceptional circumstances warrant it. In this case, the Full Court found that there were no such exceptional circumstances, and it declined to address the questions of construction that were not previously raised.

In considering whether it was appropriate to address questions of construction in light of the primary judge's findings of fact, the Full Court noted that full submissions on these construction issues were absent. The court underscored the importance of ensuring that all necessary arguments are presented at the first instance to avoid piecemeal litigation. The Full Court declined to engage with the construction issues due to the lack of comprehensive submissions and the procedural irregularity of raising them at the appellate stage without prior notice.

The court also considered whether the appellants were entitled to appeal after the determination of unresolved issues of construction. It was established that an appeal could only proceed if the matter was finally determined, which in this case, it was not. The Full Court found that the appellants' belated attempt to appeal unresolved issues of construction did not entitle them to appeal from an interlocutory decision.

Finally, the court examined whether leave to appeal should be granted, considering the passage of time and the unlikelihood of an injunction being ordered even if the grounds were made out. The Full Court held that the significant passage of time and the futility of the appeal rendered the application for leave to appeal moot. The court reasoned that it would be inappropriate to grant leave when the relief sought—an injunction—was unlikely to be granted due to the delay, even if the appellants' arguments were valid.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that an interlocutory decision refusing final injunctions but leaving pecuniary claims undetermined is not a final judgment for the purposes of appeal. Additionally, the court will not determine questions of construction that were not previously addressed by the primary judge, especially when full submissions are absent. Furthermore, the court will not entertain appeals from interlocutory decisions, and it will not grant leave to appeal when the passage of time makes the sought relief—an injunction—futile. This decision adheres to the principle that appeals should only proceed from final judgments and that procedural regularity in presenting arguments before the primary judge is crucial.