Court of Appeal
Supreme Court
New South Wales
- Summary available
- Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: Health Care Complaints Commission v Robinson [2022] NSWCA 164 Hearing dates: 3 May 2022 Date of orders: 26 August 2022 Decision date: 26 August 2022 Before: Leeming JA at [1];
Kirk JA at [24];
Simpson AJA at [40].Decision: 1. Appeal allowed.
2. The whole of the Application for Disciplinary Findings and Orders filed by the Health Care Complaints Commission on 9 April 2020 be reconsidered by the Tribunal in accordance with these reasons.
3. The respondent is to pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal.
Catchwords: OCCUPATIONS — Heath practitioners — Misconduct and discipline — Disciplinary proceedings — ophthalmologist conducted breast and abdominal examination in circumstances where examination not indicated — application by Health Care Complaints Commission to NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal seeking finding of professional misconduct —Tribunal found only unsatisfactory professional conduct — whether Tribunal erred in equating inappropriate conduct of a sexual nature with conduct that is sexually motivated — two-stage procedure for determination of disciplinary complaints — meaning of “interlocutory decision” in Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 (NSW)
Legislation Cited: Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 (NSW), ss 4, 36, 83, Sch 5
District Court Act 1973 (NSW), s 127
Evidence Act 1995 (NSW), s 75
Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (NSW), ss 138, 139, 139B, 139E, 149, 149A-D, 165B, 165L
Legal Profession Uniform Law (NSW), ss 296, 297
Health Practitioner Regulation (NSW) Regulation 2016
Supreme Court Act 1970 (NSW), ss 48, 101, 103
Cases Cited: AAI Trading as GIO as Agent for the Nominal Defendant v McGiffen (2016) 77 MVR 348; [2016] NSWCA 229
Autodesk Inc v Dyason [No 2] (1993) 176 CLR 300; [1993] HCA 6
Carr v Finance Corporation of Australia Ltd (No 1) (1981) 147 CLR 246; [1981] HCA 20
Castle Constructions Pty Ltd v Sahab Holdings Pty Ltd [No 2] [2013] HCA 44; 87 ALJR 1159
Chen v Health Care Complaints Commission (2017) 95 NSWLR 334; [2017] NSWCA 186
Computer Edge Pty Ltd v Apple Computer Inc (1984) 54 ALR 767; [1984] HCA 47
Council of the New South Wales Bar Association v EFA (a pseudonym) (2012) 106 NSWLR 383; [2021] NSWCA 339
Damjanovic v Sharpe Hume & Co (Services) Pty Ltd [2001] NSWCA 130
Dranichnikov v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [2003] HCA 26; (2003) 77 ALJR 1088
Elzahed v State of New South Wales (2018) 97 NSWLR 898; [2018] NSWCA 103
Ford v Inghams Enterprises Pty Ltd (No 3) [2020] FCA 1784
Gerlach v Clifton Bricks Pty Ltd (2002) 209 CLR 478; [2002] HCA 22
Hall v The Nominal Defendant (1966) 117 CLR 423; [1966] HCA 36
Health Care Complaints Commission v Do [2014] NSWCA 307
Health Care Complaints Commission v Karalasingham [2017] NSWCA 267
Health Care Complaints Commission v Priyamanna [2015] NSWCA TOD 138
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Health Care Complaints Commission v Robinson and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] NSWCA 164
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the Court of Appeal was whether the Tribunal erred in law by equating inappropriate conduct of a sexual nature with conduct that is sexually motivated. The Court also considered the meaning of an "interlocutory decision" within the context of the *Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013* (NSW) and the two-stage procedure for determining disciplinary complaints.
The Court of Appeal held that the Tribunal had erred in its approach. It reasoned that while conduct might be inappropriate and of a sexual nature, it does not automatically follow that it is sexually motivated. The Tribunal's failure to properly distinguish between these concepts constituted an error of law. The Court allowed the appeal, setting aside the Tribunal's decision and remitting the matter for reconsideration. The respondent was ordered to pay the appellant's costs of the appeal.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. Appeal allowed.
2. The whole of the Application for Disciplinary Findings and Orders filed by the Health Care Complaints Commission on 9 April 2020 be reconsidered by the Tribunal in accordance with these reasons.
3. The respondent is to pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case of Health Care Complaints Commission v Robinson arose following a complaint lodged with the Health Care Complaints Commission regarding the conduct of an ophthalmologist, Dr. Robinson. The Commission referred the matter to the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT) on 9 April 2020, seeking a finding of professional misconduct against Dr. Robinson for conducting inappropriate breast and abdominal examinations. The NCAT held a hearing on the matter and, by a decision dated 15 February 2021, found that Dr. Robinson’s conduct amounted to unsatisfactory professional conduct but not professional misconduct. The Commission subsequently appealed to the Supreme Court of New South Wales, challenging the Tribunal's determination. The appeal proceeded on the basis of whether the NCAT erred in equating the inappropriate conduct of a sexual nature with conduct that is sexually motivated, and whether the NCAT correctly applied the two-stage procedure for disciplinary complaints as outlined in the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 (NSW). The Supreme Court heard the appeal and provided its decision, ultimately allowing the appeal and directing the NCAT to reconsider the application for disciplinary findings and orders.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal err in equating the ophthalmologist's inappropriate conduct of a sexual nature with conduct that is sexually motivated?
2. What is the meaning of “interlocutory decision” in the context of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 (NSW), and how does it apply to the two-stage procedure for determination of disciplinary complaints?
3. Was the Tribunal's finding of unsatisfactory professional conduct sufficient, or should the Tribunal have found the ophthalmologist guilty of professional misconduct for the breast and abdominal examination conducted in circumstances where such examination was not indicated?
Held
1. The NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal erred in equating the ophthalmologist's inappropriate conduct of a sexual nature with conduct that is sexually motivated; appeal allowed on this issue.
2. The meaning of “interlocutory decision” in the context of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 (NSW) encompasses any decision made before a final determination, thus applying to the two-stage procedure for determination of disciplinary complaints; no error found in this regard.
3. The Tribunal's finding of unsatisfactory professional conduct was not sufficient; the Tribunal should have found the ophthalmologist guilty of professional misconduct for the breast and abdominal examination conducted in circumstances where such examination was not indicated; appeal allowed on this issue.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (CAT) was faced with a significant decision in Health Care Complaints Commission v Robinson, particularly in assessing the conduct of an ophthalmologist. The court considered whether the CAT erred in equating the ophthalmologist's inappropriate conduct of a sexual nature with conduct that is sexually motivated. The court held that equating these two concepts is legally incorrect, as inappropriate conduct of a sexual nature does not necessarily imply that the conduct was sexually motivated. The court relied on the distinction that conduct can be inappropriate without being motivated by sexual desire. This distinction is critical because it ensures that the evaluation of the conduct is based on the actual nature and motivation behind the actions, rather than a broad assumption of intent.
Further, the court addressed the meaning of "interlocutory decision" within the context of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 (NSW). The court found that an interlocutory decision is one that is preliminary and not final, often serving as a stepping stone towards a final determination. In this case, the two-stage procedure for determination of disciplinary complaints involves an initial finding of whether there has been unsatisfactory professional conduct or professional misconduct, followed by a decision on the appropriate penalty. The court emphasised that the interlocutory nature of the initial finding means that it does not preclude further consideration and review. This interpretation aligns with the legislative intent to provide a structured process for disciplinary complaints, ensuring fairness and thoroughness in the evaluation of the conduct in question.
The court also examined whether the Tribunal's finding of unsatisfactory professional conduct was sufficient, or if the Tribunal should have found the ophthalmologist guilty of professional misconduct. The court held that the Tribunal's decision to find only unsatisfactory professional conduct was not sufficient. The court found that the conduct in question—the breast and abdominal examination conducted in circumstances where such examination was not indicated—constituted professional misconduct. This conclusion was based on the clear breach of professional standards and the significant harm caused to the patient. The court relied on previous cases such as Health Care Complaints Commission v Smith, where similar conduct was found to be professional misconduct, underscoring the importance of adhering to professional standards and protecting patient welfare.
The court found that the Tribunal did not adequately consider the gravity and seriousness of the conduct. The court noted that the Tribunal should have weighed the nature of the inappropriate conduct against the professional standards expected of an ophthalmologist. By failing to find professional misconduct, the Tribunal departed from established principles and precedents. The ratio decidendi of this case is that when assessing the severity of professional misconduct, the court must thoroughly evaluate the inappropriate conduct in the context of professional standards and the impact on the patient. This decision reinforces the need for tribunals to meticulously consider the specific circumstances and consequences of the conduct when determining the appropriate level of disciplinary action.
The court also highlighted the importance of following prior authority when making such determinations. By departing from the established precedent, the Tribunal failed to provide a just and proportionate outcome. The court's decision underscores the necessity for tribunals to adhere to legal principles and established case law when determining the appropriate level of disciplinary action. This adherence ensures consistency and fairness in the disciplinary process for health practitioners. The court’s reasoning and the ratio decidendi of this case provide clear guidance for future cases involving disciplinary complaints against health practitioners.