Muyobe and Minister for Home Affairs (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

Muyobe and Minister for Home Affairs (Migration) [2019] AATA 108 (25 January 2019)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2018/6493

Re:Malipo Muyobe

APPLICANT

AndMinister for Home Affairs

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President S A Forgie

Date:25 January 2019

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal:

1.sets aside the decision dated 31 October 2018 made by a delegate of the respondent under s 501CA(4) of the Migration Act 1958 to refuse to revoke the cancellation of the applicant’s Class XB, Subclass 200 (Refugee) visa under s 501(3A); and

2.substitutes a decision that the decision to cancel the applicant’s Class XB, Subclass 200 (Refugee) visa under s 501(3A) of the Migration Act 1958 be revoked.

[sgd]....................................................................

S A FORGIE
Deputy President

MIGRATION – mandatory visa cancellation due to substantial criminal record - refusal to revoke mandatory cancellation – decision set aside.

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – section 500(6H) – limits imposed by requirement that information be previously set out in a written statement on information that may be presented orally – nature of a written statement – whether statement of facts, issues and contentions is a written statement - whether all information must be identified in written statement – whether extends to submissions made in support of applicant’s case – limits apply only to information given orally in support of applicant’s case and not to information given in response to questions on behalf of Minister or Tribunal.

LEGISLATION

Acts Interpretation Act 1901 s 15AA(1)
Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 ss 2A, 25(1), 25(2), 25(6), 29, 33, 33(1), 33(1)(a), 33(1)(b), 33(1)(c), 39(1), 42A(1B) and 42A(1B)
Bail Act 1990 (QLD) s 33(1)
Criminal Code Act 1899 s 215(5)

Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 s 264

Migration Act 1958 ss 5(1), 5H to 5M, 36, 36(1A) to 36(7), 48, 48A, 48B, 65, 65(1)(a)(iii), 195A, 197A, 197C, 198, 494, 499, 499(1), 499(2), 499(2A), 500, 500(6A) to 500(6H), 500(6J), 501, 501(1), 501(3), 501(3A), 501(3A)(a)(ii), 501(CA), 501CA(3), 501CA(4), 501CA(4)(b)(ii), 501G(1), 501(G(3) and 501(6)(e)

Police Powers and Responsibilities Act 2000 (QLD)
Sales Tax Assessment Act 1992 s 108(1)

Migration Regulations 1994 r 2.16(3)

CASES
Ali v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 650
Ayoub v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] FCAFC 83; (2015) 231 FCR 513
BCR16 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCAFC 96; [2017] 248 FCR 456; (2017) 248 FCR 456
Commissioner of Taxation v Hornibrook [2008] FCAFC 170; (2006) FCR 313; 65 ATR 1; 97 ALD 299
Dare v Pulham [1982] HCA 70; (1982) 148 CLR 658
Fieldhouse v DCT (1989) 25 FCR 187
Gaspar v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCA 1166
Goldie v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2001] FCA 1318; (2001) 111 FCR 378; 33 AAR 446
Goundar v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCA 1203
Grant v Repatriation Commission [1999] FCA 1629; (1999) 57 ALD 1
Holcon Australia Pty Ltd v The Corporation of the Town of Walkerville [2006] SCASC 437
Insurance and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Muyobe and Minister for Home Affairs (Migration) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 108
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerned an application by Mr Muyobe, the applicant, for the revocation of his visa cancellation. The Minister for Home Affairs, the respondent, had cancelled Mr Muyobe's visa. The dispute before Deputy S A Forgie P of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) involved the assessment of whether the cancellation of Mr Muyobe's visa should be revoked, considering various factors outlined in Direction No. 65.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were to determine the impact of the non-revocation of Mr Muyobe's visa cancellation on Australian business interests, and the impact on members of the Australian community, including victims of his criminal behaviour. The Tribunal was also required to consider the extent of any impediments Mr Muyobe might face if removed from Australia to his home country, taking into account his age, health, language and cultural barriers, and available support.

The Tribunal reasoned that Mr Muyobe's training in the security and construction industries, and his landscaping work, did not demonstrate a significant impact on Australian business interests if his visa cancellation was not revoked. The Tribunal found no evidence regarding the effect of non-revocation on victims of Mr Muyobe's crime or their families, noting that a Victim Impact Statement provided to the Director of Public Prosecutions did not address the specific issue before the Tribunal. The Tribunal also noted a lack of evidence concerning the impact on the Australian community generally, and that the likelihood of re-offending was better considered in the context of community protection. The Tribunal concluded that it lacked sufficient evidence to make findings on the impediments Mr Muyobe might face upon removal from Australia.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

What this passage shows is that the pleadings are the vehicle for stating the parties’ cases but it is not a vehicle for providing a statement or statements of the evidence. As the High Court said, the pleadings “… define the issues for decision in the litigation and thereby enable the relevance and admissibility of evidence to be determined at the trial …” (emphasis added). The evidence is separate from the issues. This was made clear by Stanley J in Nitschke v Foraco Australia Pty Ltd:[55]“A proper pleading will contain the material but not all the facts and will contain sufficient particulars being material facts necessary to give fair notice. Whether the material facts and whether sufficient particulars have been pleaded will depend upon the cause of action, the complexities of the case and the whole of the circumstances of the case.”[56] A SFIC shares similarities with pleadings. It is similar in that it sets out a statement of issues as each party sees them as well as each party’s contentions regarding those issues and the facts. Generally, a SFIC would not set out the evidence on which each party relies just as pleadings would not. Unlike pleadings in a court, SFICs lodged by the parties do not define the issues to be determined by the Tribunal in that case. The Tribunal has a duty to consider the issues raised by the relevant enactment and the material even when the those issues have not been raised by the parties in their SFICs or elsewhere. The Full Court of the Federal Court explained in in Grant v Repatriation Commission:[59]“An inquisitorial review conducted by the AAT ... is one in which the tribunal is required to determine the substantive issues raised by the material and evidence advanced before it and, in doing so, it is obliged not to limit its determination to the ‘case’ articulated by an applicant if the evidence and material which it accepts, or does not reject, raises a case on a basis not articulated by the applicant ...”[60][59] [1999] FCA 1629; (1999) 57 ALD 1; Merkel, Goldberg and Weinberg JJ[60] [1999] FCA 1629; (1999) 57 ALD 1 at [18]; 6 That said, it does not seem to me that a discussion about any similarities or differences between pleadings in a court and a SFIC in the Tribunal leads me to conclude that a SFIC satisfies the requirements of s 500(6H) as setting out information in a written statement. Whether it does so, depends on its contents and whether those contents can be characterised as “information” for the SFIC is clearly a written statement. I will begin with the nature of the contentions that have been made in the Applicant’s SFIC. I set out the meaning of “contend” at [42] above. Contentions made in that SFIC are certainly information in the sense that they provide knowledge of the contentions. The Minister has been made aware that this is Mr Muyobe’s contention but can that contention be relied upon to support the proposition that his oral evidence and that of his mother regarding how he has been active in that parental role may be relied upon in light of s 500(6H)? As I said in Carmichael, whether or not information has been set out in any written statement given to the Minister is a matter of fact and degree.A written statement may take any form and need not be a witness statement. It may be a statement of the witness who is giving oral evidence or a statement that was made for a different purpose but is included either in the G documents or in other material given to the Minister and lodged in the Tribunal. It may be referred to in a report as having been said by that witness on another occasion. The essential requirement if s 500(6H) is that the Minister has been given the information in writing and has had two or more business days to consider it. He has had that opportunity in whatever form the written statement takes.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Paragraph 14.3(1) of Direction No. 65 states:“Impact on Australian business interests if the non-citizen’s visa cancellation is not revoked, noting that an employment link would generally only be given weight where non-revocation would significantly compromise the delivery of a major project, or delivery of an important service in Australia.”C.1 Consideration The cancellation of Mr Muyobe’s visa and the non-revocation of that cancellation would not have any effect on Australian business interests. He has had training in the security industry but has never obtained employment in that field. He has also held a traineeship in the construction industry and undertaken some work in that field as well as a few months undertaking landscaping work. I am not satisfied that the continuing cancellation of Mr Muyobe’s refugee visa would significantly compromise the delivery of a major project or an important service in Australia. It would not have any impact on Australian business interests. At paragraph 14.4(1), Direction No. 65 states:“Impact of a decision not to revoke on members of the Australian community, including victims of the non-citizen’s criminal behaviour, and the family members of the victim or victims where that information is available and the non-citizen being considered for revocation has been afforded procedural fairness.” I do not have any evidence regarding the effect of a decision not to revoke the cancellation of Mr Muyobe’s visa on the victims of his crime and the family members of those victims. The sentencing remarks by Judge Read and Judge Rendlit did not refer to the impact on the young girl. She had submitted a Victim Impact Statement to the Director of Public Prosecutions in Queensland addressing the effect of Mr Muyobe’s offence on her but Mr Cunynghame, quite properly in my view, did not rely on it. Understandably because it was directed to that issue, it did not address the issue I must consider. Apart from the impact on members of the Australian community generally, the issue I must consider is focused on the impact of a decision not to revoke the cancellation of Mr Muyobe’s cancellation visa on the victim of his offence. A decision not to revoke the cancellation of his refugee visa would ultimately leave Mr Muyobe in detention. I do not have any evidence of the impact that would have on members of the Australian community. Equally, I do not have any evidence of the impact if the cancellation decision were revoked. Apart from any views that might be expressed, and I think that they are better addressed in the context of the expectations of the Australian community, any impact would come about from the likelihood of Mr Muyobe’s re-offending. The impact of any re-offending is better considered in the context of the protection of the Australian community. Direction No. 65 also states in paragraph 14.5(1) that:“The extent of any impediments that the non-citizen may face if removed from Australia to their home country, in establishing themselves and maintaining basic living standards (in the context of what is generally available to other citizens of that country), taking into account:a)The non-citizen’s age and health;b)Whether there are substantial language or cultural barriers; andc)Any social, medical and/or economic support available to them in that country.”