Munkara v Santos NA Barossa Pty Ltd (No 5)

Link copied
Case Copied 58 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Munkara v Santos NA Barossa Pty Ltd (No 5) [2024] FCA 717  

File number: VID 907 of 2023
Judgment of: CHARLESWORTH J
Date of judgment: 4 July 2024
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for leave to issue subpoenas to support an application for costs against a lawyer representing unsuccessful parties to a proceeding – whether submissions foreshadowed in support of the costs application have a sufficient foundation in the evidence to warrant consideration – whether documents sought on the subpoenas might reasonably be expected to shed light on those issues arising on the costs application as presently framed – whether the subpoenas constitute an abuse of process because they are oppressive – considerations of proportionality in the exercise of the discretion to grant leave for the subpoenas to issue – application allowed in part   
Legislation: Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 37M
Cases cited:

Anderson v Canaccord Genuity Financial Ltd (No 2) [2022] NSWSC 649

Australian Gas Light Company ACN 052 167 405 v Australian Competition & Consumer Commission [2003] FCA 110

Lemoto v Able Technical Pty Ltd (2005) 63 NSWLR 300

Munkara v Santos NA Barossa Pty Ltd (No 3) [2024] FCA 9

Munkara v Santos NA Barossa Pty Ltd (No 4) [2024] FCA 414

Patonga Beach Holdings Pty Ltd v Lyons [2009] NSWSC 869

Division: General Division
Registry: Victoria
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Number of paragraphs: 107
Date of last submissions: Respondent:   7 June 2024
Interested parties:  23 May 2024
Environmental Defenders Office (Ltd):  21 May 2024
Date of hearing: 12 June 2024
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr N Kirby
Solicitor for the Applicants: Maurice Blackburn
Counsel for the Respondent: Ms V Whittaker SC with Mr A Hochroth and Ms H Lenigas
Solicitor for the Respondent: Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan
Counsel for The Environmental Defenders Office (Ltd): Mr M Brady with Ms D Tang
Solicitor for The Environmental Defenders Office (Ltd): Gilchrist Connell
Counsel for Jubilee Australia Research Centre Ltd, The Sunrise Project Australia Limited and Environment Centre (N.T.) Inc: Ms Z Heger
Solicitor for Jubilee Australia Research Centre Ltd, The Sunrise Project Australia Limited and Environment Centre (N.T.) Inc: Marque Lawyers

ORDERS

VID 907 of 2023
BETWEEN:

SIMON MUNKARA

First Applicant

CAROL MARIA PURUNTATAMERI

Second Applicant

MARIA SIMPLICIA PURTANINGA TIPUAMANTUMIRRI

Third Applicant

AND:

SANTOS NA BAROSSA PTY LTD ACN 109 974 932

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

CHARLESWORTH J

DATE OF ORDER:

4 JULY 2024

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The respondent has leave to amend the interlocutory application dated 22 April 2024  (application) so as to substitute category 22 in Annexure A with the words reproduced at [11] of the affidavit of Michelle Fox affirmed on 14 May 2024.

2.Subject to paragraph 5, the respondent has leave to issue a subpoena to the Environmental Defenders Office Ltd in the form of Annexure A to the application.

3.Subject to paragraph 5, the respondent has leave to issue a subpoena to Dr Michael O’Leary in the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Munkara v Santos NA Barossa Pty Ltd (No 5) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 717
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Santos NA Barossa Pty Ltd applied for leave to issue subpoenas to support an application for costs against a lawyer representing unsuccessful parties to the proceeding. The Federal Court was required to determine whether the submissions made in support of the costs application had a sufficient foundation in the evidence to warrant consideration and whether the documents sought on the subpoenas might reasonably be expected to shed light on the issues arising on the costs application as presently framed. The Court also had to consider whether the subpoenas constituted an abuse of process because they were oppressive and whether the exercise of the discretion to grant leave for the subpoenas to issue was proportionate.

The Court found that the submissions made in support of the costs application had a sufficient foundation in the evidence to warrant consideration, and the documents sought on the subpoenas might reasonably be expected to shed light on the issues arising on the costs application. The Court noted that the subpoenas did not constitute an abuse of process because they were not oppressive. The Court also found that the exercise of the discretion to grant leave for the subpoenas to issue was proportionate. The Court allowed the application in part and granted leave to issue the subpoenas, subject to certain conditions and limitations.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The respondent has leave to amend the interlocutory application dated 22 April 2024 (application) so as to substitute category 22 in Annexure A with the words reproduced at [11] of the affidavit of Michelle Fox affirmed on 14 May 2024.

2. Subject to paragraph 5, the respondent has leave to issue a subpoena to the Environmental Defenders Office Ltd in the form of Annexure A to the application.

3. Subject to paragraph 5, the respondent has leave to issue a subpoena to Dr Michael O’Leary in the form of Annexure B to the application.

4. Subject to paragraph 5, the respondent has leave to issue a subpoena to Mr Gareth Lewis in the form of Annexure C to the application.

5. The leave in paragraphs 2 to 4 is subject to the following:

(a) the proposed subpoena in Annexure A is to be varied as follows:

(i) delete categories 2, 3, 4, 6, 7, 8, 10, 11, 12, 14, 15, 16, 17 and 25;

(ii) add to category 13 the words “in connection with”, followed by the same subject matters listed at (a) to (l) of category 21, and the concluding words “up to and including 22 December 2023”;

(iii) add to category 21 the words “between and including 15 September 2022 and 22 December 2023”;

(iv) delete from category 22 (as amended) the words “Market Forces Limited” and substitute the words “after November 2022” with the words “between and including 1 December 2022 and 22 December 2023”;

(v) add to categories 18, 19, 20, 23 and 24 the concluding words “up to and including 22 December 2023”.

(b) the proposed subpoena in Annexure B is to be varied as follows:

(i) delete categories 2, 3, 4 and 5;

(ii) add to categories 9, 10 and 11 the words “between and including 15 September 2022 and 22 December 2023”;

(iii) add to categories 5, 6, 7 and 8 the concluding words “up to and including 22 December 2023”.

(c) the proposed subpoena in Annexure C is to be varied as follows:

(i) delete categories 2, 3 and 4;

(ii) add to categories 8 and 9 the words “between and including 15 September 2022 and 22 December 2023”;

(iii) add to categories 5, 6 and 7 the concluding words “up to and including 22 December 2023”.

(d) each subpoena is to specify a date for service not later than 11 July 2024; and

(e) each subpoena is to specify a return date not later than 22 August 2024.

6. Any claim of legal professional privilege in any material contained in any documents described in the subpoenas referred to in paragraphs 2 to 4 is to be made in the following manner:

(a) the documents subject to the claim are to be described in a numbered list containing the following details:

(i) the date of the communication;

(ii) the purpose(s) of the communication;

(iii) all parties to the communication; and

(iv) if the communication has since been disclosed to any person (other than the original parties to the communication), the identity of the person and the purpose of the disclosure;

(b) the list in paragraph 6(a) is to be annexed to an affidavit deposing to its truth;

(c) the affidavit referred to in paragraph 6(b) is to be returned together with any documents in response to the subpoena;

(d) if the privilege claim relates to part of a document, the part that is subject to the claim is to be redacted and the redacted version is to be produced in response to the subpoena;

(e) until further order the documents subject to any claim (whether in whole or in part) are otherwise to be placed in an envelope and maintained in the possession of the addressee or the addressee’s legal representative.

7. The parties and the addressees have liberty to apply to vary the order in paragraph 6, such liberty to be exercised on or before 9 August 2024.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Following judgment in Munkara 4, each of Jubilee Australia, ECNT and Sunrise Project sought leave to appeal from the judgment. On the day of argument on the present application, Santos informed the Court that it “does not press” the subpoenas addressed to those entities. In light of that withdrawal, the Court granted those organisations a limited audience in respect of one category of documents now sought by the proposed subpoena addressed to EDO Lawyers.Evidence and submissions Santos relies on evidence contained in a Court Book dated 12 June 2024. It submits that the evidence provides a reasonable basis for the issue of subpoenas for documents that may further illuminate the relationship between EDO Lawyers and the litigation. Its position on the costs application is (at least) that EDO Lawyers is an environmental activist organisation in its own right and that the applicants’ claim in this proceeding formed a part of its own strategy to stop the construction of the pipeline and the Barossa Project more generally. It submits that the evidence presently in its possession shows that:(1)EDO Lawyers partially funded the applicants’ case;(2)EDO Lawyers engages in environmental activism with the express object of stopping the Barossa Project forming the subject of the proceeding, evidenced in part by its participation in a campaign with other activist organisations titled “Stop Barossa Gas”;(3)EDO Lawyers engaged in crowdfunding activities to meet the expenses of litigation directed to stopping the Barossa Project;(4)EDO Lawyers had dealings with the authors of the Knowing Sea Country Report having the consequences described in Munkara 3 (at [119], [896] and [1089]); and(5)EDO Lawyers was responsible for commissioning and putting before the Court expert reports that were rejected by the Court as unsound, including because of issues affecting the experts’ professional independence. Santos relies upon passages of the reasons in Munkara 3, conveniently summarised (without challenge) in its written submissions as follows (at [3.3]):(a)The finding of partial confection or construction of the applicants’ case with respect to the intangibles case at J[1025] to [1028] … and the analysis that follows which identifies the cultural mapping process as lacking integrity and unable to be relied upon by the Court.(b)The findings about the critical May Lewis Meeting and the June O’Leary Workshops, conducted with the EDO, and the witness coaching that occurred there (e.g. J[994], [1117] to [1135] and [1143] to [1170]).(c)The findings about how the cultural mapping exercise also undermined the evidence of the Tiwi islanders who participated in it (J[1027]).(d)The findings that the ‘independent experts’ put forward by the EDO for the applicants were not, they were partisan (e.g. J[1139]).(e)The findings about the role of the EDO lawyer at the May Lewis Meeting and the June O’Leary Workshop, including the following at J [1168] to [1170]:Most concerningly, I consider that Video 39 depicts what could only be described as the EDO lawyer drawing on the map in a way that could not on any reasonable view truthfully reflect what the Tiwi informant had said. In addition, the EDO lawyer stated, ‘that’s where the sea starts’. That is a curious statement, given that the map is intended to reflect a territorial landscape within which there was a freshwater lake. At the time that the sea ‘started there’ it could not be a freshwater source. The informant said ‘into the sea’ which could only be understood as something going into the sea from the island coast. The EDO lawyer created her own marking on the map and then reinforced it, ending the line in what is then referred to in a document drafted by the EDO as the ‘sacred freshwater source’. That line now appears in the so-called cultural map and is presented to this Court as evidence in Dr O’Leary’s Figure 7A (Map 4) above.The material supports an inference that Indigenous instructions have been distorted and manipulated before being presented to this Court via an expert report, and I so find.The EDO lawyer was not called to give evidence. That does not preclude the Court from acting on the evidence before it, given that the applicants’ onus includes an onus to persuade the Court that the cultural mapping exercise is scientifically sound and otherwise reliable. The content of Video 39 alone is sufficient to reduce the integrity and hence the reliability of the cultural mapping exercise to nought.(f)The findings that expert reports could not be relied on because of the process involving coaching (e.g. J[994]).(g)The finding that her Honour’s conclusions about the conduct of the EDO lawyer who attended the June O’Leary Workshop caused her Honour to approach the EDO Synthesized Narratives (given as an assumption to all experts) with extreme caution (J[1179]).(h)Her Honour’s ultimate finding that the flaws in the cultural mapping exercise were so flawed that they contaminated the EDO Synthesized Narrative document and rendered it forensically useless (J[1181]).(i)The finding that the 2023 Marie Munkara Narratives are capable of supporting an inference that Marie Munkara was acutely aware of the objective of stopping the pipeline and, in addition, that she had had regard to the maps created by Dr O’Leary at the time that she prepared her narratives so as to match the narratives to the submerged landscape (J[1177]).

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.