Mullavey v Verri

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Mullavey v Verri & Ors [2016] QSC 83

PARTIES:

BRYAN WALTER MULLAVEY

(Respondent/Plaintiff)

v
RONALD DOUGLAS VERRI
(Applicant/First Defendant)
and
DEBRA JEANETTE CENTRA
(Second Defendant)
and
SIDNEY CENTRA and ISAAC CENTRA by their litigation guardian DEBRA JEANETTE CENTRA

(Third Defendants)

FILE NO/S:

SC No 104 of 2014

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Cairns

DELIVERED ON:

11 April 2016

DELIVERED AT:

Mackay

HEARING DATE:

13 November 2015, 7 December 2015

JUDGE:

Henry J

ORDER:

1.   That component of the application seeking the grant of probate of the will dated 6 August 2010, with or without the codicil dated 11 March 2011, is dismissed.

2.   The balance of the application is adjourned for further hearing in conjunction with the hearing of the claim.

3.   I will hear the parties as to costs and as to directions calculated to expedite the hearing of the claim and balance of the application at 9.15am 20 April 2016 (out of town parties have leave to appear by telephone on that date).

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – ENDING PROCEEDINGS EARLY – SUMMARY DISPOSAL – SUMMARY JUDGMENT FOR DEFENDANT OR RESPONDENT: STAY OR DISMISSAL OF PROCEEDINGS – where the applicant seeks a declaration for the force and validity of one of various wills – where the respondent and applicant were each beneficiaries under the various wills of the testator – where a dispute emerges between the respondent and applicant regarding the validity of the last will in time – where the respondent claims the testator was not of sound mind, memory and understanding - where the respondent claims the testator did not know and approve the contents of the will and codicil – where the court held there was a lack of relevant information before it regarding the testator’s understanding of certain alleged aspects of the Will

SUCCESSION – MAKING OF A WILL – TESTAMENTARY CAPACITY – EVIDENCE – ONUS OF PROOF AND WEIGHT OF EVIDENCE - where the applicant seeks a declaration for the force and validity of one of various wills – where the respondent and applicant were each beneficiaries under the various wills of the testator – where a dispute emerges between the respondent and applicant regarding the validity of the last will in time – whether the respondent has a real prospect of successfully raising a well-grounded suspicion the testator lacked testamentary capacity

SUCCESSION – MAKING OF A WILL – TESTAMENTARY CAPACITY – EVIDENCE – ONUS OF PROOF AND WEIGHT OF EVIDENCE - where the applicant seeks a declaration for the force and validity of one of various wills – where the respondent and applicant were each beneficiaries under the various wills of the testator – where a dispute emerges between the respondent and applicant regarding the validity of the last will in time – whether the testator did not know and approve the contents of the will and codicil

Power of Attorney Act 1998 (Qld), s 87

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mullavey v Verri and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] QSC 83
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Mullavey v Verri, the court was presented with a dispute concerning the validity of the last will in time executed by the deceased testator. The applicant, who was a beneficiary under the various wills, sought a declaration regarding the force and validity of the will dated 6 August 2010. The respondent, who was also a beneficiary, challenged the validity of the will, arguing that the testator lacked testamentary capacity and did not know or approve the contents of the will and its codicil. The case required the court to determine whether there was a real prospect of the respondent successfully raising a suspicion that the testator lacked testamentary capacity at the time of executing the will.

The legal issues before the court included the onus of proof and the weight of evidence regarding the testator's testamentary capacity and knowledge and approval of the will's contents. The court had to consider whether the respondent had provided sufficient evidence to raise a well-grounded suspicion that the testator lacked testamentary capacity and whether there was a lack of relevant information before the court regarding the testator's understanding of the will's contents. The court had to balance the onus of proof on the respondent to demonstrate a real prospect of success in raising the suspicion, against the applicant's entitlement to a declaration of the will's validity.

The court concluded that there was insufficient evidence before it to determine whether the respondent had a real prospect of successfully raising a suspicion that the testator lacked testamentary capacity. The court found that there was a lack of relevant information regarding the testator's understanding of certain aspects of the will. Consequently, the court dismissed the component of the application seeking the grant of probate of the will dated 6 August 2010, with or without the codicil dated 11 March 2011. The balance of the application was adjourned for further hearing in conjunction with the hearing of the claim, with the parties to be heard regarding costs and directions to expedite the hearing of the claim.

The court's orders included dismissing the component of the application seeking the grant of probate of the will dated 6 August 2010, with or without the codicil dated 11 March 2011, and adjourning the balance of the application for further hearing in conjunction with the hearing of the claim. The court also scheduled a hearing regarding costs and directions to expedite the hearing of the claim and balance of the application, allowing out-of-town parties to appear by telephone.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. That component of the application seeking the grant of probate of the will dated 6 August 2010, with or without the codicil dated 11 March 2011, is dismissed.

2. The balance of the application is adjourned for further hearing in conjunction with the hearing of the claim.

3. I will hear the parties as to costs and as to directions calculated to expedite the hearing of the claim and balance of the application at 9.15am 20 April 2016 (out of town parties have leave to appear by telephone on that date).

Background

Background to the litigation

Before examining the validity and construction issues to which the application gives rise it is necessary to give them some broader factual context.Facts The testator died on 22 May 2013 aged 99. His wife died four years earlier, aged 93. The respondent, who has resided in China since 2009, was their only son. The applicant, who lives in Mossman and succeeded the testator on the board of the Mossman Mill, was a longstanding friend of the testator. The respondent and the applicant were each beneficiaries under the various wills of the testator.The most recent will In his final will, dated 6 August 2010, the testator left $100,000 to his granddaughter, Debra Jeanette Centra, his share in his company KM & WE Mullavey Investment COY Pty Ltd (“the company”) to the applicant and the residue of his estate to the respondent.[2][2] Affidavit of Michael Bolt ex MFB-1. His will contemplated the money in the company’s two investment accounts would be shared in equally by the applicant and the respondent. The company accounts held several million dollars. The testator’s words suggest he regarded the company’s money as his own but understood the legal reality that the money was owned by the company. The will relevantly provided: “4.1 I HOLD TWO National Bank Investment accounts in the name and style of KM & WE Mullavey Investment COY Pty Ltd ACN 011 017 100 (herein after referred to as ‘the company’) numbered 83-622-0740 and 57-103-5856 I direct that these two accounts are to be shared equally between my son BRYAN WALTER MULLAVEY and RONALD DOUGLAS VERRI.4.2 AS THE ACCOUNTS are held by the company I direct that my share in the company be transferred to RONALD DOUGLAS VERRI with the result that my son BRYAN WALTER MULLAVEY and RONALD DOUGLAS VERRI will each hold a one equal share in the company.4.3 I FURTHER DIRECT that RONALD DOUGLAS VERRI be appointed joint and equal director of the company.4.4 THE ACCOUNTS are then to be distributed in accordance with clause 4.1 of my Will and following the distribution of those accounts to my son BRYAN WALTER MULLAVEY and RONALD DOUGLAS VERRI in equal shares then it would be appropriate for the company to be wound up or if my son BRYAN WALTER MULLAVEY desired to continue to operate the company then it would be appropriate for RONALD DOUGLAS VERRI to transfer to my son BRYAN WALTER MULLAVEY or his nominee his shareholding in the company and for RONALD DOUGLAS VERRI to resign as director of the company.” Initially the testator and his wife had held the two shares in the company. After her death on 1 May 2009 the testator, who apparently was to have inherited his wife’s share, transferred the share directly to his son, the respondent, commenting that the respondent would eventually inherit the company anyway. The final will signifies a clear change in that intention.The codicil The codicil of 11 March 2011 did not affect a material change to the dispositions in the final will. It merely varied the final will’s description of the company’s investment accounts to a more generic description, to cater for variations in accounts held by the company. It relevantly provided:“2. At paragraph 4.1 of my Will I have referred to two (2) National Bank accounts held by my family company in the name and style of KM & WE Mullavey Investments Co Pty Ltd ACN 011 017 100 (“the company”).3. In clause 4.1 of my Will there is an account referred to as number 83-622 0740. This account has been closed and a substitute account has been opened in its place.4. I anticipate that the two (2) major investment accounts may change in number at some stage in the future and in order to avoid confusion I state that it is my direction that all accounts in the name of the Company are to be shared equally between my son Bryan Walter Mullavey and Ronald Douglas Verri.”The earlier wills

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

It follows that component of the application relating to the validity issue ought be dismissed. Conclusion For the above reasons, that component of the application seeking the grant of probate of the final will, with or without the codicil, should be dismissed and the balance of the application should be adjourned for further hearing in conjunction with the hearing of the claim. Given the conduct of this matter to date it appears unlikely that much more disclosure is required, with the exception of evidence about the debt, and the expeditious hearing of the claim can likely be accommodated by appropriate directions. It will be necessary to hear the parties as to costs and as to directions calculated to expedite the hearing of the claim and balance of the application.Order My orders are:1.That component of the application seeking the grant of probate of the will dated 6 August 2010, with or without the codicil dated 11 March 2011, is dismissed.2.The balance of the application is adjourned for further hearing in conjunction with the hearing of the claim.3.I will hear the parties as to costs and as to directions calculated to expedite the hearing of the claim and balance of the application at 9.15am 20 April 2016 (out of town parties have leave to appear by telephone on that date).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established