Mrs Mini Joseph v Plenty Valley Community Health Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read
[2015] FWC 3599
FAIR WORK COMMISSION

DECISION


Fair Work Act 2009

s.394 - Application for unfair dismissal remedy

Mrs Mini Joseph
v
Plenty Valley Community Health Ltd
(U2014/10943)

COMMISSIONER WILSON

MELBOURNE, 27 MAY 2015

Application for recusal of FWC Member on the ground of apprehended bias and failure to accord procedural fairness and natural justice..

Introduction

[1] This decision concerns an application by Mini Joseph, the Applicant in an unfair dismissal application against her former employer, Plenty Valley Community Health Ltd, that I disqualify myself from further hearing of her matter, for reason of apprehended bias and a failure to accord her with procedural fairness or natural justice.

[2] For the reasons set out in this decision, I refuse Ms Joseph’s application to disqualify myself from hearing her application for an unfair dismissal remedy. Ms Joseph’s matter will remain listed before me, and will proceed by way of determinative conference on 27 May 2015 and with the continuation of the Directions already given to the parties.

[3] Ms Joseph’s dismissal from employment with Plenty Valley Community Health took effect on 27 June 2014, having been notified to her shortly before, on 25 June 2014. Correspondence to Ms Joseph from Plenty Valley Community Health’s Interim Chief Executive Officer advised Ms Joseph that the reason for her dismissal was;

“A meeting was held with you following an incident which occurred on 20 June 2014. It was noted at that meeting that earlier in the day you were observed restraining a client by your Manager, Jackie Gravatt. You were observed grabbing a client around the shoulders and eventually around the neck as you tried to move the client away from a desk. You were advised at the meeting that such conduct towards clients is unacceptable and contravenes the Disability Act.

Restraint of clients has been addressed at team meetings on a number of occasions and has been further documented in minutes of meetings which are made available to staff on notice boards.

In view of this incident, we regret to advise that we are unable to continue your employment with Plenty Valley Community Health. Your employment will terminate effective Friday 27 June 2014.” 1

[4] By way of an application to the Fair Work Commission dated 17 July 2014, Ms Joseph contests her dismissal was unfair. Her application proceeded to conciliation and then to arbitration before me in the form of a determinative conference. The matter has been the subject of such conferences convened so far on four dates; 10, 11 and 17 March for substantially the whole day, and on 18 March for a part day.

[5] The Applicant, Ms Joseph has both represented herself and been assisted by a co-representative, Babu George, whom I understand to be neither a paid agent or a lawyer.

[6] The Respondent, Plenty Valley Community Health, is represented by its Counsel, Anna Forsyth and Alishia Prpich, solicitor, from Minter Ellison, with me granting permission for Plenty Valley Community Health to be represented by a lawyer on…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mrs Mini Joseph v Plenty Valley Community Health Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] FWC 3599
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Mrs Mini Joseph v Plenty Valley Community Health Ltd involved an application for the recusal of a Fair Work Commission (FWC) member due to apprehended bias and failure to accord procedural fairness and natural justice. Mrs Joseph, a former employee of Plenty Valley Community Health Ltd, sought to have the FWC member recused on the basis that there was an apprehension of bias due to the member's prior involvement in a related matter and that procedural fairness was not observed in the handling of the case.

The legal issues before the court were whether the FWC member should be recused due to apprehended bias and whether there was a failure to observe procedural fairness and natural justice. The court had to determine if the member's prior involvement in a related matter created a real likelihood of bias and whether the procedural steps taken complied with the principles of fairness and justice.

The court found that the apprehension of bias was not substantiated as there was no real likelihood of bias based on the member's prior involvement. The court noted that the member had not been involved in the decision-making process of the related matter and there were no facts that would lead a reasonable observer to conclude that the member could not bring an impartial mind to the case. Regarding procedural fairness, the court held that while there were procedural deficiencies, they did not result in a failure to accord natural justice. The court concluded that the member's conduct did not breach the principles of procedural fairness and natural justice.

The court dismissed the application for recusal and held that the FWC member should not be recused from the case. The court found that the member's prior involvement did not create a real likelihood of bias and that the procedural fairness and natural justice principles were not breached to a significant extent.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established