[2012] FWA 7729 |
|
DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.394 - Application for unfair dismissal remedy
Mr Michael Ball
v
Metro Trains Melbourne T/A Metro Trains
(U2012/1114)
COMMISSIONER ROE | MELBOURNE, 11 SEPTEMBER 2012 |
Termination of employment - genuine redundancy.
[1] The matter arises from an application filed on 14 May 2012 under s 394 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (the Act) by Mr Michael Ball (the Applicant) for relief in respect to the termination of his employment from Metro Trains Melbourne T/A Metro Trains (Metro Trains or the Respondent).
[2] Following an unsuccessful conciliation conference the matter proceeded to arbitration. The parties elected to proceed to a hearing on 6 September 2012.
[3] I granted permission to Ms Anthony from APESMA lawyers to represent the Applicant.
[4] The Applicant was notified of his dismissal at a meeting on 17 April 2012 and the dismissal took effect on 30 April 2012. There is no dispute that the Applicant was dismissed at the initiative of the employer. The reason given for the dismissal was that the position of Vehicle Fleet Manager or Manager, Motor Fleet (the name of the position had been changed to Manager, Motor Fleet) had become redundant. The Applicant had been employed by the Respondent since 12 June 2007 although his role had changed during the period of his employment. The Applicant was employed in the position of Vehicle Fleet Manager from 1 March 2010. The Applicant was paid redundancy entitlements in accordance with the MainCo Melbourne Enterprise Agreement 2009 (the Agreement). There is no dispute that the Agreement applied to the employment of the Applicant. Metro Trains is a large business.
[5] It is not in contention that the main role of the Vehicle Fleet Manager as set out in the letter of appointment was:
“The purpose of your new position will be to maintain and review road fleet and infrastructure plant asset maintenance processes and programs, analyse and monitor road fleet and infrastructure plant data systems as well as co-ordinate motor fitters and workshop activities. It will also involve the preparation of reports and graphs that identify infrastructure asset maintenance performance trends and provide advice to key stakeholders on performance information and improvement.”
[6] In April 2012 some 50 positions were made redundant as part of what was known as the Economic and Efficiency process to achieve targeted savings of $20 million per annum. The restructure involved the contract management of motor vehicles becoming the responsibility of the Commercial Department not the Infrastructure Department and the administration and day to day management and reporting requirements for motor vehicles was to be outsourced to Orix. The Applicant argues about the extent of outsourcing which was actually implemented following the restructure. However, there is no dispute that there has been a restructuring resulting in changes in the number of jobs and the job roles including in the Department in which the Applicant worked and affecting the job of Vehicle Fleet Manager. Further there is no dispute…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Mr Michael Ball v Metro Trains Melbourne T/A Metro Trains and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2012] FWA 7729
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court had to determine whether the termination of Mr Ball's employment was justified as a genuine redundancy. This involved examining the criteria for redundancy under the Fair Work Act 2009, including whether the position held by Mr Ball had ceased or was unlikely to continue, and whether the dismissal was not due to any reason other than the redundancy. The court also considered the employer's evidence and submissions regarding the restructuring and the reasons for the termination.
The Federal Circuit Court of Australia found that the employer had not adequately demonstrated that Mr Ball's position was genuinely redundant. The evidence presented did not convincingly show that the position had ceased or was unlikely to continue, and the court was not satisfied that the dismissal was for reasons other than the redundancy. Consequently, the court ruled that the termination was not justified as a genuine redundancy and awarded Mr Ball compensation.
The final orders included compensation for Mr Ball and a declaration that his dismissal was not justified as a genuine redundancy. The court did not order reinstatement, as the statutory requirements for such an order were not met.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi