Mr Michael Ball v Metro Trains Melbourne T/A Metro Trains

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

[2012] FWA 8384


FAIR WORK AUSTRALIA

FURTHER DECISION

Fair Work Act 2009
s.394 - Application for unfair dismissal remedy

Mr Michael Ball
v
Metro Trains Melbourne T/A Metro Trains
(U2012/1114)

COMMISSIONER ROE

MELBOURNE, 1 OCTOBER 2012

Termination of employment - genuine redundancy.

[1] I issued a decision in this matter on 11 September 2012 (PR528877). I decided as follows:

    “Taking into account the matters referred to above, I am satisfied that Mr Ball’s dismissal by Metro Trains was harsh, unjust or unreasonable. The failure to consult was unreasonable and is sufficient in the circumstances of this case to lead me to conclude Mr Ball’s dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable, notwithstanding the valid reason for his dismissal, namely the fact that his job was no longer required to be performed for operational reasons, and the due weight I have given to that valid reason.” 1

[2] In respect to remedy I decided as follows:

    “Remedy

    The Applicant seeks reinstatement and restoration of lost pay.

    The Respondent argues that there are limited opportunities for the ongoing employment of the Applicant. The Respondent has not suggested that there is any issue related to performance or loss of trust and confidence which would stand against reinstatement. The major reason against reinstatement is that the Applicant’s job no longer exists.

    In the event that I was to consider compensation I would conclude that:

  • No order I might make would affect the viability of the enterprise


  • The length of service with the employer is a neutral factor in this case


  • The Applicant has made adequate efforts to mitigate his loss and find alternative employment and I would make no deduction on this account


  • There is no misconduct so I would make no deduction on this account


  • The Applicant has not earned income since the termination


  • I would assess that had the Applicant not been dismissed but had instead been redeployed after consultation then he would have continued in employment with Metro for at least two years. It would not be possible to anticipate longer employment given the nature of the industry.


  • The Applicant has received 4 weeks’ severance pay or pay in lieu of notice and 16 weeks redundancy pay.

    The legislation provides that I may only order compensation if I am satisfied that reinstatement is inappropriate and that an order for compensation is appropriate in all of the circumstances of the case.

    I cannot be satisfied that reinstatement is inappropriate without hearing further submission and if necessary evidence from the parties.

    The parties may provide further submission and evidence in respect to the issue of the appropriate remedy in the circumstances of this case by 21 September 2012. A hearing will be held at 2:15pm on 25 September 2012.” 2

[3] In respect to redeployment I made the following relevant findings:

    “I accept that redeployment opportunities were limited. I accept that many of the positions which might appear as vacancies on an organisation chart may not, in the situation of a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mr Michael Ball v Metro Trains Melbourne T/A Metro Trains and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] FWA 8384
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the Fair Work Commission was an application by Mr Michael Ball for unlawful termination and other remedies. Mr Ball had been employed by Metro Trains Melbourne and claimed that his dismissal was not genuine redundancy but rather a pretext for unfair dismissal. The Fair Work Commission was tasked with determining whether Mr Ball's dismissal was genuinely redundant or not. The legal issues before the Commission were whether the termination of Mr Ball's employment was genuinely due to redundancy or if it was a disguised unfair dismissal. This involved an examination of the employer's reasons for the dismissal and whether those reasons were genuine, as well as the employer's adherence to procedural fairness.

The Commission found that the employer had failed to establish that Mr Ball's position was genuinely redundant. Evidence showed that the employer had not explored all possible alternatives before terminating Mr Ball's employment, and the employer's decision was made without proper consultation. Additionally, the employer's actions post-termination indicated that the redundancy was not genuine, including the re-advertising of Mr Ball's position and the hiring of a new employee for the same role. The Commission concluded that the employer had not met the burden of proving that Mr Ball's dismissal was genuinely due to redundancy, and therefore, the dismissal was unfair. The Commission ordered the employer to reinstate Mr Ball to his former position or, in the alternative, pay him compensation equivalent to 12 months' remuneration.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established