MQMV and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

MQMV and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2018] AATA 2924 (17 August 2018)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:           2017/7060

Re:MQMV

APPLICANT

AndChild Support Registrar

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President Rayment QC

Date:17 August 2018

Place:Sydney

The Tribunal has jurisdiction to review the decision of the Social Security & Child Support Division of this Tribunal dated 2 November 2017.

....................................[SGD]....................................

Deputy President Rayment QC


Names used in all published decisions are pseudonyms. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been removed from this decision and replaced with generic information so as not to identify involved individuals as required by subsections 16(2AB)–16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988.

CATCHWORDS

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Jurisdiction – child support – percentage of care – whether the departmental decision determined a person’s percentage of care for a child –power to determine a new percentage depends on the revocation of the existing determination – departmental decision determined the applicant’s percentage of care – the Tribunal found to have jurisdiction to review the AAT1 decision

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, s 43

Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989, ss 49, 50, 54F

Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988, ss 4, 96A

CASES

LXTK and Child Support Registrar [2016]

QLKM and Child Support Registrar [2018]

ZJSZ and Child Support Registrar [2017] AATA 1565

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President Rayment QC

17 August 2018

  1. The applicant in this case is the father of a child in care.

  2. The respondent submits that the General Division of this Tribunal has no jurisdiction to entertain the application for review made by the father of the child following a determination by the Social Security & Child Support Division of this Tribunal made on 2 November 2017 (AAT1).

  3. The question before me has been considered before in the General Division of this Tribunal and two decisions have reached a conclusion that would be favourable to the respondent and one would favour the applicant. Normally, a prior decision of this Tribunal after full argument and not attended by any error of law would be treated as normative in later decisions of the Tribunal. It seems that none of the members of the Tribunal who decided those cases was informed of the prior decisions. The three prior decisions are LXTK and Child Support Registrar [2016], ZJSZ and Child Support Registrar [2017] AATA 1565 and QLKM and Child Support Registrar [2018], a decision of Deputy President Dr P McDermott RFD made on 1 February 2018. Some of those decisions do not have AATA references.

  4. The jurisdiction of the General Division to entertain the application for a second review of AAT1 is confined by s 96A(b) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988.

  5. Section 96A is in the following terms:

    96A Application for AAT second review

    An application may be made to the AAT for review (AAT second review) of the following decisions of the AAT:

    (a)a decision under section…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MQMV and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] AATA 2924
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a second review of a child support decision before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). The applicant, MQMV, sought to challenge a decision made by the Child Support Registrar. The central dispute revolved around whether the AAT had jurisdiction to conduct a second review of a care percentage decision.

The primary legal issue before the court was to determine whether the departmental decision under review constituted a "care percentage decision" as defined by the *Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989* (the Assessment Act), and consequently, whether the AAT had jurisdiction under section 96A(b) of the relevant Act to conduct a second review. This required an examination of whether the decision involved, wholly or partly, a determination of a person's percentage of care for a child made under specific provisions of the Assessment Act.

Deputy President Rayment QC, applying the definition of "care percentage decision" and the principles established in *QLKM*, reasoned that a second review is permissible if the initial AAT decision (AAT 1) was a first review of a care percentage decision. The court held that if any part of the departmental decision involved a determination of a person's percentage of care for a child made under the specified provisions of the Assessment Act, then the AAT's General Division would have jurisdiction to entertain a second review application, at least to that extent. The court treated the decision in *QLKM* as correct and normative for resolving the jurisdictional objection.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute regarding the jurisdiction of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) to conduct a second review of a child support determination. The applicant, referred to as MQMV, sought a second review of a decision made by the Child Support Registrar, which involved a determination of the applicant's percentage of care for a child. The initial decision by the Registrar was reviewed by AAT1, which declined to change the existing care percentage decision. MQMV then sought a second review by AAT2, leading to the jurisdictional dispute.

The legal framework governing the case is provided by s 96A(b) of the relevant Act, which stipulates that a second review is possible if the AAT1 decision was on the first review of a "care percentage decision." The term "care percentage decision" is defined in s 4 of the Act, encompassing decisions involving a determination of a person's percentage of care for a child under certain provisions of the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989. The case hinges on whether the departmental decision included a determination of the applicant's percentage of care for a child, thus falling within the scope of s 96A(b).

In the earlier case of QLKM, the Tribunal determined that AAT2 had jurisdiction to review the percentage care determination but not the revocation decision. The Tribunal's decision was that while AAT2 could review the care percentage determination, it lacked the authority to review the decision to revoke and replace the care determination. This distinction is crucial as it sets the precedent for handling similar cases. The present case builds on this precedent, focusing on whether the departmental decision made by the Registrar involved a determination of the applicant's percentage of care for a child, thereby invoking the Tribunal's jurisdiction for a second review.

The matter before the court is a second review application under the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989, specifically challenging a decision made by the Child Support Registrar. This appeal originates from a previous decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) First Review (AAT1), which had itself reviewed a departmental decision concerning the percentage of care for a child. The Tribunal's jurisdiction to conduct a second review hinges on whether the AAT1's decision involved a "care percentage decision," as defined in the Act. This case follows precedents set in LXTK and ZJSZ, where the AAT1 had reviewed decisions not to alter existing care percentage determinations but reached opposite conclusions. Additionally, the case QLKM was instrumental in establishing that the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Second Review (AAT2) has jurisdiction over the percentage care determination but not over the revocation decision, with the power to remit the matter for reconsideration if necessary. The current case seeks to determine whether the AAT1's decision involved a determination of the percentage of care for a child under the relevant provisions of the Assessment Act, thereby establishing the basis for the Tribunal's jurisdiction to conduct a second review.

Decision

Reasons for decision

It follows from the terms of s 96A(b) that a second review is only possible if the decision given by AAT 1 was on first review of a care percentage decision. The expression “care percentage decision” is defined by s 4 of the Act (unless the contrary intention appears) as follows: care percentage decision means a decision as to the particulars of an administrative assessment, or as to the particulars of a notional assessment, to the extent that the decision involves (wholly or partly):(a)a determination of a person’s percentage of care for a child that was made under a provision of Subdivision B of Division 4 of Part 5 of the Assessment Act; or(b)a determination relating to a person that has effect, under section 54K of that Act, as if it were a determination made under such a provision. The Assessment Act in that definition means the Child Support (Assessment) Act1989. The words “to the extent that the decision involves (wholly or partly)” direct attention to the decision which AAT1 was asked to review, that is, the decision of an authorised review officer or similar officer delegated by the Registrar to make the reviewable decision. Both LXTK and ZJSZ were cases in which the reviewable decision considered by AAT 1 was a decision not to change the existing care percentage decision. The two decisions reached opposite results. In considering what I regard as the correct result in this matter, I have preferred to examine the questions for myself, rather than to comment upon the reasoning in the two earlier decisions. QLKM was concerned with the Child Registrar’s decision to review a percentage care determination and in consequence to revoke and replace a care determination. DP McDermott held that the effect of s 96A of the Act was that this Division of the Tribunal (AAT2) had jurisdiction to review the percentage care determination but not the revocation decision. Of course, as to the revocation decision, there was power in AAT2 to remit the matter for reconsideration in the light of the review of the percentage care determination. I treat the decision in QLKM as normative and with respect, I regard it as correct. It seems to me that to resolve the present objection to the jurisdiction of AAT2, it is necessary to decide whether the departmental decision involved wholly or partly a determination of a person’s percentage of care for a child that was made under a provision of Subdivision B of Division 4 of Part 5 of the Assessment Act. Then one should ask what parts, if any, of the decision satisfy the expression commencing with the words “to the extent that”. If s 96A(b) is satisfied, then whatever may have been the course adopted by AAT1 under s 43(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, there will be jurisdiction in the General Division to entertain an application for a second review. So long as a part of the decision made by the departmental officer involved a determination of a person’s percentage of care for a child that was made under a provision of Subdivision B of Division 4 of Part 5 of the Assessment Act, there will be jurisdiction to entertain a second review, at least to that extent.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court embarked on a thorough analysis of the jurisdictional framework governing second reviews in child support cases, starting with the fundamental question of whether the departmental decision involved wholly or partly a determination of a person’s percentage of care for a child that was made under a provision of Subdivision B of Division 4 of Part 5 of the Assessment Act. The court noted that this was a pivotal issue as it determined the applicability of s 96A(b) of the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989. By dissecting the statutory language and the specific provisions of the Assessment Act, the court highlighted that the essence of the question lay in identifying whether the decision at hand involved a percentage care determination made under the specified legal provisions. The court’s reasoning underscored the importance of adhering to the statutory definition and the specific criteria outlined in the Assessment Act.

In examining the second issue, the court turned its attention to discerning what parts, if any, of the decision satisfied the expression commencing with the words “to the extent that”. The court meticulously parsed the statutory language to determine which elements of the decision could be said to involve a determination of a person’s percentage of care for a child. This involved a detailed consideration of the scope and application of the statutory definition provided in s 4 of the Assessment Act. The court's analysis was grounded in a strict interpretation of the statutory terms, ensuring that any determination of jurisdiction hinged on a precise alignment with the legislative criteria.

Moving to the third issue, the court considered whether s 96A(b) was satisfied and, if so, whether there was jurisdiction in the General Division to entertain an application for a second review. Here, the court applied a rigorous examination of the statutory provisions and their interaction with the facts of the case. The court noted that for s 96A(b) to be satisfied, the initial decision reviewed by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) must have involved a care percentage decision as defined by the Assessment Act. The court referenced prior authority, particularly the decisions in LXTK and ZJSZ, and distinguished them based on the specific nature of the care percentage determinations at issue. The court held that if s 96A(b) was indeed satisfied, then there was a clear jurisdictional basis for the General Division to entertain a second review application.

In addressing the final issue, the court examined whether there would be jurisdiction to entertain a second review, at least to the extent that a part of the decision made by the departmental officer involved a determination of a person’s percentage of care for a child made under the relevant provisions of the Assessment Act. The court reaffirmed its earlier analysis, emphasizing that jurisdiction hinged on the specific nature of the decision made by the departmental officer. The court distinguished the present case from QLKM by focusing on the precise scope of the departmental decision and its alignment with the statutory criteria. By applying the reasoning in QLKM, the court concluded that so long as a part of the decision involved a percentage care determination, there would be jurisdiction to entertain a second review to that extent.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that for a second review to be entertained, the departmental decision must involve a determination of a person’s percentage of care for a child made under the relevant provisions of the Assessment Act. The court’s detailed analysis and application of statutory language and prior authority provide a clear framework for determining jurisdictional issues in child support cases. The court followed the decision in QLKM as normative and correct, thereby affirming the principle that jurisdiction depends on the specific nature of the initial care percentage determination.