ZJSZ and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

ZJSZ and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2017] AATA 1565 (25 September 2017)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2017/4346

Re:ZJSZ

APPLICANT

AndChild Support Registrar

RESPONDENT

AndGBLP

DECISION

Tribunal:Egon Fice, Senior Member

Date:25 September 2017  

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal has jurisdiction to review the decision of the AAT 1 made on 13 July 2017.

..............[sgd]..........................................................

Egon Fice, Senior Member

CHILD SUPPORT – second review of SSCSD decision – care percentage determination – revocation of existing determination – jurisdiction to review decision of SSCSD

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975
Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989

Child Support (Registration and Collection Act) 1988

Secondary Materials

The Shorter Oxford English Dictionary

REASONS FOR DECISION

Egon Fice, Senior Member

25 September 2017

  1. There has been an ongoing dispute between the applicant and other party regarding the care percentages determined in respect of their child. As at 11 October 2016 the percentages of care were 62% to the applicant and 38% to the other party. On that day the applicant informed the Department of Human Services (Department) that the percentage of actual care taking place had changed and that the other party had not provided overnight care of the child since March 2016.

  2. On 21 December 2016 the Department decided not to revoke the care percentages after contacting the other party, who denied that the actual care being provided had changed. On 29 December 2016 the applicant lodged an objection with the Child Support Registrar (Registrar) claiming she provided 80% to 90% of the care of the child.

  3. On 22 February 2017 the General Manager, Child Support Smart Centres, determined not to alter the existing care percentages. As a consequence, she stated that the existing care determination could not be revoked.

  4. On 14 March 2017 the applicant lodged an application with the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, Social Services & Child Support Division (AAT 1) seeking review of the Registrar’s decision disallowing the applicant’s objection. AAT 1 handed down its decision on 13 July 2017, affirming the objection decision. The applicant then lodged an application with the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, General and Other Divisions (AAT 2) on 23 July 2017 seeking review of the AAT 1 decision.

  5. Following lodgement of the application with AAT 2, the Registrar notified the Tribunal that it had formed the view that the decision made by AAT 1 could not be reviewed by this Tribunal as it did not have the jurisdiction to do so.

    CLAIMED LACK OF JURISDICTION

  6. The Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (the Registration Act) provides for an application to be made to the Tribunal on a second review. Section 96A provides:

    An application may be made to the AAT for review (AAT second review) of the following decisions of the AAT:

    (a)a decision under section 92 to refuse an extension application;

    (b)a decision under subsection 43(1) of the AAT Act on AAT first review of a care percentage decision;

    (c)a decision under subsection 95N(2) to make,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ZJSZ and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 1565
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a second review of a child support decision before Senior Member Egon Fice. The dispute involved the determination of a parent's percentage of care for a child, which is a critical component in calculating child support obligations under the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth) (the Assessment Act).

The court was required to determine the legal implications of the Registrar making a new determination of a parent's percentage of care for a child. Specifically, the court considered whether the making of a new determination necessarily implies the revocation of any prior determination regarding the same child and period.

The Senior Member reasoned that the legislative framework, particularly sections 50 and 54F of the Assessment Act, establishes a clear principle that there can only be one operative percentage of care determination for a child at any given time. Section 50 mandates that if an existing determination is revoked, the Registrar must make a new determination. Conversely, the Senior Member concluded that if the Registrar makes a new determination of a parent's percentage of care, this action inherently revokes any previous, inconsistent determination for the same child and care period. This interpretation is supported by section 54F, which outlines the circumstances under which an existing determination must be revoked when a new one is to be made.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case revolves around a second review of a child support determination, specifically focusing on the percentage of care attributed to a parent or carer of a child. The determination of the percentage of care is governed by Division 4 of the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989, particularly under sections 49 and 50. The material facts commence with the initial application by a parent for an assessment of child support costs, which was made under section 25 or 25A of the Assessment Act. Following this application, the Registrar determined the percentage of care for the child attributed to the relevant parent or carer. This initial determination was made under section 49 or 50 of the Assessment Act, based on the circumstances of the case and all relevant evidence provided.

Subsequently, the Registrar was made aware that the actual care of the child did not correspond with the existing percentage of care previously determined. This discrepancy led to the Registrar revoking the initial determination under section 54F of the Assessment Act. The Registrar then made a new determination of the percentage of care for the child under section 50(1) of the Assessment Act, considering the appropriate pattern of care for the child based on all relevant circumstances. This new determination was necessary to reflect the actual care being provided to the child, as opposed to the previously determined percentage.

The case thus centres on the sequence of events that led from the initial determination of the percentage of care, through the revocation of that determination due to a change in circumstances, to the making of a new determination by the Registrar. The key factual elements include the initial application for child support assessment, the first determination of the percentage of care, the subsequent revocation of that determination due to changes in the actual care of the child, and the making of a new determination to reflect the current situation. The interplay between sections 49, 50, 54F, and 54G of the Assessment Act is central to understanding the factual backdrop against which the legal dispute arises.

This case concerns a second review of a child support matter under the Child Support (Registration and Recovery) Act 1988 (the Registration Act) and the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (the Assessment Act). The proceedings came before the court as a result of an application by the Child Support Registrar seeking a review of a decision regarding the percentage of care for a child. The matter originated from a previous determination made by the Registrar under the Assessment Act, which involved the calculation of the percentage of care for a child. This case does not represent a first-instance hearing but rather a second review of an administrative decision. The initial determination of the percentage of care was subsequently subject to a review, leading to the current proceedings before the court. The Registrar had previously made a determination under section 50 of the Assessment Act, which mandates the Registrar to reassess a responsible person’s percentage of care if the existing determination no longer reflects the actual care arrangements for the child. This reassessment was triggered by a notification or awareness that the actual care arrangements did not align with the existing percentage of care determination. The Registrar, upon finding discrepancies, was required to revoke the existing determination and make a new assessment. The current case involves the procedural history of this reassessment and the subsequent review by the court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The expression care percentage decision is defined in s. 4 of the Registration Act in the following way:care percentage decision means a decision as to the particulars of an administrative assessment, or as to the particulars of a notional assessment, to the extent that the decision involves (wholly or partly):(a)a determination of a person’s percentage of care for a child that was made under a provision of Subdivision B of Division 4 of Part 5 of the Assessment Act; or(b)a determination relating to a person that has effect, under section 54K of that Act, as if it were a determination made under such provision. The expression percentage of care is also a defined term found in s. 5 of the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (the Assessment Act). It states:percentage of care, in relation to a responsible person for a child, means the responsible person’s percentage of care for the child that is determined by the Registrar under Subdivision B of Division 4 of Part 5. Determination of the percentage of care is dealt with under Division 4 of the Assessment Act. In this case, it appears that a determination was made under s. 50 of the Assessment Act. Section 50 applies where a parent who has a relevant dependent child makes an application under s. 25 or 25A for a parent to be assessed in respect of the costs of the child, or the Registrar revokes an existing determination regarding a person’s percentage of care for a child. As will become apparent presently, there cannot exist, for any particular period of time, two determinations made regarding the percentage of care to be attributed to each parent or person who is not a parent, but is a carer of the child. Relevantly, s. 50(1) provides:(1) This section applies if:(a)… ; or(b)the Registrar:(i) revokes, under Subdivision C of this Division, a determination of a responsible person’s percentage of care for a child that was made under section 49 or this section; and(ii) is satisfied that the responsible person has had, or is likely to have, a pattern of care for the child during such period (the care period) as the Registrar considers to be appropriate having regard to all the circumstances.(2) The Registrar must determine the responsible person’s percentage of care for the child during the care period. In other words, if an existing determination is revoked, the Registrar must determine a new percentage of care. The converse must also be true. If the Registrar makes a new determination regarding the percentage of care, the previous determination must be revoked. That is set out in Subdivision C and in particular s. 54F which provides:(1) If:(a)a determination of a responsible person’s percentage of care (the existing percentage of care) for a child has been made under section 49 or 50; and(b)if section 51 or 52 applied in relation to the responsible person – the interim period for the determination has ended; and(c)the Registrar or the Secretary is notified, or otherwise becomes aware, that the care of the child that is actually taking place and does not correspond with the responsible person’s existing percentage of care for the child; and(d)the Registrar is satisfied that the responsible person’s cost percentage for the child would change if the Registrar were to determine, under section 49 or 50, another percentage to be the person’s percentage of care for the child; and(e)section 54G does not apply;the Registrar must revoke the determination.Note:The Registrar must make a new determination under section 49 or 50 to replace the revoked determination: see paragraph 49(1)(b) or 50(1)(b).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the Registrar's authority to revoke a determination of a person's percentage of care for a child if it no longer corresponds with the actual care taking place. The court noted that section 54F of the Assessment Act mandates that the Registrar must revoke the existing determination if notified that the care of the child does not correspond with the existing percentage of care determination. The court found that the Registrar has the authority to revoke the determination if the Registrar is satisfied that the person's cost percentage for the child would change if a new determination were made. This decision was based on the principle that the determination must accurately reflect the actual care of the child, and the Registrar must make a new determination under section 49 or 50 to replace the revoked determination.

The court addressed whether a new determination of percentage of care must be made automatically if an existing determination is revoked. The court determined that the requirement to make a new determination is contingent upon the Registrar being satisfied that the person's cost percentage for the child would change. The court held that there cannot be two simultaneous determinations of the percentage of care for a child. Therefore, if the Registrar revokes an existing determination, they must make a new determination under section 49 or 50. This decision was based on the statutory provision that mandates the replacement of a revoked determination with a new one, ensuring that the determination accurately reflects the actual care of the child.

The court clarified that there cannot be two simultaneous determinations of the percentage of care for a child under the relevant sections of the Assessment Act. This principle was established by the court's interpretation of the statutory provisions which require the replacement of a revoked determination with a new one. The court noted that the existence of two simultaneous determinations would contradict the statutory framework designed to ensure that the determination accurately reflects the actual care of the child. The court's interpretation was consistent with the legislative intent to maintain a single, accurate determination of the percentage of care for a child.

The court examined whether the Registrar must consider all circumstances before determining the appropriate percentage of care for a child following a revocation of an existing determination. The court held that the Registrar must consider all the circumstances before making a new determination of the percentage of care. This decision was based on the principle that the determination must accurately reflect the actual care of the child, and the Registrar must consider all relevant factors to ensure that the new determination is appropriate. The court found that the Registrar must have regard to all the circumstances when determining the appropriate percentage of care for a child.

The court addressed the procedure the Registrar must follow if notified that the care of a child does not correspond with the existing percentage of care determination. The court held that the Registrar must revoke the existing determination and make a new determination if satisfied that the person's cost percentage for the child would change. This decision was based on the statutory provision that mandates the revocation of the existing determination and the replacement with a new one. The court found that the Registrar must follow the procedure outlined in section 54F of the Assessment Act to ensure that the new determination accurately reflects the actual care of the child. The court's interpretation was consistent with the legislative intent to maintain an accurate and up-to-date determination of the percentage of care for a child.