MPPZ and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 54 min read

MPPZ and National Disability Insurance Agency [2024] AATA 3563 (9 October 2024)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number:          2021/7818

Re:MPPZ  

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President Mischin

Date:9 October 2024

Place:Perth

The decision under review, being the decision of the National Disability Insurance Agency made on 30 September 2021 under section 100(6) of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) (NDIS Act), as remade on 9 January 2024 following reassessment pursuant to section 48 of the NDIS Act), is set aside and the matter is remitted for reconsideration in accordance with directions that:

(a)The Applicant’s statement of participant supports specifies that the reasonable and necessary supports include:

(i)Four hours of individual support per week for Assistance with Personal Domestic Activities;

(ii)16 hours of individual support per week for Access Community Social and Recreational Activities – Standard – Weekday Daytime rate;

(iii)Four hours per month of yard maintenance;

(iv)Two hours per week of house cleaning;

(v)$1,000 per annum for low-cost assistive technology – personal mobility;

(vi)$1,000 per annum for disability-related health consumables;

(vii)$1,500 per annum for low-cost assistive technology for prosthetics and orthotics;

(viii)Preparation and delivery of meals as per quote;

(ix)Transport funding (Level 3), being $3,456 per annum;

(x)Support coordination funding (80 hours per years, Level 2);

(xi)Specialist support coordination (40 hours per year, Level 3);

(xii)26 hours per year of physiotherapy;

(xiii)26 hours per year of exercise physiology including, subject to quotes, gym membership for such sessions;

(xiv)26 hours per year of occupational therapy;

(xv)20 hours for an Assistive Technology assessment report prepared by an occupational therapist with experience working with assistance animals and mental health for the request for a PTSD assistance dog;

(xvi)12 hours of podiatry;

(xvii)12 hours of specialist sex therapy/counselling (not sex worker services); and

(xviii)Six hours for a dietician assessment and recommendations.

(b)All other supports in the Applicant’s existing statement of participant supports, excepting any one-off assistive technology supports already used, are to be replicated from the date on which the supports specified above are included in the Applicant's statement of participant supports until the reassessment date.

(c)The management of funding for reasonable and necessary supports under the Applicant’s plan is to remain the same as the management of funding for those supports as specified in the statement of participant supports dated 9 January 2024.

(d)The date by which the Respondent must reassess the Applicant’s plan is to be 12 months after the date on which the supports in paragraph (a) above are included in the Applicant’s statement of participant supports.

..................................[SGD]...................................

The Hon. Michael Mischin, Deputy President

CATCHWORDS

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome, spinal cord injury, and psychosocial disorders, being Post Traumatic Stress Disorder, anxiety and depression – reasonable and necessary supports – section 34 National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) – requests for gym membership, assistive technology, sex worker, equine/hippotherapy, PTSD assistance dog, overseas travel and accommodation to access treatment – Respondent agrees to certain supports as…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MPPZ and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 3563
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal considered a dispute between MPPZ (the applicant) and the National Disability Insurance Agency (the respondent) concerning the provision of reasonable and necessary supports under the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth). The applicant sought funding for a range of supports, including a gym membership, assistive technology, sex worker services, equine therapy, a PTSD assistance dog, and overseas travel and accommodation for treatment. The applicant also sought funding for travel, accommodation, and a support worker to accompany her to the United States for medical treatment for Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome.

The Tribunal was required to determine which of the applicant's requested supports were reasonable and necessary within the meaning of section 34 of the NDIS Act. This involved assessing the applicant's conditions, including Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome, spinal cord injury, Post Traumatic Stress Disorder, anxiety, and depression, against the criteria for reasonable and necessary supports. The Tribunal also had to consider the evidence presented, which included extensive documentation from both parties and the applicant's oral evidence.

Deputy President Mischin reasoned that while the respondent had conceded a number of supports, the applicant had not established that all her requests met the criteria for reasonable and necessary supports. The Tribunal agreed with the respondent's concession regarding a one-off allocation of 20 hours for an occupational therapist to prepare an assistive technology assessment report for a PTSD assistance dog. The Tribunal directed that several specific supports, including various forms of individual support, yard maintenance, house cleaning, low-cost assistive technology, disability-related health consumables, prosthetics and orthotics, meal preparation, transport, support coordination, specialist support coordination, physiotherapy, exercise physiology (including gym membership), occupational therapy, podiatry, specialist sex therapy/counselling, and a dietician assessment, should be included in the applicant's statement of participant supports.

The Tribunal ordered that all other supports in the applicant's existing statement of participant supports, excluding any one-off assistive technology supports already used, were to be replicated from the date the specified supports were included until the reassessment date. The management of funding was to remain the same, and the respondent was directed to reassess the applicant's plan within 12 months of the inclusion of the specified supports.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Applicant advised at the commencement of the first day of the resumed substantive hearing that she was also seeking funding for travel, accommodation, and a support worker to accompany her, to receive medical treatment for Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome from a practitioner in the United States of America.[6][6] Transcript 2 August 2024 pages 20-21, 37.THE HEARING AND AVAILABLE EVIDENCE The application was heard by the Tribunal over five days, on 20 to 22 November 2023 and 2 and 7 August 2024, although there were lengthy interlocutory and directions hearings on 21 September 2022, 4 July 2023, 21 December 2023 and 26 March 2024, the latter two with a view to attempting to ensure that the matter was ready for further substantive hearing. The Tribunal had before it, prepared by the Respondent:(a)Exhibit R1: the ‘T-Documents’ filed by the Respondent pursuant to its obligations under section 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (AAT Act),[7] comprised of extracts of the NDIS Act,[8] Rules,[9] and Operational Guidelines,[10] and the application for review and a variety of correspondence and reports from both the Applicant and the Respondent (273 pages of documents);(b)Exhibit R2: a Supplementary Tender Bundle prepared by the Respondent and including documents filed in respect of an earlier application for review by the Tribunal settled in 2019, and Operational Guidelines (498 pages);[11] and(c)Exhibit R3: a Further Supplementary Tender Bundle comprised of some Tribunal documents and various reports and correspondence from both the Applicant and Respondent, including the most recent Statement of Participant Supports commencing 9 January 2024 (120 pages).[12] [7] Exhibit R1 T-Documents T1 to T20, Documents 2.1 to 2.8, and Documents 3.1 to 3.10, excepting T1B and pages 263-265.[8] Exhibit R1 T-Documents T10 pages 246-248. [9] Exhibit R1 T-Documents T11 pages 249-263.[10] Exhibit R1 T-Documents T12 pages 264-337 and T13 pages 338-347.[11] Exhibit R2 Documents ST1 to ST58; Transcript 2 August 2024 page 35.[12] Exhibit R3 Documents ST59 to ST71; Transcript 2 August 2024 page 36. The Applicant presented some further documents during the hearing on 2 and 7 August 2024 which were received as Exhibits A2 to A7. These included a variety of medical documents and correspondence, and invoices that the Applicant was seeking to have reimbursed.[13] [13] Exhibit A2, Transcript 7 August 2024 page 29; Exhibit A3, Transcript 7 August 2024 page 7; Exhibit A4, Transcript 7 August 2024 page 29; Exhibit A5, Transcript 7 August 2024 18; Exhibit A6, Transcript 7 August 2024 page 19; Exhibit A7, Transcript 7 August 2024 page 23. A letter dated 24 March 2024 written by the Applicant’s support coordinator and handed up at the hearing, outlining some ‘matters of importance’ that Applicant wanted addressed; was marked and remained as MFI A1; Exhibit R3 Document ST63 pages 532-533. The Applicant gave evidence and was cross-examined. Otherwise, no witnesses were called by either party.

Decision

Reasons for decision

However, the Respondent accepts as reasonable and necessary a one-off allocation of 20 hours to allow an occupational therapist, experienced in working with assistance animals and mental health to prepare an assistive technology assessment report in respect of the request for a PTSD assistance dog. With this, I also agree and propose to direct accordingly. CONCLUSION Having regard to the above, I am not satisfied that the Applicant’s request for additional supports, except as identified, has been made out. As noted, the Respondent has conceded a number of supports and along with a direction concerning gym membership, I consider that they ought to be included in the Applicant’s SOPS. Accordingly, I direct as follows:(i)Four hours of individual support per week for Assistance with Personal Domestic Activities;(ii)16 hours of individual support per week for Access Community Social and Recreational Activities – Standard – Weekday Daytime rate;(iii)Four hours per month of yard maintenance;(iv)Two hours per week of house cleaning;(v)$1,000 per annum for low-cost assistive technology – personal mobility;(vi)$1,000 per annum for disability-related health consumables;(vii)$1,500 per annum for low-cost assistive technology for prosthetics and orthotics;(viii)Preparation and delivery of meals as per quote;(ix)Transport funding (Level 3), being $3,456 per annum;(x)Support coordination funding (80 hours per years, Level 2);(xi)Specialist support coordination (40 hours per year, Level 3);(xii)26 hours per year of physiotherapy;(xiii)26 hours per year of exercise physiology including, subject to quotes, gym membership for such sessions;(xiv)26 hours per year of occupational therapy;(xv)20 hours for an Assistive Technology assessment report prepared by an occupational therapist with experience working with assistance animals and mental health for the request for a PTSD assistance dog;(xvi)12 hours of podiatry;(xvii)12 hours of specialist sex therapy/counselling (not sex worker services); and(xviii)Six hours for a dietician assessment and recommendations.(d)All other supports in the Applicant’s existing statement of participant supports, excepting any one-off assistive technology supports already used, are to be replicated from the date on which the supports specified above are included in the Applicant's statement of participant supports until the reassessment date. (e)The management of funding for reasonable and necessary supports under the Applicant’s plan is to remain the same as the management of funding for those supports as specified in the statement of participant supports dated 9 January 2024.(f)The date by which the Respondent must reassess the Applicant’s plan is to be 12 months after the date on which the supports in paragraph (a) above are included in the Applicant’s statement of participant supports.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established