King and National Disability Insurance Agency [2017] AATA 643 (4 May 2017)
Division
National Disability Insurance Scheme Division
File Number(s)
2016/6015
Re
Jessica King
APPLICANT
And
National Disability Insurance Agency
RESPONDENT
DECISION
Tribunal K. Parker, Member
Date 4 May 2017 Place Melbourne The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and substitutes a decision that Jessica King’s National Disability Insurance Scheme plan dated 12 August 2016 be amended to include the following additional supports for Ms King:
1. An annual gym membership for Ms King ($570);
2.Fortnightly physiotherapy sessions ($175 per hourly session) for the duration of the plan; and
3.An additional five physiotherapy sessions ($175 per hourly session) to be taken at any time, comprising:
(a)Three physiotherapy sessions for the purpose of training Ms King’s carers how to assist Ms King when she is at the gym to undertake an exercise program as recommended by Ms King’s physiotherapist; and
(b)Two physiotherapist sessions at Ms King’s home in addition to all of the above physiotherapy sessions referred to above.
.....................................[sgd]...................................
K. Parker, Member
NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME - participant’s plan - application for amendment of plan to include additional supports - gymnasium membership - physiotherapy sessions - whether supports reasonable and necessary - whether supports represent value for money - whether supports assist in undertaking activities to facilitate social and economic participation - whether supports effective and beneficial - consideration of other support available - whether supports most appropriately funded through agency - decision under review set aside
Legislation
National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) ss 33, 34, 35
National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013 (Cth)
Cases
McGarrigle v National Disability Insurance Agency [2017] FCA 308
REASONS FOR DECISION
K. Parker, Member
4 May 2017
INTRODUCTION
On 12 August 2016 a plan (Plan) was entered into between Jessica King (Ms King) and the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA)[1] under the s 33 of the National Disability Support Scheme Act (Cth) (the Act). The Plan succeeded three earlier plans. The Plan commenced on 12 August 2016 and is due to expire on 14 August 2017.
[1] The NDIA was established under s 117 of the Act and is formerly named the National Disability Insurance Scheme Launch Transition Agency.
Ms King sought an internal review of the statement of participant supports in the Plan by the NDIA. Ms King sought the inclusion of an additional 20 hours of physiotherapy and a gym membership as supports in her statement of participant supports. In entering into a plan under s 33 of the Act, the NDIA is required to prepare and approve a statement of participant’s supports, which sets out the supports which will be funded or provided under the National Disability Insurance Scheme. Exercising the discretion under s 33(2) of the Act, the NDIA had not approved the addition of the physiotherapy and gym membership referred to above in the statement of participant supports.
By letter dated 21 October 2016, a review officer of the NDIA notified Ms King,…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read King and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] AATA 643
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Tribunal was required to determine whether the physiotherapy treatment recommended by Ms King's physiotherapist, Ms Clatworthy, and her gym membership constituted reasonable and necessary supports under section 34 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth). This involved assessing whether the supports would assist Ms King to pursue her goals and aspirations, facilitate her social and economic participation, represent value for money, be effective and beneficial, take account of informal supports, and be most appropriately funded by the NDIS.
The Tribunal found that the physiotherapy treatment, specifically Bobath physiotherapy, was effective and beneficial for Ms King, having previously improved her mobility and independence. It was noted that Ms Clatworthy's evidence was not contradicted by the NDIA. The Tribunal considered that the proposed physiotherapy sessions, including those for training carers and home-based sessions, were necessary to maintain Ms King's mobility and prevent deterioration, which would otherwise increase her reliance on her mother and potentially necessitate more costly residential care. The Tribunal also found that the gym membership was a reasonable and necessary support to complement the physiotherapy.
The Tribunal set aside the NDIA's decision and substituted it with an approval for Ms King's plan to include an annual gym membership, fortnightly physiotherapy sessions for the remainder of the plan, and an additional five physiotherapy sessions. These additional sessions were to comprise three for training carers in assisting Ms King with her gym program and two home-based sessions.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
No evidence was tendered by the NDIA from any health practitioners or other experts to contradict the evidence of Ms Clatworthy or the benefits of such treatment as experienced by Ms King and as observed by Mrs King.CONSIDERATION The Tribunal considers that the physiotherapy treatment, as currently recommended by Ms Clatworthy in letter dated 5 April 2017, comprised a reasonable and necessary support within the meaning of s 34 of the Act in consideration of the following factors:(a)The physiotherapy treatment, as recommended by Ms Clatworthy, would assist Ms King to pursue the goals, objectives and aspirations included in her statement of goals and aspirations by improving her mobility. On the evidence, it was clear this had been demonstrated by previous instances of Ms King having received this specialised treatment and also on account of the expert evidence given by Ms Clatworthy;[7](b)By improving Ms King’s mobility as it had in the past, the Tribunal is satisfied that the physiotherapy treatment in conjunction with the assisted gym sessions would help Ms King to undertake activities. It would facilitate her social and economic participation, for instance, by allowing her to remain motivated and content to continue working as she does at Karingal Kommercial and also by having the confidence and purpose to continue attending at the gym which, on the evidence, had been a good social outlet for her;[8](c)The Tribunal is satisfied that the treatment represents value for money in that the costs of the support are reasonable, relative to both the benefits achieved and the cost of alternative supports. By the end of the hearing, the NDIA did not press ahead with its initial contention[9] that it would be more cost-effective if an alternative (lesser skilled and therefore, less expensive) service provider should be trained up to provide the same Bobath treatment to Ms King (referred to as a delegated therapy model). However, the NDIA did raise an objection after the hearing about particular physiotherapy sessions being used to train replacement carers (as distinct from existing carers) to assist Ms King with a continuing exercise program at the gym, as it considered that it was the responsibility of the service provider to meet those costs when there was a change of carer. The Tribunal considers this to be a matter for the NDIA to take up with those service providers. (d)Ms Clatworthy has recommended a further three additional sessions for Ms King to ensure that the present carers, whoever they are, may be sufficiently trained to assist Ms King with the exercise program to be reinstated for Ms King from now until the end of the Plan. The Tribunal does not consider this to be excessive and regards three sessions between now and the end of the Plan for this purpose as a necessary and reasonable support. It will allow one session forthwith to set up and reinstate the program; one to undertake an interim review in the next few months; and one to assess the program at the end of the Plan or alternatively to modify it between now and then if required;[10](e)The physiotherapy treatment as recommended by Ms Clatworthy has been effective and beneficial for Ms King, having regard to current good practice. It appears to the Tribunal from the evidence of Ms Clatworthy that the Bobath techniques have been practised for some time, dating back to at least 2002 when Ms Clatworthy first undertook a Bobath course, and are practised broadly including overseas. The Tribunal also notes that the prominence of Bobath techniques is such that it had been adopted by St Vincent’s Hospital as mentioned above and used specifically for persons with cerebral palsy. The previous benefits experienced by Ms King in 2016 and January 2017, also satisfy the Tribunal that this treatment has been effective and beneficial for her;[11](f)The funding or provision of the physiotherapy treatment as recommended by Ms Clatworthy takes account what it is reasonable to expect of families, carers, informal networks and the community to provide. The Tribunal notes that this is a support that is unable to be provided to Ms King by her carers, Mrs King or others in the community. The Tribunal accepts Ms Clatworthy’s evidence that professional skill and care of a physiotherapist is required to be exercised in order to deliver the hands-on Bobath treatment safely and effectively to Ms King. This is not a support that others can safely provide. (g)The Tribunal also notes the limited income available to Mrs King, being on a pension and living in public housing, to otherwise fund this support on a personal basis. The Tribunal takes into account the age of Mrs King (being in her 60’s) and the corresponding increasing limitation upon her capacity to be able to physically support Ms King as her mobility deteriorates in the absence of being provided with such treatments, in addition to the likely negative impact on Mrs King’s wellbeing if she is required to do so. The Tribunal recognises that Ms King’s mobility may decline to a level where Mrs King is no longer able to support her in the home environment meaning that Ms King would need to move to special accommodation with the costs associated with that. If Ms King is required to rely on Mrs King to fund these treatments it will reduce Ms King’s level of independence and if the treatments are not provided, it will be cause her level of mobility to deteriorate as has been shown from past experience also reducing her degree of physical independence;[12](h)The physiotherapy treatment is most appropriately funded or provided through the NDIS, and is not more appropriately funded or provided through other general systems of service delivery or support services offered by a person, agency or body, or systems of service delivery or support services offered. By the end of the hearing, the NDIA itself had accepted that this type of treatment should be provided as a support to Ms King under the NDIS, save that it considered the level of this particular support (or funding for it) should be less than the level as contended for by Ms King;[13](i)By the end of the hearing, it was also was not contended by the NDIA that the physiotherapy treatment as recommended by Ms Clatworthy was prescribed by the Rules as a support that would not be funded or provided under the NDIS. Regardless of this, it was clear from the evidence that the recommended physiotherapy treatment was directly related to Ms King’s functional impairment as described by Mrs King and Ms Clatworthy and integrally linked to Ms King’s care and support she required to live in the community and to participate in her current employment. Mobility is essential to her quality of life in the home and in her place of work and the physiotherapy treatment is directly designed to improve and optimise her mobility as much as possible. For this reason, the Tribunal considers that this support falls into Rule 7.4 rather than Rule 7.5 of the Rules and consistent with those rules, this support as recommended by Ms Clatworthy on 5 April 2017 should be included the Plan.[14][7] Refer s 34(1)(a) of the Act.[8] Refer s 34(1)(b) of the Act.[9] Refer paragraph [22] of the Respondent’s Statement of Issues, Facts and Contentions dated 21 March 2017.[10] Refer s 34(1)(c) of the Act and Rule 3.1 of the Rules.[11] Refer s 34(1)(d) of the Act.[12] Refer s 34(1)(e) of the Act and Rule 3.4 of the Rules.[13] Refer s 34(1)(f) of the Act[14] Refer s 34(1)(g) and (h) of the Act.