ZCPY and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read

ZCPY and National Disability Insurance Agency [2017] AATA 3052 (4 December 2017)

Administrative Appeals Tribunal

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL                   )

)No: 2016/1173

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION              )

Re: ZCPY
Applicant

And: National Disability Insurance Agency
Respondent

TRIBUNAL:    Ms K Parker, Member

DATE:            23 February 2018

PLACE:          Melbourne

CORRIGENDUM TO DECISION

The Tribunal directs the Registrar, pursuant to subsection 43AA(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, to alter the heading of the written reasons dated 21 December 2017 as follows:

·The Division: on the cover page should read:

National Disability Insurance Scheme

[sgd]...............................................................
Member

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):  2016/1173

Re:               ZCPY

APPLICANT

National Disability Insurance AgencyAnd  

RESPONDENT

WRITTEN REASONS FOR DECISION

Tribunal:Member Kim Parker

Date of decision:               4 December 2017

Date of written reasons         21 December 2017

Place:Melbourne

The reviewable decision in this application is a decision by the NDIA to approve the Statement of Supports for the Applicant forming part of his previous NDIS plan which commenced on 1 November 2015 (Plan Under Review). 

The Tribunal decides:

  1. To vary the reviewable decision by adding a specific literacy program as an additional support to the Statement of Supports in the Plan Under Review.  This specific literacy program is the Seeing Stars: Symbol Imagery for Phonological and Orthographic Processing in Reading and Spelling (SI) program to be delivered directly by Lindamood-Bell Learning Processing (LBLP) Centre in Hawthorn, Victoria, as part of an intensive program being four hours per day, five days per week, for a consecutive period of eight weeks.

The Tribunal notes:

1.That the Plan Under Review has been replaced by new NDIS plans for the Applicant. By operation of s 37(3) of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013, the Plan Under Review has ceased to exist.  This means that the decision of the Tribunal which relates to the Statement of Supports in the Plan Under Review has no practical effect or operation.  However, the NDIA has voluntarily given an undertaking to the Tribunal that it is prepared to reflect any findings made by the Tribunal in relation to this support in the pending new NDIS plan for the Applicant.

To assist the NDIA to comply with the undertaking provided and in light of the decision of the Tribunal as set out above, the Tribunal recommends:

  1. That the Statement of Supports to be approved by the NDIA and included in the pending new plan for the Applicant, should include the specific literacy program outlined above, to commence on 11 December 2017; and
  1. That this program be commenced by the Applicant on condition that a full interim progress assessment of the Applicant will be conducted by LBLP, at the end of the first four completed weeks of the program, to ensure that reasonable progress has been made by the Applicant in relation to his reading and writing skills and if not, the program is to be immediately discontinued by the Applicant exiting the program and no further service…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ZCPY and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 3052
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by the Applicant, a 17-year-old with Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) and significant literacy impairments, for review of a decision by the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA). The dispute centred on whether a proposed intensive literacy program, "Seeing Stars: Symbol Imagery for Phonological and Orthographic Processing in Reading and Spelling" (SI program), constituted reasonable and necessary support under section 34 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth). The Applicant sought funding for this program, which was recommended by LBLP, to be delivered via one-on-one video conferencing over 8-10 weeks.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether the proposed SI program met the criteria for reasonable and necessary supports as outlined in section 34(1) of the Act. Specifically, the court had to consider whether the support would assist the Applicant to pursue his goals, objectives, and aspirations; whether it would facilitate his social and economic participation; and whether it would be, or be likely to be, effective and beneficial for him, having regard to current good practice. The NDIA contended that the program would not be effective or beneficial, citing expert opinion and the Applicant's previous response to a different literacy program.

The Tribunal reasoned that if the SI program successfully improved the Applicant's reading and writing abilities, it would directly assist him in achieving his stated goals, such as obtaining part-time employment and increasing his independence in daily activities. This improvement, in turn, would facilitate his social and economic participation. The Tribunal considered the evidence presented, including the Applicant's significant literacy deficits and the proposed intensive delivery method of the SI program, which differed from a previously undertaken program. The Tribunal was satisfied that the mandatory requirements of section 34(1)(a) and (b) were met.

Although the Plan Under Review had been replaced by subsequent NDIS plans, rendering the Tribunal's decision without practical effect on that specific plan, the NDIA provided an undertaking to reflect any findings in the Applicant's pending new plan. The Tribunal's jurisdiction was limited to the decision concerning the Plan Under Review, but the parties agreed to narrow the focus to the reasonableness and necessity of the SI program to allow for an expeditious decision before the Applicant's summer school holidays.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The NDIA has published internal Operational Guidelines on its website which guides delegates of the CEO of the NDIA in reaching the requisite state of satisfaction under s 34 of the Act. It is appropriate for the Tribunal to consider those guidelines and act consistently with them, unless there are good reasons not to or unless the Tribunal considers them to be inconsistent with the legislative regime – see Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No.2)(1979) 2 ALD 634.FACTUAL BACKGROUNDThe Applicant The Applicant is 17 years of age and has attended a mainstream public secondary school since Year 7 on a full-time basis. He is about to complete Year 10 and will enter either VCE or VCAL next year. The Applicant also attended a mainstream public primary school, though there were two short periods, during which he was home schooled due to reported instances of bullying. On 6 July 2010, the Applicant was diagnosed by his former treating paediatrician, Dr Kym Anderson, as having a “multidisciplinary diagnosis of Autism Spectrum Disorder” (ASD).[6] It was not in contest between the parties that the Applicant has severely impaired phonemic awareness and literacy skills, making it extremely difficult for the Applicant to read and write. His current reading age was assessed in September 2016 to be between 6 to 7 years old. These impairments have substantially reduced the Applicant’s capacity to communicate in the written form and to engage independently in some daily activities as a result. This has also presented significant obstacles with respect to the Applicant accessing the academic curriculum at his school without assistance.[6] Refer to open letter by Dr Kym Anderson dated 24 November 2017. The Applicant’s mother gave evidence that her son had previously completed reading recovery programs, but that they “didn’t work”. The Applicant’s mother is the sole parent and carer of the Applicant. She also cares for her 11 year old daughter, also an NDIS participant, who was reported to have ASD and high care needs. The Applicant’s mother said that her son had not been treated by any medical practitioners in about the last two years, nor was he presently being treated by a speech pathologist or psychologist. He was, however, participating in family therapy sessions and was receiving the assistance of an occupational therapist (OT) and an OT assistant.The Plan Under review In the Plan Under Review, the Applicant’s goals were described as follows:(a)to get a part-time job (to learn how to travel by bus and to develop work ready skills);(b)to get his driver’s licence (to start developing the skills required to apply for his Learner’s Permit);(c)to increase his independence (to learn how to travel by bus, have opportunities to stay away from home, independent from his family);(d)to regularly engaged in social and recreational activities (to continue to access the computer club, go on camps and engage in activities that are of interest to me);(e)to maintain his health and well-being (to improve his relationship with his sister to learn how to better manage the symptoms of anxiety).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Ms King was asked whether she knew why Ms Baker from LBLP had initially recommended that the Applicant undertake both the SI and V/V program and Mr Trew had more recently recommended only the SI program (as outlined in more detail in paragraph [90]).[28] Ms King said that Mr Trew had made “a further recommendation”. Ms King said she considered that the SI program was the “most prominent” program for the Applicant, although the V/V program was of value to the Applicant to assist him with his “dual decoding skills” and that she still recommended it “as an adjunct” to the SI program.[28] Refer letter from Mr Gareth Trew, Acting Centre Director, LBLP dated 5 October 2017 lodged with the Tribunal on 9 October 2017.Evidence from LBLP On 26 September 2017, Mr Trew of LBLP administered a Learning Ability Evaluation in relation to the Applicant. Mr Trew stated that the scores indicated that “the underlying sensory-cognitive functions needed for reading and spelling are a significant weakness; it also shows that [the Applicant’s] receptive oral vocabulary and expressive oral vocabulary are within the average range and are a significant strength for him”. The results of these tests included:(a)Woodcock Reading Mastery Test - ability to decode words quickly and accurately - percentile ranking 0.1;(b)Slosson Oral Reading Achievement Test - ability to recognise words accurately and quickly - percentile ranking 1;(c)The Wide Range Achievement Test - ability to spell words in isolation - percentile ranking 0.2;(d)The Gray Oral Reading Test 4 - reading fluency - percentile ranking 1;(e)Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test - IV (PPVT-4) - matching pictures with words - percentile ranking 70;(f)Detroits Tests of Learning Aptitude 4 - word opposites subtest - expressive oral vocabulary - percentile ranking 50. Mr Trew stated that the diagnostic Learning Ability Evaluation results indicated that the Applicant “may benefit from intensive, daily instruction - 4 hours per day, five days per week - for 8-10 weeks to develop his language and literacy skills. It should be noted that given [the Applicant’s] substantial weakness on multiple measures there may necessarily be multiple rounds of instruction”. Mr Trew recommended that the SI program only be undertaken. Mr Trew did not appear at the hearing of this matter. Instead, Mr Russell gave oral evidence at the hearing in relation to LBLP’s recommendations. Mr Russell said he had not met the Applicant in person but he had access to the assessment results for the Applicant. Based on that information, Mr Russell said that it was his recommendation that the Applicant undertake the SI program delivered on a one-on-one basis by video conference four hours per day, five days week for eight to 10 weeks. Mr Russell has a Bachelor of Science in Psychology and a Masters in Special Education. He is not a qualified speech pathologist. He said he had worked at LBLP for about six years and was the Centre Director in Sydney (at Double Bay). Mr Russell said he commenced working at LBLP as a clinician and then moved into a consultant/case manager role, before becoming a Centre Director.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The NDIA completed its internal review and issued a decision on 8 February 2016 (Internal Review Decision) to the following effect:(a)in relation to the first two supports, the NDIA stated that funding for those supports was available to the Applicant under approved supports already included in the Plan Under Review;(b)in relation to the last two supports, the NDIA affirmed that it did not consider that those two supports were reasonable and necessary under s 34 of the Act and for that reason; the NDIA affirmed its earlier decision to approve a statement of supports for the Applicant which did not include those last two supports. The Applicant’s mother sought review on behalf of her son by this Tribunal under s 103 of the Act of the Internal Review Decision in relation to all four supports. Since then, the Plan Under Review has been replaced by a subsequent NDIS plan for the Applicant which commenced on 27 October 2016. This was in turn, replaced by a further subsequent NDIS plan which commenced on 5 December 2016 (Current Plan). The Current Plan was due to be reviewed on 5 December 2017 and a new NDIA plan for the Applicant was due to be approved (Pending New Plan). In this application, the jurisdiction of the Tribunal is limited to the decision of the NDIA to approve the Statement of Supports in the Plan Under Review. As the Plan Under Review was replaced by subsequent NDIS plans, by operation of s 37(3) of the Act, the Plan Under Review has ceased to exist. Accordingly, the decision of the Tribunal has no practical effect or operation. However, the NDIA has voluntarily given an undertaking to the Tribunal that it is prepared to reflect any findings made by the Tribunal in relation to supports, in the Plan Under Review in the Pending New Plan. At the hearing, it was identified that an expeditious decision by the Tribunal was required because, if approved, the proposed literacy program would be commenced on 11 December 2017. This program could be undertaken by the Applicant over his 2017/2018 summer school holidays. At the time of the Internal Review Decision, the Applicant’s mother sought the provision of the LiPS program for her son. This program was developed by Lindamood-Bell Learning Processing (LBLP) and it offers to deliver the program through its LBLP Centres, as explained in more detail below. By the time of the hearing, the Applicant’s mother’s evidence had evolved to include recommendations for the funding for a different but related literacy program called Seeing Stars: Symbol Imagery for Phonological and Orthographic Processing in Reading and Spelling (SI), also offered by LBLP. At the hearing, it was proposed by the Applicant’s mother that her son undertake the SI program for 4 hours a day, 5 days a week, for a period of 8 to 10 weeks commencing on 11 December 2017. This was to be delivered by LBLP via one-on-one video conferencing sessions with LBLP staff. The hearing of this application took place on 23, 24 and 29 November 2017. At the commencement of the hearing, the parties agreed that the Tribunal should narrow its present focus on the question of whether the SI program as proposed was a reasonable and necessary support under s 34 of the Act. This was considered appropriate so as to allow the Tribunal to deal with the application expeditiously before the next review date of the Applicant’s NDIS plan which was 5 December 2017. This would permit the Applicant to commence the proposed program on 11 December 2017 and complete it over summer school holidays, if the Tribunal found in favour of the Applicant.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal will consider each of the factors set out in subsection 34(1) of the Act in turn, in relation to the proposed SI literacy program.Subsection 34(1)(a) – Whether the support will assist the Applicant to pursue the his goals, objectives and aspirations The Applicant’s goals, objectives and aspirations in the Plan Under Review are set out in paragraph [31] above. The proposed SI program is intended to improve the Applicant’s ability to read and write in the English language. If the program succeeds in improving the Applicant’s abilities in these areas, it will assist the participant to pursue his goals, objectives, and aspirations. He would have an increased capacity to get a part time job, get his driver’s licence, increase his independence by learning how to travel independently, read menus independently, find toilet facilities independently when he is out of the home, which will in turn allow for him to become more engaged in social and recreational activities on an independent basis. The Tribunal is satisfied that the mandatory requirement under subsection 34(1)(a) is met.Subsection 34(1)(b) – Whether the support will assist the Applicant to undertake activities, so as to facilitate his social and economic participation For the reasons outlined in the above paragraph, if the support achieves what is intended, and the Applicant’s ability to read and write is improved, the Tribunal is satisfied that this will assist him to undertake activities as detailed above which will facilitate his social and economic participation. The Tribunal is satisfied that the mandatory requirement under subsection 34(1)(b) is met.Subsection 34(1)(c) – Whether the support will be, or is likely to be, effective and beneficial for the participant, having regard to current good practice The NDIA contends that the proposed SI program would not be effective or beneficial for the Applicant and refers to the following:(a)The expert opinion expressed by Ms Mary Woodward, speech pathologist, who undertook an assessment of the Applicant and who gave evidence at the hearing; and(b)The Applicant’s response to the specialised literacy program, LiPS, that was previously undertaken by the Applicant. The Applicant’s mother on behalf of her son, contended that it would be effective or beneficial for the applicant to undertake a specialised literacy program through LBLP, such as the SI program as proposed, because:(a)The SI program would be delivered to the Applicant on an intensive basis, unlike the previous LiPS program which was not delivered on an intensive basis;(b)Her own observations were that there was some improvements in the Applicant’s ability to read and write following the previous LiPS program delivered to the Applicant;(c)The expert opinion expressed by Ms Heather King, speech pathologist; and(d)The views of Mr Russell from LBLP.Mary Woodward – speech pathologist Ms Woodward was engaged by the NDIA to assess and provide an opinion about the Applicant. Ms Woodward was provided with previous specialists’ reports and assessments relating to the Applicant from speech pathologists, Jenny Absalom and Adam Velcek; an occupational therapist, Kelsey Jamieson; the Applicant’s former treating psychologist, Colin McMeekin; and a literature review prepared by Speech Pathology Australia (SPA).