Morton v Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 80 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Morton v Commissioner of Taxation [2025] FCA 336

File number(s): VID 606 of 2023
Judgment of: WHEELAHAN J
Date of judgment: 11 April 2025
Catchwords: TAXATION – appeal under Part IVC of the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) against objection decision – where amended assessments of taxation brought proceeds from the sales of lots on a residential development into account as assessable income – whether assessments were excessive – whether lots on development were trading stock for the purposes of Part 2-25 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth) – whether property sale was in the course of carrying on a business of property development – where proceeds from the sales of the allotments were capital receipts derived upon the realisation of an asset – where taxpayer embarked upon enterprising means of achieving the best price when realising a capital asset – assessments were excessive – objection decision should be varied in part under s 14ZZP of the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth)
Legislation:

A New Tax System (Luxury Car Tax) Act 1999 (Cth) ss 9-5(1), 15-30(3)(c)

Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) ss 6(1), 25(1), 26(a), 36(1)

Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth) ss 6-5, 70-10, 104-10(5)(a)

Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) s 14ZZP

Cases cited: Automotive Invest Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation [2024] HCA 36; 419 ALR 324
Californian Copper Syndicate (Ltd and Reduced) v Harris (1904) 5 TC 159
Casimaty v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1997) 37 ATR 358
Commissioner of Taxes v British Australian Wool Realization Association, Ltd (in liq) [1931] AC 224
Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union v Personnel Contracting Pty Ltd [2022] HCA 1; 275 CLR 165
Crow v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1988) 19 ATR 1565
Federal Commissioner of Taxation v St Hubert’s Island Pty Ltd (1978) 138 CLR 210
Federal Commissioner of Taxation v The Myer Emporium Ltd (1987) 163 CLR 199
Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Whitfords Beach Pty Ltd (1982) 150 CLR 355
Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Williams (1972) 127 CLR 226
Howland-Rose v Commissioner of Taxation [2002] FCA 246; 118 FCR 61
Kennedy v De Trafford [1897] AC 180
Landrey v Nine Network Australia Pty Ltd [2024] FCAFC 76; 305 FCR 246
Lotus Oaks Pty Ltd v Commissioner of State Revenue (Vic) [2021] VSC 388; 113 ATR 379
Makrylos v Commissioner of Taxation [2023] FCA 971
Northern Land Council v Quall [2020] HCA 33; 271 CLR 394
Puzey v Commissioner of Taxation [2003] FCAFC 197; 131 FCR 244
Statham v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1988) 20 ATR 228
Stevenson v Commissioner of Taxation (1991) 29 FCR 282
The Hudson’s Bay Co Ltd v Stevens (1909) 5 TC 424
The Scottish Australian Mining Co Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1950) 81 CLR 188
Whitfords Beach Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1979) 44 FLR 312
Division: General Division
Registry: Victoria
National Practice Area: Taxation
Number of paragraphs: 209
Date of hearing: 30 September…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Morton v Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FCA 336
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Morton v Commissioner of Taxation, the applicant, Mr Morton, appealed against the disallowance of his objections to amended notices of assessment issued by the Commissioner of Taxation. The primary issue was whether the amended assessments, which included proceeds from the sales of lots on a residential development as assessable income, were excessive. A secondary issue concerned whether the lots on the development constituted trading stock for the purposes of Part 2-25 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997.

The court had to determine if the sales were made in the course of Mr Morton carrying on a business of developing, subdividing and selling land, and if the lots were trading stock. The court also considered if Mr Morton entered into a profit-making undertaking or scheme in respect of the property. The court reasoned that the sales of the lots were not income but capital receipts derived upon the realisation of an asset. The court concluded that the assessments were excessive because no part of the proceeds of the sale of Dave’s Block should have been included in Mr Morton’s assessable income.

The court found that the amended assessments were excessive and ordered that the Commissioner’s objection decisions be varied to allow for the excision of specific amounts from Mr Morton’s assessable income. The court also ordered the Commissioner to pay Mr Morton’s costs of the proceeding. The court emphasised that the sales were not in the course of a business but rather a mere realisation of a capital asset.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. By 3.00pm on 14 April 2025, the parties are to confer and submit by email to the Chambers of the Hon Justice Wheelahan proposed orders to give effect to the reasons for judgment.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

By order made on 8 December 2023, I fixed six separate questions for an initial hearing. A further two questions concerning the value of Dave’s Block have been deferred to a date to be fixed, as the need for their determination would be contingent upon the answers to one or more of the six initial questions. The six questions now before the Court for determination are –(1)Were the sales made in the course of Mr Morton carrying on a business of developing, subdividing and selling Dave’s Block?(2)Was Dave’s Block, or any or all of the lots, trading stock of Mr Morton pursuant to s 70-10 of the ITAA 1997?(3)If Dave’s Block or any or all of the lots were trading stock of Mr Morton, on which date or dates did Dave’s Block or the lots become trading stock?(4)Did Mr Morton enter into a profit-making undertaking or scheme in respect of Dave’s Block?(5)If Mr Morton entered into a profit-making undertaking or scheme, on what date was Dave’s Block ventured into that undertaking or scheme?(6)Were the sales made pursuant to the profit-making undertaking or scheme into which Mr Morton ventured Dave’s Block?Background To a substantial degree, the primary facts were not disputed. The issues in the proceeding turn on questions of characterisation and conclusions to be drawn from the primary facts. The Morton Farm Mr Morton’s father, Colin Morton, was a life-long farmer who purchased around 344 acres of land in Tarneit in the mid-1950s. Along with 40 acres held by Mr Morton’s mother, Alison Morton, which was known as “Alison’s Block”, this land constituted the Morton Farm. The Morton Farm was bisected by a north–south road named Derrimut Road. For the purposes of the eventual development, the land to the west of Derrimut Road was known as “Morton West”, and the land to the east of Derrimut Road was known as “Morton East”. Dave’s Block was a parcel of land of about 4.17 hectares, or 10 acres, in size. Colin Morton subdivided it from his larger holding in 1973, and in 1980 sold it to Mr Morton for $13,500. Dave’s Block abutted the western side of Derrimut Road, making it part of the Morton West development. It is relevant to the Commissioner’s case that Dave’s Block was situated with other blocks that were held by Mr Morton and his brother, Peter Morton, on trust for the beneficiaries of their respective family trusts. These other blocks were referred to as the “Home Block” and the “East Block” and together were referred to in submissions as the “Trust Land”. Those blocks were transferred in 1977 from Mr Morton’s parents to Mr Morton and Peter Morton as trustees of their respective family trusts. The position immediately before the development of the Morton Farm appears to have been that Mr Morton held Dave’s Block both legally and beneficially, and that Mr Morton and Peter Morton held the balance of the Morton Farm as trustees of the family trusts. All of the Morton Farm had been farmed by Mr Morton’s father, Colin Morton, as one property from the 1950s. Initially, Mr Morton’s father ran sheep on the Morton Farm, and from the 1970s he grazed cattle. Mr Morton assisted his father on the farm from childhood. In the early 1990s, Mr Morton increased his involvement with work on the farm as his father grew older. Mr Morton was at this time living in Swan Hill, but travelled regularly to Melbourne.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On 30 September 2022, Mr Morton objected to the amended notices of assessments. On 7 June 2023, decisions were made by the Deputy Commissioner of Taxation to disallow Mr Morton’s objections. As I have already explained, Mr Morton now appeals to the Court against the disallowance of his objection to the amended assessments, on the basis that the amended assessments were excessive. Evidence The evidence in the proceeding comprised –(a)an affidavit of Mr Morton with its annexures;(b)an affidavit of Mr Ross Donald Eva, who is an associate of Mr Morton; and(c)an index to a filleted version of the court book that was agreed between the parties, which was taken to include the documents referred to in it. Mr Morton and Mr Eva were cross-examined.Mr Morton I have summarised relevant aspects of Mr Morton’s affidavit evidence in the background section of these reasons. Mr Morton’s account of events was not seriously challenged, and so it is enough to summarise the topics addressed during his cross-examination.Cross-examination of Mr Morton Mr Morton was cross-examined at length by senior counsel for the Commissioner. Mr Morton was asked about his initial assessment of how to maximise the profit to be made from selling the Morton Farm. Mr Morton said that he had not made any independent inquiries as to the value of the land, but that he considered that the sale price of the land would be maximised if it were subdivided before being sold. Mr Morton was taken to two documents evidencing early negotiations between Dacland and the Morton family that preceded the execution of the development agreements. The first, a draft terms sheet, stated that the projected target financial return to the Morton family was 37.4% of gross revenue from the sale of lots, which “based on the initial feasibility would be $143 million”. Mr Morton stated that this was a negotiated figure, and that he had not conducted his own analysis as to the market value of the Morton Farm. The second document was an unsigned heads of agreement that expressed an intention to include in the final agreement the terms contained in the terms sheet. This document specified that the financial return to the Morton family would be the proceeds from the sale of lots, after the subtraction of a Development Fee that would not exceed 61% of gross sales proceeds. Senior counsel for the Commissioner pressed Mr Morton on whether various contractual documents, including the development agreements, were prepared by solicitors acting for the Morton family. Mr Morton gave evidence that the Dave’s Block development agreement was prepared by his solicitors in accordance with his instructions. As for Mr Morton’s negotiations with Dacland, he explained that the key tenets to which he adhered while negotiating were that the Morton Farm properties should not be used as security for loans taken out by Dacland, and that the Morton family should receive a fixed percentage of the proceeds from each subdivided lot, so that Dacland could not artificially inflate expenses so as to reduce the entitlements of the Morton family. Mr Morton explained that the 51.9% figure that was ultimately included in the development agreements was reached after a negotiation process that followed Mr Morton’s tenets, and which started at a 50/50 split between Dacland and the Morton family. Mr Morton stated that he accepted this division on the basis of his own business sense, rather than any formal analysis.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Accordingly, if I had found that Mr Morton’s activities had amounted to a business, I would have concluded that Dave’s Block began to be held as trading stock on 23 November 2012. If I had reached that conclusion, it would have followed that the amended assessments adopted the correct date for the valuation of Dave’s Block, but a question would remain concerning the appropriate amount that should have been brought to account as the value of Dave’s Block as at that date.Conclusion For these reasons, I conclude that the amended assessments issued by the Commissioner to Mr Morton in relation to the 2019 and 2021 years of income are excessive. The power of the Court in a proceeding of this nature is to “make such order in relation to the [objection] decision as it thinks fit, including an order confirming or varying the decision”: s 14ZZP of the Taxation Administration Act. The relevant decision is the decision of the Commissioner that did not allow Mr Morton’s objections. The Commissioner’s objection decision must be varied. Mr Morton’s objections canvassed a range of issues that have not been agitated in this proceeding. The relevant aspects of Mr Morton’s objection were paragraph [3(d)], in relation to the 2019 amended assessment, and paragraph [4(d)], in relation to the 2021 amended assessment. Those paragraphs called for the excision from Mr Morton’s assessable income of the amounts representing the net proceeds of the sale of Dave’s Block, or some lesser amount. Given my conclusion that no part of the proceeds of the sale of Dave’s Block should have been included in Mr Morton’s assessable income, it is not necessary for the objection decisions to be varied to allow for some lesser amount to be excised. The amounts specified in the objections accord with the amounts acknowledged by the Commissioner in this proceeding to be the amounts in issue. Accordingly, I propose orders to the effect that –(1)The respondent’s objection decision made on 7 June 2023 in relation to the applicant’s objections to amended assessments issued to him on 2 August 2022 in respect of the income years ended 30 June 2019 and 30 June 2021 be varied such that the objections are allowed in part, by:(a)excising from the amended assessment of the applicant’s assessable income in respect of the income year ended 30 June 2019 the sum of $3,153,536, and recalculating the tax payable thereon accordingly; and(b)excising from the amended assessment of the applicant’s assessable income in respect of the income year ended 30 June 2021 the sum of $660,402, and recalculating the tax payable thereon accordingly.(2)The respondent pay the applicant’s costs of the proceeding. I wish to hear from the parties on the form of orders.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the Commissioner’s submission, that intention was formed when Mr Morton executed the Dave’s Block development agreement on 23 November 2012. The Commissioner submitted that steps necessary to effect the sale of Dave’s Block in the form of subdivided lots might be relevant to the date on which Mr Morton began to carry on a business, but that assuming Mr Morton was carrying on a business at the relevant time, these events were not determinative of the time at which the requisite intention was formed. The Commissioner submitted that by the time Mr Morton executed the development agreement on 23 November 2012, he had committed the land to being developed, subdivided, and sold in accordance with the terms of the agreement. In this way, an intention to sell Dave’s Block in the ordinary course of his business could be discerned.ConsiderationGeneral principles on mere realisation of a capital asset The general principle upon which Mr Morton relied was stated by the Lord Justice Clerk in Californian Copper Syndicate (Ltd and Reduced) v Harris (1904) 5 TC 159 (Californian Copper) at 165–166 –[i]t is quite a well settled principle in dealing with questions of assessment of Income Tax, that where the owner of an ordinary investment chooses to realise it, and obtains a greater price for it than he originally acquired it at, the enhanced price is not profit … assessable to Income Tax. But it is equally well established that enhanced values obtained from realisation or conversion of securities may be so assessable, where what is done is not merely a realisation or change of investment, but an act done in what is truly the carrying on, or carrying out, of a business. …What is the line which separates the two classes of cases may be difficult to define, and each case must be considered according to its facts; the question to be determined being—Is the sum of gain that has been made a mere enhancement of value by realising a security, or is it a gain made in an operation of business in carrying out a scheme for profit-making? In The Hudson’s Bay Co Ltd v Stevens (1909) 5 TC 424 (Hudson’s Bay Co), the Court of Appeal considered a similar question, albeit on very peculiar facts involving a chartered corporation selling parcels of land as they were obtained, over time, under an arrangement with the Canadian and British governments. Cozens-Hardy MR relevantly said at 436 –The real question is whether this money can be regarded as profits or gains derived by the Company from carrying on a trade or business. In my opinion it cannot. The Company are doing no more than an ordinary landowner does who is minded to sell from time to time, as purchasers offer, portions suitable for building of an estate which has devolved upon him from his ancestors. I am unable to attach any weight to the circumstance that large sales are made every year. This is not a case where land is from time to time purchased with a view to resale; the Company are only getting rid by sale as fast as they reasonably can of land which they acquired as part of a consideration for the surrender of their Charter.