Morellini v Mizzi Family Holdings Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 62 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Morellini v Mizzi Family Holdings Pty Ltd [2016] FCAFC 13

Appeal from:

Mizzi Family Holdings Pty Ltd v Morellini [2013] FCA 1435

Mizzi Family Holdings Pty Ltd v Morellini (No 2) [2014] FCA 807

File number(s): QUD 462 of 2014
QUD 464 of 2014
Judge(s): BENNETT, GREENWOOD AND YATES JJ
Date of judgment: 16 February 2016
Catchwords:

PATENTS – innovation patent for cane billet planter – infringement – whether infringement proved  

PATENTS – validity – novelty – whether lack of novelty established

PATENTS – validity – innovative step – whether lack of innovative step arises as an issue

PATENTS – validity – false suggestion or misrepresentation – whether primary judge erred in construction of claims – whether false suggestion established

PATENTS – unjustifiable threats – whether primary judge erred in finding claim for damages for unjustifiable threats had been abandoned

Legislation: Patents Act 1990 (Cth) ss 7, 18, 40, 102, 119, 138
Cases cited: Commercial Union Assurance Company of Australia Ltd v Ferrcom Pty Ltd (1991) 22 NSWLR 389
Jones v Multiple Sclerosis Society of Victoria Ltd [1996] 1 VR 499
Kuhl v Zurich Financial Services Ltd (2011) 243 CLR 361; [2011] HCA 11
Laguerre’s Patent [1970] RPC 587
Mizzi Family Holdings Pty Ltd v Morellini (2013) 104 IPR 109; [2013] FCA 1435
Mizzi Family Holdings Pty Ltd v Morellini (2014) 109 IPR 182; [2014] FCA 807
Ranbaxy Australia Pty Ltd v Warner-Lambert Co LLC (2008) 77 IPR 449; [2008] FCAFC 82
S & I Publishing Pty Ltd v Australian Surf Life Saver Pty Ltd (1998) 88 FCR 354
Toyo Tsushinki Kabushiki Kaisha’s Application [1962] RPC 9
Windsurfing International Inc v Petit [1984] 2 NSWLR 196
Date of hearing: 26, 27 February 2015
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Intellectual Property
Sub-area: Patents and Associated Statutes
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 155
Counsel for the Appellant in QUD 462 of 2014 and the Respondent in QUD 464 of 2014: Mr A Ryan SC
Solicitor for the Appellant in QUD 462 of 2014 and the Respondent in QUD 464 of 2014: Griffith Hack Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondents in QUD 462 of 2014 and the Appellants in QUD 464 of 2014: Mr D Campbell QC with Mr J Horton QC
Solicitor for the Respondents in QUD 462 of 2014 and the Appellants in QUD 464 of 2014: Boulton Cleary & Kern Lawyers

ORDERS

QUD 462 of 2014
BETWEEN:

DARYL MARK MORELLINI

Appellant

AND:

MIZZI FAMILY HOLDINGS PTY LTD (ACN 132 033 615)

First Respondent

PAUL LAURENCE MIZZI

Second Respondent

JUDGES:

BENNETT, GREENWOOD AND YATES JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

16 FEBRUARY 2016

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.By 23 February 2016, the parties bring in agreed orders giving effect to the reasons for judgment published 16 February 2016.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

ORDERS

QUD 464 of 2014
BETWEEN:

MIZZI FAMILY HOLDINGS PTY LTD (ACN 132 033 615)

First…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Morellini v Mizzi Family Holdings Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FCAFC 13
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Morellini v Mizzi Family Holdings Pty Ltd, the dispute centred around the infringement and validity of a patent for a cane billet planter. The case was heard by the Federal Court of Australia. The appellant, Mr Morellini, claimed that the respondent, Mizzi Family Holdings Pty Ltd (MFH), had infringed his patent. MFH argued that the patent was invalid on grounds including lack of novelty and innovative step, and that Mr Morellini had abandoned his claim for damages for unjustifiable threats.

The court needed to determine whether MFH had infringed the patent, whether the patent was valid, and whether Mr Morellini had abandoned his claim for damages. The court found that MFH had not infringed the patent as Mr Morellini had failed to prove the infringement. The court also found that the patent was invalid due to lack of novelty. Issues regarding the innovative step and false suggestion or misrepresentation were not considered necessary due to the patent's invalidity. The court concluded that Mr Morellini had not abandoned his claim for damages for unjustifiable threats, and this claim should be remitted to the primary judge for determination.

The appeal by Mr Morellini was allowed, and the primary judge's order dismissing the cross-claim was set aside. MFH and Mr Mizzi were ordered to pay the costs of the appeal and the cross-claim. The patent was ordered to be revoked. Mr Morellini's claim for damages for unjustifiable threats was to be remitted to the primary judge for determination. The appeal by MFH was dismissed, and MFH was ordered to pay Mr Morellini's costs of that appeal. The parties were directed to bring in draft orders giving effect to the judgment.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. By 23 February 2016, the parties bring in agreed orders giving effect to the reasons for judgment published 16 February 2016.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Having regard to the fact that, for other reasons, infringement has not been proved, and that the patent has been found to be invalid in any event, it is not necessary to embark upon a consideration of any of these grounds. This is particularly so where, in relation to the first two grounds, there are no relevant findings of fact by the primary judge. These grounds were not developed in the appeal in a way that would assist us in attempting to make the relevant findings now. Had it become necessary to determine those grounds then, in all likelihood, it would also have been necessary to remit them to the primary judge for that purpose.CONCLUSION AND DISPOSITION The Morellini appeal should be allowed. The primary judge’s order otherwise dismissing the cross-claim should be set aside. MFH and Mr Mizzi should pay the costs of the Morellini appeal and of the cross-claim, including reserved costs. An order should be made that the patent be revoked. Mr Morellini’s claim for damages for unjustifiable threats should be remitted to the primary judge for determination on the evidence now before his Honour. The Mizzi appeal should be dismissed. MFH should pay Mr Morellini’s costs of that appeal. The parties should bring in draft orders giving effect to these reasons.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Morellini also submitted that it was never argued by MFH, and not accepted by Mr Morellini, that the effect of downward force on soil in a mound with a gentle incline would cause the incline to increase to the “angle of repose” of that soil sample. Mr Morellini submitted that, clearly, soil cannot fall to its natural angle of repose if the incline is not above that angle in the first place.Consideration MFH has not demonstrated error in the primary judge’s reasoning or conclusion that infringement had not been proved. The primary judge was, plainly, mindful of the fact that the Morellini device as operated at the demonstration was different to the device that had been operated at a previous time. In particular, the primary judge was mindful of the fact that the compression spring on the wheel assembly had been removed and that tension springs had been added. But his Honour was, with respect, correct to observe that it does not follow that, but for those adjustments, the Morellini device would form mounds which had a relatively flat top or sides inclined at angles between 20° and 60°. It is important to note the basis on which Mr Sulman expressed the opinion on which MFH relied. At [88] of his report of 16 April 2012, Mr Sulman said:… it is my opinion that the absence of a hydraulic drive motor on the Morellini mound profiler as fitted to the Mizzi mound profiler, prevents the Morellini mound profiler from engaging with an adequate down force, and subsequently, functioning in such a manner that it would not apply compression to the top of the mound forming a neat apex profile as described in [the patent]. At [91] of that report, Mr Sulman said:… it is my opinion that if the Morellini mound profiler had been fitted with a down force spring combined with a hydraulic drive to assist rotating the mound profiler, allowing for correct engagement along the top of the mound, then it would be expected that one would witness a final mound profile consisting of a top surface that is relatively flat, resulting in the soil along the lower sides of the mound squeezed outwards to form an increased incline between 20° and 60° as described in [the patent]. So expressed, Mr Sulman reasoned that profiling the mound with a relatively flat top surface would necessarily result in the sides of the mound being inclined at between 20° and 60°. As the primary judge correctly observed, Mr Sulman’s opinion in this regard appears to have been based on the Morellini device operating with an hydraulic drive—a feature which the Morellini device did not have at any time. Contrary to MFH’s submissions, the primary judge was not ‘stipulating’ that the claims of the patent required the creation of force by hydraulics. The primary judge was merely noting the particular basis on which Mr Sulman had given his opinion. The fact that the Morellini device had never operated with an hydraulic drive is telling. It plainly undermined Mr Sulman’s opinion, as expressed in his report.