Mizzi Family Holdings Pty Ltd v Morellini

Link copied
Case Copied 68 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Mizzi Family Holdings Pty Ltd v Morellini [2013] FCA 1435

Citation: Mizzi Family Holdings Pty Ltd v Morellini [2013] FCA 1435
Parties: MIZZI FAMILY HOLDINGS PTY LTD (ACN 132 033 615) v DARYL MARK MORELLINI; DARYL MARK MORELLINI; MIZZI FAMILY HOLDINGS PTY LTD (ACN 132 033 615) and PAUL LAURENCE MIZZI
File number: QUD 112 of 2011
Judge: DOWSETT J
Date of judgment: 24 December 2013
Catchwords:

PATENTS – innovation patent – invention for device to plant billets of sugar cane within mound – whether patent invalid for want of novelty, lack of innovative step, false suggestion or misrepresentation or lack of fair basing – where onus on cross-claimant to prove invalidity – consideration of meaning of false suggestion or misrepresentation – where invalidity not proved upon proper construction of specification

PATENTS – innovation patent – whether respondent’s invention infringes innovation patent – where evidence that device modified during demonstration – where expert evidence nonetheless equivocal as to effect of modification – where applicant therefore unable to prove infringement   

Legislation: Patents Act 1990 (Cth) ss 18, 40, 138
Cases cited: In the matter of Alsop’s Patent (1907) 24 RPC 733 cited
JMBV EnterprisesPty Ltd v Camoflag Pty Ltd (2005) 67 IPR 68 cited
Dates of hearing: 28, 29, 30 and 31 May 2012
Date of last submissions: 15 October 2012
Place: Brisbane (heard in Townsville)
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 121
Counsel for the Applicant and the First Cross-Respondent: Mr D Campbell SC with Mr J Horton
Solicitor for the Applicant and the First Cross-Respondent: Boulton Cleary & Kern
Counsel for the Respondent and the Cross-Claimant: Mr A Ryan SC with Mr D Eliades
Solicitor for the Respondent and the Cross-Claimant: Griffith Hack Lawyers

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

QUD 112 of 2011

BETWEEN:

MIZZI FAMILY HOLDINGS PTY LTD (ACN 132 033 615)
Applicant

DARYL MARK MORELLINI
Cross-Claimant

AND:

DARYL MARK MORELLINI
Respondent

MIZZI FAMILY HOLDINGS PTY LTD (ACN 132 033 615)
First Cross-Respondent

PAUL LAURENCE MIZZI
Second Cross-Respondent

JUDGE:

DOWSETT J

DATE:

24 DECEMBER 2013

PLACE:

BRISBANE (HEARD IN TOWNSVILLE)

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. The applicant is the patentee pursuant to Innovation Patent No 2010100955 (the “Patent”).  The invention described therein involves a “cane billet planter”, a planting apparatus and a method for planting sugarcane (the “Invention”).  The Patent is dated 30 September 2010.  The Patent is derived from Standard Patent Application No 20072102931 filed on 25 June 2007.  At the time of trial the Standard Patent Application had not been granted, but its grant was anticipated.  The applicant alleges that the respondent has infringed the Patent by the use of a cane planting device (the “Morellini device”).  The respondent denies infringement and cross-claims for revocation on the grounds of:

    ·want of novelty;

    ·lack of an innovative step;

    ·false suggestion or misrepresentation; and

    ·that there has been non-compliance with s 40 of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth) (the “Act”).

  2. I am not sure whether the s…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mizzi Family Holdings Pty Ltd v Morellini and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCA 1435
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mizzi Family Holdings Pty Ltd took legal action against Morellini in the Federal Court of Australia over the alleged infringement of an innovation patent. The patent in question pertains to a device designed for planting sugar cane billets within a mound. The primary legal issues addressed by the court involved the validity of the patent and whether Morellini's invention infringed upon it. Regarding validity, the court had to determine whether the patent was invalid due to lack of novelty, absence of an innovative step, false suggestion or misrepresentation, or lack of fair basing. Additionally, the court examined whether Morellini's invention infringed on any of the claims of the patent.

The court found that the patent was not invalid on any of the grounds presented. It clarified the meaning of "false suggestion or misrepresentation" and concluded that the patent's specification, when properly construed, did not contain any misleading information. The court also considered the respondent's arguments regarding the infringement of the patent by Morellini's device. Despite some modifications to the device during a demonstration, the court found the expert evidence equivocal regarding the impact of these modifications, leading to the conclusion that the applicant could not prove infringement.

The court ultimately ruled that Morellini's device did not infringe on any of the patent claims. It held that the device did not produce a mound with sides inclined at the specified angles as required by the patent, and it lacked a mound profiler as stipulated in some of the claims. Consequently, the court dismissed Mizzi Family Holdings' claims of patent infringement. No final orders were mentioned in the text.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

I accept that a superficial reading of the specification might suggest that a particular inclination of the side of a mound would increase the warming effect of the sun. However a reading of p 4 ll 16-25 with the diagrams discloses a quite different proposition. As I have previously observed, the inclination simply describes a mound which will catch the sun’s rays. This purely mechanical proposition is clearly demonstrated by the diagrams in the Patent. Mr Sulman demonstrates the same point in exhibit 9. The allegation of false suggestion or misrepresentation lacks substance.Conclusion on validity No ground of invalidity has been established.INFRINGEMENT The applicant submits that the Morellini device exhibits the integers of all five claims. The respondent asserts that the device does not infringe any of the claims for the following reasons:3.The Morellini Device does not infringe any of the 5 claims of the … [Patent] patent.4. Claim 1 is not infringed as:(a)The Morellini Device does not produce a mound where each side of the mound is at an incline of between 20o to 60o;(b)The press wheels used by the Morellini Device are not a mound profiler. They are used to press the top of the mound so that the billets have better sett to soil contact.5.Claim 2 is a dependent claim on Claim 1 and so the same arguments that apply to Claim 1 apply to claim 2.6.Claim 3 is a dependent claim on Claim 1 and so the same arguments that apply to Claim 1 apply to claim 3.7.Claim 4 is not infringed as:(a)The top of the mound created by the Morellini Device is not ‘relatively flat’ as required by subparagraph (d).(b)the requirement in subparagraph (d) that “each side of the mound is inclined at an angle which promotes warming by the sun” may either mean:(i)That the angle is construed as being between 20o to 60o, in which case the same argument applies to this claim as it does in respect of Claim 1.(ii)Where the angle is not identified as being between 20o to 60o, the claim is invalid under s 40 of the Patents Act as there is nothing in the claim or the body of the specifications to identify the measurement of the angle.8.Claim 5 is not infringed as the Morellini Device does not produce a mound where each side of the mount is at an incline of between 20o to 60o.Prior Use9.It is found that the Morellini Device infringed the ’955 patent, Mr Morellini claims that he was immediately before the priority date of the ’955 patent, 25 June 2007:(a) Exploiting the Morellini Device in Australia, or alternative,(b) Taking definite steps to exploit the Morellini Device,within s 119 of the Patents Act. The evidence concerning these matters comes primarily from Mr Sulman and Mr Robotham. Most of their evidence is derived from an examination of the Morellini device and a test operation conducted in their presence on 29 March 2012. Setting aside the claim of prior use, the respondent submits that use of the Morellini device does not infringe because:·the shape of the mound which it produces is not the shape identified in the Patent; and·it lacks a mound profiler as required by claims 1, 2 and 3.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established