Minotaur Constructions (ACT) Pty Ltd v Construction Occupations Registrar (Occupational Discipline)

Link copied
Case Copied 53 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL



MINOTAUR CONSTRUCTIONS (ACT) PTY LTD v CONSTRUCTION OCCUPATIONS REGISTRAR (Occupational Discipline) [2014] ACAT 43

OR 13/50

Catchwords:             OCCUPATIONAL DISCIPLINE – CONSTRUCTION OCCUPATION -– principles of statutory construction in relation to regulatory statutes - construction of sections 19(1), 19(4) and 19(6) of the Construction Occupations (Licensing) Act 2004 (COLA) - tribunal’s jurisdiction and power to make orders under section 19(6) of the COLA - the duty of Registrar to issue, or refuse to issue, licence on application is mandatory – Registrar’s decision must be made “as soon as possible” – decision under review was made outside the permitted time frame - section 19(1), 19(4) and 19(6) are limited to the facts as they existed at the date of the licence application - - regard can be had to evidence to the date of hearing that shed light on relevant facts at the date of licence application - Registrar’s refusal of licence is ultra vires – tribunal’s power and jurisdiction to review Registrar’s ultra vires decision - “accrued rights” to the benefit of the law as it stood at the date of the licence application.

Legislation:ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008, ss 68 and 69

Construction Occupation (Licensing) Act 2004, ss 15, 17, 19, 28, 123, 123A and 123C

Legislation Act 2001, ss 146 and 151B

Subordinate              

Legislation:Construction Occupations (Licensing) Regulation 2004, ss 15, and 19, and schedule 4

Cases:B & T Constructions (ACT) P/L v Constructions Registrar and the Owners – Unit Plan 3324 [2013] ACTSC 219

Certain Lloyd's Underwriters Subscribing to Contract No IH00AAQS v Cross [2012] HCA 56
Collector of Customs (NSW) v Brian Lawlor Automotive P/L (1979) 41 FLR 338
Comcare Australia v Lees (1997) 151 ALR 647
Committee of Direction of Fruit Marketing v Collins (1925) 36 CLR 410
Commonwealth v Progress Advertising and Press Agency Co P/L (1910) 10 CLR 45
Drake v Minister For Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1979) 2 ALD 60
Esber v Commonwealth [1992] HCA 20
Georgalis v ACT Planning and Land Authority [2012] ACAT 1
Northern Territory v Arnhem Land Aboriginal Land Trust (2008) 236 CLR 24
R & R Fazzolari P/L v Parramatta City Council (2009) 237 CLR 603
Re Sarina and Secretary, Department of Social Security [1988] 14 ALD 437
Reilly and Secretary, Department of Social Security (1987) 12 ALD 407
Ruchschloss v Simmons and Middlemiss (No2) [2013] ACTSC 133
Secretary, Department of Family & Community Services v Holmes [2000] FCA 513
Shi v Migration Agents Registration Agency [2008] HCA 31
Springhall v Kirner [1988] VR 159
Sunol v Collier [2012] NSWCA 14

Texts/Papers:            Pearce D.C. and Geddes R.S, Statutory Interpretation in Australia, 7th Edition

Tribunal:Mr A. Anforth – Senior Member       

Date of Orders:  17 July 2014

Date of Reasons for Decision:       17 July 2014

ACT CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL          OR 13/50

BETWEEN:

MINOTAUR CONSTRUCTIONS

(ACT) PTY LTD

Applicant

AND:

CONSTRUCTION OCCUPATIONS

REGISTRAR

Respondent

TRIBUNAL:             Mr A. Anforth – Senior Member

DATE:17 July 2014

FINDINGS

  1. The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Minotaur Constructions (ACT) Pty Ltd v Construction Occupati... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] ACAT 43
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Minotaur Constructions (ACT) Pty Ltd sought to challenge a decision by the Construction Occupations Registrar to refuse the grant of a licence. The dispute centred on the interpretation of sections 19(1), 19(4) and 19(6) of the Construction Occupations (Licensing) Act 2004 (ACT) (the COLA) which deal with the power to refuse or defer a decision on a licence application. The Applicant argued that the power to refuse a licence under sections 19(1) or 19(4), or to defer a decision on the licence under 19(6), was a temporally conditioned power: that is, it is a decision made on the facts as they stood at the date of the licence application (an accrued right based on the existing facts). The Applicant contended that there was no basis to refuse the grant of the licence or to defer a decision on the licence under sections 19(1) or 19(4) as there were no disciplinary proceedings afoot at the date that the licence application was lodged. The Applicant also took issue with the evidence of Mr Green for the Respondent to the effect that the rectification work at Empire Apartments has not been completed and contends that this dispute is not a relevant consideration for the purposes of either section 19(4) or 19(6). The Respondent submitted that the word ‘must’ in section 19(1) of the COLA imported nothing other than an imperative that a decision must be made on an application; that is, only that it eventually be made. It did not carry any implication for when that decision must be made or upon what basis it was made. The Respondent relied heavily upon Shi v Migration Agents Registration Agency [2008] HCA 31 for the proposition that the Tribunal may have regard to all the facts that existed to the date of the Tribunal’s hearing, and that no part of section 19 is a temporally conditioned provision. The Court considered the principles of statutory interpretation that provide for a minimalist construction of provisions that intrude into existing common law rights or private statutory rights and found that the power to refuse a licence under section 19(4) of the COLA is a subset of the more broadly expressed power in section 19(1). The Court found that the same could not be true of section 19(6) of the COLA. The Court held that the power under section 19(6) of the COLA to defer making a decision on the licence application only arises in the Tribunal once the Tribunal is properly seized of jurisdiction in relation to a reviewable decision. Accordingly, the application for review of the Registrar’s decision was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

7.

The application is to be listed for directions for the further consideration.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Applicant submitted that the power to refuse a licence under sections 19(1) or 19(4), or to defer a decision on the licence under 19(6), was a temporally conditioned power: that is, it is a decision made on the facts as they stood at the date of the licence application (an accrued right based on the existing facts). Insofar as there were no disciplinary proceedings afoot at the date that the licence application was lodged (or at the date of the Registrar’s decision), there was no basis under either section 19(1) or section 19(4) to refuse the grant of the licence and no basis for deferring a decision on the licence under section 19(6). The Applicant took issue with the evidence of Mr Green for the Respondent to the effect that the rectification work at Empire Apartments has not been completed and contends that this dispute is not a relevant consideration for the purposes of either section 19(4) or 19(6). The Applicant did not specifically advert to issue of the non-existence of section 19(4) at the date of the licence application. The Respondent submitted that the word ‘must’ in section 19(1) of the COLA imported nothing other than an imperative that a decision must be made on an application; that is, only that it eventually be made. It did not carry any implication for when that decision must be made or upon what basis it was made. The Respondent relied heavily upon Shi v Migration Agents Registration Agency [2008] HCA 31 for the proposition that the Tribunal may have regard to all the facts that existed to the date of the Tribunal’s hearing, and that no part of section 19 is a temporally conditioned provision. At the hearing, the Tribunal raised with the parties for their consideration the principles of statutory interpretation that provide for a minimalist construction of provisions that intrude into existing common law rights or private statutory rights (R&R Fazzolari P/L v Parramatta City Council (2009) 237 CLR 603 at [619-20]; Commonwealth v Progress Advertising and Press Agency Co P/L (1910) 10 CLR 45; Committee of Direction of Fruit Marketing v Collins (1925) 36 CLR 410; Northern Territory v Arnhem Land Aboriginal Land Trust (2008) 236 CLR 24). The Tribunal notes that a similar issue was raised in the context of the COLA in Ruchschloss v Simmons and Middlemiss (No2) [2013] ACTSC 133. Specifically, it was put to the parties that the right to participate in trade and commerce in a chosen trade/profession is a right that existed at common law prior to the COLA. The COLA has abrogated the common law right and then imposed a licensing regime to regulate the trade. The legislative policy underpinning statutes of a regulatory kind such as the COLA require a construction that is sufficient to achieve its legislative policy but that intrudes to the least extent into these existing rights. This approach to the construction should apply to the COLA as whole and therefore should apply equally to provisions that deal with the granting of the licence and to those that refuse licences.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Sections 68 and 69 of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 (the ACAT Act) set out the power of the Tribunal to review decisions.68Review of decisions(1)This section applies if the tribunal reviews a decision by an entity.(2)The tribunal may exercise any function given by an Act to the entity for making the decision.NoteA reference to an Act includes a reference to the statutory instruments made or in force under the Act, including regulations (see Legislation Act, s 104).(3)The tribunal must, by order—(a)confirm the decision; or(b)vary the decision; or(c)set aside the decision and—(i)make a substitute decision; or(ii)remit the matter that is the subject of the decision for reconsideration by the decision-maker in accordance with any direction or recommendation of the tribunal.69Effect of orders for administrative review(1)This section applies if the tribunal makes an order under section 68 (3) in relation to a decision.(2)The order—(a)is taken to be the decision of the decision-maker; and(b)takes effect from the day the tribunal makes the order, unless the tribunal orders otherwise. It is significant to note for present purposes that sections 19(1) and (4) of the COLA, as they presently stand, relate to the power to refuse a licence application; whereas section 19(6) is only a power to defer making any decision on a licence application pending outstanding disciplinary action against the applicant for the licence or its nominee. Section 123A of the COLA provides that ‘reviewable decisions’ (that is, decisions reviewable by the Tribunal) are prescribed in the COLA Regulation. Section 123C of the COLA defines the persons who may exercise that right of review. Schedule 4 of the COLA Regulation provides that a decision to refuse a licence under section 19(1) of the COLA is reviewable by the Tribunal. Schedule 4 does not define a ‘reviewable decision’ to include section 19(4) of the COLA, or a decision under 19(6) to defer making a decision on a licence application. It may be that the power to refuse a licence under section 19(4) of the COLA is a subset of the more broadly expressed power in section 19(1) and hence, a decision to refuse a licence under section 19(4) would be a ‘reviewable decision’ under section 19(1). The same could not be true of section 19(6) of the COLA. Assuming a decision under section 19(6) to defer making a decision on a licence application can be properly described as a ‘decision’ for the purposes of section 68 of the ACAT Act, it is still the case that section 68 relies upon the COLA and in particular Schedule 4 of the COLA Regulation, as its source of jurisdiction. Schedule 4 does not confer a right of review on the Tribunal for decisions made under section 19(6) of the COLA. In the context of the COLA, the Tribunal is not a primary decision maker; rather it reviews a defined range of decisions that have already been the subject of a primary decision. In this sense the Tribunal’s role is akin to that the Commonwealth Administrative Appeals Tribunal as set out in Comcare Australia v Lees (1997) 151 ALR 647. In order to be seized of jurisdiction the Tribunal must have before it for review a decision of the kind set out in Schedule 4 of the COLA Regulation. It may be that once properly seized of jurisdiction in this manner, sections 68 and 69 of the ACAT Act permit the Tribunal to exercise any power that may have been open to the Registrar, including the power under section 19(6) of the COLA to defer making a decision on the licence application. But this is not the same thing as saying that the decision under review is a decision by the Registrar under section 19(6); not the least because the Registrar did not in fact purport to make any such decision, but rather made an affirmative decision to refuse the licence. Even viewed as a source of power (as opposed to jurisdiction), the power in section 19(6) only arises in the Tribunal once the Tribunal is properly seized of jurisdiction in relation to a reviewable decision. Hence the need to identify the relevant reviewable decision.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Under section 15 of the Construction Occupations (Licensing) Regulation 2004 (the COLA Regulation), the Applicant is entitled to apply for a builder’s licence provided its nominee is a licensed builder:15 Corporations and partnerships eligible for some occupations(1) A corporation or partnership is eligible to be licensed only in the following construction occupations or occupation classes: …(b) builder; …(2) Also, a corporation or partnership is eligible to be licensed in a construction occupation or occupation class only if the corporation or partnership has a nominee who is licensed in the occupation or class. … Under section 19 of the COLA Regulation, a person may be a nominee of a company if they are a director of the company and personally hold the relevant licence being sought by the company:19Eligibility to be nominee—Act, s 28 (4)An individual is eligible to be a nominee of a corporation or partnership if—(a) for a corporation—the individual is a director or employee of the corporation; and...(c) the individual is licensed in a construction occupation that the corporation or partnership is licensed in or applying to be licensed in; and...(e) for a construction occupation divided into classes—either—(i)the individual is licensed in the same class as, or a class that allows the exercising of the same functions as, the class the corporation or partnership is licensed in or applying to be licensed in; or (ii) the corporation or partnership has a nominee mentioned in subparagraph (i); and... The power of the Registrar to reject the Applicant’s application for a licence is found in section 19 of the COLA. Prior to 6 August 2013 section 19 read:19 Decision on licence application19(1) If an entity applies for a licence for a construction occupation or occupation class, the registrar must issue, or refuse to issue, the licence.…(3) The registrar must refuse to issue a licence for a construction occupation or occupation class to an applicant if—(a) the registrar is not satisfied that the applicant is eligible to be licensed in the occupation or class; or(b) the applicant is disqualified from holding a licence under section 98 (Licence disqualification).(4) If an application for occupational discipline in relation to an applicant or nominee of an applicant has been made by the registrar under division 5.2 (Occupational discipline—licensees), the registrar need not decide whether to licence the applicant until the application has been dealt with by the ACAT, and any appeal or review arising from the occupational discipline, is finished. Section 19 was amended by section 27 of the Construction and Energy Efficiency Legislation Amendment Act 2013 effective 26 August 2013 to read:19Decision on licence application(1)If an entity applies for a licence for a construction occupation or occupation class, the registrar must issue, or refuse to issue, the licence....(3)The registrar must refuse to issue a licence for a construction occupation or occupation class to an applicant if—(a)the registrar is not satisfied that the applicant is eligible to be licensed in the occupation or class; or(b)the applicant is disqualified from holding a licence under section 98 (Licence disqualification).(4)The registrar may refuse to issue a licence for a construction occupation or occupation class to an applicant if—(a)the applicant, a director or nominee of an applicant that is a corporation, or a partner or nominee of an applicant that is a partnership, is a licensee or former licensee (however described) under this Act or a corresponding law who—(i)is prohibited from providing a construction service (however described) under this Act or a corresponding law; or(ii)is subject to occupational discipline (however described) under this Act or a corresponding law; or(iii)the registrar believes on reasonable grounds surrendered a licence (however described) in circumstances that related to a ground for occupational discipline (however described) under this Act or a corresponding law; and(b)the registrar believes on reasonable grounds that the refusal is necessary or desirable to protect the public....(6)If an application for occupational discipline in relation to an applicant or nominee of an applicant has been made by the registrar under division 5.2 (Occupational discipline—licensees), the registrar need not decide whether to licence the applicant until the application has been dealt with by the ACAT, and any appeal or review arising from the occupational discipline, is finished.