Minister for Sustainability, Environment and Conservation v Zander

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

MINISTER FOR SUSTAINABILITY, ENVIRONMENT AND CONSERVATION v ZANDER

[2014] SASCFC 83

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Justice Gray, The Honourable Justice Vanstone and The Honourable Justice Stanley)

25 July 2014

ENERGY AND RESOURCES - WATER - WATER MANAGEMENT - WATER MANAGEMENT PLANS

ENERGY AND RESOURCES - WATER - WATER MANAGEMENT - IRRIGATION

STATUTES - ACTS OF PARLIAMENT - INTERPRETATION - GENERAL APPROACHES TO INTERPRETATION - GENERALLY

Appeal from a decision of a single Judge of the Supreme Court overturning a decision of a Judge of the Environment, Resources and Development Court on the proper construction of the Water Allocation Plan for the Barossa Prescribed Water Resources Area.  The preliminary question was: Does the [Barossa Water Allocation Plan] (and Principle 5.2.14 in particular) permit the allocation of water on [the Zanders’ licence], so that: (a) each individual resource nominated on the licence has a maximum volume allocated to it/them; and (b) the total amount that may be taken from all or any resource in any water use year does not exceed 42 ML; but (c) the sum of the volumes nominated on the licence to each of the individual resources exceeds 42 ML?

Whether the Judge erred in holding that the preliminary question should be answered in the affirmative.

Held per the Court allowing the appeal:

1.  The Judge erred in holding that the preliminary question should be answered in the affirmative.

2.  The Barossa Water Allocation Plan is to be construed as a statutory instrument.

3.  Clause 5.2.14 requires the Minister to convert area based water allocations to volumetric allocations.  Where the licence contains more than one water resource, the Minister must then assign that allocation between the resources.

4.  The Minister cannot delegate the task of assignment to the licensees so as to enable them to determine how their allocation is assigned between the different resources on the licence.

Natural Resources Management Act 2004 (SA) s 7, s 10(1), s 76, s 79, s 80, s 124, s 125, s 126, s 127, s 149, s 153 and s 156; Acts Interpretation Act 1915 (SA) s 4, referred to.
Glengyle Proprietors Pty Ltd v Minister for Environment and Conservation (2009) 105 SASR 520; Project Blue Sky v Australian Broadcasting Authority (1998) 194 CLR 355; Cooper Brooks (Wollongong) Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (1980) 147 CLR 297; Mount Barker Properties Ltd v District Council of Mount Barker [2001] SASC 249; Australian Education Union v DECS (2012) 248 CLR 1; Carr v WA (2007) 232 CLR 138; Alcan (NT) v Commissioner of Territory Revenue (2009) 239 CLR 27; Draycott v Minister for Environment and Conservation [2007] SASC 463; District Council of Munno Para v Remove-All Rubbish Co Pty Ltd (1985) 41 SASR 188; Frankham v Adelaide City Council [2004] SASC 263, considered.

MINISTER FOR SUSTAINABILITY, ENVIRONMENT AND CONSERVATION v ZANDER
[2014] SASCFC 83

Full Court:       Gray, Vanstone and Stanley JJ

GRAY…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Minister for Sustainability, Environment and Conservation v... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] SASCFC 83
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal concerned the interpretation of clause 5.2.14 of the Barossa Water Allocation Plan, a statutory instrument made under the *Natural Resources Management Act 2004* (SA). The parties were the Minister for Sustainability, Environment and Conservation (the Minister) and the Zander family, who held a licence to take underground and surface water for irrigating their vineyard. The dispute arose from the conversion of the Zanders' historical "area based" water licence, which did not limit the volume of water taken, to a new "volumetric" licence.

The central legal issue before the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia was the proper construction of clause 5.2.14 of the Water Allocation Plan. Specifically, the court had to determine whether the Minister, in converting an area-based licence to a volumetric one where water was drawn from multiple sources, was permitted to assign a portion of the total volumetric allocation to each resource in a way that allowed the licensee discretion in choosing the source, provided the aggregate volume did not exceed the total allocation.

The Full Court reasoned that the Barossa Water Allocation Plan, as a statutory instrument, should be interpreted using the same principles as statutes. It held that the language of clause 5.2.14 was "intractable" and did not permit the flexibility contemplated by the lower court. The court found that the obligation to "assign" the volumetric allocation to various resources meant allotting a fixed share to each, and that these assigned shares, in aggregate, must not exceed the overall volumetric allocation. Therefore, the Minister could not assign a portion to surface water and a portion to underground water such that the sum of those portions exceeded the total annual allocation, even if the licensee was ultimately limited to the total volume.

The Full Court allowed the appeal, concluding that the judge's construction of clause 5.2.14 was inconsistent with the scheme of the statutory instrument. The preliminary question was answered in the negative.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The issue for this Court is the proper construction of a provision of the Water Allocation Plan for the Barossa Prescribed Water Resources Area, made in June 2009, pursuant to the Natural Resources Management Act 2004 (SA).Background The Zander family have farmed lands in the Barossa Valley for many years. The respondents, Ian and Josephine Zander, take underground water through a bore and collect surface water in dams to irrigate their vineyard in the Barossa Valley. They also use the surface water for stock and domestic purposes. It is common ground that an authorisation or allocation under section 124(3) of the Natural Resources Management Act was required for the Zanders’ use of water for irrigation purposes. The Zanders had been the holders of a water licence for some time and until recently held what was commonly referred to as an “area based” licence. An area based licence permitted a licensee to draw water, usually for a nominated irrigation purpose, and limited the area that may be irrigated, but did not usually limit the volume of water that may be taken. The Zanders’ area based licence authorised the irrigation of 28 hectares of vines from both dams and a bore. Together with other area based licensees, the Zanders were free to take any volume of water from the resources endorsed on the licence – they were only limited by the size of the area they were entitled to irrigate. A decision was taken by government to replace area based licences with volumetric licences. Apparently, the view was taken that area based licences, with no volumetric cap, provide no disincentive against poor irrigation practices or the prolonged use of inefficient irrigation equipment. There was no reason to guard against water wastage as there was no limit on the amount of water that could be taken. In addition, because there was no limit on the amount of water that could be taken, the aggregate volume that all irrigators could take was not capped to an environmentally sustainable limit, or even fully known. On 18 June 2009, a water allocation plan for the Barossa Prescribed Water Resources Area was adopted by the Minister for Environment and Conservation, pursuant to section 80(3)(a) of the Natural Resources Management Act. In the course of drafting the Barossa Water Allocation Plan, it was recognised that special consideration needed to be given to a number of area based licences. This was explained in an affidavit of Lawrence Poppleton, a water planner:In the course of these discussions, it became apparent that there were a number of area based licences that, in the opinion of the Department, could not be converted to a volumetric licence. These licences were those that had water allocations expressed with a unit of measurement of hectares from multiple water resources. The principles in the draft plan provided no guidance, direction, or basis for the conversion of these area based licences to volumetric licences. These considerations led to the inclusion in the Plan of clause 5.2.14. The Statutory Scheme

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

This analysis demonstrates that the Judge’s construction is not consistent with the scheme of the statutory instrument.Conclusion We would allow the appeal. We would answer the preliminary question in the negative. VANSTONE J: In 2009 a new Water Allocation Plan (the Plan) was adopted for the Barossa prescribed water resources area. It was made pursuant to the Natural Resources Management Act 2004 (SA) (the Act). Absent specific authorisation, landholders in such an area may only use surface, underground or watercourse water for irrigation purposes in accordance with allocations in a water licence: ss 124 to 127. Water allocations granted must be consistent with such Plans: s 153. The respondents, the Zanders, are landholders in the area encompassed by the Plan and have for some years held a licence to take water, being water held in dams on their property (surface water) as well as underground water. Under that licence, the Zanders’ water allocation was limited by the area they could irrigate, but not by the volume they could take. The Plan required that a water allocation which was previously determined by use and area would be converted to a volumetric allocation, again based on use. Since the Zanders have historically taken water from more than one resource the Plan also required that the allocation be assigned to either one or both of those resources. Therefore it was necessary for the Minister for Sustainability, Environment and Conservation to vary the Zanders’ water allocation: s 156. In due course the Minister advised the Zanders of their new allocation and issued a new licence. Later that was varied and it was agreed that the total water allocation per annum to the Zanders would be 42ML. The Minister proposed that the allocation of 42ML would be assigned, and reflected on the licence, in this way: 21ML to surface water and 21ML to underground water. (Notwithstanding that, we were told that the Minister has sought and will consider the Zanders’ own view as to the split.) This process is regulated by section 5, Water Allocation Criteria, and particularly principle 14 of section 5.2 of the Plan. The question for decision is concerned with the interpretation of principle 14. In essence, the question is whether the Minister may, in assigning the Zanders’ water allocation, allow them a measure of discretion in choosing the source of the water used, by assigning to each resource a maximum amount, the sum of which exceeds the allocation, albeit with the rider that, irrespective of the source of the water taken, total use must not exceed the allocation. The Plan appears to come within the definition of “statutory instrument” in s 4 of the Acts Interpretation Act 1915 (SA), although it is not to be assumed that it was drawn with the precision with which a statute or a regulation might be drawn. The question is essentially a matter of law. The reasoning of the judge under appeal is informative, but it is for this Court to determine whether the answer given was correct.Background

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

We consider the Barossa Water Allocation Plan is a statutory instrument by virtue of the provisions of section 4 of the Acts Interpretation Act 1915 (SA).[12] While not free from doubt, the view we prefer is that the principles of construction applicable to statutes also apply to a statutory instrument such as a water allocation plan.[13] [12] District Council of Munno Para v Remove-All Rubbish Co Pty Ltd (1985) 41 SASR 188, 204; Mount Barker Properties Ltd v District Council of Mount Barker [2001] SASC 249, [6]. [13] Frankham v Adelaide City Council [2004] SASC 263, [20]. Consideration The primary question before this Court is one of construction of the Barossa Water Allocation Plan and, in particular, clause 5.2.14, which concerns the conversion process from area based to volumetric allocations. We begin with a consideration of the ordinary grammatical meaning of the words of clause 5.2.14 having regard to their context and legislative purpose. Clause 5.2.14 of the Barossa Water Allocation Plan is fundamentally concerned with the process of converting an area based water allocation to a volumetric water allocation. In the case of the conversion of a single licence endorsed with an area based allocation, which can be taken from more than one resource, the allocation converted to a volume will be assigned to those resources using a hierarchy of surface water, followed by underground water, followed by watercourse water, allocating surface water first up to a prescribed maximum dam storage capacity. The assignment of an allocation to a resource or resources is to take into account the historical use of the resource and any other information the Minister deems appropriate. The conversion must occur and take effect on 1 July following the first full water use year after the date of adoption of the Plan. The allocation is to be assigned by the Minister amongst the water resources endorsed on the licence. This is implicit in the fact that it is the Minister who has statutory responsibility for converting the licences and the terms of clause 5.2.14(c). The Shorter Oxford English Dictionary relevantly defines the verb “assign” to mean “allot as a share (to)” or “fix, specify”. The obligation imposed on the Minister, or delegate, by clause 5.2.14 is to allot a fixed share of the overall volumetric allocation to which the licensee is entitled between the various resources endorsed on the licence. The assignment commences with the Minister, or delegate, allotting a fixed share of the overall allocation to surface water, if applicable, followed by underground water, if applicable, followed by watercourse water, if applicable. That assignment is undertaken by reference to the historical use of the resource and any other information the Minister deems appropriate. We consider this construction is, at the very least, consistent with the definition of “water allocation” in the glossary in the Barossa Water Allocation Plan. In our view, the text of the Barossa Water Allocation Plan does not permit the kind of flexibility contemplated by the Judge under appeal. In our view, the language is intractable. The concept of an assignment of the volumetric allocation of water under the licence to the various resources endorsed on the licence does not permit an assignment amongst those resources which in aggregate exceeds the overall allocation, so as to confer a discretion on the licensee to use water from different resources to avoid the mischief of leaving the licensee in any one year with less water than his or her annual allocation. There may be much to be said for allowing licensees who are aware of the climactic variations from year to year on their property to exercise some discretion in the management of the water resources endorsed on their licence, but the terms of clause 5.2.14 do not permit that to occur. The assignment of the allocation must aggregate the total allocation and not exceed it. If the licensee was allotted fixed shares in respect of each resource endorsed on the licence in an aggregate amount exceeding the overall allocation, then that would not constitute an assignment of the allocation within the meaning of the clause.