Mount Barker Properties Ltd v District Council of Mount Barker

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

MOUNT BARKER PROPERTY INVESTMENTS PTY LTD v DISTRICT COUNCIL OF MOUNT BARKER &
THE MINISTER FOR TRANSPORT, URBAN PLANNING, THE ARTS AND THE STATUS OF WOMEN
[2001] SASC 249

Land and Valuation Division

  1. DEBELLE J.          In this application for judicial review the plaintiff challenges the validity of the process so far implemented for the purpose of amending the Development Plan for the area of the District Council of Mount Barker (“the Council”).

  2. The plaintiff owns a substantial parcel of land in the town of Mount Barker.  On that land is erected a shopping centre including a Bi-Lo supermarket and other shops, together with car parking.  The plaintiff’s land is within the area of the Council and is subject to the Council’s Development Plan.  The shopping centre forms a part of a District Centre Zone in the existing Plan.  It is the only District Centre Zone in the Council area.

    A Challenge to a PAR

  3. The Council seeks to have several amendments made to the Development Plan. They include amendments to the District Centre Zone. The procedures by which amendments to the Development Plan are made at the instigation of a council are set out in s 25 of the Development Act 1993. I will describe the procedures in a moment. For the present, it is sufficient to note that the proposed amendments are to be contained in a Plan Amendment Report (“PAR”). The plaintiff contends that both the Council and the Minister for Urban Planning have failed to comply with certain of the procedures prescribed by s 25. The plaintiff therefore seeks

    (1)a declaration that the draft Mount Barker and Littlehampton Township Centres PAR is unlawful and invalid; and

    (2)a declaration that the acceptance by the Minister of the said draft PAR as the basis for public consultation pursuant to s 25(9) of the Act was invalid because the draft PAR had failed to comply with the provisions of s 25 of the Act.

    There is no challenge to the plaintiff’s standing to bring these proceedings.

    The Statutory Process

  4. Before examining the grounds upon which the plaintiff relies, it is convenient to examine the procedure by which a Development Plan is amended.  All of the references to the Development Act in these reasons are to the Act before it was amended by the Development (System Improvement Program) Amendment Act, 2000 (the Act No. 88 of 2000) which substantially amended the relevant procedures.  Reference will also be made to the Development Regulations 1993 as they stood at the relevant times and before recent amendments.

  5. The procedures for amending a Development Plan are set out in s 24 to s 30 of the Act. The Governor publishes the amendment (see s 29) but it is effectively the Minister who makes the amendment. Section 25 of the Act authorises a council to initiate the amendment process and, subject to the Minister’s control, to prepare amendments. Section 26 of the Act authorises the Minister to initiate and make amendments. The same procedures apply…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mount Barker Properties Ltd v District Council of Mount Bark... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] SASC 249
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mount Barker Properties Ltd, the plaintiff, sought to challenge the validity of the process implemented for the purpose of amending the Development Plan for the area of the District Council of Mount Barker, the defendant. The plaintiff argued that the Council and the Minister for Urban Planning had failed to comply with certain procedures prescribed by s 25 of the Development Act 1993. The plaintiff sought a declaration that the draft Mount Barker and Littlehampton Township Centres Plan Amendment Report was unlawful and invalid, as well as a declaration that the Minister's acceptance of the draft PAR as the basis for public consultation was invalid. The court examined the statutory process and found that the Minister has extensive control over the amendment process. The court concluded that the intention of the Parliament was that a council proposes an amendment and seeks to justify it with a PAR; the Minister decides whether the PAR will be released for public consultation; if released, there will be a process of public consultation; and, informed of any representations made by the public, the Minister decides whether the amendment will be made, either as proposed or as amended by the Minister. The court found that the Council had substantially complied with s 25(4)(a) and dismissed the application. The plaintiff had failed to establish that the PAR was invalid.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

DEBELLE J

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: DEBELLE J