Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs v Su

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs v Su [2024] FCAFC 68

Review of: Su and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs (Citizenship) [2023] AATA 3919 (9 November 2023)
File number(s): VID 1089 of 2023
Judgment of: WHEELAHAN, CHEESEMAN AND HESPE JJ
Date of judgment: 5 June 2024
Catchwords: CITIZENSHIP – eligibility – citizenship by descent – where applicant for citizenship was born outside Australia – whether the Administrative Appeals Tribunal erred in construing and failing to apply ordinary meaning of the phrase “at the time of the birth” in s 16(2)(a) of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth) – whether the facts as found by the Tribunal necessarily fell outside the description of “at the time of the birth”, properly construed
Legislation:

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) s 44

Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth) ss 12, 16

Cases cited:

Collector of Customs v Agfa-Gevaert Ltd [1996] HCA 36; (1996) 186 CLR 389

Comptroller-General of Customs v Pharm-A-Care Laboratories Pty Ltd [2020] HCA 2; (2020) 270 CLR 494

H v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2010] FCAFC 119; (2010) 188 FCR 393

Haritos v Commissioner of Taxation [2015] FCAFC 92; (2015) 233 FCR 315

Hope v Bathurst City Council [1980] HCA 16; (1980) 144 CLR 1

Koka v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2021] FCAFC 82; (2021) 284 FCR 346

McKenzie v Repatriation Commission [2014] FCA 777

Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs v Koka [2020] FCA 1471

Plaintiff M76/2013 v Minister for Immigration, Multicultural Affairs and Citizenship [2013] HCA 53; (2013) 251 CLR 322

Sharp Corporation of Australia Pty Ltd v Collector of Customs [1995] FCA 707; (1995) 59 FCR 6

Vetter v Lake Macquarie City Council [2001] HCA 12; (2001) 202 CLR 439

Division: General Division
Registry: Victoria
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Number of paragraphs: 30
Date of hearing: 14 May 2024
Counsel for the Applicant Mr N Wood SC and Mr J Barrington
Solicitors for the Applicant Australian Government Solicitor
Counsel for the Respondent Ms G A Costello KC and Ms B J Goding
Solicitors for the Respondent Oboodi Solicitors

ORDERS

VID 1089 of 2023
BETWEEN:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION, CITIZENSHIP AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS

Applicant

AND:

ENJI SU

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

WHEELAHAN, CHEESEMAN AND HESPE JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

5 JUNE 2024

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The decision of the Tribunal dated 9 November 2023 is set aside.

2.In lieu thereof, the decision of the delegate of the Minister made on 5 January 2023 is affirmed.

3.There is no order as to costs.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

THE COURT:

  1. This is an “appeal” brought by the Minister pursuant to s 44 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (AAT Act), from a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal setting aside a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affa... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCAFC 68
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs v Su, the Federal Court was tasked with determining the validity of a decision made by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) regarding Ms Su's eligibility for Australian citizenship. Ms Su, born in China in 2001, was abandoned by her biological parents due to her significant health issues at birth. She was subsequently cared for and raised by Ms Jagelman, an Australian citizen who had been working in China at the time of Ms Su's birth. The primary issue before the court was whether the AAT erred in its interpretation and application of the phrase "at the time of the birth" as it appears in section 16(2)(a) of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth).

The Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs challenged the AAT's decision, contending that the Tribunal misinterpreted the phrase "at the time of the birth" and that the facts found by the Tribunal did not align with the proper construction of this phrase. The Minister argued that the Tribunal should have interpreted "at the time of the birth" as the precise moment when the child is born. Conversely, Ms Su maintained that the AAT's conclusions were reasonable and legally sound, and that the Minister's appeal did not properly raise questions of law. The court's analysis needed to consider the ordinary meaning of the phrase in question, the established precedents from H v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship and Koka v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs, and whether the Tribunal's factual findings aligned with the legal requirements.

The Federal Court found that the AAT's interpretation of the phrase "at the time of the birth" was too broad and did not adhere to its ordinary meaning. The court held that the phrase should be interpreted as the precise moment when a child is born, aligning with the Minister's contention. Furthermore, the court determined that the facts as found by the AAT necessarily fell outside the proper construction of "at the time of the birth." Consequently, the decision of the AAT was set aside, and the original decision of the Minister's delegate was affirmed. The court did not make any orders regarding costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The decision of the Tribunal dated 9 November 2023 is set aside.

2. In lieu thereof, the decision of the delegate of the Minister made on 5 January 2023 is affirmed.

3. There is no order as to costs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ms Su was born in China in the morning of 28 December 2001. Neither of her biological parents were Australian citizens. Ms Su was abandoned by her biological parents, having suffered substantial brain haemorrhaging, following a protracted and obstructed three‑day labour by a 15-year-old biological mother. Ms Jagelman, an Australian citizen, was working in China at the time. While walking home from the city with her three older children on 28 December 2001, Ms Jagelman was informed of Ms Su’s birth and that Ms Su was expected to have significant disabilities. The people of Ms Su’s biological mother’s village tended to believe that children with disabilities were cursed. Fearing Ms Su would be killed, Ms Jagelman took responsibility for Ms Su and gave her the name Hope. Ms Su was then cared for and raised by Ms Jagelman. Ms Su overcame her early challenges, and now lives as a healthy vibrant young woman.DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL The Tribunal concluded that Ms Jagelman was Ms Su’s parent at the time of Ms Su’s birth. The reasoning of the Tribunal is found in TR [30]–[33], where the Tribunal said: [30]Critically, I am satisfied these facts show the circumstances of Ms Jagelman being Ms Su’s parent only arose because she was born with substantial health issues and expected to have significant disabilities and, if this was not the situation, Ms Su would not have been abandoned by her biological parents. [31]Considering the policy guidance in CPI 23, I find that the sort of evidence listed to show a claimed parent-child relationship existed at or before the time of a child’s birth, is not relevant to the factual circumstances of the birth of Ms Su. Therefore, I also weigh relevant social and/or legal factors to determine whether Ms Jagelman was the parent of Ms Su at the time of her birth. [32]Consistent with the Full Federal Court decision H v Minister, I accept that the meaning of ‘at the time of the birth’ should be given its ordinary meaning as evident in ordinary contemporary English usage, and I should not attribute some technical meaning to the word. In view of this, I simply cannot accept that ‘at the time of the birth’ is the precise moment in time on a particular day that a child is born. This interpretation would not allow for the various experiences of birth that occur in the ordinary sense of the word. [33]In the circumstances of Ms Jagelman and Ms Su, I find that Ms Jagelman became Ms Su’s parent at the time she was born with substantial brain haemorrhaging and was expected to have significant disabilities. I accept the evidence of Ms Jagelman that a child born in the area with a physical ‘defect’ was either abandoned or killed at that time. I further consider that these social and cultural circumstances at the time of Ms Su’s birth meant that, especially in the context of Ms Jagelman already raising two older boys she received in very similar circumstances, Ms Su would be abandoned by her biological parents when she was born with disabilities and she would be parented by Ms Jagelman. GROUNDS OF “APPEAL”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

By an amended notice of appeal, the Minister states two questions of law:(1)Whether the Tribunal’s interpretation of the phrase “at the time of the birth” in s 16(2)(a) of the Act was correct as a matter of law. (2)Whether the facts as fully found by the Tribunal fall within s 16(2)(a) of the Act, properly construed.CONSIDERATION The Minister contends that:(1)The Tribunal ought to have construed the phrase “at the time of the birth”, in s 16(2)(a) of the Act, as meaning the precise moment in time on the particular day that a child is born; and(2)The facts as found by the Tribunal fell necessarily outside the description of “at the time of [Ms Su’s] birth” in s 16(2)(a) of the Act, properly construed. Ms Su contends that:(1)The Minister’s appeal does not raise questions of law; and(2)The conclusions reached by the Tribunal were reasonably open on the facts as found and the Tribunal did not err in reaching its conclusion that Ms Jagelman was Ms Su’s parent at the time of her birth. The parties’ contentions are to be understood against a background of decided cases, in particular, the decisions in H v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2010] FCAFC 119; (2010) 188 FCR 393 and Koka v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2021] FCAFC 82; (2021) 284 FCR 346. In H, the Full Court (Moore, Kenny and Tracey JJ):(a)decided that: the word “parent” in s 16(2) was not limited to a biological parent and that a non-biological parent could be a “parent” depending on the circumstances (at [127]). The determination of whether an individual is a child’s parent within the ordinary meaning of the word may depend on various factors, including social, legal and biological (at [129]);(b)accepted that the words “at the time of the birth” in s 16(2)(a) qualify both the status of being a parent and the parent’s citizenship (at [67]–[68]). In other words, the section requires that an applicant for citizenship had, at the time of their birth, a parent who was an Australian citizen. In Koka the second of these propositions was confirmed. The Full Court agreed with the primary judge that, except for express exceptions for which it provides, the provisions of the Act dealing with citizenship by descent focus on the factual situation as at the time of the physical birth of a person (at [31]–[32]). The ordinary meaning of the words used in s 16(2) was that the eligibility requirements needed to be established at the time of birth as a matter of fact. As the Full Court said (at [35]):[Section 16(2)(a)] is concerned with the factual question of whether, when a child is born, she or he has — at that particular point in time — a ‘parent’ (construed in accordance with H) who is an Australian citizen. Against that background, it was accepted by both parties and the Tribunal, that the phrase “at the time of the birth” was to be given its ordinary meaning. Ms Su submitted that as the ordinary meaning of words is a question of fact, the first ground of appeal did not properly raise a question of law. The second ground of appeal could only engage a question of law if the Tribunal failed to conform to legal requirements as to the nature of the fact-finding task required to be undertaken. This condition was said to not be satisfied as none of the evidence taken into account by the Tribunal was irrelevant to the task it was required to perform.