Younas v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2) [2024] FCA 853
File number:
VID 698 of 2023
Judgment of:
WHEELAHAN J
Date of judgment:
2 August 2024
Catchwords:
MIGRATION — citizenship – Australian Citizenship Act 1948 (Cth) s 10B(1) – where the applicant sought a declaration that he is an Australian citizen – where the applicant claimed that he obtained citizenship under s 10B(1) in 2007, on the basis that his biological uncle was his non-biological parent at the time of his birth – H v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2010] FCAFC 119; 188 FCR 393, applied – Held: the applicant’s biological uncle was not a parent of the applicant at the time of his birth – application dismissed.
Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Number of paragraphs:
215
Date of last submissions:
10 May 2024
Date of hearing:
26–27 March, 8–9, 11–12, 22–3 April 2024
Counsel for the Applicant:
Mr M Guo
Solicitor for the Applicant:
Asylum Seeker Resource Centre
Counsel for the Respondent:
Mr N Wood SC with Mr J Barrington
Solicitor for the Respondent:
Australian Government Solicitor
ORDERS
VID 698 of 2023
BETWEEN:
HAMZA YOUNAS
Applicant
AND:
COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
Respondent
ORDER MADE BY:
WHEELAHAN J
DATE OF ORDER:
2 AUGUST 2024
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1.The application is dismissed.
2.By 4.00 pm on 9 August 2024, the applicant file and serve written submissions as to costs, not exceeding two pages.
3.By 4.00 pm on 16 August 2024, the respondent file and serve written submissions as to costs, not exceeding two pages.
4.Subject to further order of the Court, the question of costs be determined on the papers.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
WHEELAHAN J:
The applicant is a man of about 30…
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Younas v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2) and more:
Younas v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2) involved the applicant, who sought a declaration that he was an Australian citizen under section 10B(1) of the Australian Citizenship Act 1948 (Cth). The applicant contended that his biological uncle, Mohammed Shahid, was his non-biological parent at the time of his birth. The court had to determine whether the applicant’s claim was valid and if Mohammed Shahid was indeed the applicant’s parent at the time of his birth. The court examined the evidence, including expert testimony, and the applicant’s submissions, to assess the circumstances surrounding the applicant’s birth and the relationship between the applicant and Mohammed Shahid.
The primary legal issue was whether Mohammed Shahid was the applicant’s non-biological parent at the time of his birth, which would have conferred Australian citizenship on the applicant under section 10B(1) of the Act. This required the court to scrutinise the evidence presented and evaluate the credibility and reliability of the applicant’s claims. The court also considered the actions of Mohammed Shahid, particularly his failure to list the applicant as his child or dependant in various visa applications, and his subsequent criminal conviction for providing false information regarding the applicant’s parentage.
The court found that the applicant’s claim was not supported by the evidence. It noted that the applicant was named after his biological father, which contradicted the applicant’s assertion that Mohammed Shahid would take the place of his biological father. Additionally, Mohammed Shahid never identified the applicant as his child or dependant in any of the visa applications he signed, and he did not make any plea in mitigation of his sentence based on his supposed non-biological parenthood of the applicant. The court concluded that Mohammed Shahid did not consider the applicant to be his child and did not express an intense commitment to him. Therefore, the court dismissed the applicant’s claim.
The court's decision was based on the evidence that Mohammed Shahid did not consider the applicant to be his child, as evidenced by his actions and omissions. The court found that the applicant's case was inconsistent with the objective circumstances and that the applicant had failed to provide sufficient evidence to support his claim. As a result, the court dismissed the application and ordered the parties to file written submissions regarding costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The application is dismissed.
2. By 4.00 pm on 9 August 2024, the applicant file and serve written submissions as to costs, not exceeding two pages.
3. By 4.00 pm on 16 August 2024, the respondent file and serve written submissions as to costs, not exceeding two pages.
4. Subject to further order of the Court, the question of costs be determined on the papers.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
Forensically, the applicant relied on Dr Suhail’s expert evidence for two further purposes. First, the evidence was relied upon as relevant to the Court’s assessment of the likelihood that the applicant’s family lived in a joint family system, and that Mohammed Shahid assumed the role of being the applicant’s parent by the time of his birth. Secondly, Dr Suhail’s evidence was relied upon to give content to the role of the head of a joint family, in support of the claim that, in that role, Mohammed Shahid acted as the parent of persons who were not his biological children — including the applicant.Background Before summarising the evidence of the witnesses, I will identify some surrounding circumstances that are established by the evidence. Mohammed Shahid, the applicant’s biological uncle, was born in Pakistan and is now 70 years of age. He first arrived in Australia in 1977. He is an Australian citizen, having been granted citizenship in 1985. In 1987, Mohammed Shahid was convicted in the County Court of Victoria of an offence under s 233B(1)(d) of the Customs Act 1901 (Cth) in relation to the importation of heroin. He was sentenced to a term of imprisonment of 14 years, with a non-parole period of eight years. In October 1991, he was released from prison on parole. Based upon a movement history produced by the Australian Department of Home Affairs, I find that following his release on parole, Mohammed Shahid left Australia in March 1992, and returned more than eight years later in October 2000. He then served a further period of imprisonment on account of a breach of his parole conditions, and was released from prison on parole for a second time in January 2001. The movement history from the Department of Home Affairs shows that Mohammed Shahid left Australia again in February 2006, and returned on 18 May 2006. The applicant was born in 1993 or 1994. The evidence as to his precise date of birth is not reliable. Over the years, Mohammed Shahid signed a number of forms in support of applications that his first wife, Iffat Parveen, and their children be able to migrate to Australia. Those applications included the following –(a)an application for migration dated 1 April 1996;(b)a sponsorship for migration form dated 19 April 1996;(c)an application for review dated 27 September 1996;(d)a sponsorship for migration form dated 9 August 1999;(e)an application for migration dated 14 April 2001; and(f)a sponsorship for migration form dated 14 April 2001. Mohammed Shahid gave evidence in cross-examination that he signed the above forms that apparently bear his signature. He said that he did not complete the forms himself but provided information to other persons who completed the detail in the forms on his behalf. The forms have the following common features. First, Mohammed Younas, who is said to be Mohammed Shahid’s brother and the applicant’s biological father, is not listed as one of the brothers and sisters of Mohammed Shahid in response to any of the questions in the forms which sought that information. Secondly, the applicant is not listed as one of the children of Mohammed Shahid and Iffat Parveen in circumstances where other evidence put before the Court on behalf of the applicant was that the applicant was brought up thinking they were his parents. Thirdly, in those forms which asked Mohammed Shahid to list his dependants, he did not list the applicant as a dependant. Fourthly, the residential address of Iffat Parveen was given in the 1996 forms as “591” Karim Block in Allama Iqbal Town, Lahore, Pakistan. In the 1999 form, it was given as “625” Karim Block. In the application form dated 14 April 2001, the address of Iffat Parveen was given as a different address in Rana Road, Township, Lahore, with the address for Mohammed Shahid for the period March 1992 to 26 October 2000 being given as the 625 Karim Block address.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
In February 2019, Mohammed Shahid pleaded guilty to dishonestly influencing a Commonwealth public official, contrary to s 135.1(7) of the Criminal Code. The particulars of the charge were that Mohammed Shahid made applications for Australian citizenship for 11 persons to the Australian High Commission in Islamabad containing false information, with the intention of dishonestly influencing a Commonwealth public official. The 11 persons included the applicant, “Awais Shahid”, and “Momina Shahid”, whose names were entered in the register on 31 May 2007. Mohammed Shahid was sentenced in the County Court of Victoria to 12 months’ imprisonment with a direction that he be released after three months on a recognizance release order in the sum of $3,000. Detective Leading Senior Constable Joanne Turner, who was the informant, gave evidence that Mohammed Shahid had pleaded guilty to one rolled-up charge, and that the focus of the investigation leading to the charge was the falsity of statements to the effect that he was the biological father of the 11 persons.The evidence Counsel for the applicant adduced evidence from five witnesses –(a)Fatima Shahid;(b)Mohammed Shahid;(c)Rubina Younas; (d)Detective Leading Senior Constable Joanne Turner; and(e)Dr Adeem Suhail, the expert social anthropologist to whom I referred above. The applicant was not called as a witness. It was not suggested by counsel for the Commonwealth that the applicant could give admissible evidence as to circumstances at the time of his birth, although counsel did submit that the applicant could have given evidence about subsequent events, and that it should be inferred that his evidence would not have assisted his case. The evidence is that Mohammed Shahid’s first wife, Iffat Parveen, lives with him in Melbourne, and was living in Pakistan at the time of the applicant’s birth, but she did not give evidence. Counsel for the Commonwealth submitted that Iffat Parveen could have given relevant evidence, and that it should be inferred that her evidence would not have assisted the applicant’s case. Counsel for the Commonwealth tendered parts of two affidavits that annexed various documents. No direct evidence-in-chief was adduced on behalf of the Commonwealth. Counsel for the Commonwealth also tendered parts of an Australian Federal Police record of interview, to which I will return in due course.Fatima ShahidAffidavit evidence Fatima Shahid made an affidavit and was cross-examined by senior counsel for the Commonwealth. She was born in Lahore, Pakistan, and has resided in Australia since 2002, becoming an Australian citizen in about 2003. Ms Shahid’s biological father is Mohammed Shahid and her biological mother is his first wife, Iffat Parveen. Her parents both reside in Melbourne as do her brothers Saif and Usman. Ms Shahid stated that she was the applicant’s “non-biological sister”. She stated that she was around 12 years old when the applicant was born. At that time, she lived in Pakistan. She stated that she remembered that before the applicant was born her father travelled to Pakistan to care and provide for the applicant and his biological mother, Rubina Younas, because the applicant’s biological father, Mohammad Younas, was very ill and very limited in the activities that he could perform around the house.
Decision
Reasons for decision
However, I also consider that the circumstances of the investigation and conviction do shed some light on the question presently before me, in the following way. Senior counsel for the Commonwealth submitted that it is relevant that, on the evidence before the Court, it appears that Mohammed Shahid never made any plea in mitigation of sentence that, despite not being the biological parent of the applicant, he should receive a lighter sentence because he had in fact been the non-biological parent of the applicant since birth. Senior counsel submitted that this would have been a highly relevant submission to have made. I accept this submission. I consider it significant that Mohammed Shahid did not suggest, as a matter relevant to his sentence, that he had in fact been the non-biological parent of the applicant since his birth pursuant to some arrangement with his late brother. I cannot be sure of the exact reasons why Mohammed Shahid did not raise this suggestion by way of plea in mitigation, and so I do not attach decisive weight to it. I simply consider this to be another circumstance, consistent with a volume of other evidence, that suggests that Mohammed Shahid did not consider himself to be, and was not, the non-biological parent of the applicant at the time of his birth.Conclusion For these reasons, I am not persuaded that Mohammed Shahid was a parent of the applicant at the time of his birth. The relevant relationship of parenthood upon which the applicant relied was claimed to exist between the applicant, and Mohammed Shahid. In the event, the applicant submitted that the evidence of Mohammed Shahid should not be accepted, and the applicant himself did not give evidence. The case put forward by the applicant cannot be reconciled with the objective circumstances. The applicant’s case is inconsistent with the fact that the applicant was named “Hamza Younas” by his biological parents, and after his biological father, within a society in which children are named after their “fathers”, as that term is understood by members of the society. This circumstance is squarely inconsistent with the applicant’s case that Mohammed Shahid would take the place of his biological father, Mohammed Younas. Further, the applicant’s case was inconsistent with the objectively established actions of Mohammed Shahid at the crucial times. Despite being repeatedly asked to name all of his and Iffat Parveen’s children and his dependants, Mohammed Shahid never identified the applicant as a child or a dependant. Nor did Mohammed Shahid attempt — until much later and in a very different context, which has had its own criminal ramifications — to help the applicant to migrate to Australia, despite repeated attempts to obtain visas for all of his biological children with Iffat Parveen. As I have noted, the preferable inference is that Mohammed Shahid did not, in these crucial years, consider the applicant to be his child. I am not satisfied that Mohammed Shahid expressed an intense commitment to the applicant at the time of his birth or in the years following it, and I am not persuaded that Mohammed Shahid considered the applicant one of “his own”, as he did with his four biological children with Iffat Parveen.