Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v MZYCE

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v MZYCE [2010] FCA 767

Citation: Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v MZYCE [2010] FCA 767
Appeal from: MZYCF & Anor v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship & Anor [2010] FMCA 11
Parties: MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP v MZYCE, MZYCF and REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
File number(s): VID 96 of 2010
Judge: GRAY J
Date of judgment: 22 July 2010
Catchwords: MIGRATION – visa – protection visa – whether Refugee Review Tribunal failed to discharge its function, or reached an unreasonable conclusion – Tribunal refused to accept that newspaper articles tendered in support of applicant’s case were evidence of the alleged events reported in them – Tribunal relied on information as to the level of document fraud in India – whether Tribunal bound to make its own inquiries as to genuineness of newspaper articles – whether federal magistrate in error in finding that applicant had asked Tribunal to investigate genuineness of newspaper articles using the internet
Legislation: Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss 5(1), 36, 36(2)(a), 36(2)(b), 65, 91R, 424, 424A(1)
Convention relating to the Status of Refugees done at Geneva on 28 July 1951
Protocol relating to the Status of Refugees done at New York on 31 January 1967
Cases cited: Associated Provincial Picture Houses Ltd v Wednesbury Corporation [1948] 1 KB 223 applied
Brown v Minister for Immigration & Citizenship [2009] FCA 1098 cited
Khant v Minister for Immigration & Citizenship [2009] FCA 1247 cited
Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Le [2007] FCA 1318 (2007) 164 FCR 151 cited
Minister for Immigration & Citizenship v SZIAI [2009] HCA 39 (2009) 259 ALR 429 applied
MZYCF & Anor v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship & Anor [2010] FMCA 11 referred to
Prasad v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1985) 6 FCR 155 cited
SZLGP v Minister for Immigration & Citizenship [2009] FCA 1470 cited
Date of hearing: 27 May 2010
Place: Melbourne
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 45
Counsel for the appellant: Mr S Lloyd SC and Mr R Knowles
Solicitor for the appellant: Clayton Utz

The first respondent appeared in person

There was no appearance by the second respondent or the third respondent


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 96 of 2010

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP
Appellant

AND:

MZYCE
First Respondent

MZYCF
Second Respondent

REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
Third Respondent

JUDGE:

GRAY J

DATE OF ORDER:

22 JULY 2010

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal be allowed.

2.The orders made by the Federal Magistrates Court on 27 January 2010 in proceeding number MLG 1224 of 2008 be set aside.

3.There be substituted for those orders orders that:

(1)The application of the first respondent and the second respondent to the Federal Magistrates Court in proceeding number MLG 1224 of 2008 be dismissed.

(2)The first respondent and the second respondent pay the appellant’s costs of that proceeding.

4.The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v MZYCE and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FCA 767
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v MZYCE involved an application for review of a decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal (the Tribunal) relating to the refusal to grant the applicants a protection visa. The applicants challenged the Tribunal's decision on several grounds, including that the Tribunal failed to discharge its function or reached an unreasonable conclusion by not accepting the newspaper articles tendered in support of their case as evidence of the reported events. The Federal Magistrates Court dismissed the application, but this decision was appealed to the Full Court of the Federal Court.

The legal issues before the court included whether the Tribunal was bound to make its own inquiries as to the genuineness of the newspaper articles and whether the federal magistrate was correct in finding that the applicants had asked the Tribunal to investigate the genuineness of the newspaper articles using the internet.

The Full Court held that the Tribunal was not bound to make its own inquiries into the authenticity of the newspaper articles, but in this case, it was open to the Tribunal to determine the authenticity of the documentary evidence presented by the applicants. The court found that the Tribunal's decision to disregard the documentary evidence without making reasonable inquiries was unreasonable in a Wednesbury sense. The court also held that the federal magistrate was incorrect in finding that the applicants had asked the Tribunal to investigate the genuineness of the newspaper articles using the internet, as the applicants had merely suggested that the Tribunal could do so.

The appeal was allowed, the orders of the Federal Magistrates Court were set aside, and orders were made dismissing the application of the applicants to the Federal Magistrates Court and awarding costs to the appellant.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be allowed.

2. The orders made by the Federal Magistrates Court on 27 January 2010 in proceeding number MLG 1224 of 2008 be set aside.

3. There be substituted for those orders orders that:

(1) The application of the first respondent and the second respondent to the Federal Magistrates Court in proceeding number MLG 1224 of 2008 be dismissed.

(2) The first respondent and the second respondent pay the appellant’s costs of that proceeding.

4. The first respondent and the second respondent pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal, save for the costs of and incidental to the application by the appellant to have the appeal heard by a Full Court.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Accompanying this further application was an affidavit, annexing a number of documents. The first annexure was a further certificate from Bhrastachar Abhiyan. In the letterhead of this certificate, the second word of the newspaper’s title was spelt “Abhiiyan”, although the spelling of that word in the seal at the foot of the document matched the spelling in all other documents containing the name of that newspaper. The document certified that the articles dated 17 April 2002, 14 November 2004, 31 July 2006, 24 April 2007 and 25 September 2007 were true and genuine. This was followed by the death certificate and report of post-mortem examination of the daughter of the first and second respondents. There was a document purporting to verify the purchase of a copy of The Sandesh newspaper for Ahmedabad for 9 September 2007. There was material downloaded from the internet concerning The Sandesh Limited, including the contact details of its various offices and material concerning its content and history. That material showed at the foot of each page a universal reference locater (URL) for the page concerned. The material then included an internet page referring to Bhrastachar Abhiyan, but the URL referred to a site called “corruptionabhiyan.com”. There followed internet material from Gujarat Samachar, again with a URL for each page. A further affidavit of the first respondent, filed at the same time, produced the newspaper clippings previously relied on, along with their English translations.The Federal Magistrate’s reasons for judgment At [17]-[19] of the federal magistrate’s reasons for judgment, his Honour dealt with the grounds stated in the application to that court. In doing so, his Honour identified that the principal concern of the first respondent, as expressed at the hearing in the Federal Magistrates Court, was the Tribunal’s use of information relating to fraudulent documents in India in relation to the newspaper clippings he had provided. At [18], his Honour said:the second ground relating to procedural fairness and the third relating to a denial of natural justice, again without sufficient particulars, were centred upon his basic complaint that the Tribunal found that the newspaper clippings to be [sic] fraudulent in circumstances where the applicant alleged he had produced the originals and had invited the Tribunal to confirm such by searching the internet where these newspapers maintained sites. The federal magistrate pointed out that the Tribunal had complied with s 424A(1) of the Migration Act in relation to a considerable amount of information, and that it was at liberty to hand down its decision despite a request for more time to respond. At [21]-[29], the federal magistrate dealt with what he described as an issue raised in the hearing. His Honour referred to the power of the Tribunal to obtain such information as it considers relevant, pursuant to s 424 of the Migration Act. He also said that there was no general duty on the Tribunal to undertake its own inquiries. His Honour quoted from the judgment of French CJ, Gummow, Hayne, Crennan, Kiefel and Bell JJ in SZIAI at [25]. The whole of the relevant passage is as follows:Although decisions in the Federal Court concerned with a failure to make obvious inquiries have led to references to a “duty to inquire”, that term is apt to direct consideration away from the question whether the decision which is under review is vitiated by jurisdictional error. The duty imposed upon the tribunal by the Migration Act is a duty to review. It may be that a failure to make an obvious inquiry about a critical fact, the existence of which is easily ascertained, could, in some circumstances, supply a sufficient link to the outcome to constitute a failure to review. If so, such a failure could give rise to jurisdictional error by constructive failure to exercise jurisdiction. It may be that failure to make such an inquiry results in a decision being affected in some other way that manifests itself as jurisdictional error. It is not necessary to explore these questions of principle in this case.The portion quoted by the federal magistrate began with the words “a failure to make an obvious inquiry” and finished with the words “manifests itself as jurisdictional error.” His Honour also interpolated in the quote the text of a footnote, which I have omitted.At [23], his Honour said:It has been held that a failure to make inquiries in order to discover appropriate material if readily available, in limited instances, may constitute unreasonableness on the part of the Tribunal in a Wednesbury sense.His Honour cited Associated Provincial Picture Houses Ltd v Wednesbury Corporation [1948] 1 KB 223, Prasad v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1985) 6 FCR 155 and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Le [2007] FCA 1318 (2007) 164 FCR 151 and continued:I am of the view that where the question of the applicant’s credibility was determinant of the outcome and where that credibility was so reliant upon the documentary evidence presented by the applicant, and further, where it was readily open to the Tribunal to determine the authenticity of such documentary evidence, not to make relatively simple inquiries as suggested by the applicant, who had otherwise provided all the authentication reasonably available to him, is so unreasonable that no Tribunal could have not made the inquiry.The rest of the federal magistrate’s reasoning is set out at [24]-[29]:[24.]The applicant’s principal contention as articulated at the hearing is that he should be believed as he had provided genuine documentary evidence supportive of his claims to the Tribunal, in my view, raises significant issues as to how the Tribunal approached the determination of the issue of the applicant’s credibility.[25.]On the face of the Tribunal’s decision, it appears the Tribunal, on finding inconsistencies in the stories told by the applicant, determined that the reliance the applicant placed on his documentary supportive evidence must be ignored because they must be false. This in my view, for the reasons set out below, is unreasonable in a Wednesbury sense.The Tribunal, in my view, should have asked itself, what if the newspaper clippings are true. Had the answer to that question been yes, then it was open to the Tribunal to find the other claims plausible. In my view, on the face of them, they are not so implausible to lead to a conclusion the newspaper clippings should be disregarded if proved to be authentic. Should the clippings prove to be authentic then there is the possibility that the focus on “inconsistencies” would ameliorate and a new understanding of the applicant’s claim emerge.[26.]In support of the Tribunal’s conclusion of “high prevalent [sic] of fraud in India” it relies on the annexures to the s.424A(1) letter. In themselves, they do not lead to such a conclusion, in my view.[27.]The applicant asked what more he could do to persuade the Tribunal of their authenticity than what he had done. He had provided original clippings supported, he would say, by translations certified by a notary and stamped as such. It is unclear from the Tribunal’s decision whether the translations are said to be fraudulent, or the clippings are, or both; or whether they are authentic translations of forged documents.[28.]For such a pivotal issue, that is, the authenticity of the translations and the clippings, it is incumbent, in my view, on the Tribunal to take all reasonable steps to determine the issue. In this instance, the first respondent and the Tribunal have available to them the services of a documents authentication unit located in Queensland. A referral to this unit would not have been to ask too much of the Tribunal. In addition, the applicant suggested to the Tribunal that the newspapers involved have websites readily accessible and invited the Tribunal to go to them. Again, although it may have necessitated the services of an interpreter, these sites could have been readily accessed without too much effort on the part of the Tribunal.[29.]It seems to me the Tribunal formed a view about the credibility of the applicant and had then found it necessary to discredit the applicant’s major supportive documentation. The approach taken, in my view, was a reverse of that which should have been taken in this instance, and because of such, the conclusions reached about the credibility of the applicant are not reliable, and unreasonable in a Wednesbury sense.The grounds of appeal

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established