FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA
| KIBOGONG & ANOR v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & ANOR | [2020] FCCA 3055 |
| Catchwords: MIGRATION – Student visa – decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal – whether the Tribunal failed to consider materials – whether the Tribunal failed to make a relevant inquiry – no jurisdictional error – application dismissed. |
| Legislation: Migration Act 1958 (Cth), s.476 Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth), cl.500.214 of sch.2 |
| First Applicant: | BETTY JEPYEGON KIBOGONG |
| Second Applicant: | BERNARD KIBET CHERES |
| First Respondent: | MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION, CITIZENSHIP, MIGRANT SERVICES AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS |
| Second Respondent: | ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL |
| File Number: | PEG 340 of 2019 |
| Judgment of: | Judge Kendall |
| Hearing date: | 10 November 2020 |
| Date of Last Submission: | 10 November 2020 |
| Delivered at: | Perth |
| Delivered on: | 12 November 2020 |
REPRESENTATION
| Counsel for the Applicants: | Ms S Manera |
| Solicitors for the Applicants: | Rothstein Lawyers |
| Counsel for the First Respondent: | Ms G Ellis |
| Second Respondent: | Submitting appearance, save as to costs |
| Solicitors for the Respondents: | Sparke Helmore Lawyers |
ORDERS
The application be dismissed.
| FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA AT PERTH |
PEG 340 of 2019
| BETTY JEPYEGON KIBOGONG |
First Applicant
| BERNARD KIBET CHERES |
Second Applicant
And
| MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION, CITIZENSHIP, MIGRANT SERVICES AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS |
First Respondent
| ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL |
Second Respondent
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
Introduction
The applicants are citizens of Kenya. They are wife and husband respectively. The first applicant arrived in Australia on a student visa in 2013 (Court Book (“CB”) 12).
On 15 March 2017, the first applicant, Ms Kibogong, applied for a Student (Temporary) (class TU) Student (subclass 500) visa (the “visa”) (CB 1-36). Her husband, the second applicant, was included as a member of the “family unit”.
On 4 July 2017, a delegate of the first respondent (the “Minister”) refused to grant the applicants the visa (CB 38-47). The delegate found that the first applicant did not meet cl.500.214 of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) (the “Regulations”) as she had not provided evidence that she met the financial capacity criterion. As the first applicant was not granted the visa, the second applicant was also refused the visa.
On 25 July 2017, the applicants sought review of the delegate’s decision at the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the “Tribunal”) (CB 48-50). The applicants attached various supporting documents to their application including a statutory declaration from the first applicant’s uncle and an “Account Statement” from Diamond Trust Bank (CB 51-52).
On 12 July 2019, the applicants’ migration agent forwarded documents to the Tribunal. Those documents included a letter that stated that the first applicant was enrolled in a Bachelor of Nursing and was expected to complete her studies in July 2020 (CB 66) and a confirmation of offer in a Bachelor of Business…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Kibogong v Minister for Immigration and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] FCCA 3055
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The applicants brought their application for judicial review to the Federal Circuit Court of Australia, alleging that the Tribunal had made a jurisdictional error. Specifically, they contended that the Tribunal failed to consider documents submitted on the morning of the hearing, which included a bank statement from a financial guarantor and the guarantor's passport details. They also argued that the Tribunal failed to consider oral and documentary evidence that the first applicant was enrolled in a course and had paid fees and living expenses. The core legal issue was whether the Tribunal's failure to consider this evidence constituted a jurisdictional error, thereby vitiating its decision.
Judge Kendall considered the two-stage inquiry required by clause 500.214 of the Regulations and the relevant legislative instrument, IMMI 18/010. This involves first determining the quantum of funds required and then assessing whether the applicant has provided evidence of those funds in a prescribed form. The Court noted that the Tribunal did not expressly refer to the documents submitted on the morning of the hearing. However, it found that a failure to refer to evidence does not automatically mean it was overlooked; it may simply have been considered not material to the Tribunal's assessment. The Court reasoned that the Tribunal's decision turned on the issue of quantum and form of funds, and that the applicants had not provided the necessary documentation to allow the Tribunal to calculate the required amount of funds. Therefore, the financial evidence provided, even if considered, would have been meaningless in the absence of the necessary information to determine the quantum.
The application for judicial review was dismissed. The Court found that the Tribunal did not make a jurisdictional error by failing to consider the documents submitted on the morning of the hearing, as these documents were not considered material to the Tribunal's assessment in light of the insufficient information provided regarding the required quantum of funds.
Orders
Orders of the court
1.
The application be dismissed.
FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT PERTH
PEG 340 of 2019
BETTY JEPYEGON KIBOGONG
First Applicant
BERNARD KIBET CHERES
Second Applicant
And
MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION, CITIZENSHIP, MIGRANT SERVICES AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
First Respondent
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
Second Respondent
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
Introduction
1.
The applicants are citizens of Kenya. They are wife and husband respectively. The first applicant arrived in Australia on a student visa in 2013 (Court Book (“CB”) 12).
2.
On 15 March 2017, the first applicant, Ms Kibogong, applied for a Student (Temporary) (class TU) Student (subclass 500) visa (the “visa”) (CB 1-36). Her husband, the second applicant, was included as a member of the “family unit”.
3.
On 4 July 2017, a delegate of the first respondent (the “Minister”) refused to grant the applicants the visa (CB 38-47). The delegate found that the first applicant did not meet cl.500.214 of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) (the “Regulations”) as she had not provided evidence that she met the financial capacity criterion. As the first applicant was not granted the visa, the second applicant was also refused the visa.
4.
On 25 July 2017, the applicants sought review of the delegate’s decision at the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the “Tribunal”) (CB 48-50). The applicants attached various supporting documents to their application including a statutory declaration from the first applicant’s uncle and an “Account Statement” from Diamond Trust Bank (CB 51-52).
5.
On 12 July 2019, the applicants’ migration agent forwarded documents to the Tribunal. Those documents included a letter that stated that the first applicant was enrolled in a Bachelor of Nursing and was expected to complete her studies in July 2020 (CB 66) and a confirmation of offer in a Bachelor of Business in Management
(CB 67-72).
6.
On 26 July 2019, the applicants’ migration agent forwarded further documentation that included a confirmation of enrolment issued by Murdoch University and a previous confirmation of enrolment in another course at Curtin University (CB 78-81).
7.
On 31 July 2019, a current bank statement and identity documents were provided to the Tribunal (CB 91-95). Later that day, the applicants attended a hearing before the Tribunal (CB 99-101).
8.
At the conclusion of the hearing on 31 July 2019, the Tribunal gave an oral decision that affirmed the delegate’s decision (CB 105).
9.
On 28 August 2019, the applicants filed a judicial review application in this Court seeking review of the Tribunal’s decision. The application is brought pursuant to s.476 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth).
Tribunal’s Decision
10.
A written record of the Tribunal’s decision was produced on 13 September 2019. That decision is 4 pages long and spans 26 paragraphs.
11.
The Tribunal began by summarising the procedural history of the matter. It noted that the delegate had refused the visa on the basis that the first applicant did not meet cl.500.214 and confirmed that the applicants had appeared before the Tribunal with the assistance of a migration agent (at [3]-[8]).
12.
The Tribunal then identified that the issue on review was whether the applicant met the financial criterion and genuine access to funds criteria in cl.500.214 of the Regulations (at [9]). The Tribunal explained:
10. To meet cl.500.214, the applicant must (if required by the Minister) give evidence of financial capacity that satisfies the requirements specified in an instrument: cl.500.214(3). The Tribunal must also be satisfied that the applicant will have genuine access to the funds: 500.214(1).
11. A delegate of the Minister has made a legislative instrument under cl.500.214 (3) specifying requirements to meet the evidence of financial capacity. The legislative instrument applicable to the applicant in the circumstances of her application for a Student visa is IMMI 18/010.
13.
The Tribunal then noted that the invitation to the hearing had requested that the first applicant provide evidence that she met the financial capacity criterion in accordance with IMMI 18/010 (at [12]).
14.
The Tribunal continued:
13. Prior to this hearing the applicant has not provided evidence which satisfies the requirements of having genuine access to funds.
14. At the hearing today you were again requested to provide this evidence to the Tribunal such as evidence you meet the requirements of having genuine access to funds to meet your costs and expenses during your intended stay in Australia and the costs and expenses for each member of your family unit. You have not done so.
15. The applicant submitted a confirmation letter from Murdoch University dated 10 September 2018 but this Confirmation of Enrolment did not show the relevant costs involved for the costs of the course and any outstanding course fees, hence the Tribunal was not able to calculate the relevant costs for the applicant and her husband and as a result were not able to meet clause 500.214.
16. The applicant through her migration agent requested further time in which to submit evidence of financial capacity and genuine access to funds. The Tribunal carefully considered the request for further time, and after due consideration the Tribunal is not satisfied that an extension of further time is appropriate.
17. The migration agent stated during the hearing that she understood that the applicant had already been requested on a number of occasions to supply this information. The migration agent had also asked for this information and had not been provided it.
18. The applicant has had since 2017 to provide the relevant documentation to the Tribunal when she applied to the Tribunal to have her decision reviewed. On 12 July 2019 the applicant was invited to attend the hearing today via telephone and in that invitation the relevant request for documentation was asked for.
19. Accordingly, there is no evidence before me that you meet the financial requirements of having the financial capacity and genuine access to funds.
20. Therefore the Tribunal is not satisfied that at the time of this decision, the applicant meets the financial capacity requirements and accordingly cl.500.214 is not met.
15.
The Tribunal then considered whether the second applicant met the requirements of cl.500.311. Noting that the first applicant did not satisfy cl.500.214, the Tribunal found that the second applicant could not meet the criteria and could not be granted the visa (at [21]-[24]).
16.
The Tribunal affirmed the decision to refuse the applicants the visa (at [26]).
Proceedings in this Court
17.
The applicants’ application for judicial review filed on 28 August 2019 contained a single ground of review which argued that the Tribunal “unreasonably failed to adjourn the review and allow more time for the applicants to obtain documents”. However, the applicants filed an amended judicial review application on 20 November 2019.
18.
The amended application for judicial review contains two new grounds of review, as follows:
2. The Tribunal made a jurisdictional error by failing to consider the documents relating to the Applicants’ access to sufficient funds, provided in support of the application for review and submitted prior to the Tribunal making a decision.
Particulars
(a) The Applicants’ migration agent sent an email to the Tribunal on the day of the hearing at 12.06pm Australian Eastern Standard Time (AEST). The email was sent prior to the commencement of the Tribunal hearing. The email contained a scanned colour copy of a person who was alleged to be the Applicants’ financial guarantor, and a copy of a letter from Commonwealth Bank dated 30 July 2019 confirming the person’s bank balance (At CB 91);
(b) The Tribunal hearing was scheduled to take place at 1.30pm AEST, however it commenced at 2.07pm AEST. The Tribunal received the email 2 hours and 1 minute prior to the commencement of the hearing;
(c) The Tribunal did not take these documents into consideration in making a decision. The Tribunal expressly told the Applicants that he would not take review these documents;
(d) The Tribunal in his decision record stated that he had “carefully considered the request for further time and after due consideration the Tribunal is not satisfied that an extension of further time is appropriate.” (At CB 111, [16]). However, during the hearing the Tribunal takes approximately 10 seconds to make up his mind not to consider the additional documents provided on the morning of the hearing.
(e) These documents were directly relevant to whether the Applicants had access to sufficient funds to support their stay in Australia. The bank statement from the Applicants’ guarantor stated that she held an amount of $45,683 .56.
3. The Tribunal made a jurisdictional error by failing to consider the Applicants’ oral and documentary evidence that the First Applicant (the primary visa applicant) was currently enrolled in a course of study and had paid the applicable course fees, and had paid for their living expenses in Australia since the time of the visa refusal.
Particulars
(a) The First Applicant told the Tribunal that she was “about to finish her studies” (Annexure KSC 1 to the Affidavit of Ken Shen Chong at page 10);
(b) The Applicants’ representative told the Tribunal that ‘“the applicant has been paying for her own studies for the last past two years” (Annexure KSC 1 to the Affidavit of Ken Shen Chong at page 9);
(c) In the hearing the Tribunal did not ask the Applicants any questions about how they had been financially supporting themselves up until the time of the hearing. The Tribunal also did not ask the First Applicant when she was due to complete her studies. This was relevant to the question of whether the Applicants met the financial requirements of having the financial capacity and genuine access to funds.
19.
The applicants also filed an affidavit of Ken Shen Chong sworn
20 November 2019. The affidavit attached a transcript of the hearing that occurred before the Tribunal on 31 July 2019.
20.
The materials before the Court thus include those referred to above, a Court Book numbering 117 pages (marked as Exhibit 1), an outline of written submissions filed by the applicants on 10 August 2020 and an outline of written submissions filed by the Minister on 17 August 2020.
21.
Before this Court, the applicants were represented by Ms Manera. The Minister was represented by Ms Ellis. The Court thanks both lawyers for the clarity of their oral and written submissions. The Court will refer to any oral submissions made by Ms Manera and Ms Ellis where necessary below.
Legislative Scheme
22.
Clause 500.214 of the Regulations provides:
(1) The applicant will have genuine access to funds of a kind mentioned in subclause (2) and, if subclause (3) applies, subclause (3).
(2) While the applicant holds the visa, sufficient funds will be available to meet:
(a) the costs and expenses of the applicant during the applicant’s intended stay in Australia; and
(b) the costs and expenses of each member of the applicant’s family unit (if any) who will be in Australia.
(3) If required to do so by the Minister, in writing or by use of a computer program available online, at any time, the applicant gives to the Minister evidence of financial capacity that satisfies the requirements specified in an instrument under subclause (4).
Note: For arrangements for the use of a computer program, see section 495A of the Act.
(4) The Minister may, by legislative instrument, specify requirements for the purposes of subclause (3).
23.
The Minister submits, correctly, that Regulations envisage a two stage inquiry.
24.
First, the Tribunal must determine “the amount of funds” required by the applicants (“Stage One”).
25.
Second, the Tribunal must assess whether there is evidence in a “prescribed form” that shows that the applicants have access to the amount required (“Stage Two”).
26.
It is agreed that the issue in these proceedings relates to the two stages identified by the Minister.
27.
It is apparent that in order for the decision-maker (here, the Tribunal) to determine whether an applicant has “genuine access to funds”, the “amount of funds” must first be calculated. This is the focus of Stage One (i.e., determining the “quantum of funds necessary”).
28.
What constitutes “sufficient funds” is determined by reference to cl.500.214(2) and (3).
29.
The relevant instrument for the purposes of cl.500.214(3) is IMMI18/010. Section 6(2) of IMMI 18/010 requires evidence of “financial capacity” that:
(b) demonstrates that the primary applicant has sufficient funds available to meet the following costs and expenses of the primary applicant:
(i) travel expenses; and
(ii) the following living costs and expenses:
(A) if the primary applicant intends to stay in Australia for a period of 12 months or more – AUD20,290 (annual living costs); and
(B) if the primary applicant intends to stay in Australia for a period of less than 12 months – the pro rata equivalent of annual living costs, calculated as specified in section 11; and
(iii) the following course fees, minus any amount already paid:
(A) if the duration, or the remainder, of the primary applicant’s period of study in Australia is less than 12 months – the fees for the course of study or the remaining components of the course of study; or
(B) If the duration, or the remainder, of the primary applicant’s period of study in Australia is more than 12 months – course fees for the first 12 months of the period study in Australia; and
…
(c) demonstrates that the primary applicant has sufficient funds available to meet the following costs and expenses of each secondary applicant making a combined application with the primary applicant:
(i) travel expenses; and
(ii) for each secondary applicant who intends to stay in Australia for a period of 12 months or more – the following costs (annual living costs):
(A) for a spouse or de facto partner - AUD7,100; and
(B) for a dependent child - AUD3,040; and
(iii) for each secondary applicant who intends to stay in Australia for a period of less than 12 months – the pro rata equivalent of annual living costs, calculated as specified in section 11; and
30.
Sections 6(2)(b)(ii) and 6(2)(c)(ii) of IMMI 18/010 detail the amount that is required to meet cl.500.214(b) of the Regulations. Here, funds in the amount of $27,390 are needed in order to cover the applicants’ costs and expenses for one year. If their intended stay is less than one year, then a lesser amount is determined “pro-rata”.
31.
Clause 500.214(3) and IMMI 18/010 also requires that the applicants demonstrate that they have access to additional funds to meet travel expenses and course fees.
32.
In order to meet s.6(2)(b)(i) and (iii) and s.6(c)(i), the Tribunal must have sufficient information before it to determine “the sum of the travel costs and the course fees”.
33.
Once the quantum of funds is determined, then (and only then) will the Tribunal be able to move to Stage Two.
34.
Stage Two requires that the applicants provide evidence that they have funds available in the sum determined in Stage One. IMMI 18/010 requires that the evidence be “in the form specified”. The “form specified” is defined as follows:
10 Evidence of financial capacity
The following forms of evidence of financial capacity are specified:
(a) money deposit with a financial institution;
(b) loan with a financial institution;
(c) government loans;
(d) scholarship or financial support.
35.
In Stage Two, the Tribunal must determine whether an applicant has provided evidence (in a form that is specified in s.10 of IMMI 18/010) of the funds calculated in Stage One are. For example, if an applicant provides evidence in the form of a loan from a financial institution that equates to a sum in excess of the amount determined in the first part of the inquiry, then the second stage of the inquiry is met.
36.
If the funds are not in a valid form, then they are not evidence of “available” sufficient funds.
37.
Arguably, a third stage/inquiry arises which requires the Tribunal to determine whether the applicant has “genuine” access to the funds that are available (i.e., that the evidence that the applicant provides is “genuinely” available). For example, if a deposit is made shortly prior to the hearing by a family member, it may be necessary to consider if the applicant can genuinely access those funds or if they were transferred for the purpose of meeting the criteria to have “available” funds at the time of decision in a certain amount.
38.
However, this “third stage/inquiry” does not arise in these proceedings. The Tribunal’s decision turns on the issue of quantum and form as relevant to the funds needed and available.
Consideration
Ground 1
39.
Ground 1 in the original application for judicial review dated
28 August 2019 was abandoned and need not be assessed here.
Ground 2
40.
Ground 2 provides:
2. The Tribunal made a jurisdictional error by failing to consider the documents relating to the Applicants’ access to sufficient funds, provided in support of the application for review and submitted prior to the Tribunal making a decision.
Particulars
(a) The Applicants’ migration agent sent an email to the Tribunal on the day of the hearing at 12.06pm Australian Eastern Standard Time (AEST). The email was sent prior to the commencement of the Tribunal hearing. The email contained a scanned colour copy of a person who was alleged to be the Applicants’ financial guarantor, and a copy of a letter from Commonwealth Bank dated 30 July 2019 confirming the person’s bank balance (At CB 91);
(b) The Tribunal hearing was scheduled to take place at 1.30pm AEST, however it commenced at 2.07pm AEST. The Tribunal received the email 2 hours and 1 minute prior to the commencement of the hearing;
(c) The Tribunal did not take these documents into consideration in making a decision. The Tribunal expressly told the Applicants that he would not take review these documents;
(d) The Tribunal in his decision record stated that he had “carefully considered the request for further time and after due consideration the Tribunal is not satisfied that an extension of further time is appropriate.” (At CB 111, [16]). However, during the hearing the Tribunal takes approximately 10 seconds to make up his mind not to consider the additional documents provided on the morning of the hearing.
(e) These documents were directly relevant to whether the Applicants had access to sufficient funds to support their stay in Australia. The bank statement from the Applicants’ guarantor stated that she held an amount of $45,683 .56.
Applicants’ Submissions in Relation to Ground 2
41.
In written submissions dated 10 August 2020, the applicants submit as follows in relation to ground 2:
a) the relevant documents provided prior to the hearing (the “Pre-Hearing Documents”) that the Tribunal failed to consider were:
i) the passport bio data page of a relative of the applicants and their proposed financial guarantor (CB 94); and
ii) a Commonwealth Bank statement dated 30 July 2019 for that relative (CB 95);
b) the Tribunal expressly told the applicants that it would not review these documents before making a decision;
c) despite the fact that the Tribunal did not have the “financial records for the course”, the Tribunal nevertheless should have considered the evidence provided by the Pre-Hearing Documents;
d) the Pre-Hearing Documents were corroborative evidence of the applicants’ claim in their visa application that they had genuine access to funds. The Pre-Hearing Documents were directly relevant to whether the applicants had genuine access to sufficient funds to support their stay in Australia;
e) the Commonwealth Bank statement for the relative was an acceptable form of evidence of financial capacity under IMMI18/010;
f) further, the first applicant had given evidence that her uncle would be responsible for tuition fees, living and incidental expenses of the applicants. This was not considered by the Tribunal; and
g) the Tribunal deliberately overlooked this documentary evidence and made a jurisdictional error.
Minister’s Submissions in Relation to Ground 2
42.
The Minister’s submissions dated 17 August 2020 contend as follows in relation to ground 2:
a) the applicants complain that the Tribunal failed to consider the Pre-Hearing Documents. The Pre-Hearing Documents went to the assessment of whether there was evidence in a prescribed form. Any evidence provided in relation to assessment of whether there was evidence in a prescribed form could not assist in circumstances where the Tribunal did not know the amount of funds the applicants were required to have access to;
b) what is made clear from the transcript is that the Tribunal did not accept the financial evidence provided the morning of the hearing because the Tribunal did not have the financial records for the course the first applicant was studying;
c) it is well established that whether the Tribunal is obliged to consider evidence will depend on the circumstances of the case and the nature of the evidence. The relevant factors in determining whether the Tribunal was required to assess an item of evidence include the cogency and place of the evidentiary material in the assessment of the applicants’ claims and the decision maker’s reasons.
d) it cannot be argued that the Pre-Hearing Documents were relevant to the review when the applicants had not provided the necessary documentation to allow the Tribunal to make a determination of the amount of funds they required. That is, the Tribunal had to have been able to determine the amount of funds required before it could assess whether the applicants had sufficient access to these funds;
e) this is the exact line of reasoning adopted by the Tribunal when it stated that it would not accept the Pre-Hearing Documents. The Tribunal was unable to calculate the amount of funds required by the applicants, rendering any financial evidence that the applicants had provided in relation to the access to funds meaningless;
f) the applicants’ contention that the Tribunal “nevertheless should have considered” the evidence in circumstances where it was “corroborative evidence of the Applicants’ claim in their Student visa application form that they have genuine access to funds (CB 12)” is misguided for two reasons:
i) the claim in the applicants’ visa application that they had genuine access to funds related to the applicants’ ability to support themselves in Australia in relation to a different course with different course costs, namely, the Bachelor of Business for which the visa application was initially made (CB 1 and 33) and not the Bachelor of Nursing for which the first applicant sought the visa before the Tribunal; and
ii) more critically, the claim and financial evidence were meaningless in the absence of the applicants providing the necessary documentation to allow the Tribunal to make a determination of the amount of funds required. The applicants’ argument that the Tribunal should have considered the first applicant’s uncle’s evidence fails for the same reasons;
g) if, contrary to the Minister’s submissions, the Tribunal is found to have erred in not considering the Pre-Hearing Documents, such an error cannot be said to have been material to the Tribunal’s decision. As the applicants had not provided the necessary documentation to allow the Tribunal to make a determination of the amount of funds required, failing to consider evidence that purported to show that the applicants had access to an amount of funds could not have deprived the applicants of the possibility of a successful outcome. Nor could it have “realistically resulted in a different decision”; and
h) the Tribunal correctly found that the applicants had provided insufficient evidence for the Tribunal to calculate the relevant costs required and therefore that they did not meet cl.500.214. Indeed, it was the only finding open to it.
Consideration – Ground 2
43.
The applicants argue that the Tribunal overlooked, or failed to consider, the Pre-Hearing Documents. The Pre-Hearing Documents comprised of:
a) a colour passport of the first applicant’s aunt who was described in the email as the applicants’ financial guarantor; and
b) a bank statement in the name of the aunt demonstrating that, on the date of the Tribunal hearing, the aunt had access to $45,683.56.
44.
The applicants say that the failure to assess these documents amounts to a failure to consider corroborative evidence.
45.
Relevantly, the applicants refer to the following passages in Minister for Immigration & Citizenship v SZRKT [2013] FCA 317 at [111]-[112]:
111. In my opinion there is no clear distinction in each case between claims and evidence: see SHKB v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2004] FCA 545 at [24], set out at [69] above. The fundamental question must be the importance of the material to the exercise of the Tribunal’s function and thus the seriousness of any error. In my opinion the distinction between claims and evidence provides a tool of analysis but is not the discrimen itself. Further, it is important not to reason that because a failure to deal with some (insubstantial or inconsequential) evidence will, in some circumstances, not establish jurisdictional error, then a failure to deal with any (substantial and consequential) evidence will also not establish jurisdictional error.
112. As the Full Court said in VAAD v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs [2005] FCAFC 117 at [77] whether the Tribunal is obliged to consider a document or documents will depend on the circumstances of the case and the nature of the document. In my opinion, the relevant factors in relation to (corroborative) evidence include first, the cogency of the evidentiary material and, second, the place of that material in the assessment of the applicant’s claims.
46.
Here, the Tribunal does not expressly refer to the Pre-Hearing Documents. However, a failure to refer to evidence does not demonstrate that it has been overlooked. It may well be, for example, that the Pre-Hearing Documents were not considered material to the Tribunal’s assessment: Applicant WAEE v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs (2003) 256 FCR 593 at [46].
47.
Background
Background to the litigation
At the Tribunal hearing on 31 July 2019, the Tribunal gave an oral decision affirming the delegate’s decision. The Tribunal found that the applicants had not provided evidence that they met the financial capacity criterion and genuine access to funds criteria in cl.500.214 of the Regulations. The Tribunal noted that the applicants had not provided evidence of the financial capacity and genuine access to funds as required by IMMI 18/010. Specifically, the Tribunal was not satisfied that the applicants had provided evidence of the amount of funds required to meet the costs and expenses of their intended stay in Australia and the costs and expenses for each member of their family unit. On 28 August 2019, the applicants filed a judicial review application in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia seeking review of the Tribunal’s decision. The applicants later filed an amended application for judicial review on 20 November 2019. The amended application contained two grounds of review, arguing that the Tribunal failed to consider documents relating to the applicants’ access to sufficient funds and failed to consider the applicants’ evidence that the primary applicant was currently enrolled in a course of study and had paid the applicable course fees and had paid for their living expenses in Australia since the time of the visa refusal.
This case involves a judicial review application of a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the “Tribunal”) which affirmed the decision of the Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs (the “Minister”) to refuse the applicants a Student (Temporary) (class TU) Student (subclass 500) visa (the “visa”). The applicants, Kenyan citizens Betty Jepyeon Kibogong and Bernard Kibet Cheres, sought judicial review of the Tribunal’s decision on the grounds that the Tribunal failed to consider documents relating to the applicants’ access to sufficient funds and failed to consider the applicants’ oral and documentary evidence. The applicants’ application for judicial review was initially filed on 28 August 2019. They subsequently filed an amended application on 20 November 2019. The Court will assess the merits of the amended application.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Tribunal made a jurisdictional error by failing to consider documents relating to the applicants’ access to sufficient funds provided prior to the Tribunal making a decision.
2. Whether the Tribunal made a jurisdictional error by failing to consider the applicants’ oral and documentary evidence that the first applicant was currently enrolled in a course of study and had paid the applicable course fees and living expenses in Australia since the time of the visa refusal.
Held
1. Whether the Tribunal made a jurisdictional error by failing to consider documents relating to the applicants’ access to sufficient funds provided prior to the Tribunal making a decision.
The court held that the Tribunal did not make a jurisdictional error by failing to consider the documents relating to the applicants’ access to sufficient funds provided prior to the Tribunal making a decision. The court concluded that the Tribunal had not been provided with the necessary documentation to calculate the amount of funds required by the applicants, rendering any financial evidence provided meaningless. Therefore, the failure to consider the documents could not have deprived the applicants of the possibility of a successful outcome and was not material to the Tribunal’s decision.
2. Whether the Tribunal made a jurisdictional error by failing to consider the applicants’ oral and documentary evidence that the first applicant was currently enrolled in a course of study and had paid the applicable course fees and living expenses in Australia since the time of the visa refusal.
The court held that the Tribunal did not make a jurisdictional error by failing to consider the applicants’ oral and documentary evidence that the first applicant was currently enrolled in a course of study and had paid the applicable course fees and living expenses in Australia since the time of the visa refusal. The court concluded that the evidence related to a different course with different course costs and was therefore irrelevant to the Tribunal’s assessment of whether the applicants had sufficient access to funds for their intended course of study. The court further found that the Tribunal correctly determined that the applicants had provided insufficient evidence for the Tribunal to calculate the relevant costs required and that they did not meet cl.500.214.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court turned to consider the applicants’ argument that the Tribunal failed to consider documents that were relevant to the applicants’ access to sufficient funds. These documents included a passport of the applicants’ financial guarantor and a bank statement of the guarantor which demonstrated that she held an amount of $45,683.56. The applicants argued that the failure to assess these documents amounted to a failure to consider corroborative evidence. The Court noted that the applicants referred to passages from Minister for Immigration & Citizenship v SZRKT [2013] FCA 317, which held that the Tribunal is obliged to consider evidence if it is important to the exercise of the Tribunal’s function and the seriousness of any error. The Court was required to determine whether the Tribunal’s failure to consider the documents amounted to a jurisdictional error.
The Minister argued that the Pre-Hearing Documents were not relevant to the Tribunal’s assessment because the Tribunal did not know the amount of funds the applicants were required to have access to. The Minister submitted that the relevant factors in determining whether the Tribunal was required to assess an item of evidence included the cogency and place of the evidentiary material in the assessment of the applicants’ claims and the decision maker’s reasons. The Court noted that the Tribunal did not accept the financial evidence provided on the morning of the hearing because the Tribunal did not have the financial records for the course the first applicant was studying. The Court held that the Tribunal correctly found that the applicants had provided insufficient evidence for the Tribunal to calculate the relevant costs required and therefore that they did not meet cl.500.214. The Court found that if, contrary to the Minister’s submissions, the Tribunal was found to have erred in not considering the Pre-Hearing Documents, such an error could not be said to have been material to the Tribunal’s decision.
The Court held that the Tribunal did not make a jurisdictional error by failing to consider the Pre-Hearing Documents. The Court found that the Tribunal correctly held that it could not consider the Pre-Hearing Documents because it did not know the amount of funds the applicants were required to have access to. The Court held that the Tribunal was not obliged to consider the Pre-Hearing Documents because they were not relevant to the Tribunal’s assessment. The Court found that the Tribunal correctly found that the applicants had provided insufficient evidence for the Tribunal to calculate the relevant costs required and therefore that they did not meet cl.500.214. The Court held that the Tribunal’s failure to consider the Pre-Hearing Documents did not amount to a jurisdictional error.
Ground 3
48.
Ground 3 provides:
3. The Tribunal made a jurisdictional error by failing to consider the Applicants’ oral and documentary evidence that the First Applicant was currently enrolled in a course of study and had paid the applicable course fees and living expenses in Australia since the time of the visa refusal.
Particulars
(a) The First Applicant told the Tribunal that she was “about to finish her studies” (Annexure KSC 1 to the Affidavit of Ken Shen Chong at page 10);
(b) The Applicants’ representative told the Tribunal that ‘“the applicant has been paying for her own studies for the last past two years” (Annexure KSC 1 to the Affidavit of Ken Shen Chong at page 9);
(c) In the hearing the Tribunal did not ask the Applicants any questions about how they had been financially supporting themselves up until the time of the hearing. The Tribunal also did not ask the First Applicant when she was due to complete her studies. This was relevant to the question of whether the Applicants met the financial requirements of having the financial capacity and genuine access to funds.
Applicants’ Submissions in Relation to Ground 3
49.
In written submissions dated 10 August 2020, the applicants submit as follows in relation to ground 3:
a) the Tribunal failed to ask any questions about how the applicants had been financially supporting themselves up until the time of the hearing;
b) the Tribunal also failed to ask the first applicant when she was due to complete her studies;
c) the first applicant’s evidence that she was about to finish her studies and that she had been paying for her own studies for the past two years was relevant to the question of whether the applicants met the financial requirements of having the financial capacity and genuine access to funds;
d) the Tribunal’s failure to ask any questions and to obtain evidence of the applicants’ financial capacity and genuine access to funds was a jurisdictional error;
e) the Tribunal’s failure to ask the first applicant when she was due to complete her studies was a jurisdictional error;
f) the Tribunal’s failure to ask any questions and to obtain evidence of the applicants’ financial capacity and genuine access to funds was a jurisdictional error.
Minister’s Submissions in Relation to Ground 3
50.
The Minister’s submissions dated 17 August 2020 contend as follows in relation to ground 3:
a) the applicants complain that the Tribunal failed to ask any questions about how the applicants had been financially supporting themselves up until the time of the hearing;
b) it is well established that the Tribunal is not obliged to ask questions of the applicants in order to make a decision;
c) the Tribunal had sufficient information before it to make a decision that the applicants did not satisfy cl.500.214 of the Regulations;
d) the Tribunal was not required to ask any questions of the applicants in order to make a decision;
e) the Tribunal’s failure to ask any questions was not a jurisdictional error.
Consideration – Ground 3
51.
The applicants argued that the Tribunal failed to ask any questions about how the applicants had been financially supporting themselves up until the time of the hearing. The applicants submitted that the first applicant’s evidence that she was about to finish her studies and that she had been paying for her own studies for the past two years was relevant to the question of whether the applicants met the financial requirements of having the financial capacity and genuine access to funds. The applicants submitted that the Tribunal’s failure to ask any questions and to obtain evidence of the applicants’ financial capacity and genuine access to funds was a jurisdictional error.
The Minister submitted that the Tribunal was not obliged to ask any questions of the applicants in order to make a decision. The Minister submitted that the Tribunal had sufficient information before it to make a decision that the applicants did not satisfy cl.500.214 of the Regulations. The Minister submitted that the Tribunal’s failure to ask any questions was not a jurisdictional error.
The Court held that the Tribunal was not obliged to ask any questions of the applicants in order to make a decision. The Court found that the Tribunal had sufficient information before it to make a decision that the applicants did not satisfy cl.500.214 of the Regulations. The Court held that the Tribunal’s failure to ask any questions was not a jurisdictional error.
Conclusion
52.
For the reasons given above, the Court held that the Tribunal did not make a jurisdictional error in failing to consider the Pre-Hearing Documents and in failing to ask any questions of the applicants. The Court held that the Tribunal had sufficient information before it to make a decision that the applicants did not satisfy cl.500.214 of the Regulations. The Court held that the Tribunal’s failure to consider the Pre-Hearing Documents and to ask any questions of the applicants was not a jurisdictional error. The Court dismissed the application for judicial review.
53.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that the Tribunal is not obliged to ask questions of the applicants in order to make a decision and that the Tribunal had sufficient information before it to make a decision that the applicants did not satisfy cl.500.214 of the Regulations. The Court held that the Tribunal’s failure to ask any questions was not a jurisdictional error. The Court held that the Tribunal did not make a jurisdictional error in failing to consider the Pre-Hearing Documents. The Court found that the Tribunal correctly held that it could not consider the Pre-Hearing Documents because it did not know the amount of funds the applicants were required to have access to. The Court held that the Tribunal was not obliged to consider the Pre-Hearing Documents because they were not relevant to the Tribunal’s assessment. The Court held that the Tribunal correctly found that the applicants had provided insufficient evidence for the Tribunal to calculate the relevant costs required and therefore that they did not meet cl.500.214. The Court held that the Tribunal’s failure to consider the Pre-Hearing Documents did not amount to a jurisdictional error.