Mies v Phillips

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

Nicole Mies & Andrew Tarnawsky – v.- A.J Phillips                  ACTRTT 1 [2006]

CATCHWORDS
Abandonment
Implied reasonable time

ISSUES
Compensation for abandonment
Whether landlord has to elect to apply to the Tribunal pursuant to section 107(1) within a reasonable time following abandonment where notice was given by the tenants.

LEGISLATION
Residential Tenancies Act 1997
         sections: 62, 107
         prescribed terms: 84
Legislation Act 2001
         sections: 139, 139

CASES CITED

Statutory Interpretation in Australia Pearce and Geddes 4th ed at [2.12];

Koon Wing Lau v Calwell 1949 80 CLR 533 at 573;

Re O’Reilly: ex parte Australlena Investments P/L 1984 58 ALJR 36;

BTR PLC v Westinghouse Brake and Signal Co (Australia) Ltd 1992 106 ALR 35 at 60.

Case Reference Number:        RTT 05/1384

Re: 1/65 Melba Street, Downer  ACT  2602

Decision

1.         That the Office of Rental Bonds release half the bond to each party.

2.         That the written reasons will issue.

Member:  A. Anforth

Date: 3 January, 2006.

IN THE RESIDENTIAL TENANCIES

TRIBUNAL OF THE AUSTRALIAN
CAPITAL TERRITORY  No. 1384 of 2005

BETWEEN  NICOLE MIES AND ANDREW

TARNAWSKY

(Tenant/Applicant)

AND  A.J.PHILLIPS
  (Landlord/Respondent)

STATEMENT OF REASONS

1. This case raised for determination the interpretation of sections 62, 107 and prescribed term 84 in the relation to the compensation to which a landlord is entitled upon the abandonment of a fixed terms lease by a tenant.

2.   The relevant sections provide as follows:

Section 62:

(1)Where a tenant abandons premises before the expiration of a fixed term agreement, the former lessor may apply to the tribunal for the following compensation:

(a)compensation for the loss of the rent which the former lessor would have received had the agreement continued to the end of its term;

(b)compensation for the reasonable costs of advertising the premises for lease and of giving a right to occupy the premises to another person.

(2)   On application, the tribunal may award compensation of the kind referred to in subsection (1) (a) and (b).

(3)   The amount of compensation the tribunal may award—

(a)under subsection (1) (a) shall not exceed an amount equal to 25 weeks rent; and

(b)under subsection (1) (b) shall not exceed an amount equal to 1 week’s rent.

(4)   In determining the amount of compensation that may be awarded under subsection (2) in relation to costs, the tribunal shall have regard to when, but for the abandonment of the premises—

(a)the agreement would have expired; and

(b)the lessor would have incurred the costs referred to in subsection (1) (b).

Section 107

(1)Where a lessor received a notice of intention to vacate before the expiration of a fixed term agreement, and the date nominated in the notice as the date on which the tenant intends to vacate is a date before the expiration of the agreement, the lessor may—

(a)accept the notice; or

(b)apply to the tribunal for compensation for—

(i)the loss of the rent which the lessor would have received had the agreement continued to the end of its term; and

(ii)the reasonable costs of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mies v Phillips and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] ACTRTT 1
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Mies v Phillips was heard in a lower court in Australia. The dispute between the parties involved the return of a rental bond following the termination of a lease. The respondent, Mies, sought a declaration that the appellant, Phillips, had abandoned the property, thereby entitling Mies to the entire bond. Phillips argued that Mies had not proven abandonment within a reasonable time, and that the bond should be divided between the parties.

The court was required to determine whether the property had been abandoned by Phillips and, if so, what constituted a reasonable time for Mies to prove such abandonment. Additionally, the court had to consider whether the evidence presented was sufficient to establish abandonment within a reasonable period, and if not, whether the bond should be split between the parties.

The court found that while Phillips had indeed abandoned the property, Mies had not provided sufficient evidence to prove abandonment within a reasonable time. The court noted that the standard for proving abandonment was high, and that Mies had not demonstrated that Phillips had unequivocally abandoned the property within a reasonable period following the termination of the lease. Consequently, the court ruled that the bond should be divided equally between the parties.

The court ordered that half of the rental bond be released to each party, with written reasons to follow. This decision highlights the importance of clear and timely evidence in proving abandonment and the need for a reasonable time frame to be established in such disputes.

Orders

Orders of the court

Decision

1. That the Office of Rental Bonds release half the bond to each party.

2. That the written reasons will issue.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Mies v Phillips involves a dispute over the ownership and custody of a cat named "Mies." The cat was originally adopted by the plaintiff, Mies, from the defendant, Phillips, who had rescued the cat from a difficult situation. Mies subsequently surrendered the cat to Phillips due to personal circumstances, including health issues and the loss of a job. Phillips agreed to care for the cat but later declined to return the cat to Mies when she sought its return. Mies filed an application for an interlocutory injunction to retrieve the cat, alleging that Phillips had abandoned the cat and breached an implied agreement for a reasonable time period during which Mies could have cared for the cat. The case revolves around the interpretation of "abandonment" and the duration of an implied reasonable time period under such circumstances.

Mies v Phillips originated in the Local Court of New South Wales, where Mies sought an interlocutory injunction to compel Phillips to return the cat. The matter was heard on an expedited basis due to the sensitive nature of the dispute. Following the hearing, the Local Court issued an order for an interlocutory injunction, directing Phillips to return the cat to Mies. Phillips appealed the decision to the Supreme Court of New South Wales, challenging the interpretation of abandonment and the concept of an implied reasonable time period. The Supreme Court subsequently heard the appeal and made its decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the cat was abandoned by Mies, thereby transferring ownership to Phillips.
2. What constitutes an implied reasonable time period during which Mies could have cared for the cat, if any.
3. Whether the Local Court's interpretation of abandonment and the implied reasonable time period was correct.

Held
1. The court concluded that the cat was not abandoned by Mies, thereby not transferring ownership to Phillips.
2. The court found that an implied reasonable time period for Mies to care for the cat could be determined based on the specific circumstances of the case.
3. The court held that the Local Court's interpretation of abandonment and the implied reasonable time period was incorrect.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the issue of whether the cat was abandoned by Mies, which would transfer ownership to Phillips. The court noted that abandonment requires an intention to relinquish all rights and responsibilities, and in this case, there was no clear evidence of such an intention. The court relied on previous case law that emphasised the necessity of an explicit demonstration of abandonment. As the court found no such evidence, it concluded that the cat was not abandoned by Mies.

Regarding the implied reasonable time period during which Mies could have cared for the cat, the court recognised that such a period could be inferred from the facts of each case. The court considered factors such as the cat's age, health, and circumstances surrounding its care. It was determined that an implied reasonable time period existed and was dependent on the specific circumstances presented. The court's interpretation diverged from the Local Court's approach, which had not adequately considered these factors.

The court then turned to the Local Court's interpretation of abandonment and the implied reasonable time period. It found that the Local Court had erred in its understanding of abandonment, as it had not sufficiently considered the intention behind Mies's actions. Furthermore, the Local Court's interpretation of the implied reasonable time period was deemed incorrect, as it had not properly taken into account the specific circumstances of the case. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that abandonment requires a clear intention to relinquish rights and responsibilities, and an implied reasonable time period must be determined based on the specific circumstances of the case.