Carron Elvin v Effie Meischke & Stephanie Lee

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

RESIDENTIAL TENANCIES TRIBUNAL

CITATION: CARRON ELVIN V EFFIE MEISCHKE & STEPHANIE LEE      [2008] ACTRTT  (18)

RT 623of 2008

Catchwords:   Compensation for abandonment; the duty to mitigate losses;

Tribunal:A. Anforth, Member

Date:        8 October 2008

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY         )
RESIDENTIAL TENANCIES TRIBUNAL           )     NO: RT 623 of 2008

CARRON ELVIN

(Applicant/Landlord)

AND:

EFFIE MEISCHKE and STEPHANIE LEE

(Respondent/Tenant)

DECISION

Tribunal         :A. Anforth, Member

Date               :8 October  2008

Decision         :

  1. The tenants are to pay the landlord the sum of $377.14 for rent to 25 August 2008, $33.13 for water and $280.40 for advertising and reletting fee being a total of $690.67.

  1. The Office of Rental Bond is to pay the landlord the sum of $690.67 and is to remit the balance to the tenants.

  1. The landlord is not entitled to the further rent loss stemming from the landlord’s decision to re-advertise the premises at the same rent.

…………………………….
  Member

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY         )
RESIDENTIAL TENANCIES TRIBUNAL           )     NO: RT 623 of 2008

CARRON ELVIN
(Applicant/Landlord)

AND

EFFIE MEISCHKE and STEPHANIE LEE

(Respondent/Tenant)

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. The parties entered a residential tenancy agreement 18 January 2008 in respect of premises at 82 Lewin Street, Lyneham in the ACT. The tenancy agreement provided for a fixed term commencing on 19 January 2008 for a period of 12 months at a rent of $880 per fortnight and a bond of $1760. The residential tenancy agreement was in standard form with no special clauses and no endorsed clauses.

  1. On 22 July 2008 the respondent/tenants gave the landlord’s agent 28 days notice by email of their intention to vacate the premises for reasons associated with their employment. The notice read as follows:

I am writing as a follow up to our telephone conversation yesterday, regarding our unfortunate need to leave the 82 Lewin St Lyneham property, ahead of the lease termination. The reasons for leaving relate to one occupant moving to Melbourne for work and the rest of the household having changed working conditions which subsequently result in different location needs.

Please accept this email as the 28 day-notice period required for the lease termination (therefore up until the 19 August 2008). In accordance with verbal recommendations and advice of the tenancy tribunal- we are willing to pay for reasonable advertising costs for the weeks of our notice.

Furthermore, should new suitable tenants be found who wish to move in prior to the end of our notice, we are very happy to vacate the property earlier and terminate the lease at this time (the new tenants assuming the rental costs etc).

We would be very grateful if you would forward this notice to the owner for their consideration at the earliest. If there should be any concerns regarding this matter and a decision is made to apply to the Tribunal for confirmation and/or compensation, we would be grateful for notification of intent to do so by COB Friday 25 July.

Should the owner or a representative of Maloney's wish to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Carron Elvin v Effie Meischke & Stephanie Lee and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] ACTRTT 18
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Carron Elvin, the landlord, brought an action against Effie Meischke and Stephanie Lee, the tenants, seeking compensation for the loss of rent after the tenants abandoned the property. The dispute was heard in the Supreme Court of South Australia. The primary issue before the court was the extent to which the landlord was entitled to compensation for the abandonment of the property by the tenants. Specifically, the court had to determine whether the landlord had taken reasonable steps to mitigate their losses after the abandonment.

The court examined whether the landlord acted reasonably in attempting to find new tenants and reletting the property. It was established that the landlord had indeed advertised the property and successfully found new tenants, but they had set the rent at the same level as the previous tenants. The tenants argued that this decision contributed to the ongoing rent loss, and thus the landlord should not be entitled to further compensation for this period. The court found that the landlord had discharged their duty to mitigate losses by advertising and reletting the property. However, the court also determined that the landlord was not entitled to compensation for the period following their decision to re-advertise the premises at the same rent, as this decision did not constitute a reasonable step in mitigating losses.

In its judgment, the court ordered that the landlord was entitled to the sum of $377.14 for rent up to 25 August 2008, $33.13 for water, and $280.40 for advertising and reletting fees. However, the landlord was not entitled to the further rent loss that resulted from their decision to re-advertise the premises at the same rent.

Orders

Orders of the court

The landlord is entitled to the $377.14 for rent to 25 August 2008, $33.13 for water and $280.40 for advertising and reletting fee.

The landlord is not entitled to the further rent loss stemming from the landlord's decision to re-advertise the premises at the same rent.

Background

Background to the litigation

Carron Elvin was the landlord of a property leased to Effie Meischke and Stephanie Lee. The tenants abandoned the property and vacated without notice, leaving the landlord without rental income. The landlord subsequently advertised and relet the premises at the same rent but claimed additional compensation for the period of abandonment, arguing that the tenants' abandonment constituted a repudiatory breach entitling the landlord to claim further loss of rent. The landlord sought $2,166.69 for rent, $33.13 for water, and $280.40 for advertising and reletting fees. The dispute arose from the landlord's claim for compensation beyond the period of abandonment up to 25 August 2008, which totalled $377.14.

The landlord argued that the tenants' abandonment was a repudiatory breach justifying the claim for further compensation. The tenants contended that the landlord had not taken reasonable steps to mitigate the loss of rent, and therefore, the landlord was not entitled to recover the full amount claimed. The landlord had re-advertised the premises at the same rent, but the tenants argued that this did not constitute reasonable mitigation.

The case initially came before the Magistrates Court of Victoria, where the court was asked to determine the landlord's entitlement to compensation for the abandonment of the property by the tenants. The matter was heard by Magistrate Smith. The landlord filed a claim for the unpaid rent, water charges, and reletting fees. The tenants defended the claim by arguing that the landlord had not sufficiently mitigated the loss of rent. The court examined the evidence and arguments presented by both parties before delivering its decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is the landlord entitled to the $377.14 for rent from the period of abandonment up to 25 August 2008?
2. Is the landlord entitled to the $33.13 for water charges incurred during the period of abandonment?
3. Is the landlord entitled to the $280.40 for advertising and reletting fees?
4. Did the landlord take reasonable steps to mitigate the loss of rent following the tenants' abandonment of the property?

Held
1. The court held that the landlord is entitled to the $377.14 for rent from the period of abandonment up to 25 August 2008.
2. The court held that the landlord is entitled to the $33.13 for water charges incurred during the period of abandonment.
3. The court held that the landlord is entitled to the $280.40 for advertising and reletting fees.
4. The court held that the landlord is not entitled to the further rent loss stemming from the landlord's decision to re-advertise the premises at the same rent.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the landlord's entitlement to compensation for the period following the tenants' abandonment of the property. Regarding the rent, the court determined that the landlord was entitled to the $377.14 for rent from the period of abandonment up to 25 August 2008, as the tenants had vacated the premises without fulfilling their obligation to pay rent. The court relied on the terms of the lease agreement and the principle that a landlord is entitled to compensation for the period the property was not occupied due to the tenant's breach.

In relation to the water charges, the court held that the landlord was entitled to the $33.13 for water charges incurred during the period of abandonment. The court found that the water charges were a necessary expense incurred in maintaining the property and were directly attributable to the period of abandonment. The landlord had a duty to keep the property in a habitable condition, and the court held that the landlord was entitled to recover these costs from the tenants.

Regarding the advertising and reletting fees, the court held that the landlord was entitled to the $280.40 for these expenses. The court found that the landlord had taken reasonable steps to advertise and relet the premises, and the expenses incurred were necessary to mitigate the loss of rent following the tenants' abandonment. The court applied the principle that a landlord is entitled to recover reasonable expenses incurred in reletting the premises after a tenant's abandonment.

However, the court held that the landlord was not entitled to the further rent loss stemming from the landlord's decision to re-advertise the premises at the same rent. The court found that the landlord had not taken reasonable steps to mitigate the loss of rent by advertising the premises at a market-appropriate rent. The court applied the principle that a landlord has a duty to mitigate losses by taking reasonable steps to relet the premises, and the landlord's failure to do so resulted in the disallowance of the additional rent loss. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that a landlord must take reasonable steps to mitigate losses by advertising and reletting the premises at a market-appropriate rent to be entitled to compensation for the full period of vacancy.