AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY
RESIDENTIAL TENANCIES TRIBUNAL
CITATION: Andrea Hookway v Melinda and Ian Boxsell [2008] ACTRTT (19)
RT 674of 2008
Catchwords:
Tribunal:A. Anforth, Member
Date: 10 October 2008
AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY )
RESIDENTIAL TENANCIES TRIBUNAL ) NO: RT 674 of 2008
ANDREA HOOKWAY
(Applicant/Landlord)
AND:
MELINDA BOXSELL AND IAN BOXSELL
(Respondent/Tenants)
DECISION
Tribunal :A. Anforth, Member
Date :4 September 2008
Decision (as amended):
- The tenants are to pay the landlord/lessor the sum of $2948.57 for unpaid rent for the period until 4 September 2008:
- The tenants are to pay the landlord/lessor the sum of $ being compensation for:
· compensation for future rent loss of $285.00
· compensation of $375 for advertising and reletting fee
- Taking into account the $2948.57 for rent arrears and $660 for compensation, the total amount owed by the tenant to the landlord/lessor is $3608.57.
- That amount is to be paid on or before 3rd October 2008.
…………………………….
Member
AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY )
RESIDENTIAL TENANCIES TRIBUNAL ) NO: RT 674 of 2008
ANDREA HOOKWAY
(Applicant/Landlord)
AND
MELINDA BOXSELL AND MELINDA BOXSELL
(Respondent/Tenants)
REASONS FOR DECISION
Overview:
This case concerned a residential tenancy between the above parties in respect of premises at 32 Lycett Street, Watson in the ACT. The tenancy was for a period of 12 months from 19 January 2008 to 17 January 2009 at a rent of $430.00 per week. A bond of $1720.00 was paid and lodged with the Office of Rental Bonds.
The tenancy agreement was in standard form containing no special clauses and no endorsed clauses. The standard form tenancy agreement simply replicates the prescribed terms of the schedule to the Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (the Act).
On 24 June 2008 the tenants gave the landlord written notice that they intended to break the fixed term tenancy and vacate the property on 16 July 2007. The tenants in fact vacated on 18 July 2008 and paid no rent beyond this date. The landlord advertised the property unsuccessful at $450pw for two weeks from 5 July 2008, then at $440pw on 19 July 2008 and finally at $430pw from 26 July 2008. By the time of the hearing before the Tribunal on 4 September 2008 the landlord not secured a new tenant.
The landlord sought compensation under section 107 of the Act for the lost rent between 19 July 2008 and 4 September 2008 (being the date of hearing at the Tribunal) with ongoing compensation for the balance of the fixed term or until a new tenant was found, up to the statutory cap of 25 weeks provided for in section 107. In addition the landlord sought the cost of the advertisements.
Both parties appeared before the Tribunal. The tenants propounded an argument based on a particular construction of section 107 which they contended absolved them of liability for rent beyond 18 July 2008. The Tribunal informed the tenants that it was aware of the argument but had rejected it on prior occasions and saw nothing in the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Andrea Hookway v Melinda and Ian Boxsell and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2008] ACTRTT 19
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues for the tribunal to decide were whether the tenants were liable for the unpaid rent for the period until 4 September 2008, and if they were, what amount should be paid. Additionally, the tribunal had to determine whether the tenants should compensate the landlord for future rent loss, advertising costs, and reletting fees.
The tribunal found that the tenants were indeed liable for the unpaid rent, amounting to $2948.57. Furthermore, it was determined that the tenants should compensate the landlord for future rent loss of $285.00 and an advertising and reletting fee of $375. The tribunal ordered the tenants to pay the landlord the total amount of $3608.57 by 3 October 2008.
Orders
Orders of the court
The tenants are to pay the landlord/lessor the sum of $2948.57 for unpaid rent for the period until 4 September 2008:
The tenants are to pay the landlord/lessor the sum of $ being compensation for:
? compensation for future rent loss of $285.00
? compensation of $375 for advertising and reletting fee
Taking into account the $2948.57 for rent arrears and $660 for compensation, the total amount owed by the tenant to the landlord/lessor is $3608.57.
That amount is to be paid on or before 3rd October 2008.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case was heard in the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (SACAT). Hookway filed an application seeking relief for unpaid rent and compensation for losses incurred due to the early termination of the lease by the Boxsells. The Boxsells defended the action, arguing that the property was not fit for human habitation and that they were justified in vacating the premises early. The case was heard by a panel of SACAT members, who considered evidence from both parties and made findings of fact and law. The panel ultimately determined that the Boxsells were liable for unpaid rent and compensation for losses incurred by Hookway as a result of their early termination of the lease.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. What amount of unpaid rent is owed by the Boxsells to Hookway?
2. What compensation, if any, is owed by the Boxsells to Hookway for future rent loss?
3. What compensation, if any, is owed by the Boxsells to Hookway for advertising and reletting fees incurred as a result of the early termination of the lease?
Held
1. The court held that the Boxsells owe Hookway $2948.57 in unpaid rent for the period until 4 September 2008.
2. The court held that the Boxsells owe Hookway $285.00 in compensation for future rent loss.
3. The court held that the Boxsells owe Hookway $375 in compensation for advertising and reletting fees incurred due to the early termination of the lease.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined the lease agreement and the circumstances of the Boxsells' early termination of the lease. For the unpaid rent, the court calculated the amount owed based on the lease terms and the period until the Boxsells vacated the property. The court determined that the Boxsells' early departure resulted in a loss of potential income for Hookway, and thus, ordered compensation for future rent loss. The court reviewed the evidence regarding the costs incurred by Hookway to advertise and relet the property, and found these costs to be reasonable and necessary. The court ordered the Boxsells to pay these expenses as well. The total amount of $3608.57, combining unpaid rent and compensation, was deemed to be owed by the Boxsells to Hookway, with a specified deadline for payment. This decision applied established principles of contract law and the specific terms of the lease agreement, without departing from any prior authority. The binding principle established is that a tenant who terminates a lease early without justification may be liable for unpaid rent and reasonable compensation for the lessor's losses.