Meissner v Commissioner for Liquor and Gaming

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Meissner v Commissioner for Liquor and Gaming & Anor  [2019] QCAT 338

PARTIES: DONALD MEISSNER

(applicant)

v

COMMISSIONER FOR LIQUOR AND GAMING
and
CROWE AND NEVILLE PTY LTD TRADING AS ROLLINGSTONE BEACH CARAVAN RESORT

(respondents)

APPLICATION NO/S:

GAR064-19

MATTER TYPE:

General administrative review matters

DELIVERED ON:

6 November 2019

HEARING DATE:

4 November 2019

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Member Kanowski

ORDERS:

The application for miscellaneous matters (application for a direction that the review proceeding not progress further until a Planning and Environment Court proceeding has been completed, and for directions relating to proposed new evidence) filed by Donald Meissner on 23 September 2019 is refused.

CATCHWORDS:

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALS – QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL – where related proceeding in Planning and Environment Court – whether review proceeding should await outcome of Court proceeding

GAMING AND LIQUOR – ADMINISTRATION – LIQUOR LICENSING – LICENSING TRIBUNALS GENERALLY – REVIEWS, APPEALS AND CASES STATED – GENERALLY – where objector seeks to lead new evidence – whether tribunal can receive evidence that came into existence after reviewable decision made

Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), s 3(b)

Liquor Act 1992 (Qld), s 33, s 34

Butler & Ors v Office of Liquor and Gaming Regulation GBBC Pty Ltd [2013] QCAT 226

Cameron v Noosa Shire Council [1996] QCA 486
Cooper & Ors v Commissioner for Liquor and Gaming & Anor [2014] QCAT 627

The AM Darling Unit Trust t/as AM Darling Pty Ltd v Commissioner for Liquor and Gaming Regulation [2017] QCAT 394

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

Wilson Ryan Grose Lawyers

Respondents:

D Robinson for Commissioner for Liquor and Gaming; Macrossan and Amiet Solicitors for Crowe and Neville Pty Ltd trading as Rollingstone Beach Caravan Resort

REASONS FOR DECISION

Introduction

  1. Mr Meissner lives near the Rollingstone Beach Caravan Resort. That resort is owned by Crowe and Neville Pty Ltd. The company has a liquor licence for a bar at the resort. It has musicians performing at the bar at times, and it hosts some music festivals.

  2. On 9 January 2019 the Commissioner for Liquor and Gaming varied the licence conditions. The effect of the variation was to remove two of the noise conditions. 

  3. Mr Meissner, who had objected to Crowe and Neville Pty Ltd’s application to vary the licence, has applied to the Tribunal for a review of the Commissioner’s decision. In his application to review a decision, he contends that certain conditions should be added to the licence in order to manage noise output. 

  4. The matter has had a compulsory conference but has not yet proceeded to hearing.

  5. The present decision is an interlocutory one, relating to an application for miscellaneous matters filed by Mr Meissner on 23 September 2019. That application seeks directions that:

    (a)preliminary questions of law should be determined before the matter proceeds to hearing;

    (b)Mr Meissner should be given leave to present new evidence; and

    (c)copies of Mr Meissner’s proposed new evidence must be delivered to the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Meissner v Commissioner for Liquor and Gaming and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QCAT 338
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Meissner v Commissioner for Liquor and Gaming, the matter before the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) involved a dispute over the admissibility of new evidence in a review of a decision by the Commissioner for Liquor and Gaming. Donald Meissner sought to introduce new evidence in his review application against a decision made by the Commissioner regarding a liquor licence. The Commissioner argued that new evidence could not be considered if it came into existence after the original decision.

The central legal issue was whether section 34 of the Liquor Act allows a tribunal to accept new evidence that was not before the Commissioner when the decision was made, and if such evidence could be introduced even if it came into existence after the decision. The court had to interpret the scope of section 34 and determine whether it permitted the tribunal to consider evidence introduced post-decision. The arguments hinged on the interpretation of "new evidence" and the circumstances under which the tribunal could allow such evidence.

The QCAT concluded that section 34 of the Liquor Act does not explicitly preclude the tribunal from considering evidence that came into existence after the Commissioner’s decision. However, the tribunal found that the evidence in question had either been known or should have been known to Meissner before the decision, or it came into existence only after the decision was made. The court referred to previous cases such as Butler and Ors v Office of Liquor and Gaming Regulation GBBC Pty Ltd and The AM Darling Unit Trust t/as AM Darling Pty Ltd v Commissioner for Liquor and Gaming Regulation, which held that new evidence must be available at the time of the original decision to be considered under section 34. Consequently, the application to introduce new evidence was refused.

The orders of the tribunal were that the application for miscellaneous matters filed by Donald Meissner was refused, which included the request to halt the review proceeding until a related proceeding in the Planning and Environment Court was completed and directions relating to proposed new evidence.

Orders

Orders of the court

The application for miscellaneous matters (application for a direction that the review proceeding not progress further until a Planning and Environment Court proceeding has been completed, and for directions relating to proposed new evidence) filed by Donald Meissner on 23 September 2019 is refused.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Sections 33 and 34 of the Liquor Act limit the introduction of new evidence:33 Tribunal to decide review on evidence before the commissioner(1) In a proceeding for a review of a decision of the commissioner by the tribunal, the tribunal must—(a) hear and decide the review of the decision by way of a reconsideration of the evidence before the commissioner when the decision was made; …34 Tribunal may give leave for review to be decided on new evidence in particular circumstances(1) Despite section 33, the tribunal may grant a party to a proceeding for a review of a decision of the commissioner (the decision) leave to present new evidence if the tribunal is satisfied—(a) the party did not know, and could not reasonably be expected to have known, of the existence of the new evidence before the decision; and(b) in the circumstances, it would be unfair not to allow the party to present the new evidence.…(3) In this section—new evidence means evidence that was not before the commissioner when the decision was made. Mr Morton submits that a narrow reading of section 34 should be avoided. The topic of excessive noise was clearly raised in the objection; Mr Meissner contended there had been past non-compliance; and reference was made in the objection to Mr King’s opinion. Failure by the Commissioner to look into these matters should not preclude Mr Meissner from placing appropriate evidence about them before the Tribunal, Mr Morton submits. The respondents oppose the application to introduce additional evidence: firstly, some of the evidence must have been known to Mr Meissner before the Commissioner’s decision was made, and, secondly, some of it came into existence only later. Mr Robinson, for the Commissioner, submits that section 34 does not permit the Tribunal to grant leave to introduce evidence that came into existence after the Commissioner’s decision was made. He drew my attention to Butler and Ors v Office of Liquor and Gaming Regulation GBBC Pty Ltd[4] (‘Butler’), in which the Tribunal took the view that leave can be given under section 34 only in respect of ‘evidence that may have been available at the time the decision was made but not considered by the Commissioner’.[5][4][2012] QCAT 226.[5]Ibid, [9]. A different view, however, was taken by the Tribunal in Cooper & Ors v Commissioner for Liquor and Gaming and Anor[6] (‘Cooper’):I am not satisfied that the terms of s 34 necessarily preclude the granting of leave to permit the consideration by the Tribunal of evidence, which came into existence after the decision was made. The definition of new evidence combined with the terms of s 34(1) do not clearly require such a limitation to be imposed.[6][2014] QCAT 627, [10]. Later, however, in The AM Darling Unit Trust t/as AM Darling Pty Ltd v Commissioner for Liquor and Gaming Regulation,[7] the Tribunal preferred the view taken in Butler. The Tribunal commented that section 34(1) does not refer to evidence that comes into existence after the decision was made, and ‘if that interpretation had been intended it would have been easy to make that intention clear’.[8] [7][2017] QCAT 394.[8]Ibid, [16].

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.