Cooper v Commissioner for Liquor and Gaming

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read
CITATION: Cooper & Ors v Commissioner for Liquor and Gaming & Anor [2014] QCAT 627
PARTIES: Peter Cooper
Sandra Cooper
Vladimir Lipsky
Raewyl Lipsky
Ian Clark
Carol Clark
Lindsay Crutch
Cathie Crutch
Thomas Quinn
Frances Quinn
(Applicants)
v
Commissioner for Liquor and Gaming
(First Respondent)
Blackbird Bar & Restaurant Pty Ltd
(Second Respondent)
APPLICATION NUMBER: GAR162-14
MATTER TYPE: General administrative review matters
HEARING DATE: On the papers
HEARD AT: Brisbane
DECISION OF: Member Deane
DELIVERED ON: 2 December 2014
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
ORDERS MADE:

1.    Leave is granted for the following documents to be considered by the Tribunal:

a.    David Moore & Associates Report dated 18 November 2010

b.    WHO Guidelines for Community Noise identified as documents 6 and 7 in the Quinns’ submissions

c.    Plan and Photographs identified as documents 1 in the Quinns’ submissions and the Clarks’ submissions, part 4

d.    Google earth image identified as documents 3 in the Quinns’ submissions

e.    Response to the Queensland Ombudsman Liquor Report identified in book of documents p680-681

f.     Investigation Running Sheet identified in book of documents p650 – 662.

2.    Leave is refused to lead the following evidence:

a.    correspondence with the QPS identified in the Clarks’ submissions, part 2

b.     advertisement of Notice of Application and photograph identified in the Clarks’ submissions, part 6

c.    letter to the Attorney- General and the Attorney- General’s reply identified in the Clarks’ submissions, part 5.

3.    The following documents were documents before the decision maker when the decision was made for which leave is not required:

a.    Liquor Report Queensland Ombudsman 2013

b.    Documents omitted from the Clarks’ Objection dated 18 November 2013 identified in the Clarks’ submissions, part 1

c.    Sequence of Liquor Licences for Queensland Rugby Union Club Inc and Blackbird documents identified in the Clarks’ submissions, part 3

d.    letters passing between the Clarks and the Office of Liquor and Gaming Regulation in 2011 and 2013, part of the documents identified in the Clarks’ submissions, part 5.

CATCHWORDS:

APPLICATION TO REVIEW A DECISION - New evidence – whether leave ought to be granted

Liquor Act 1992 (Qld) s 33, s 34
Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld) s 28

Butler & Ors v Office of Liquor and Gaming Regulation GBBC Pty Ltd [2013] QCAT 226

Drake v Chief Executive, Office of Liquor and Gaming Regulation [2013] QCAT 238

APPEARANCES:

APPLICANTS: Ian Clark
Carol Clark
Thomas Quinn
Frances Quinn
RESPONDENT: Commissioner for Liquor and Gaming
(First Respondent)
Blackbird Bar & Restaurant Pty Ltd
(Second Respondent)

REPRESENTATIVES:

APPLICANTS: Ian Clark and Carol Clark, self represented
Thomas Quinn and Frances Quinn, self represented
RESPONDENT: Commissioner for Liquor and Gaming, First Respondent, represented by Dominic Robinson, Principal Legal Officer, Office of General Counsel, Department of Justice and the Attorney General
Blackbird Bar & Restaurant Pty Ltd, Second Respondent, represented by Matthew Jones, Director, Liquor & Gaming Specialists Pty Ltd

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. The Applicants have sought review of the Commissioner’s decision to grant an extended trading hours permit. The review…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cooper v Commissioner for Liquor and Gaming and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] QCAT 627
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Cooper v Commissioner for Liquor and Gaming involved an application for review of a decision relating to a liquor licence application. The applicant, Cooper, sought to have certain evidence considered by the Tribunal that was not presented to the decision maker, the Commissioner for Liquor and Gaming. The legal issues before the court centred on whether the Tribunal should grant leave for the consideration of new evidence that came into existence after the decision was made, as per the Liquor Act 1992.

The court examined the definition of new evidence and the criteria for granting leave under section 34(1) of the Liquor Act. It considered whether the applicant did not know and could not reasonably be expected to have known of the new evidence prior to the decision. The court also assessed whether it would be unfair not to allow the applicant to present this new evidence. In reaching its decision, the court noted that while the definition of new evidence might exclude evidence that came into existence after the decision, the terms of section 34(1) did not necessarily preclude the consideration of such evidence if it met the criteria for leave.

The court concluded that leave should be granted for certain documents to be considered by the Tribunal, including specific reports and correspondence, as they met the criteria for new evidence and it would be unfair not to allow their consideration. However, leave was refused for other evidence, such as certain correspondence and advertisements, as they did not meet the criteria or were not new evidence. Certain documents, including the Liquor Report Queensland Ombudsman 2013, were identified as being before the decision maker when the decision was made, thus not requiring leave for their consideration.

The final orders of the court granted leave for certain documents to be considered, refused leave for others, and noted that some documents did not require leave as they were already before the decision maker.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Leave is granted for the following documents to be considered by the Tribunal:

a. David Moore & Associates Report dated 18 November 2010

b. WHO Guidelines for Community Noise identified as documents 6 and 7 in the Quinns’ submissions

c. Plan and Photographs identified as documents 1 in the Quinns’ submissions and the Clarks’ submissions, part 4

d. Google earth image identified as documents 3 in the Quinns’ submissions

e. Response to the Queensland Ombudsman Liquor Report identified in book of documents p680-681

f. Investigation Running Sheet identified in book of documents p650 – 662.

2. Leave is refused to lead the following evidence:

a. correspondence with the QPS identified in the Clarks’ submissions, part 2

b. advertisement of Notice of Application and photograph identified in the Clarks’ submissions, part 6

c. letter to the Attorney- General and the Attorney- General’s reply identified in the Clarks’ submissions, part 5.

3. The following documents were documents before the decision maker when the decision was made for which leave is not required:

a. Liquor Report Queensland Ombudsman 2013

b. Documents omitted from the Clarks’ Objection dated 18 November 2013 identified in the Clarks’ submissions, part 1

c. Sequence of Liquor Licences for Queensland Rugby Union Club Inc and Blackbird documents identified in the Clarks’ submissions, part 3

d. letters passing between the Clarks and the Office of Liquor and Gaming Regulation in 2011 and 2013, part of the documents identified in the Clarks’ submissions, part 5.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Leave may be granted if the Tribunal is satisfied that: (a)the party did not know and could not reasonably be expected to have known, of the existence of the new evidence before the decision; and(b)in the circumstances, it would be unfair not to allow the party to present the new evidence.[5] [5] Liquor Act 1992 (Qld) s 34(1). New evidence is evidence that was not before the Commissioner when the decision was made.[6] [6] Ibid s 34(3). Blackbird Bar & Restaurant submits that evidence, which came into existence after the decision was made is not capable of constituting ‘new evidence’. It relies upon Butler & Ors v Office of Liquor and Gaming Regulation GBBC Pty Ltd[7] in which the Tribunal refused leave to lead new evidence relating to the conduct of the business subsequent to the granting of the license. In that case the Tribunal considered that this evidence was not evidence which could have been before the decision maker in relation to the grant of the licence and ought not be allowed to be considered in the review of whether a licence ought to have been granted but provided grounds for the possible cancellation of the licence by the Commissioner. [7] [2013] QCAT 226. The Tribunal has previously granted leave to admit new evidence in circumstances where the applicant had no opportunity to place evidence before the decision maker because he did not receive a copy of the show cause notice.[8] [8] Drake v Chief Executive, Office of Liquor and Gaming Regulation [2013] QCAT 238. There was no similar procedural issue in the Butler case but a procedural issue is raised by the Applicants. I am not satisfied that the terms of s 34 necessarily preclude the granting of leave to permit the consideration by the Tribunal of evidence, which came into existence after the decision was made. The definition of new evidence combined with the terms of s 34(1) do not clearly require such a limitation to be imposed. The second reading speech says little more than to repeat the terms of the section and in my view does not provide additional guidance as contended for by Blackbird Bar & Restaurant’s representative in support of its contention that evidence which came into existence after the decision was made cannot be ‘new evidence’. I am satisfied that the Ombudsman’s report[9] was a document before the decision maker when the decision was made and therefore does not require leave for it to be considered by the Tribunal.[9] Quinns’ submissions folder document 5. The Quinns contend that this document is not ‘new evidence’ but rather has been omitted by the Commissioner from the book of relevant documents. They submit that the report was delivered to the Commissioner in support of the objections. The Quinns’ objection[10] referred to this report, expressly incorporated the report ‘by reference’ and indicated a copy was delivered. The Commissioner submits that whilst a copy was not within the file he was at all material times aware of the report.[10] Statement of Reasons and book of documents at 276 [57]-[61].

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.