Meissner v Commissioner for Liquor and Gaming

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Meissner v Commissioner for Liquor and Gaming & Anor [2020] QCAT 378

PARTIES:

DONALD MEISSNER
(applicant)

v

COMMISSIONER FOR LIQUOR AND GAMING

(first respondent)

and

CROWE AND NEVILLE PTY LTD TRADING AS ROLLINGSTONE BEACH CARAVAN RESORT

(second respondent)

APPLICATION NO:

GAR064-19

MATTER TYPE:

General administrative review matters

DELIVERED ON:

28 September 2020

HEARING DATE:

24 March 2020

HEARD AT:

Townsville

DECISION OF:

Member Pennell

ORDER:

The decision of the Commissioner for Liquor and Gaming made on 9 January 2019 to grant a variation to the liquor licence issued to Crowe and Neville Pty Ltd trading as Rollingstone Beach Caravan Resort is confirmed

CATCHWORDS:

GAMING AND LIQUOR – LIQUOR – GENERALLY – PREMISES TO WHICH LICENCE EXTENDS – variation to liquor licence – applicant opposed a variation to license’s licence – minimising harm or adverse effects on the amenity of the community – whether steps taken by licence mitigated any adverse effects 

 Liquor Act 1992 (Qld), s 3, s 3(a), s 30(1)(a)(i), s 33, s 105, s 107, s 121

Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), s 18, s 19, s 20(1), s 20(2), s 21, s 24(1), s 28(2), s 28, s 28(3)(a), s 28(3)(b), s 28(3)(c)

Kioa v West (1985) 159 CLR 550
Meissner v Commissioner for Liquor and Gaming and Anor [2019] QCAT 338

Staddon and Ors v Chief Executive, Department of Employment, Economic Development and Innovation and Anor [2011] QCAT 258
The King v The War Pensions Entitlement Appeal Tribunal and Another; ex parte Bott (1933) 50 CLR 228

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATIONS:

Applicant:

B Rix of Counsel instructed by D Morton, Wilson Ryan Grose Solicitors.

First Respondent:

Second Respondent:

D Robinson, Principal Legal Officer with M Chen

A W Collins of Counsel instructed by S Naylor, Macrossan & Amiet Solicitors

REASONS FOR DECISION

Introduction

  1. The applicant this matter is Donald Meissner (‘the applicant’).  He is the owner of a property located approximately 60 kilometres north of Townsville at Hencamp Creek Road, Rollingstone.  This area was developed in the early 1960s with the allocation of large allotments designed to take advantage of the natural values of the area and the coastal location.  Located within the same area is the Rollingstone Beach Caravan Resort, which is owned by Crowe and Neville Pty Ltd, trading as the Rollingstone Beach Caravan Resort (‘the licensee’).  Separating the properties belonging to those parties is a tract of land that is also owned by the licensee.

  2. The licensee applied to the Commissioner for Liquor and Gaming (‘the Commissioner’) to vary the conditions of its liquor licence (‘the licence’).[1]  That application was successful with the removal of two of the noise conditions from the licence.[2]  

    [1]The application was made on 20 August 2018. 

    [2]Commissioner’s decision made on 9 January 2019.

  3. The applicant objected to the Commissioner’s decision and applied to the Tribunal for a review of that decision.  He contends that the amplified output of noise from the licensee’s premises changed the tranquillity, ambience and value of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Meissner v Commissioner for Liquor and Gaming and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] QCAT 378
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Meissner v Commissioner for Liquor and Gaming, the applicant, Meissner, contested a variation to the liquor licence of Crowe and Neville Pty Ltd, trading as Rollingstone Beach Caravan Resort. The dispute centred around whether the variation would result in harm or adverse effects on the amenity of the community. Meissner opposed the variation on the grounds that the licensee's amplified entertainment posed a noise nuisance to nearby residents. The case was heard by the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT), which was tasked with deciding whether the Commissioner for Liquor and Gaming's decision to approve the variation was appropriate.

The legal issues that the Tribunal had to resolve included whether the Commissioner correctly considered the impact of the variation on the amenity of the community and whether the proposed conditions for the variation were necessary. The Tribunal had to weigh the applicant's concerns against the evidence of compliance and the licensee's history of managing noise issues. The Tribunal also had to consider whether the Commissioner's decision to grant the variation was justified, given that both the Townsville City Council and the police had no objections.

The Tribunal concluded that the Commissioner had appropriately assessed the application for the variation, taking into account the risk of harm and the licensee's efforts to mitigate any adverse effects. The Tribunal found that the licensee had a good compliance history and had implemented measures to control noise, including recommendations from an acoustic engineer. Additionally, the Tribunal noted that the licensee maintained a monitoring regime as required by the licence conditions. The Tribunal was satisfied that the Commissioner's decision to grant the variation was reasonable, given that no objections were raised by the Council or the police, and the licensee was deemed a fit and proper person.

The Tribunal confirmed the Commissioner's decision to grant the variation to the liquor licence of Crowe and Neville Pty Ltd trading as Rollingstone Beach Caravan Resort, thereby upholding the Commissioner's determination.

Orders

Orders of the court

The decision of the Commissioner for Liquor and Gaming made on 9 January 2019 to grant a variation to the liquor licence issued to Crowe and Neville Pty Ltd trading as Rollingstone Beach Caravan Resort is confirmed

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant has since filed an application in the Planning and Environment Court.[23] The respondents to that application are the Townsville City Council (‘the Council’) and the licensee. Those proceedings formed part of the applicant’s earlier interlocutory application before the Tribunal, with the Tribunal refusing to make the directions sought by the applicant.[24] It is unknown when the Planning and Environment Court proceedings will be finalised. [23] Filed on 18 September 2019.[24]Meissner v Commissioner for Liquor and Gaming and Anor [2019] QCAT 338.Background information Situated towards the north-east boundary of the licensee’s premises is an established entertainment area called the Cro-Bar. The Cro-Bar consists of a covered stage area facing south-west. The area able to accommodate 150 patrons, including seating and a dance floor. The closest residential dwellings are located 350 metres to the west-south-west and 275 metres to the north-west.[25] [25]Commissioner’s Statement of Reasons, paragraph 17. For a number of years, amplified entertainment has been conducted on the premises. The entertainment has consisted of live performers every Friday and Saturday night, and an annual Rock ‘n’ Roll Music Festival. The entertainment is provided by a small band or soloist/duo with pre-recorded backing on stage or background music played through the in-house entertainment system. Typically the entertainment is conducted between 4:00pm and 11:00pm on Saturday nights with live entertainment provided between 4:30pm and 7:00pm.[26] [26]Commissioner’s Statement of Reasons, paragraph 18. The licensee has been subjected to a number of targeted compliance inspections, along with other risk assessments by the Commissioner. The licensee has also responded to complaints made by members of the public, including the applicant, about noise emanating from the premises. On 6 December 2017, the Commissioner received a complaint from the applicant. The basis of the complaint was that although the licensee generally played music on Saturday nights until 7:30pm, it had never been an issue until the weekend of 24 November 2017. On that occasion, the music was ‘booming’ until midnight. The applicant approached the licensee to complain about the noise level, however the applicant felt that instead of the noise level being abated, the volume was increased.[27] [27]Commissioner’s bundle of documents, page 106. There appears to be some ‘history’ between the applicant and the licensee, as the applicant told the Commissioner that previously the licensee tried to open a reception centre, however the applicant objected to the proposal. The applicant considered that since then, the licensee has played the music louder on the Saturday nights. On 15 January 2018, the Commissioner’s investigators went to the licence premises where they spoke to the licensee about the applicant’s complaint. The licensee told investigators that the music was never played too loud or too late. This was because not all of the guests staying at caravan resort appreciated loud music, and as such he did not want to have those guests disturbed. In regard to the music being played until midnight, the licensee told the investigators that there were only two occasions when that occurred. That was during the annual music festival and on New Year’s Eve, which the premises had received a temporary variation to the licence for those occasions.[28][28]Commissioner’s bundle of documents, page 104.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Both the Council and the police have raised no objection, and the Council took a further step by offering support for the variation to the licence, and there was no history of the licensee being non-compliant with the conditions of the licence. A further mitigating feature was the conclusion drawn that the licensee was a fit and proper person.[49] All of those factors were persuasive and weighed in favour of the Commissioner making the ultimate decision.[50] [49]Liquor Act 1992 (Qld), s 107.[50]Email from Sergeant Sands, Townsville Police District Liquor Unit. Commissioner’s bundle of documents, page 63.Conclusion and decision The aim of the Liquor Act[51] is to regulate the liquor industry in a way to minimise harm in the vicinity of licensed premises and minimise adverse effects on the amenity of the community. The starting point is the proposition that a community is entitled to access premises having a general liquor licence within that locality. The legislation does not contemplate that the grant of a licence will have no adverse impact on the amenities of the locality, and the presumption remains in favour of, rather than against, the granting of a variation to the licensee’s licence on the proviso that the community impacts are minimised.[52] [51]Liquor Act 1992 (Qld), s 3.[52]Staddon and Ors v Chief Executive, Department of Employment, Economic Development and Innovation and Anor [2011] QCAT 258, [31]. This is a matter where great attention has been paid to, and serious consideration given to all the features of the applicant’s complaint, along with the issues relating to the amenity of the community. I concur with the position arrived at in the Community Impact Assessment Report that there will always be an element of risk when premises propose to conduct amplified entertainment in reasonable proximity to residential areas. In considering that, I acknowledge the concerns raised by the applicant, particularly given that the licensee’s premises consists of an outdoor entertainment area that has limited abilities to contain sound. However, notwithstanding my acknowledgment of the applicant’s concerns, I am of the view that it was reasonable to assume that amplified entertainment could be adequately controlled at the licensee’s premises provided the acoustic engineer’s recommendations are complied with, and the licensee maintain the monitoring regime as provided for in the provisions of licence condition LL266. Having given due consideration to the facts and circumstances of this matter, I am not persuaded that the Commissioner’s decision should be set aside, or that the conditions proposed by the applicant should be applied to the licensee’s licence. In arriving at that position, I am satisfied that the evidence shows the licensee has met all the requirements on making the application and there are no concerns over the licensee’s suitability and compliance history, and nor is any objection raised by the Council or the police.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.