QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION
CITATION: | McHardy v Queensland Rail Transit Authority t/a Queensland Rail [2020] QIRC 202 |
PARTIES: | McHardy, Kyle v Queensland Rail Transit Authority t/a Queensland Rail |
CASE NO: | B/2020/14 |
PROCEEDING: | Application to recover unpaid wages |
DELIVERED ON: | 25 November 2020 |
CONFERENCE: HEARING DATE: | 15 May 2020 On the papers |
MEMBER: | Power IC |
ORDER: | The Application is dismissed. |
| CATCHWORDS: | INDUSTRIAL LAW - APPLICATION FOR RECOVERY OF UNPAID WAGES - where applicant seeking recognition for continuity of service - where applicant re‑employed after three months - whether applicant entitled to recognition for continuity of service - whether employer is estopped from relying upon alleged representations. |
LEGISLATION: CASES: | Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld), s 133, s 475 Gregg Alan Miles AND Q-COMP (B/2013/31) - Decision < Hawkins Road Transport Pty Ltd v Transport Workers’ Union of Australia [1999] QIC 20 Owners Corporation SP82070 v Taricon Pty Ltd [2017] NSWCATCD 37 Jack Gordon Kidd v Savage River Mines (1984) 6 FCR 398 Walton Stores (Interstate) Ltd v Maher (1988) 164 CLR 387 |
| APPEARANCES: | Mr L. Kennedy, Australian Rail Tram & Bus Industry Union of Employees, Queensland Branch for the Applicant. |
Reasons for Decision
Background
Mr Kyle McHardy ('the Applicant') filed an Application on 14 February 2020 to recover unpaid wages pursuant to s 475 of the Industrial Relations Act 2016 ('the Act') seeking recognition for his continuity of service with the Queensland Rail Transit Authority t/a Queensland Rail (QR) ('the Respondent').
The Applicant seeks an order that the Respondent recognise his service from 12 October 2009 to 24 March 2014 for the purposes of long service leave entitlement.
The Applicant states that he is not seeking payment of long service leave monies, rather recognition of continuity of service on which his entitlement is based.
The following facts are not in dispute between the parties:
(a) the Applicant was employed by the Respondent on 12 October 2009 as an electrical apprentice;
(b) on 13 October 2013, the Applicant ceased employment upon completion of his apprenticeship; and
(c) on 24 March 2014, the Applicant commenced work with the Respondent in the position of Signal Electrician
The issue for determination is whether the period between the end of the Applicant's apprenticeship (13 October 2013) and the commencement of his employment as a Signal Electrician (24 March 2014) should be recognised under the continuity provisions of the Industrial Relations Act 2016. If this continuity is recognised, it follows…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read McHardy v Queensland Rail Transit Authority t/a Queensland R... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] QIRC 202
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue was whether McHardy was entitled to recognition for continuity of service under section 133(1)(b)(ii) of the Act, given that he was re-employed outside the three-month period stipulated by the statute. Another significant issue was whether the employer could be estopped from relying on representations made during the apprenticeship regarding the continuation of employment and recognition of service. Additionally, the Court had to determine whether the application was filed within the six-year limitation period as stipulated by the relevant legislation.
The Court found that the entitlement for long service leave only arose when McHardy reached seven years of service, which was in November 2016. Consequently, the six-year limitation period for filing the claim began in November 2016, and the application filed three years later was deemed timely. The Court also held that the statutory requirement for re-employment within three months was not strictly applicable, and a fair and equitable interpretation of the provision could allow for a more beneficial entitlement for the employee. However, the Court dismissed the application, finding that McHardy's re-employment outside the three-month period precluded him from claiming continuity of service under the specific statutory provision.
ORDERS:
The Application is dismissed.
Orders
Orders of the court
The Application is dismissed.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Applicant states that based on a calculation commencing in November 2009, the completion of his seven years of service occurs at a point in November 2016. The entitlement for which the Applicant is seeking to recover could only come into existence at the earliest in November 2016. Consequently, the Applicant argues that he could not make an application under s 475 of the Act prior to November 2016 as he had not yet met the seven year requirement imposed by clause 39.1 of the Agreement. The period between November 2016 and the date of filing this Application approximates three years and three months making it within the six year limitation period. Consideration of time limit It is my view that the six year limit for a claim of this type operates from the date at which the entitlement vests. As submitted by the Applicant, there is no entitlement for long service leave under the Agreement or the Act until the Applicant reached seven years of service. The entitlement for long service leave in this matter only arises on the date upon which the Applicant has reached seven years of service. The six year time limit commences on this date, which at the earliest point based upon commencement in November 2009, would be November 2016. This application was filed approximately three years following the earliest point in which the entitlement arose and as such is within the statutory time limitation period. The Respondent correctly submits that the six year limitation period is to provide certainty to employers with respect to claims. This interpretation does not upset that policy objective, rather it simply confirms that the six year limit arises from a time in which the entitlement arises and not an earlier point in the employment history. I accept that the application was filed within the required timeframe. As noted above, the Applicant seeks recognition of his entitlement to long service leave based on his service commencing on 12 October 2009 as an apprentice with the same employer. Section 133(1(b)(ii) of the Act creates the following entitlement to the recognition of continuity of service:133 Continuity of service - apprentices or trainees(1) This section applies if - (a)an employee, while employed with the employer, starts an apprenticeship or traineeship; or(b)the employer - (i)continues to employ an apprentice or trainee (the "employee") on the completion of the apprenticeship or traineeship; or(ii)re-employs the employee within 3 months after completion of the employee's apprenticeship or traineeship.(2)The period of the apprenticeship or traineeship does not break the employee's continuity of service. It is not disputed that the Applicant was re-employed with the Respondent outside of the three month period provided in s 133(1)(b)(ii) of the Act.Applicant's submissions The following submissions, in summary, were made by the Applicant's representative, Mr L. Kennedy of the Australian Rail Tram & Bus Industry Union of Employees, Queensland Branch:● in October 2013, Mr McHardy and his apprenticeship cohort were told at several meetings that upon completion of their apprenticeships they would be able to secure ongoing employment with QR as Facility electricians;● in the weeks leading up to the completion of Mr McHardy's apprenticeship, QR Management notified the apprenticeship cohort that the Facility electrician positions would be eliminated from QR Network Division;● prior to the completion of his apprenticeship, Mr McHardy was informed by his Manager, Mr Phil Clarke, that the apprenticeship cohort would be able to apply for the newly created position of Signal electrician;● Mr McHardy was informed that successful applicants would have their service numbers carried over and their continuity of service recognised;● in November 2013, Mr McHardy was provided two documents titled, "Change Notification and Redeployment Opportunities SEQ Facilities Electricians and Electrical Apprentices Network" and "Expression of Interest";● these documents set out the recruitment process for the new Signal electrician role, with applicants to complete EOI forms by 27 November 2013 and successful applicants recommencing their employment in the role by 16 December 2013;● if QR had complied with this timeline Mr McHardy would have recommenced his employment within two months and six days from the date he completed his apprenticeship;● Mr McHardy was successfully re-employed by QR recommencing his employment five months and seven days after the completion of his apprenticeship and three months and one day after the expected recommencement date;● the Acts Interpretation Act 1954 (Qld)(AIA) requires the Commission, when interpreting a provision to comply with s 14A of the AIA which provides:"In the interpretation of a provision of an Act, the interpretation that will best achieve the purpose of the Act is to be preferred to any other interpretation."● section 3(a) of the IR Act sets out the purpose of the Act, providing for a "framework for cooperative industrial relations that is fair and balanced";● it is imposed upon the Commission to seek a reading of s 133(1)(b)(ii) that emphasises a fair, right, equitable, and reasonable interpretation of the provision; and● for the Applicant, a fair and equitable reading of the provision would be that an employer may provide an employee a more beneficial entitlement than that created under s 133(1)(b)(ii).