Duncan v Ellis

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read
21 CLR 379

Employer and Employee-Offence-Employer paying less than minimum wages-

Mens rea-Factories and Shops Act 1915 (Vict.) (No. 2650), sec. 226.

Sec. 226 of the Factories and Shops Act 1915 (Vict.) provides: (1) Where a price or rate of payment for any person or persons or classes of persons has been determined by a Special Board and is in force, then any person-(a) who either directly or indirectly, or under any pretence or device, attempts to Barton, Isaacs, employ or employs or authorizes or permits to be employed any person apprentice or improver at a lower price or rate of wages or piece-work (as the case be) than the price or rate so determined

shall be guilty of an offence against this Act

(2) The registration of the factory of any person who is convicted under this Act of a third offence shall without further or other authority than this Act be forthwith cancelled by the chief inspector, provided that such person knowingly and wilfully committed each of such

Held, that knowledge or wilfulness is not necessary to constitute an offence under sec. 226 (1) (a), and, therefore, that it is not a defence to a prosecution for such an offence that the defendant reasonably believed in a state of facts which if true would have disproved the charge.

Hall v. Bartlett, 24 V.L.R., 1; 20 A.L.T., 37; and dictum in Billingham V. Oaten, (1911) V.L.R., 44, at p. 48; 32 A.L.T., 170, at p. 171, overruled.

Decision of the Supreme Court of Victoria: Duncan v. Ellis, (1916) V.L.R., 131; 37 A.L.T., 162, reversed.

21 CLR 380

APPEAL from the Supreme Court of Victoria.

At the Court of Petty Sessions at South Melbourne an infor- mation was heard whereby James Thomas Duncan, an Inspector of Factories and Shops, charged that, after the coming into opera- tion of a Special Board appointed under the provisions of the Factories and Shops Act 1915, William Ellis, trading as W. Ellis &Son, in respect of the week ending 4th September 1915 unlawfully employed one Arthur Ernest Tozer at a lower rate of wages than that determined by the Special Board. It appeared that at the time in question Tozer, who was a painter by trade, was of such an age that he was entitled to be paid wages at the rate fixed by the Special Board for a journeyman painter, but that the defendant, on Tozer's false statement as to his age, paid him wages at a lower rate, to which he would have been entitled if he had been young enough to be an improver.

The Magistrates dismissed the information stating that they accepted the defendant's statement that he believed Tozer to be an improver and paid him as such.

The informant obtained an order nisi to review that decision, which was discharged by the Full Court: Duncan v. Ellis 1.

From the decision of the Full Court the informant now, by special leave, appealed to the High Court.

Pigott…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Duncan v Ellis and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1916] HCA 32
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia heard an appeal from the Supreme Court of Victoria concerning a prosecution under section 226(1)(a) of the *Factories and Shops Act 1915* (Vic.). The appellant, an Inspector of Factories and Shops, charged the respondent, a trading employer, with employing a worker at a wage lower than that determined by a Special Board. The respondent had paid the worker, who was of an age entitling him to a journeyman's wage, an improver's wage based on the worker's false statement regarding his age. The Magistrates dismissed the charge, accepting the respondent's defence that he believed the worker was an improver and acted without knowledge or wilfulness. The Supreme Court upheld this decision.

The central legal issue before the High Court was whether knowledge or wilfulness was a necessary element to constitute an offence under section 226(1)(a) of the *Factories and Shops Act 1915*. Specifically, the court had to determine if a defence of reasonable belief in a mistaken set of facts, which if true would have disproved the charge, was available to an employer prosecuted under this section. This required an interpretation of the statutory language and the overall purpose of the Act.

The High Court, in allowing the appeal, reasoned that section 226(1)(a) creates an absolute prohibition, meaning that knowledge or wilfulness is not a required element for an offence under this provision. The court applied the principle that while there is a presumption of *mens rea* for offences, this presumption can be displaced by the wording of the statute or its subject matter. The court found that the Act, being a measure of social reform aimed at protecting wage earners, and the specific wording of section 226, particularly the contrast with the proviso in section 226(2) which expressly requires knowledge and wilfulness for the cancellation of a factory registration, indicated a legislative intention to impose strict liability for underpayment of wages. The court considered that allowing a defence based on reasonable belief would render the protective provisions of the Act illusory and that the Legislature had deliberately omitted such a requirement from section 226(1)(a).

Consequently, the High Court reversed the decision of the Supreme Court, convicted the respondent, and imposed a nominal fine of one shilling. The appellant was awarded the costs of the appeal to the High Court.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established