McGuinness v Workplace Eye Protection Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

McGuinness v Workplace Eye Protection Pty Ltd (No 2) [2020] FCA 872

File number: NSD 47 of 2020
Judge: GLEESON J
Date of judgment: 25 June 2020
Catchwords: COSTS – whether refusal by plaintiff to accept settlement offer unreasonable – plaintiff to pay portion of defendant’s costs on indemnity basis
Legislation:

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 25.14, 25.14(2)

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 1317K

Cases cited:

Baulderstone Hornibrook Engineering Pty Ltd v Gordian Runoff Ltd (No 2) [2009] NSWCA 12

Facton Ltd (formerly known as G-Star Raw Denim KFT) v Seo [2011] FCA 344; (2011) 91 IPR 135

Factory 5 Pty Ltd v Victoria (No 2) [2011] FCA 323

NMFM Property Pty Ltd and Ors v Citibank Ltd (No 2) [2001] FCA 480; (2001) 109 FCR 77

Visscher v Teekay Shipping (Australia) Pty Ltd (No 2) [2014] FCAFC 19

Date of hearing: Determined on the papers
Date of last submissions: 10 June 2020 (Plaintiff)
3 June 2020 (Defendant)
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Corporations and Corporate Insolvency
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 26
Counsel for the Plaintiff: JM Harris
Solicitor for the Plaintiff: Jemmeson Fisher Lawyers
Counsel for the Defendant: A Harding
Solicitor for the Defendant: Glenn R Walters & Co

ORDERS

NSD 47 of 2020
BETWEEN:

PHILLIP EDWARD MCGUINNESS

Plaintiff

AND:

WORKPLACE EYE PROTECTION PTY LTD (ACN 128 607 607)

Defendant

JUDGE:

GLEESON J

DATE OF ORDER:

25 JUNE 2020

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The plaintiff pay 50% of the defendant’s costs of the proceeding from 24 March 2020 on an indemnity basis.

2.Otherwise, the plaintiff pay the defendant’s costs of the proceeding on a party/party basis.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

GLEESON J:

  1. The defendant (Workplace) now seeks a special costs order, following the dismissal of the proceeding (McGuinness v Workplace Eye Protection Pty Ltd [2020] FCA 626), in the following terms:

    (1)The plaintiff to pay the defendant’s costs of the proceeding (except to the extent those costs are already covered by order 2 made on 19 May 2020), including the reserved costs of 5 March 2020.

    (2)The costs the subject of order 2 made on 19 May 2020, and the costs in order (1) above, are to be assessed:

    a.        before 11:00 am on 4 March 2020 – on a party party basis;

    b.        after 11:00 am on 4 March 2020 – on an indemnity basis.

  2. Proposed order (1) above is sought on the basis that the costs order made on 19 May 2020 was limited to the claim for relief in prayer 1 of the originating process. Now that the whole of the proceeding has been dismissed, Workplace seeks its costs of the whole proceeding.

  3. Proposed order (2) above is based on an offer to compromise made by Workplace, said to have been unreasonably rejected by the plaintiff, Mr McGuinness, and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McGuinness v Workplace Eye Protection Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCA 872
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of McGuinness v Workplace Eye Protection Pty Ltd, the plaintiff, Mr McGuinness, brought a claim against the defendant, Workplace, seeking compensation for dividends declared in 2012, January 2014, and May 2014. The Federal Court was tasked with determining the reasonableness of Mr McGuinness's refusal to accept a settlement offer made by Workplace and whether he should bear some of Workplace's legal costs. The court found that while Mr McGuinness's refusal to accept the settlement offer was not unreasonable, his claim on certain dividends lacked merit.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether Mr McGuinness's decision to reject Workplace's settlement offer was unreasonable under the relevant procedural rules. The court examined whether Mr McGuinness was justified in waiting until Workplace filed its evidence before deciding on the offer. It concluded that Mr McGuinness should have considered the offer upon receipt, in line with the procedural rules, to avoid potential consequences for the estate if his refusal was deemed unreasonable. However, the court held that Mr McGuinness's refusal was not unreasonable because the offer was to settle the entire proceeding.

The court's reasoning focused on the procedural rules governing offers of compromise, which mandate that such offers be considered regardless of the stage of the evidence in the proceedings. It highlighted that Mr McGuinness's claim had significant weaknesses, particularly concerning the burden of proof on him to establish that the proposed derivative claim was in the company's best interests. The settlement offer letter provided detailed reasons for Workplace's position, including documentary evidence, which made the key issues apparent to Mr McGuinness even before Workplace filed its evidence. While the court found that Mr McGuinness's refusal was not unreasonable, it noted that his claims regarding the January 2014 and May 2014 dividends lacked merit, which was brought to his attention in the settlement offer.

The final orders of the court were that Mr McGuinness pay 50% of Workplace's costs from 24 March 2020 on an indemnity basis, and otherwise pay Workplace's costs on a party/party basis. The court reasoned that this outcome was in the interests of justice, given the lack of merit in certain aspects of Mr McGuinness's claims.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The plaintiff pay 50% of the defendant’s costs of the proceeding from 24 March 2020 on an indemnity basis.

2. Otherwise, the plaintiff pay the defendant’s costs of the proceeding on a party/party basis.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Workplace filed its evidence on 25 March 2020. Mr McGuinness submitted that it was not unreasonable for him to wait for that evidence in order to consider his position in relation to the offer. I do not accept this submission. Having regard to the terms of r 25.14, Mr McGuinness ought to have considered the position on receipt of the settlement offer letter in order to avoid the possible consequences for the estate in the event of a finding that his refusal to accept the offer was unreasonable.CONCLUSION I am not persuaded that Mr McGuinness acted unreasonably by failing to accept the offer made pursuant to r 25.14(2) because it was an offer to settle the whole proceeding. Accordingly, I will not make proposed order (2). However, I accept that Mr McGuinness’s case on the January 2014 dividend and the May 2014 dividend lacked merit and this was drawn to his attention by the settlement offer letter. On that basis, in my view, it is in the interests of justice that Mr McGuinness pay a portion of Workplace’s costs on any indemnity basis, following a reasonable period after the offer was made. Accordingly, I will make the following orders:(1)The plaintiff pay 50% of the defendant’s costs of the proceeding from 24 March 2020 on an indemnity basis.(2)Otherwise, the plaintiff pay the defendant’s costs of the proceeding on a party/party basis.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Workplace argued that Mr McGuinness’ submission that it was not unreasonable for him to reject the offer of compromise because Workplace had not yet filed and served its evidence is without merit for the following reasons:(1)Rule 25.14 operates on an offer of compromise at all stages of a proceeding, “whatever the state of the evidence when it is served”: Visscher v Teekay Shipping (Australia) Pty Ltd (No 2) [2014] FCAFC 19 at [7].(2)Mr McGuinness’ claim failed in large part because of his failure to discharge the onus on him of establishing that the proposed derivative claim raised a serious question to be tried and was in the best interests of the company. The Court held that Mr McGuinness had failed to adduce evidence of various matters important to his claim, including that Mr McGuinness did not verify that he believed the proposed claim for relief in relation to the 2012 dividend to be in the best interests of the company and it was not obvious he had considered that question; and there was no evidence of inquiries about the proposed defendants’ capacity to pay any compensation that might be ordered. (3)In the offer, Workplace advised Mr McGuinness of the key weaknesses of his claims and provided supporting documentary evidence. Hence, Mr McGuinness was aware of Workplace’s position on these issues, and of the key evidence supporting Workplace’s contentions, notwithstanding that Workplace had not yet served its affidavits.CONSIDERATION Mr McGuinness’s claim concerned three dividends declared, respectively, in 2012, January 2014 and May 2014. The claims regarding the May 2014 dividend added nothing of substance to Mr McGuinness’ case and, accordingly, the case was principally concerned with the first two dividends. The settlement offer letter raised some of the matters which were the reasons for the dismissal of the proceeding (for example, s 1317K), but not all of them (for example, the proposed statement of claim did not articulate a serious question to be tried). The settlement offer letter alleged, in relation to both the 7 June 2012 and 8 January 2014 dividends, that no loss or damage was suffered and therefore there was no basis for compensation. The settlement offer letter also raised matters that were ultimately not reasons for the dismissal of the proceeding (for example, that Ms Dunstan and Ms Hantzi were not directors of the company when the 2012 dividend was declared). In NMFM Property Pty Ltd and Ors v Citibank Ltd (No 2) [2001] FCA 480; (2001) 109 FCR 77, Lindgren J explained the significance of conveying to the offeree the unreasonableness of not accepting the offer, at [87] and [88]:[87]No doubt where a party puts with sufficient particularity to the opposing party the reasons why the latter must fail, yet the latter does not recognise the inevitable, this will be a factor pointing to an award of indemnity costs ...[88]The requirements of “sufficient particularity” and “inevitability of failure” are important. In their absence, it would be open to parties to put their respective cases to the opposing party urging it to recognise the merit of what is put in the hope that if it ultimately finds favour with the Court, an award of indemnity costs will follow. If this were correct, one might ask rhetorically, “Why write a letter as distinct from simply relying on the pleadings?” ...