JURISDICTION : DISTRICT COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
IN CHAMBERS
LOCATION: PERTH
CITATION: MAZZONI -v- SORRENTO FAMILY PRACTICE PTY LTD [2021] WADC 12
CORAM: REGISTRAR KINGSLEY
HEARD: 4 NOVEMBER 2020
DELIVERED : 12 FEBRUARY 2021
FILE NO/S: CIV 1079 of 2015
BETWEEN: PHILIPPA MARY MAZZONI
Plaintiff
AND
SORRENTO FAMILY PRACTICE PTY LTD
First Defendant
EDWARD SAMIR BEBAWAY SOLOMAN
Second Defendant
EIHAB KAMIL BOULOS
Third Defendant
OSAMA MORIS TAKLA ESTEFANOUS
Fourth Defendant
Catchwords:
Practice - Application to adduce expert evidence after entry for trial - Application for discovery by both plaintiff and defendants - Application for further and better particulars - Application for particulars of damage
Legislation:
District Court Rules 2005 (WA)
Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA)
Result:
Applications in part successful
Representation:
Counsel:
| Plaintiff | : | Mr P M Poliwka |
| First Defendant | : | Mr H M Reynoldson |
| Second Defendant | : | Mr H M Reynoldson |
| Third Defendant | : | Mr H M Reynoldson |
| Fourth Defendant | : | Mr H M Reynoldson |
Solicitors:
| Plaintiff | : | Poliwka Legal |
| First Defendant | : | Hotchkin Hanly Lawyers |
| Second Defendant | : | Hotchkin Hanly Lawyers |
| Third Defendant | : | Hotchkin Hanly Lawyers |
| Fourth Defendant | : | Hotchkin Hanly Lawyers |
Case(s) referred to in decision(s):
FAI General Insurance Company Limited v Southern Cross Exploration NL (1988) 165 CLR 268
REGISTRAR KINGSLEY:
The plaintiff is a podiatrist and had purchased a podiatry practice from a third party. The practice at that time was leased from Sorrento Medical Practice. In 2011 the premises were sold and in January 2012 the plaintiff entered into a lease whereby the first defendant was lessee and the plaintiff sub‑lessee.
Since 2011 the second, third and fourth defendants have conducted a medical practice through the first defendant.
The plaintiff pleads that she had podiatry patients that were exclusively her patients (Exclusive Patients) and that it was an implied term of the lease that the information provided about the Exclusive Patients to the first defendant was confidential information and not to be exploited, appropriated, or otherwise used by the first defendant.
The plaintiff goes on to plead that information concerning her patients and medical notes concerning patients were on her own computer, or on handwritten medical notes. The second defendant demanded that all information be migrated to the defendants' computer system. The plaintiff pleads that from March 2012 the plaintiff was entering her patients' medical notes onto the defendants' computer and this information remained confidential to the plaintiff and had not been assigned to the defendants.
The plaintiff pleads she was not granted access to the billing section of the defendants' software on its computer (known as Best Practice) and so was unable to generate her own patient bills.
The plaintiff pleads that the defendants used the plaintiff's information to solicit her patients to attend clinics conducted by the defendants.
The plaintiff goes on to plead that two podiatrists employed by her left the plaintiff's employment on 12 January 2013 and 13 January 2013.…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Mazzoni v Sorrento Family Practice Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] WADC 12
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was whether the plaintiff should be granted leave to adduce expert evidence at the trial of the action. The plaintiff had filed an entry for trial on 17 July 2018, as mandated by a notice of default. However, the plaintiff sought to adduce expert evidence, which was not permitted under the Rules as they then stood. The court had to determine whether it had the power to extend the time and make the interlocutory order under the relevant Rules of the Supreme Court and the District Court Rules.
The court found that it had the power to extend the time and make the interlocutory order. The court relied on Order 3 rule 5 of the Rules of the Supreme Court, which provides that a court may, on such terms as is just, extend or abridge the period within which a person is required or authorised to do any act in any proceedings. The court also referred to rule 32(2)(c) of the District Court Rules, which provides that at the hearing of a summons for directions, or any other application, an order under rule 32(2) may be made. The court considered that while case management considerations are important, they should not be given precedence over the proper opportunity for the parties to ensure that a court determines the facts on the evidence that is reasonably put to the court by the parties.
The court granted leave to the plaintiff to adduce expert evidence at the trial of the action. The court found that the expert evidence would be needed to enable the plaintiff to prove her loss, which was necessary to establish her case. The court considered that the purpose of civil proceedings is to determine the respective rights of litigants, and that considerations of efficiency should not detract from this. The court also noted that the parties were still some way off listing the matter for trial, and that there was still disputation in relation to discovery and particulars of damage. The expert evidence, as submitted by the plaintiff's counsel, would inform the content of the particulars of damage.
The court did not make any other orders in relation to the case. The parties were directed to continue with the case management process, including resolving the outstanding issues in relation to discovery and particulars of damage. The matter was listed for further directions.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Order 3 r 5 Rules of the Supreme Court1971 (WA) (RSC) provides that on such terms as is just, a court may extend or abridge the period within which a person is required or authorised to do any act in any proceedings. FAI General Insurance Company Limited v Southern Cross Exploration NL (1988) 165 CLR 268 is authority for the proposition that O 3 r 5 RSC confers on the court a broad power to overcome injustice. However, the rule does not provide the parties with an unqualified right to an extension of time. One of the purposes of civil proceedings is to determine respective rights of litigants. An important consideration is giving the parties a proper opportunity to ensure that a court determines the facts on the evidence that is reasonably put to the court by the parties. This is not to say that case management considerations ought be ignored but those considerations be placed in the context of the stage the proceedings are at. An objective of case flow management is to ensure the just determination of litigation. In this matter the parties are still some way off listing this matter for trial. As seen from the two remaining applications there is disputation in relation to discovery and particulars of damage. The expert evidence, as submitted by plaintiff's counsel, will inform the content of the particulars of damage. Rule 24(1) DCR confers a wide power on the court to make any procedural direction that is just to facilitate the case being conducted and concluded efficiently, economically, and expeditiously. Rule 24(2) DCR does not limit the ambit of r 24(1) DCR. Rule 26 DCR provides that at the hearing of a summons for directions, or any other application, an order under r 32(2) may be made. Rule 32(2)(c) provides that any interlocutory order may be made. Whilst a party will not be given unlimited opportunity to present their case, they must be given sufficient opportunity, and considerations of efficiency do not detract from this. The notice of default dated 2 July 2018 stated the action would become inactive if an entry for trial was not filed on or before 17 July 2018. Whilst there were other options, the plaintiff filed the entry for trial on 17 July 2018. That entry is in the context of the Rules as they then were. It is apparent that expert evidence will be needed to enable the plaintiff to prove her loss. In my opinion, pursuant to O 3 r 5 RSC and r 32(2)(c) DCR, I have the power to extend the time and make the interlocutory order. Accordingly, leave is given pursuant to r 47F(3)(c) DCR for the plaintiff to adduce expert evidence at the trial of this action. The plaintiff seeks mutually exclusive remedies of account of profits and damages. In an action of this nature, the remedy of an account of profits is to have, in this case, the defendants give up their ill‑gotten gains to the plaintiff whose purported rights have been infringed. In relation to the remedy of damages, the defendants are to compensate the plaintiff for the loss she has suffered.