Apacia Pty Ltd (ACN 112 571 758) v Versaci

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

JURISDICTION     :   DISTRICT COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CHAMBERS

LOCATION:   PERTH

CITATION:   APACIA PTY LTD  (ACN 112 571 758) -v- VERSACI [2021] WADC 23

CORAM:   REGISTRAR KUBACZ

HEARD:   12 MARCH 2021

DELIVERED          :   23 MARCH 2021

FILE NO/S:   CIV 4812 of 2018

BETWEEN:   APACIA PTY LTD  (ACN 112 571 758)

Plaintiff

AND

RENEE MARIE VERSACI

Defendant

RENEE MARIE VERSACI

Plaintiff by counterclaim

APACIA PTY LTD (ACN 112 571 758)

Defendant by counterclaim


Catchwords:

Practice and procedure - Plaintiff's application to extend time in which to serve expert evidence after entry for trial - Plaintiff's application for Scott Schedule

Legislation:

District Court Rules 2005 (WA)
Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA)

Result:

Application in part successful

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff : Mr G J Pynt
Defendant : Mr D K Wee
Plaintiff by counterclaim : Mr D K Wee
Defendant by counterclaim : Mr G J Pynt

Solicitors:

Plaintiff : James Chong
Defendant : Chan Galic
Plaintiff by counterclaim : Chan Galic
Defendant by counterclaim : James Chong

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

FAI General Insurance Company Ltd v Southern Cross Exploration NL (1988) 165 CLR 268

Mazzoni v Sorrento Family Practice Pty Ltd [2021] WADC 12

Outboard Marine Australia Pty Ltd v Byrnes [1974] 1 NSWLR 27

Ratnam v Cumarasamy [1964] 3 All ER 933

REGISTRAR KUBACZ:

  1. The plaintiff is a company which employed the defendant to provide accounting services to it between 8 January 2013 and 28 June 2018.  These services included to prepare and lodge Business Activity Statements (BAS), PAYG returns and superannuation returns.

  2. In its claim, the plaintiff alleges that the defendant performed her job incompetently and alleges 342 instances of such incompetence.  The defendant denies the allegations as put against her.

  3. The plaintiff has brought two applications:

    1.seeking an extension of time in which to serve expert evidence; and

    2.leave to be able to produce and rely on a Scott Schedule.

  4. This matter has had a long and protracted case management history since its commencement in December 2018, which for clarity, needs to be outlined to understand this application.  In brief:

    1.17 May 2019 - directions hearing which was adjourned;

    2.24 May 2019 - directions hearing where orders were given by the principal registrar for filing and service of amended writ, particulars of claim, counter claim, discovery and mediation;

    3.8 October 2019 - mediation where no orders were given;

    4.1 November 2019 - notice of default issued by court for failure to enter the matter for trial;

    5.13 November 2019 - entry for trial papers lodged by the defendant;

    6.13 January 2020 - pre-trial conference which was adjourned;

    7.12 February 2020 - pre-trial conference where orders were made by Deputy Registrar Hewitt giving the parties leave to adduce expert evidence at the trial of the matter and programing the provision of such expert evidence with the plaintiff's expert evidence to be provided by 31 March 2020 and the defendant's by 30 April 2020;

    8.2 June 2020 - directions hearing where an extension of time was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Apacia Pty Ltd (ACN 112 571 758) v Versaci and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] WADC 23
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Apacia Pty Ltd (ACN 112 571 758) versus Versaci, the Federal Circuit and Family Court was called upon to decide the admissibility of expert evidence and whether an extension should be granted for the defendant to respond to that evidence. The plaintiff, Apacia Pty Ltd, had provided two expert reports from Ms Julie Strack from Pitcher Partners, one dated 16 December 2019 and the second on 28 January 2021. The defendant contested the reports' admissibility due to delays in their provision and alleged inadmissible evidence and reliance on unprovided reports. The defendant also argued that the delay in providing the reports contravened the court's timetable and that the plaintiff's delay had caused them prejudice.

The court acknowledged the importance of case flow management and the principles set out in the case of FAI General Insurance Company Ltd v Southern Cross Exploration NL, but it also recognised the necessity of allowing genuine issues to be litigated when it can be done fairly. The court noted that the matter was yet to be listed for trial and that it was unlikely to occur before 2022. The court found that, while it was not prepared to give the parties unlimited opportunity to serve their expert evidence, the circumstances warranted a final opportunity for both parties to present their expert evidence. The court did not determine the admissibility of the evidence, leaving it to the presiding judge, but it did order the plaintiff to provide the defendant with any documents relied upon by the expert.

Ultimately, the court granted the plaintiff's application for an extension to allow the defendant to respond to the expert evidence, subject to the plaintiff providing the required source documentation. The court balanced the principles of case flow management with the need to ensure the parties had a proper opportunity to present their evidence. The court's decision underscores the importance of giving parties a fair opportunity to present their cases, while also maintaining an efficient and expeditious process.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The rule is remedial and confers broad powers upon the court to relieve an injustice: FAI General Insurance Company Ltd v Southern Cross Exploration NL (1988) 165 CLR 268. Parties do not have an unqualified right to an extension; Ratnam v Cumarasamy [1964] 3 All ER 933, 935 however, if an extension is sought to enable a genuine issue to be litigated and this can be done with fairness to all concerned then it appropriate to make the order: Outboard Marine Australia Pty Ltd v Byrnes [1974] 1 NSWLR 27, 30. This of course all needs to be balanced against the principles and objects of case flow management and r 24(1) DCR confers a wide power on the court to make any procedural directions that is just to facilitate the case being conducted and concluded efficiently, economically and expeditiously. As Registrar Kingsley eloquently stated in Mazzoni v Sorrento Family Practice Pty Ltd [2021] WADC 12 [20] - [21] one of the purposes of civil proceedings is to determine respective rights of litigants and an important consideration is giving the parties a proper opportunity to ensure that a court determines the facts on the evidence that is reasonably put to the court by the parties. This is not to say that case management considerations ought be ignored, but they should be placed in the context of the stage the proceedings are at. The plaintiff has already provided to the defendant two expert reports from Ms Julie Strack from Pitcher Partners, one dated the 16 December 2019 (which was served on the defendant on 28 January 2020) and the second report on 28 January 2021 which was produced to the defendant under the cover of an affidavit on Denning Chong sworn 28 January 2021 in support of this application. The defendant objects to the reports being relied upon due to the delay in providing the reports in contravention of the court timetabling and given that, in its opinion, the reports contain inadmissible evidence and reliance on other reports which have not been provided to the defendant. Apart from these issues the defendant has not shown that there has been any prejudice by reason of the delay. This matter has yet to be listed for trial and based on the current court listings it is unlikely that a trial will be listed before 2022. Whilst I am not prepared to give the parties unlimited opportunity to serve their expert evidence, in these circumstances, I am of the opinion that it is appropriate to allow both parties a final opportunity to present their expert evidence. Expert evidence in this case will assist the court. With respect to the defendant's concerns regarding the admissibility of the evidence, this is ultimately an issue for the presiding judge and it would be remiss of me to attempt to make any determination as to the admissibility of the evidence. With respect to the non‑provision of source documentation referred to in the reports, this can be remedied with an order compelling the plaintiff to provide the defendant with any documents relied upon by the expert.