Pimley v Fremantle Sailing Club Inc

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

JURISDICTION     :   DISTRICT COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CHAMBERS

LOCATION:   PERTH

CITATION:   PIMLEY -v- FREMANTLE SAILING CLUB INC [2019] WADC 156

CORAM:   PRIOR DCJ

HEARD:   2 SEPTEMBER 2019

DELIVERED          :   20 NOVEMBER 2019

FILE NO/S:   CIV 3911 of 2017

BETWEEN:   JOHN PIMLEY

Plaintiff

AND

FREMANTLE SAILING CLUB INC

Defendant


Catchwords:

Appeal - Appeal by plaintiff from deputy registrar's decision for leave to adduce non‑medical expert evidence at trial

Legislation:

District Court Rules 2005 (WA) r 15 and r 47F

Result:

Appeal allowed
Leave to adduce non-medical expert evidence

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff : Mr G Stubbs
Defendant : Mr J J Sheldrick

Solicitors:

Plaintiff : WA Legal Pty Ltd
Defendant : Hall & Wilcox (Perth)

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Coal and Allied Operations Pty Ltd v Australian Industrial Relations Commission [2000] HCA 47

Guy v Hampson [2019] WADC 19

Hazart Pty Ltd v Rademaker (1993) 11 WAR 26

Process Minerals International Pty Ltd v Consolidated Minerals Pty Ltd [2012] WASC 254

Stewart v Hames [2019] WASCA 127

Tremeer v City of Stirling [2002] WASCA 281

PRIOR DCJ:

Introduction

  1. The plaintiff's claim against the defendant is for damages for personal injuries sustained and losses suffered in and as a result of an accident on or about 3 November 2014 when he fell from a finger jetty at Fremantle Sailing Club at 151 Marine Terrace, Fremantle (the jetty).

  2. The pleadings disclose that there is a contest between the parties as to the state and safety of the jetty.  The defendant by its defence admits that it was the occupier of the jetty as defined in the Occupiers Liability Act 1985 (WA). 

  3. On 8 February 2019, the plaintiff filed a chamber summons pursuant to District Court Rules 2005 (DCR) r 47F seeking leave to adduce non‑medical expert evidence at trial (the plaintiff's application).

  4. The plaintiff had obtained an expert evidence report dated 31 July 2018 prepared by engineers Peter Airey and Marian Kustra of Airey Taylor Consulting (the expert report).[1]

    [1] Affidavit of Radek Zacharek affirmed 12 August 2019, Annexure RZ1.

  5. The defendant opposed the plaintiff's application on the basis that the expert report is inadmissible, submitting that the evidence in the expert report was obtained improperly or illegally as one of the authors of the expert report and a legal representative of the plaintiff had gone onto the jetty on 28 June 2018 without the defendant's permission.  The defendant also submitted that it had been prejudiced as no representative of the defendant was present on 28 June 2018 when an inspection was carried out by an author of the expert report.[2]

    [2] Affidavit of Bree Lawrence sworn 30 May 2019, par 16, Affidavit of Elizabeth Anne-Louise Seggie affirmed 21 February 2019, par 15 and transcript of proceedings 5 June 2019 pages 18 - 19.

  6. The plaintiff denies that when the author of the expert report and a legal representative attended the premises on 28 June 2018 they trespassed on the jetty.[3]

    [3] Affidavit of Radek Zacharek affirmed 12 August 2019, par…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pimley v Fremantle Sailing Club Inc and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] WADC 156
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter of Pimley v Fremantle Sailing Club Inc was heard in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia. The plaintiff sought leave to adduce non-medical expert evidence at trial, an appeal from the decision of a deputy registrar. The defendant, Fremantle Sailing Club Inc, opposed the plaintiff's application, arguing that the expert evidence was inadmissible. The court was required to determine whether the plaintiff's application for leave to adduce non-medical expert evidence should be granted, and if the court must consider the admissibility of the evidence at the time of the application.

The court considered the provisions of rule 47F, which governs non-medical expert evidence in personal injury cases. The court noted that the plaintiff's case had not yet been listed for trial, and therefore the plaintiff was still able to apply for leave to adduce the expert evidence. The court also considered the purpose of the rule, which is to ensure that no party is taken by surprise at trial and that each party has an adequate opportunity to consider and respond to expert evidence. The court held that the grant of leave to adduce expert evidence does not require the court to consider the admissibility of the evidence at that stage. The court found that the plaintiff had made a sufficient application for leave to adduce the expert evidence and that the court's discretion under rule 47F(3)(c) should be exercised in favour of the plaintiff.

The court granted the plaintiff leave to adduce the non-medical expert evidence at trial. The court held that the grant of leave does not require the court to consider the admissibility of the evidence at that stage. The court emphasised the importance of the purpose of the rule, which is to ensure that no party is taken by surprise at trial and that each party has an adequate opportunity to consider and respond to expert evidence. The court's decision ensures that the plaintiff has the opportunity to present the expert evidence at trial, while also ensuring that the defendant is not prejudiced by the late introduction of the evidence. The court did not make any orders regarding the admissibility of the expert evidence, as that matter will be considered at trial.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The rule is in the following terms:47FOther expert evidence(1)This rule applies to expert evidence other than expert medical evidence in personal injury cases.(2)A direction given under this rule may apply to only a part of the report or evidence of an expert.(3)Expert evidence cannot be adduced at a trial unless –(a)the party seeking to adduce the evidence has applied to Court to determine whether a direction should be given under this rule and has complied with any direction given on the application; or(b) all parties consent to it being adduced; or(c) the Court has given leave for it to be adduced; or(d)the Court has permitted the evidence to be given by affidavit.(4)After a case is entered for trial -(a)the party who entered the case for trial cannot apply under subrule (3); and(b)any other party cannot apply after the time for applying under rule 38B for an order countermanding the entry for trial expires, or any later time that may be fixed by an order made on any such application.(5)On an application made under this rule, the Court may direct -(a)that a copy of an expert witness's report, the substance of which a party intends to rely on at the trial, be served on such other parties and within such period as the Court may specify; or(b)the substance of all or any expert evidence that a party intends to adduce at the trial be disclosed in writing to such other parties and within such period as the Court may specify.(6)The author of a report containing expert evidence must certify in the report to having read and complied with the practice direction made by the Court for the purposes of this subrule.(7)If a report has not be certified as required by subrule (6), it is not admissible at trial, except with the Court's leave. Rule 47F came into effect on 21 September 2018. It has not been the subject of any judicial consideration by this court or the Court of Appeal of Western Australia. Rule 47F complements r 47E which deals with expert medical evidence. The purpose of rules requiring disclosing of expert evidence is to ensure that no-one is taken by surprise at trial and that each party has an adequate opportunity to consider, investigate and, if necessary, answer expert evidence to be led by an opposing party.[9][9] Tremeer v City of Stirling [2002] WASCA 281 [33]. The plaintiff's case has not been listed for trial. If the plaintiff's case had been listed for trial r 47F(4)(a) would have precluded the plaintiff's application. The plaintiff's legal representatives have not confirmed at this stage whether they will rely on the expert's report as evidence at the trial. Due to the defendant's response to the plaintiff's application the plaintiff is on notice that the defendant takes issue with the admissibility of the expert report. The plaintiff submits that the court's discretion pursuant to r 47(3)(c) to grant leave to a party to adduce an expert report does not require at that stage that the court consider whether the expert evidence is admissible.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established