Maxims Caterers Limited v Magnona Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by MAXIMS CATERERS LIMITED to registration of trade mark application 1126989 (30, 35, 43) - CHINESE CHARACTERS (“MEI-XIN”) - filed in the name of MAGNONA PTY LTD.

Delegate: Heath Wilson
Representation: Opponent: Christian Dimitriadis of Counsel instructed by Blake Dawson.
Applicant: Sophie Goddard, Senior Counsel instructed by Mok & Associates.
Decision: 2009 ATMO 98
Section 52 Opposition - Grounds under sections 42(b), 44, 60, and 62A - Prior use under s44(4) applied - Goods and services restricted – Reputation of opponent’s trade mark not sufficient -Trade mark not contrary to law - Application not in bad faith - Registration proceeding for restricted goods - No award of costs.

Background

  1. On 1 August 2006, Magnona Pty Ltd (“the applicant”) applied to register the following trade mark:

    Trade mark application:        1126989
    Trade mark:  
    Goods/Services:       

    Class: 30 Coffee, tea, sugar, artificial coffee, bread, pastries, biscuits, buns, cakes, bread rolls, cookies, torts, waffles, confectionery, chocolates, ices, spices, syrup for food, honey, sauces, ice creams, Chinese style wedding cakes, Western style wedding cakes, mooncakes, Chinese mooncakes, Chinese mooncakes with nuts, ham and nuts mooncakes, sticky-rice dumplings, mini lotus seed paste mooncakes, mini red bean paste mooncakes, mini white lotus seed paste mooncakes, mooncakes with egg yolk

    Class: 35 Retailing of mooncakes, Chinese style wedding cakes, Western style wedding cakes

    Class: 43 Catering of food and drink, cafes, cafeterias, canteens, restaurants, self service restaurants, snack bars         

    Endorsement: The applicant has advised that the Chinese characters appearing in the trade mark may be translated into English as BEAUTIFUL HEART CAKE AND PASTRY SHOP.* Provisions of subsection 44(4) applied.*

  2. The trade mark was advertised for possible registration in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks on 25 January 2007, On 26 April 2007, Maxim’s Caterers Limited (“the opponent”) filed a notice of opposition (“the notice”) to this trade mark application under section 52 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (“the Act”).

  3. During the examination stage for this application, the opponent’s trade mark no. 1038992 (see below) was raised as a citation under section 44 of the Act. The applicant provided evidence of prior continuous use which satisfied the examiner that the provisions of subsection 44(4) could be applied, and the application was accepted on that basis.

    Evidence

  4. The parties filed and served evidence as set out below:

    Evidence in Support

    ·    Statutory Declarations of Michael Wu, (Managing Director of Maxim’s Caterers Limited):

    ØDated 2 May 2007 (Annexures A to I)

    ØDated 24 October 2007.

    Evidence in Answer

    ·    Statutory Declarations of Ching Yuen Tse: 

    ØDated 11 May 2006 (Annexures A to B)

    ØDated 30 November 2006 (Annexures A to B)

    ØDated 26 February 2008 (Annexures A to E)

    ·    Statutory Declaration of Jian Hui Zhong dated 2 May 2006.

    ·    Statutory Declaration of Tat Chin Yeung dated 9 May 2006 (Annexures A to B)

    ·    Statutory Declaration of Man Wai Ching dated 2 May 2006 (Annexures A to B)

    ·…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Maxims Caterers Limited v Magnona Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] ATMO 98
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an opposition by Maxims Caterers Limited against an application by Magnona Pty Ltd for the registration of a trade mark. The opposition was heard by Heath Wilson, acting as a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks. The dispute centred on whether Magnona's trade mark application should be rejected on various grounds, including those under sections 44, 42(b), 60, and 62A of the relevant Act.

The primary legal issues before the delegate were to determine whether any of the grounds of opposition cited by Maxims Caterers Limited had been established on the balance of probabilities. Specifically, the delegate was required to consider the grounds of opposition under sections 44 (identical or deceptively similar trade marks), 42(b) (misleading or deceptive conduct), 60 (trade marks used by the opponent), and 62A (trade marks sought to be registered in bad faith). The delegate noted that while several grounds were initially raised, the opponent pressed sections 44, 42(b), 60, and 62A, and that the remaining grounds had not been established.

The delegate found that the ground of opposition under section 44 of the Act had been established. This section pertains to the rejection of an application if the applicant's trade mark is substantially identical with, or deceptively similar to, a registered trade mark or a trade mark for which registration is being sought by another person, in respect of similar or closely related goods or services, and the priority dates are not earlier than the other trade mark. The delegate's reasoning for this finding is not detailed in the provided text, but the outcome was that the application could not proceed to registration in its current form.

Consequently, the delegate ordered that Magnona Pty Ltd be allowed one month from the date of the decision to request an amendment to the specification of goods and services for its trade mark application. If such an amendment was requested, the application could then proceed to registration. The delegate also directed that registration would be stayed if an appeal was filed before the amendment request, pending the outcome of the appeal. Given that both parties had achieved some success, the delegate ordered that each party bear their own costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The parties filed and served evidence as set out below:Evidence in Support· Statutory Declarations of Michael Wu, (Managing Director of Maxim’s Caterers Limited): ØDated 2 May 2007 (Annexures A to I) ØDated 24 October 2007. Evidence in Answer· Statutory Declarations of Ching Yuen Tse: ØDated 11 May 2006 (Annexures A to B)ØDated 30 November 2006 (Annexures A to B)ØDated 26 February 2008 (Annexures A to E)· Statutory Declaration of Jian Hui Zhong dated 2 May 2006.· Statutory Declaration of Tat Chin Yeung dated 9 May 2006 (Annexures A to B)· Statutory Declaration of Man Wai Ching dated 2 May 2006 (Annexures A to B)· Statutory Declarations of Boshala Yaan Fong Chan:ØDated 19 February 2008 (Annexures A to D)ØDated 17 March 2008 (Annexures 1 to 29)Evidence in Reply· Statutory Declaration of Hang Yee Wong dated 8 December 2008 (Annexures A to T)· Statutory Declarations of May Lee, Trang Tran Tiet, Lai Yin Chiu and Chun Ching Chan dated 29 January 2009Grounds of Opposition For an opposition to succeed, the opponent bears the onus of establishing at least one of the grounds cited in the notice, on the balance of probabilities (Pfizer Products Inc v Karam (2006) 70 IPR 599, per Gyles J at [6] to [26]; Chocolaterie Guylian N.V. v Registrar of Trade Marks [2009] FCA 891 (18 August 2009) per Sundberg J at [26]). The notice cites grounds of opposition under sections 41, 42(b), 43, 44, 58, 59, 60, 61 62(a) and 62(b) of the Act. At the hearing, the opponent pressed sections 44, 42(b) and predominately sections 60 and 62A, and I will address those particular grounds in detail in the following reasons. For the sake of completeness, I note that the remaining opposition grounds nominated in the notice have not been established. I heard this matter on 9 September 2009 in Sydney as a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks. Christian Dimitriadis of Counsel appeared on behalf of the opponent and Sophie Goddard, Senior Counsel appeared on the applicant’s behalf. ReasonsSection 44: Identical etc. trade marks The relevant provisions of section 44 state:(1) Subject to subsections (3) and (4), an application for the registration of a trade mark (applicant’s trade mark) in respect of goods (applicant’s goods) must be rejected if:(a) the applicant’s trade mark is substantially identical with, or deceptively similar to:(i) a trade mark registered by another person in respect of similar goods or closely related services; or(ii) a trade mark whose registration in respect of similar goods or closely related services is being sought by another person; and(b) the priority date for the registration of the applicant’s trade mark in respect of the applicant’s goods is not earlier than the priority date for the registration of the other trade mark in respect of the similar goods or closely related services.(2) Subject to subsections (3) and (4), an application for the registration of a trade mark (applicant’s trade mark) in respect of services (applicant’s services) must be rejected if:(a) it is substantially identical with, or deceptively similar to:(i) a trade mark registered by another person in respect of similar services or closely related goods; or(ii) a trade mark whose registration in respect of similar services or closely related goods is being sought by another person; and(b) the priority date for the registration of the applicant’s trade mark in respect of the applicant’s services is not earlier than the priority date for the registration of the other trade mark in respect of the similar services or closely related goods.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 55: Decision(1) Unless the proceedings are discontinued or dismissed, the Registrar must, at the end, decide:(a) to refuse to register the trade mark; or(b) to register the trade mark (with or without conditions or limitations) in respect of the goods and/or services then specified in the application;having regard to the extent (if any) to which any ground on which the application was opposed has been established.Note: For limitations see section 6. A ground of opposition under section 44 of the Act has been established. I will allow the applicant one month from the date of this decision to request the following amendment to the specification of goods and services: Class: 30 Mooncakes, Chinese mooncakes, Chinese mooncakes with nuts, ham and nuts mooncakes, mini lotus seed paste mooncakes, mini red bean paste mooncakes, mini white lotus seed paste mooncakes, mooncakes with egg yolk Class: 35 Retailing of mooncakesClass: 43 Catering of food and drink, cafes, cafeterias, canteens, restaurants, self service restaurants, snack bars In which case, the application may proceed to registration. If the Registrar has been served with a notice of appeal before that time, I direct that registration shall not occur until the appeal has been withdrawn or discontinued, or a court so orders.Costs As both parties have been successful to a certain extent in this matter, I find it appropriate that each party bear their own costs of these proceedings. Heath WilsonHearing OfficerTrade Marks Hearings2 December 2009

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.