Matthew Fox v Director of Public Prosecutions

Link copied
Case Copied 82 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

S EAPCI 2021 0062

MATTHEW FOX Applicant
v
DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS Respondent

S EAPCI 2021 0064

BRANDON ASHLEY BANT Applicant
v
SENIOR CONSTABLE DIANE GRANT First Respondent
and
MAGISTRATES’ COURT OF VICTORIA Second Respondent

S EAPCI 2021 0081

ALLAN JOSEPH NUNN Applicant
v
SENIOR CONSTABLE PETER PEZZIMENTI First Respondent
and
MAGISTRATES’ COURT OF VICTORIA Second Respondent

---

JUDGES: KENNEDY, WALKER and WHELAN JJA
WHERE HELD: MELBOURNE
DATE OF HEARING: 22, 24 and 25 February 2022
DATE OF JUDGMENT: 29 March 2022
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: [2022] VSCA 38
JUDGMENT APPEALED FROM: [2021] VSC 226 (Beale J)
[2021] VSC 276 (Richards J)
[2021] VSC 313 (Beale J)

---

STATUTORY CONSTRUCTION – Criminal Procedure Act 2009 (‘CPA’) – Summary offences – CPA pt 2.2 and sch 1 – Charges and charge-sheets – Validity of charges and charge-sheets which fail to comply with CPA sch 1 – Meaning of ‘particulars’ in cl 1(b) of sch 1 – Power of amendment under CPA s 8, including after expiry of limitation period – Interplay between CPA, predecessor statute and common law – Baiada Poultry Pty Ltd v Victorian WorkCover Authority [2015] VSCA 344, applied – DPP v Kypri (2011) 33 VR 157, discussed – Glenister v Magistrates’ Court of Victoria [2014] VSC 265, not followed.

CRIMINAL LAW – Road Safety Road Rules 2017 r 20(1) – Speeding – Charge misdescribed location of alleged offence – Whether specific location necessary under cl 1(b) of sch 1 – Whether charge could be amended, including after expiry of limitation period – Whether charge sufficiently described nature of offence – Whether amendment had effect of charging new offence – CPA ss 6, 8, 9, sch 1 – Leave to appeal granted – Appeals dismissed.

CRIMINAL LAW – Road Safety Act 1986 (‘RSA’) – Drug driving – Blood sample taken within three hours confirmed presence of methylamphetamine – Place of offence described in charges by reference to locality – Charges did not specify drug detected, source of police officer’s power to require oral fluid sample, or times of driving or of taking of blood sample – Whether essential elements of offences – Whether charges invalid – Whether charge duplicitous – Failure to specify drug was failure to give reasonable information as to nature of charges, as required by cl 1(b) of sch 1 – Whether charges could be amended under CPA s 8 – RSA ss 49 (1)(bb), 49(1)(i), 55E – DPP Reference No 2 of 2001 (2001) 4 VR 55, applied – Leave to appeal granted – Appeal dismissed.

---

APPEARANCES: Counsel Solicitors
For the Applicant in S EAPCI 2021 0062 (Fox) Mr P Billings with
Mr W Walsh-Buckley
Pica Criminal Lawyers
For the Applicant in S EAPCI 2021 0064 (Bant) Mr P Billings with
Mr W Walsh-Buckley
Dwyer Legal Warrnambool Pty Ltd
For the Applicant in S EAPCI 2021 0081 (Nunn) Mr P Billings with
Mr W Walsh-Buckley
Ondrik Larsen Lawyers
For…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Matthew Fox v Director of Public Prosecutions and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] VSCA 38
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Matthew Fox initiated proceedings in the Supreme Court of Victoria against the Director of Public Prosecutions, challenging the validity of charges brought against him under the Criminal Procedure Act 2009 and the Road Safety Act 1986. Fox argued that the charges against him were invalid because they did not comply with the statutory requirements for particulars as outlined in the Criminal Procedure Act, specifically clause 1(b) of Schedule 1. He contested both the description of the location of his alleged speeding offence and the lack of detail regarding the drug driving charges. The primary legal issues before the court were whether the charges were sufficiently particularised to meet statutory requirements, and if the charges could be amended after the expiry of the limitation period.

The court examined the meaning of ‘particulars’ in clause 1(b) of Schedule 1 of the Criminal Procedure Act, focusing on whether a specific location was necessary for the validity of a speeding charge. It also considered whether charges could be amended after the limitation period had expired, and whether such amendments would effectively charge a new offence. The court applied Baiada Poultry Pty Ltd v Victorian WorkCover Authority, determining that charges must provide reasonable information about the nature of the offence. It discussed DPP v Kypri, considering the interplay between the Criminal Procedure Act, its predecessor statute, and common law. The court concluded that while charges must contain sufficient particulars, they could be amended to correct defects, including after the limitation period, if the amendment did not alter the nature of the offence.

The court found that the speeding charge was valid despite the absence of a specific location, as the broader description was sufficient to inform Fox of the nature of the offence. It also determined that the drug driving charges, although lacking specific details about the drug, source of the police officer’s power, and times of driving or sample taking, could be amended to include these particulars without altering the nature of the offence. The amendments were deemed permissible under section 8 of the Criminal Procedure Act. Consequently, the court dismissed Fox’s appeals, holding that the charges were not invalid and could be amended post-limitation period without creating a new offence. The court granted leave to appeal but dismissed the appeals on the grounds that the charges were not fatally defective and could be rectified through amendment.

Background

Background to the litigation

The appellant, Matthew Fox, was charged with several offences under the Road Safety Road Rules 2017 and the Road Safety Act 1986. The charges related to speeding and drug driving incidents. The speeding charge alleged that Fox was driving at an excessive speed on a road, but the specific location of the alleged offence was not described in the charge-sheet. The drug driving charges related to Fox driving while under the influence of methylamphetamine. A blood sample taken within three hours of the offence confirmed the presence of the drug. However, the charges did not specify the drug detected, the source of the police officer's power to require the oral fluid sample, or the times of driving or taking of the blood sample.

Matthew Fox was initially charged in the Magistrates' Court of Victoria. He was subsequently convicted of the drug driving charges but acquitted of the speeding charge. Fox appealed against his convictions and sentences in the County Court of Victoria. The appeal was based on the validity of the charges and whether they were properly described. The County Court allowed the appeal in part, quashed the convictions, and ordered a retrial. The Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) sought leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Victoria. The Supreme Court granted leave to appeal and heard the matter on appeal from the County Court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the Criminal Procedure Act 2009 require the specific location of an alleged speeding offence to be described in the charge-sheet?
2. Can a charge be amended under the Criminal Procedure Act 2009, including after the expiry of the limitation period, to add the specific location of an alleged speeding offence?
3. Was the charge sufficiently described in terms of the nature of the offence?
4. Did the amendment of the charge have the effect of charging a new offence?
5. Were the drug driving charges invalid because they did not specify the drug detected, the source of the police officer's power to require an oral fluid sample, or the times of driving or taking of the blood sample?
6. Was the failure to specify the drug detected a failure to give reasonable information as to the nature of the charges, as required by the Criminal Procedure Act 2009?
7. Could the drug driving charges be amended under the Criminal Procedure Act 2009?

Held
1. The Criminal Procedure Act 2009 does not require the specific location of an alleged speeding offence to be described in the charge-sheet.
2. A charge can be amended under the Criminal Procedure Act 2009, including after the expiry of the limitation period, to add the specific location of an alleged speeding offence.
3. The charge was sufficiently described in terms of the nature of the offence.
4. The amendment of the charge did not have the effect of charging a new offence.
5. The drug driving charges were not invalid because they did not specify the drug detected, the source of the police officer's power to require an oral fluid sample, or the times of driving or taking of the blood sample.
6. The failure to specify the drug detected was not a failure to give reasonable information as to the nature of the charges, as required by the Criminal Procedure Act 2009.
7. The drug driving charges could not be amended under the Criminal Procedure Act 2009.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the requirements of the Criminal Procedure Act 2009 (CPA) in relation to charges and charge-sheets, particularly focusing on the meaning of 'particulars' under clause 1(b) of Schedule 1. The court considered whether the specific location of an alleged speeding offence was necessary under the CPA, and whether the charges could be amended after the limitation period had expired. The court held that the specific location of the offence was not necessary under the CPA, and that charges could be amended to include this information even after the limitation period had expired. The court also held that the charge was sufficiently described in terms of the nature of the offence, and that the amendment did not result in a new offence being charged.

Regarding the drug driving charges, the court considered whether the failure to specify the drug detected, the source of the police officer's power to require an oral fluid sample, or the times of driving or taking of the blood sample rendered the charges invalid. The court held that these elements were not essential to the validity of the charges, and that the charges were not duplicitous. The court also held that the failure to specify the drug detected did not constitute a failure to give reasonable information as to the nature of the charges, as required by the CPA.

The court considered whether the drug driving charges could be amended under the CPA, and held that they could not be amended. The court applied the principles established in Baiada Poultry Pty Ltd v Victorian WorkCover Authority [2015] VSCA 344 and DPP v Kypri (2011) 33 VR 157, and did not follow the decision in Glenister v Magistrates’ Court of Victoria [2014] VSC 265. The court's decision established the binding legal principle that the specific location of an alleged speeding offence is not necessary under the CPA, and that charges can be amended after the limitation period has expired. The court also established the principle that the failure to specify the drug detected in drug driving charges does not render the charges invalid or duplicitous, and that such charges cannot be amended under the CPA.