Director of Public Prosecutions v Fogarty

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA Not Restricted

AT MELBOURNE

COMMON LAW DIVISION

JUDICIAL REVIEW AND APPEALS LIST

S CI 2020 04264
S CI 2020 04265

DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS (on behalf of Rebecca Jane Ayson) Appellant/Plaintiff
v  
SHAUN JAMES FOGARTY Respondent/Defendant

---

JUDGE:

PRIEST JA

WHERE HELD:

Melbourne

DATE OF HEARING:

25 June 2021

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

2 July 2021

CASE MAY BE CITED AS:

DPP v Fogarty

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2021] VSC 392

---

CRIMINAL LAW – Criminal Procedure – Motor vehicle offences – Breath test – Refusing – Charge under s 49(1)(e) of the Road Safety Act 1986 of failing to comply with a requirement to furnish a sample of breath for analysis under s 55(1) – Charge under s 49(1)(e) of the Road Safety Act 1986 of failing to comply with a requirement to furnish a further sample of breath for analysis under s 55(2A) – Whether charges sufficiently described nature of offences – Whether charges adequately particularised the manner in which the accused failed to comply with requirements – Whether charges capable of amendment – Whether Magistrate erred in privately seeking information as to particularisation of charges in other cases – Road Safety Act 1986 ss 49(1)(e), 55(1) and 55(2A) – Criminal Procedure Act 2009 ss 6, 8 and 9, Sch 1.

---

APPEARANCES:

Counsel Solicitors
For the Appellant/Plaintiff Ms E Ruddle SC Ms A Hogan, Solicitor for Public Prosecutions
For the Respondent/Defendant Mr W Walsh-Buckley ZD Legal Lawyers

HIS HONOUR:

The respondent is charged with refusing a breath test

  1. At 1.55 am on 2 June 2019, Shaun James Fogarty (for convenience, ‘the respondent’), was driving a motor vehicle in Gisborne, when he was intercepted by Senior Constable Rebecca Ayson (for convenience, ‘the informant’) and another police officer, who were performing traffic re-direction duties.

  1. When requested to produce his driver licence the respondent failed to do so, producing instead another form of identification.  Police then administered a preliminary breath test (‘PBT’), which proved positive.  At the informant’s request, the respondent accompanied her to the Gisborne Police Station for the purposes of an ‘evidentiary’ breath test.

  1. At 3.06 am, the informant — who is an authorised operator of a breath analysing instrument under s 55(3) of the Road Safety Act 1986 (‘RSA’) — required the respondent to furnish a sample of breath into a breath analysing instrument. The respondent refused, however, to provide a sample of breath, and the instrument produced a ‘no sample’ certificate.

  1. Having advised the respondent of the consequences of refusing to furnish a sample of breath for analysis, at 3.11 am the informant made a further requirement that the respondent furnish a sample of breath.  The respondent again refused, however, and the instrument once more produced a ‘no sample’ certificate.  The respondent then left the police station.

  1. On 14 August 2019, the informant issued a charge-sheet and summons containing two charges.[1] Charge 1 alleged a breach of s 49(1)(e) of the RSA, and was expressed in the following terms:

The accused at…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Fogarty and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] VSC 392
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the court involved the Director of Public Prosecutions as the prosecutor and the accused, Mr Fogarty, who was charged with two offences under the Road Safety Act 1986. The charges related to Mr Fogarty's refusal to comply with police requests to provide samples of breath for analysis, both under sections 55(1) and 55(2A) of the Act. The case was heard and determined in the Magistrates’ Court of Victoria.

The primary legal issues addressed by the court were whether the charges against Mr Fogarty adequately described the nature of the offences and the manner in which he failed to comply with the requirements to provide breath samples. Additionally, the court considered whether the charges could be amended to better particularise the offences and whether the Magistrate had erred in privately seeking information about the particularisation of charges in other cases.

The court found that the charges were insufficiently particularised as they did not adequately describe how Mr Fogarty failed to comply with the requirements to provide breath samples. The court held that the charges were not capable of amendment to rectify this deficiency. The court also found that the Magistrate's actions in privately seeking information about the charges in other cases was improper and constituted a breach of procedural fairness. Consequently, the court quashed the convictions and ordered a retrial.

The final orders of the court were to quash the convictions against Mr Fogarty and order a retrial. The court found that the charges did not adequately particularise the offences and that the Magistrate's actions were improper, leading to a breach of procedural fairness. The case underscores the importance of ensuring that charges are sufficiently detailed to inform the accused of the nature of the offence and the manner in which they are alleged to have failed to comply with legal requirements.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established