PROCEDURE - INFERIOR COURTS - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - DISTRICT AND LOCAL COURTS PROCEDURE UNDER FORMER LOCAL COURT RULES - PRACTICE - PROCEDURE BEFORE TRIAL - OTHER MATTERS
Defence of justification - whether Judge erred in granting leave to allow the defendant to plead such a defence - application to amend defence refused on the basis that it was too late to plead justification.
On 22 March 2004, Dr Manock issued proceedings alleging he was defamed by Channel Seven Adelaide Pty Ltd. In its original defence Channel Seven pleaded a number of defences including fair comment on a matter of public interest. The defence of fair comment has been the subject of extensive litigation, which was eventually determined by the High Court which struck out the defence. On the 15 February 2008, Channel Seven sought to plead justification, which is the subject of this appeal.
Background Facts
Mr Henry Keogh had been charged with murdering Anna Jane Cheney by drowning her in a bath on 18 March 1994. Dr Manock gave expert evidence at the trial and retrial of Mr Keogh. He had conducted an autopsy on 20 and 21 March 1994.
The prosecution case was that Mr Keogh had held Ms Cheney’s legs in a manner which had forced her head under the water, causing her to drown. Dr Manock, the applicant in these proceedings, gave evidence of his observations and examination of Ms Cheney’s body, which supported the prosecution contention of how Ms Cheney had died.
The jury could not reach a verdict at the first trial. The second trial, at which Mr Keogh was convicted, was held in August 1995. Dr Manock’s evidence and the opinions he expressed at each trial have been the subject of criticism, some of which have been canvassed by Channel Seven in its program, Today Tonight.
Dr Manock claims that on or about 5 March 2004, Channel Seven broadcast a promotional item for a future edition of the program “Today Tonight”…
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Manock v Channel Seven Adelaide Pty Ltd (ACN 007 625 603) and more:
The matter before the South Australian District and Local Courts was an appeal by Dr Manock against a decision to deny an application to amend the defence to include a plea of justification. Channel Seven had originally pleaded a number of defences to Dr Manock’s defamation claim, including fair comment. This defence was ultimately struck out by the High Court, leaving Channel Seven with a plea of justification. Dr Manock sought to amend the defence to include this plea, but the application was refused by Judge Muecke on the basis that it was too late to plead justification. The primary issue before the court was whether the Judge had erred in refusing the application to amend the defence to include the plea of justification. This required consideration of the circumstances which led to the delay in pleading justification and whether this was due to the conduct of Channel Seven. The court considered the history of the pleadings, the comments of the High Court in Channel Seven Adelaide v Manock, and the principles set out in AON Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University. The court concluded that the delay in pleading justification was not due to the conduct of Channel Seven and that it was understandable why the defence had not been pleaded earlier. The court also observed that the earlier arguments were confined to challenging the particulars pleaded in support of the defence of fair comment and that it was not until the matter was argued in the High Court that Dr Manock suggested that the words complained of were arguably fact. The court concluded that by granting the application, it would not delay the matter proceeding to trial and that whatever his decision, he could not ignore the possibility of an appeal.
The court found that the Judge had not erred in refusing the application to amend the defence to include the plea of justification. The court considered the history of the pleadings and concluded that the delay in pleading justification was not due to the conduct of Channel Seven. The court also observed that the earlier arguments were confined to challenging the particulars pleaded in support of the defence of fair comment and that it was not until the matter was argued in the High Court that Dr Manock suggested that the words complained of were arguably fact. The court concluded that by granting the application, it would not delay the matter proceeding to trial and that whatever his decision, he could not ignore the possibility of an appeal. The court considered the principles set out in AON Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University and concluded that the rules were to be interpreted and applied with the purpose of promoting the just and efficient determination of litigation and not to defeat a proper claim or defence of a litigant who is genuinely endeavouring to comply with the procedures of the Court. The court found that Channel Seven had not acted tactically by not pleading justification and that it was understandable why the defence had not been pleaded earlier. The appeal was dismissed.
The court made no orders as to costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
On 22 March 2004, Dr Manock issued proceedings alleging he was defamed by Channel Seven Adelaide Pty Ltd. In its original defence Channel Seven pleaded a number of defences including fair comment on a matter of public interest. The defence of fair comment has been the subject of extensive litigation, which was eventually determined by the High Court which struck out the defence. On the 15 February 2008, Channel Seven sought to plead justification, which is the subject of this appeal.Background Facts Mr Henry Keogh had been charged with murdering Anna Jane Cheney by drowning her in a bath on 18 March 1994. Dr Manock gave expert evidence at the trial and retrial of Mr Keogh. He had conducted an autopsy on 20 and 21 March 1994. The prosecution case was that Mr Keogh had held Ms Cheney’s legs in a manner which had forced her head under the water, causing her to drown. Dr Manock, the applicant in these proceedings, gave evidence of his observations and examination of Ms Cheney’s body, which supported the prosecution contention of how Ms Cheney had died. The jury could not reach a verdict at the first trial. The second trial, at which Mr Keogh was convicted, was held in August 1995. Dr Manock’s evidence and the opinions he expressed at each trial have been the subject of criticism, some of which have been canvassed by Channel Seven in its program, Today Tonight. Dr Manock claims that on or about 5 March 2004, Channel Seven broadcast a promotional item for a future edition of the program “Today Tonight” in which the following statement was made whilst a picture of Dr Manock was displayed across the background. The statement was:The new Keogh facts. The evidence they kept to themselves. The data, dates and documents that don’t add up. The evidence changed from one Court to the next. Dr Manock claims that the promotional, in its ordinary and natural meaning meant, and was understood to mean, that he had deliberately concealed evidence from the trials of Mr Keogh when Mr Keogh was tried for murder. Dr Manock seeks damages, including exemplary damages, for the statement. He alleges the statement defamed him, injured his character, credit, reputation and profession, and that he has been brought into public scandal, odium and contempt. He has suffered considerable stress and embarrassment as a result. Dr Manock issued a Statement of Claim, which was filed in the District Court on 22 March 2004. A Defence was filed on 16 June 2004, and an Amended Defence was filed on 2 March 2005. In its Amended Defence, Channel Seven denied that the promotion bore, or was capable of bearing, the meaning that Dr Manock had deliberately concealed evidence from the trials of Mr Keogh. It was further pleaded that, if the promotion could be understood to refer to Dr Manock (which is not admitted), Channel Seven denied that the promotion would be, or would be capable of being understood to refer solely or primarily to Dr Manock. Further, and in the alternative, Channel Seven claimed that the words of the promotion constituted fair comment on a matter of public interest. In support of that claim, the Amended Defence provided particulars of the public interest and particulars of facts upon which the comment is based.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Judge Muecke considered whether, in the circumstances which I have outlined, the application to amend the defence should be refused on the basis that it was too late to plead justification. He correctly stated that this was a matter for the exercise of his discretion. Judge Muecke had regard to the High Court’s comments in Channel Seven Adelaide v Manock,[12] and the decision of the High Court in AON Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University.[13]He referred to the history of the pleadings, and concluded that the delay in the action in reaching its current position was not due to the conduct of Channel Seven. He concluded that it was understandable why the justification defence had not been pleaded earlier. He observed that the earlier pleading appeals had centred upon the issue of fair comment, and it was not until the matter was argued in the High Court that Dr Manock suggested that the words complained of were arguably fact. Judge Muecke observed that the earlier arguments were confined to challenging the particulars pleaded in support of the defence of fair comment. He was not prepared to conclude that Channel Seven had made a tactical decision not to plead justification and, rather, to “keep its powder dry” until the issue of fair comment had been finally determined. He concluded that, by granting the application, it would not delay the matter proceeding to trial, and he considered that, whatever his decision, he could not ignore the possibility of an appeal.[12] (2007) 232 CLR 245.[13] (2009) 239 CLR 175.The decision in AON AON was a case which was decided pursuant to the Court Procedure Rules 2006 (ACT). Rule 21(2) of those Rules provided that the rules were to be applied in civil proceedings:… with the objective of achieving (a) the just resolution of the real issues in the proceedings; and (b) the timely disposal of the proceedings, and all other proceedings in the Court, at a cost affordable by the respective parties. The relevant South Australian rules, which are applicable to this action, are the 1987 Rules. Rule 2.02 of the Supreme Court Rules 1987 provides that the rules are to be applied:With the object of:(a)promoting the just determination of litigation;(b)disposing efficiently of the business of the Court;(c)maximising the efficient use of available judicial and administrative resources; and(d)facilitating the timely disposal of business at a cost affordable by parties; actions in the Court will be managed and supervised in accordance with a system of positive case flow management. These rules are to be construed and applied and the processes and procedures of the Court conducted so as best to ensure the attainment of the above objects. Rule 2.01 provides as follows:These Rules are made for the purpose of establishing orderly procedures for the conduct of litigation in the Court and of promoting the just and efficient determination of such litigation. They are not intended to defeat a proper claim or defence of a litigant who is genuinely endeavouring to comply with the procedures of the Court, and are to be interpreted and applied with the above purpose in view.