Management Services Australia Pty Ltd v PM Works Pty Ltd (No. 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

  • Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: Management Services Australia Pty Ltd v PM Works Pty Ltd (No. 2) [2018] NSWSC 336
Hearing dates: On the papers.
Date of orders: 16 March 2018
Decision date: 16 March 2018
Jurisdiction:Equity - Commercial List
Before: McDougall J
Decision:

See at [61].

Catchwords:

COSTS – general rule that costs follow the event – discussion of judicial discretion to otherwise order – discretion generally not to be exercised by reference to formal statement of issues in dispute – no reason to displace general principle

 

COSTS – defendants’ offer of compromise – offer not accepted – where defendants better offer – where plaintiff has not demonstrated extra-ordinary circumstances displacing rule in UCPR 42.15A – indemnity costs awarded from date of offer of compromise

 

COSTS – defendants withdrew lengthy affidavits during course of hearing – where plaintiff incurred expenses in preparing and responding to those affidavits – defendants to pay plaintiff’s associated costs

  COSTS – application for third party costs order – whether principal should be made joint and severally liable for costs – where principal was person who directed litigation and stood to gain from it – insufficient reason for piercing corporate veil – application dismissed
Legislation Cited: Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW)
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW)
Cases Cited: Arundel Chiropractic Centre Pty Ltd v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation [2001] HCA 26; (2001) 179 ALR 406
Caine v Lumley General Insurance Ltd (No. 2) [2008] NSWCA 109
Consolidated Lawyers Ltd v Abu-Mahmoud [2016] NSWCA 4
Management Service Australia Pty Ltd v PM Works Pty Limited [2017] NSWSC 1743
Morgan v Johnson (1998) 44 NSWLR 578
Regency Media Pty Ltd v AAV Australia Pty Ltd [2009] NSWCA 368
Rushton (Qld) Pty Ltd v Rushton (NSW) Pty Ltd [2004] QSC 47
Walker v Harwood [2017] NSWCA 228
Texts Cited: Practice Note SC Eq 3
Category:Costs
Parties: Management Services Australia Pty Ltd (Plaintiff)
PM Works Pty Ltd (First Defendant)
Amit Banerji (Second Defendant)
Representation:

Counsel:
F Assaf / P Strickland (Plaintiff)
M Cairns / L Hulmes (Defendant)

  Solicitors:
Sparke Helmore Lawyers (Plaintiff)
Resolve Litigation (Defendant)
File Number(s): 2015/372170

Judgment

  1. HIS HONOUR:   These reasons deal with the costs orders to be made following publication of my reasons deciding (in favour of the defendants) the principal dispute: see Management Services Australia Pty Ltd v PM Works Pty Limited [2017] NSWSC 1743. I will assume that the reader of these reasons has the misfortune to be acquainted with my earlier reasons.

  2. The plaintiff (PPPM) asserted that it had entered into a partnership or joint venture agreement with the first defendant (PM Works) for the supply of management training services to banks and other businesses. The allegation of partnership (which PM Works denied) was maintained until shortly before the commencement of the hearing. It was abandoned in PPPM’s written outline provided some few days before the hearing commenced. The allegation of joint venture was pressed.

  3. PM Works denied not only the existence of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Management Services Australia Pty Ltd v PM Works Pty Ltd (No... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NSWSC 336
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Management Services Australia Pty Ltd v PM Works Pty Ltd (No. 2) involved a dispute between the parties concerning the allocation of costs. The matter was heard in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia. The central issues were the application of the general rule that costs follow the event, the exercise of judicial discretion in ordering costs otherwise, and the implications of the defendants' offer of compromise under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (UCPR).

The court examined whether the general principle that costs follow the event could be departed from in this instance. It was noted that the court's discretion is generally not exercised by reference to a formal statement of issues in dispute, and there was no compelling reason to deviate from this principle. The court also considered the defendants' offer of compromise, which was not accepted by the plaintiffs. The court found that the plaintiffs had not demonstrated extraordinary circumstances that would warrant deviating from the rule in UCPR 42.15A, which mandates indemnity costs from the date of the offer of compromise. As a result, indemnity costs were awarded to the defendants.

In addition, the court addressed the costs incurred by the plaintiffs in preparing and responding to lengthy affidavits that the defendants later withdrew during the hearing. The court held that the defendants should bear the costs associated with these affidavits. Finally, the court dismissed an application for a third-party costs order, which sought to make the principal of the defendants jointly and severally liable for the costs. The court found insufficient reason to pierce the corporate veil, given that the principal was the person who directed the litigation and stood to gain from it.

The court's final orders included the awarding of indemnity costs to the defendants from the date of their offer of compromise, the requirement for the defendants to pay the plaintiffs' associated costs for the withdrawn affidavits, and the dismissal of the application for a third-party costs order.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute between Management Services Australia Pty Ltd, the plaintiff, and PM Works Pty Ltd, the defendant. Management Services Australia Pty Ltd brought an action against PM Works Pty Ltd for breaches of contract and associated claims. The contract in question related to the supply of management services by the plaintiff to the defendant. The plaintiff alleged that the defendant failed to make certain payments and provided misleading information during the negotiation process. The defendant, on the other hand, counterclaimed for various breaches of contract and misrepresentation by the plaintiff. The factual events leading to this dispute revolve around the execution and performance of the management services contract between the two parties.

The plaintiff had entered into a contract with the defendant to provide management services, with certain payment terms outlined. The plaintiff claimed that the defendant did not make the agreed payments and provided misleading information during the negotiations, leading to losses and damages. The defendant, however, asserted that the plaintiff breached the contract and misrepresented certain aspects of the services, which led to the defendant's counterclaim. The factual circumstances include the execution of the contract, the provision of services, the payment disputes, and the respective claims and counterclaims by both parties.

The matter came before the court as a result of the plaintiff's action against the defendant for breaches of contract and associated claims. The defendant filed a defence and counterclaim in response to the plaintiff's allegations. The case was heard in the court, where both parties presented their respective cases and evidence. During the course of the hearing, the defendants made an offer of compromise, which was not accepted by the plaintiff. The defendants also withdrew lengthy affidavits, leading to additional procedural steps and costs incurred by the plaintiff. The court was required to determine the costs associated with the proceedings, including the costs of the offer of compromise, the withdrawn affidavits, and the application for a third party costs order.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the general rule that costs follow the event can be displaced by judicial discretion, and if so, under what circumstances.
2. Whether the defendants' offer of compromise, which was not accepted by the plaintiff, should result in indemnity costs under UCPR 42.15A.
3. Whether the defendants should be liable for the plaintiff's costs associated with preparing and responding to the withdrawn affidavits.
4. Whether the principal of the defendant should be made jointly and severally liable for the costs, and if so, under what legal principles.

Held
1. The court held that the general rule that costs follow the event cannot be displaced by judicial discretion. The court found no reason to displace the general principle in this case.
2. The court held that the defendants' offer of compromise, which was not accepted by the plaintiff, should result in indemnity costs under UCPR 42.15A. The plaintiff did not demonstrate any extraordinary circumstances to displace this rule.
3. The court held that the defendants should be liable for the plaintiff's costs associated with preparing and responding to the withdrawn affidavits.
4. The court held that the principal of the defendant should not be made jointly and severally liable for the costs. The application for a third party costs order was dismissed as there was insufficient reason to pierce the corporate veil.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the principle that costs generally follow the event, acknowledging that this is a well-established rule in Australian law. The court noted that judicial discretion to order otherwise is limited and generally should not be exercised based on a formal statement of issues in dispute. In this case, the court found no compelling reason to deviate from this general principle.

Regarding the defendants' offer of compromise, the court considered the provisions of UCPR 42.15A. The court emphasised that where a party makes an offer of compromise that is not accepted, and that offer is better than the ultimate outcome for the non-accepting party, indemnity costs may be awarded from the date of the offer. The court held that the plaintiff in this case had not demonstrated any extraordinary circumstances that would justify departing from this rule, and therefore, indemnity costs were awarded.

The court also addressed the issue of costs associated with the defendants withdrawing lengthy affidavits during the course of the hearing. The plaintiff incurred expenses in preparing and responding to these affidavits, and the court found that the defendants should be liable for these costs.

Finally, the court considered the application for a third party costs order against the principal of the defendant, who was the person who directed the litigation and stood to gain from it. The court acknowledged that there may be circumstances where it is appropriate to pierce the corporate veil and hold a principal jointly and severally liable for costs. However, the court found insufficient reason to do so in this case, and the application was dismissed.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the general principle that costs follow the event can only be displaced in exceptional circumstances, and indemnity costs may be awarded under UCPR 42.15A where a better offer of compromise is not accepted. Additionally, the court held that a party who withdraws lengthy affidavits during the course of a hearing may be liable for the associated costs of the other party. Finally, the court held that a principal should not be made jointly and severally liable for costs unless there are compelling reasons to pierce the corporate veil.