Magi Enterprises Pty Ltd v Luvalot Clothing Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Magi Enterprises Pty Ltd v Luvalot Clothing Pty Ltd (No 2) [2017] FCA 1143

File number: VID 306 of 2016
Judge: MURPHY J
Date of judgment: 25 September 2017
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for the evidence of witnesses resident in China to be given by video link – application dismissed – application for adjournment of trial to allow witnesses to give evidence in person – application allowed
Legislation:

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), ss 37M(1), 47A, 47C(1)

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), rr 1.40, 5.04(3), 29.09

Cases cited:

Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University (2009) 239 CLR 175; [2009] HCA 27

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Pirovic [2014] FCA 544

Australian Medical Imaging Pty Ltd v Marconi Medical Systems Australia Pty Ltd (2001) 53 NSWLR 1; [2001] NSWSC 651

Blackrock Asset Management Australia Services Ltd v Waked (No 2) [2011] FCA 479

Campaign Master (UK) Ltd v Forty Two International Pty Ltd (No 3) (2009) 181 FCR 152; [2009] FCA 1306

Dorajay Pty Ltd v Aristocrat Leisure Ltd [2007] FCA 1502

Jones v Treasury Wine Estates (No 3) [2017] FCA 961

Kirby v Centro Properties Ltd (2012) 288 ALR 601; [2012] FCA 60

Magi Enterprises Pty Ltd v Luvalot Clothing Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 340

Mastipour v Secretary, Department of Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2004) 140 FCR 137; [2004] FCA 1571

Moyette Pty Ltd v Foundation Healthcare Ltd [2003] FCA 116

Seymour v Commissioner of Taxation (2016) 241 FCR 361; [2016] FCAFC 18

State Rail Authority of New South Wales v Earthline Constructions Pty Ltd [1999] HCA 3

Stuke v ROST Capital Group Pty Ltd (2012) 207 FCR 86; [2012] FCA 1097

Tetra Pak Marketing Pty Ltd v Musashi Pty Ltd [2000] FCA 1261

Traxys Europe SA v Balaji Coke Industry Pvt Ltd (No 4) [2012] FCA 1416

Unilever Australia Ltd v Revlon Australia Pty Ltd (No 4) [2014] FCA 1074

Versace v Monte [2001] FCA 1454

Date of hearing: 3 April 2017
Registry: Victoria
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Intellectual Property
Sub-area: Copyright and Industrial Designs
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 36
Counsel for the Applicant/Cross-Respondent: Ms S Gatford
Solicitor for the Applicant/Cross-Respondent: K&L Gates
Counsel for the Respondent/Cross-Claimant: Mr J Langmead QC
Solicitor for the Respondent/Cross-Claimant: Actuate IP

ORDERS

VID 306 of 2016
BETWEEN:

MAGI ENTERPRISES PTY LTD

Applicant/Cross-Respondent

AND:

LUVALOT CLOTHING PTY LTD

Respondent/Cross-Claimant

JUDGE:

MURPHY J

DATE OF ORDER:

25 SEPTEMBER 2017

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The Respondent’s application for the Court to hear testimony from Ms Huang Bi Zi by video link is dismissed.

2.The Respondent pay the Applicant’s costs of the application on an indemnity basis, on a lump sum basis to be taxed if not agreed, doing so forthwith.

Note:    Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

MURPHY J:

  1. In this matter the respondent/cross-claimant, Luvalot Clothing Pty Ltd (

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Magi Enterprises Pty Ltd v Luvalot Clothing Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] FCA 1143
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Magi Enterprises Pty Ltd v Luvalot Clothing Pty Ltd (No 2) involves a dispute between two companies, Magi and Luvalot, over the alleged infringement of a registered design. The dispute was heard in the Federal Court of Australia. The main issue was whether the court should allow two witnesses, Mr Wei Dong and Ms Bi Zi, to give their evidence by video link from China. These witnesses were crucial to Luvalot's case, as they were the only ones with firsthand knowledge of a prior publication of the design on the internet. Luvalot sought to have the trial adjourned to allow these witnesses to give evidence in person, while Magi opposed this, arguing that it would cause significant prejudice and unfairness.

The court considered several factors in its decision, including the relevance of the witnesses' evidence, the reasons for their inability to travel to Australia, and the potential disadvantages of cross-examining them by video link. The court also noted the importance of ensuring that justice is served between the parties and that justice is administered fairly and efficiently. The court ultimately decided to allow the adjournment of the trial, enabling the witnesses to give their evidence in person if possible. However, the court dismissed the application to allow Ms Bi Zi's testimony by video link, as she had indicated a strong preference not to travel internationally due to her young child. The court held that the potential loss of her evidence outweighed any disadvantages of cross-examining her by video link.

In summary, the court allowed the adjournment of the trial to permit the witnesses to give their evidence in person, but dismissed the application to allow one witness's testimony by video link. The court's decision was based on a careful consideration of the relevant factors and the need to ensure that justice is served between the parties. The orders made by the court included dismissing the application for the evidence of Ms Bi Zi to be given by video link and requiring Luvalot to pay Magi's costs of the application.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Respondent’s application for the Court to hear testimony from Ms Huang Bi Zi by video link is dismissed.

2. The Respondent pay the Applicant’s costs of the application on an indemnity basis, on a lump sum basis to be taxed if not agreed, doing so forthwith.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons I explain, I earlier refused to take Mr Wei Dong’s evidence by video link and I allowed the adjournment of the trial. I now also make orders to refuse the application to hear Ms Bi Zi’s testimony by video link.THE FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND Magi designs, manufactures and sells fashion garments in Australia and New Zealand under the brand “Kookai”. Luvalot is a designer, manufacturer and wholesaler of garments and operates in China and Australia. Magi alleges that Luvalot infringed its registered design in a garment called the “Macy Tie Top”. Luvalot denies that it did so, on the basis that the design was not validly registered because an image of a garment in that design was published on a Chinese website prior to the priority date for registration. Luvalot therefore challenges the validity of the registered design but concedes that if the design was validly registered Luvalot has engaged in infringing conduct.The first adjournment application The trial in this proceeding was listed to be heard on 4 April 2017. By application dated 23 March 2017 Luvalot sought orders to adjourn the hearing because Mr Wei Dong and Ms Bi Zi were unable to come to Australia to give evidence because neither had Chinese passports nor visas to enter Australia, and Ms Bi Zi was heavily pregnant. Their evidence is critical to Luvalot’s case because they are the only witnesses that provide first-hand evidence of having viewed the alleged prior publication of a garment in Magi’s registered design. At the relevant time Ms Bi Zi was employed by Luvalot as a production assistant in Guangzhou, China, but she has since left Luvalot’s employ. In Magi Enterprises Pty Ltd v Luvalot Clothing Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 340 at [18] (Magi v Luvalot No 1) I summarised the evidence which she proposed to give as follows:…Ms Bi Zi says that she worked in Luvalot’s product development department in Guangzhou and was responsible for, amongst other things, sourcing designs and fabric from local shops, local websites and local markets. She says that on 11 June 2015 while browsing the Taobao website she saw three images of a garment and she made an online purchase of the garment, which garment was then delivered to her on 14 June 2015. She annexes a number of documents:(a)an (apparently) undated screenshot from the Taobao website showing the relevant garment;(b)a screenshot of her online chat with the garment vendor dated 11 June 2015;(c)a confirmation of the shipping of the garment dated 11 June 2015;(d)an invoice for the purchase of the garment dated 12 June 2015;(e)a copy of the consignment note for the garment from Hongrui to Luvalot showing delivery on 14 June; and (f)photographs of the garment that she stated she received on 14 June 2015. At the relevant time Mr Wei Dong was the owner of a Chinese registered company which ran an online clothing distribution business. In Magi v Luvalot No 1 at [19] I summarised his proposed evidence as follows:… Mr Wei Dong says that he is the owner of Hongrui, a clothing distribution business which trades through the Taobao website. He says that he is responsible for ensuring that the orders received from the Taobao website are followed up and sent out. He says that Ms Bucoy [the sole director of Luvalot] had provided him with a copy of a document which appeared to be a copy of a screenshot taken from the Taobao website showing a garment for sale. He annexed that document (which appears to be the same as the screenshot which Ms Bi Zi said she took on 11 June 2015). He confirms that the copy screenshot is from an online advertisement published on the Taobao website by his company, and said that based on his review of his business records, the copy screenshot was an accurate representation of the advertisement as it existed on 11 June 2015. He says that the shipping confirmation, invoice and consignment note annexed to Ms Bi Zi’s affidavit were consistent with the business records of his company relating to the shipment, invoicing and delivery of the garment referred to.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

There is also some dissonance between Magi’s position that Mr Wei Dong should not be allowed to give evidence by video link because it would disadvantage Magi in cross examining him, and its position that the trial should not be adjourned which would meant he cannot give evidence at all. I consider justice will best be served by allowing the adjournment. That will permit Mr Wei Dong to travel to Australia to give his evidence, as well as Ms Bi Zi, if her position changes, and the claim and cross-claim can be determined on their merits.THE APPLICATION TO TAKE MS BI ZI’S EVIDENCE BY VIDEO LINK Once it was decided that the trial was to be adjourned there was no urgency to deciding the application to hear Ms Bi Zi’s testimony by video link. I made orders for Luvalot to advise Magi of the details of the arrangements that it proposed for Ms Bi Zi to testify by video link, for the parties to file short written submissions in relation to that application, and for the question to be determined on the papers. In this application Luvalot relied on the affidavits it filed in support of both interlocutory applications, on its submissions in the interlocutory hearing on 3 April 2017, and on its short written submissions. The written submissions largely reiterated the arguments Luvalot made in relation to Mr Wei Dong. In summary it submitted that:(a)Ms Bi Zi is an important witness in the proceeding. She proposes to give evidence that she viewed an image of the relevant design on the internet and that she purchased the garment shown in the publication on a date prior to the priority date. She is independent of the publisher of the image and her evidence is corroborative of Mr Wei Dong’s evidence as to the fact of prior publication;(b)she is a resident of China and it is not within Luvalot’s power to compel her to give evidence in any manner. She has indicated a strong preference not to travel internationally because she has an infant who is under 12 months old. Luvalot has no choice but to rely upon her voluntary cooperation, which presently only extends to making herself available to give evidence by video link from Guangzhou, but not in person in Australia; (c)Luvalot has put on evidence that is has located an appropriate video link facility in Guangzhou; and(d)weighing the detriment Luvalot would suffer if it were denied the benefit of Ms Bi Zi’s evidence against the disadvantage, if any, inherent in cross-examining her by video link rather than in person, justice is best done between the parties by the Court permitting her testimony to be given by video link. There is an important difference between the application in relation to Mr Wei Dong’s testimony and the application in relation to Ms Bi Zi. Mr Wei Dong is willing and able to travel to Australia to give evidence and, if he is not permitted to testify by video link but an adjournment is allowed, Luvalot will not have lost the benefit of his evidence. For Ms Bi Zi, the evidence is that she is not willing to travel to Australia to give evidence even if the hearing is adjourned. If she is not permitted to testify by video link Luvalot said that it will have lost the benefit of her evidence.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Pirovic (at [11]) Flick J set out a non-exhaustive list of considerations which may assume relevance in a particular case, as follows:Ÿthe extent to which the proposed witness seeks to give evidence of facts relevant to the dispute as opposed to opinions founded upon, or largely founded upon, agreed facts or assumptions;Ÿwhether the parties are in agreement as to the utility in allowing evidence to be given by way of video link;Ÿwhether the proposed evidence is centrally relevant to the issues to be resolved or more tangential to those matters of real dispute;Ÿthe extent to which any cross-examination may be inhibited by the absence of the witness being present; Ÿthe relevance of the evidence the subject of any cross-examination – the more limited the cross-examination and the more questionable the relevance of the evidence the more limited may be the prejudice to the cross-examiner;Ÿthe reasons proffered by the witness as to the inability to come to Australia; and Ÿthe practical impediments that a refusal to allow cross-examination to proceed by way of video link upon the ability of a party to present its case. Considerations in any particular case could also include:Ÿfactors peculiar to the proposed witness, including ill-health or an inability to freely travel to and depart from Australia; andŸthe extent to which the Court itself may consider that it would be assisted by evidence being given in person.The overriding consideration must, however, forever remain what is considered by the Court to be in the best interests in the administration of justice, including the need to ensure that justice is done as between the parties. I respectfully agree.Consideration In summary Luvalot submitted that:(a)Mr Lao’s first affidavit established that there were appropriate arrangements in place to show that the requirements of s 47C of the Act had been met, such that an order under s 47A could be made for Mr Wei Dong (and/or Ms Bi Zi) to give their testimony by video link;(b)there was little force in Magi’s contention that if Mr Wei Dong (or Ms Bi Zi) committed a contempt of court or perjury, he or she would be beyond the jurisdiction of the Court. Luvalot argued that they would be lay witnesses voluntarily giving evidence on a factual matter of small ambit, and that the inability of the Court to deal with such hypothetical difficulties was not a matter to be given much weight;(c)there were unlikely to be logistical problems in hearing Mr Wei Dong’s evidence by video link as Magi had informed Luvalot that the documents upon which it would cross-examine him were limited to those attached to his affidavit. Counsel for Magi did not, however, confirm this;(d)allowing Mr Wei Dong to give evidence by video link would not deny Magi the opportunity to cross-examine him effectively, and it would suffer no significant forensic disadvantage; (e)allowing Mr Wei Dong to give evidence by video link would not reduce the ability of the Court to closely observe him so as to assess his evidence, and in any event the importance of appearance and demeanour in an assessment of the credibility of a witness is marginal: State Rail Authority of New South Wales v Earthline Constructions Pty Ltd [1999] HCA 3 at [87]-[92] per Kirby J and;(f)refusal to allow Mr Wei Dong (and/or Ms Bi Zi) to give evidence by video link would mean Luvalot was denied the opportunity to defend the case and to prosecute its cross-claim - that is, unless the renewed application for an adjournment is allowed.