MacPherson v Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL [1998] QCA 396
SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
Brisbane

C.A. No. 157 of 1998

[MacPherson v. Commissioner of Taxation]

BETWEEN:

GRAHAM JOHN MacPHERSON

(Defendant/Appellant) Appellant

AND:

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION
by LEIGHTON DAVID EVANS

(Complainant/Respondent) Respondent

C.A. No. 153 of 1998

[MacPherson v. Commissioner of Taxation]

BETWEEN:

GRAHAM JOHN MacPHERSON

(Defendant/Appellant) Appellant

AND:

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION
by KEVIN MARK THOMPSON

(Complainant/Respondent) Respondent

McMurdo P.
McPherson J.A.

Shepherdson J.

Judgment delivered 27 November 1998.

Separate reasons for judgment of each member of the Court; each concurring as to the orders made.

CATCHWORDS: STATUTES - Inconsistent State and Commonwealth - Making false statement to Taxation Officer - understatement of income by failing to disclose gross income - Dismissal for want of prosecution - Magistrate refused to award costs to appellant - Whether s.8ZN Taxation Administration Act (Cth.) covered the field - Whether s.8ZN directly inconsistent with s.158A Justices Act (Qld.) - Commonwealth provision prevailed under s.109 Constitution - Exercise of general discretion under s.8ZN - Discussion of Latoudis v. Casey - Misconduct of appellant.

Section 109 Constitution (Cth); s.44 Criminal Code; ss.8P(a), 8ZN Taxation Administration Act (1953); s.26(e) Income Tax Assessment Act 1936; ss.3, 157, 158(1), 158A Justices Act (1886) (Qld.); s.78B Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth); R. v. MacPherson [1996] 1 Qd.R. 656; Latoudis v. Casey (1990) 170 C.L.R. 534; Barameda Enterprises Pty. Ltd. v. O’Connor [1988] 1 Qd.R. 359; Redl v. Toppin (1993) (Butterworths Unrep. Jmts. B.C. 93 00621; Nguyen v. Hoekstra (1998) (Butterworths Unrep. Jmts. B.C. 98 00601); Cheatle v. The Queen (1993) 177 C.L.R 541.

Counsel:  Mr J.S. Douglas Q.C., with him Mr M.K. Conrick, for the
appellant
Mr D.J.S. Jackson Q.C., with him Mr D.N. Adsett, for the
respondent
Solicitors:  McDonald Brown for the appellant
Department of Public Prosecutions (Commonwealth) for the
respondent
Hearing Date:  18 September 1998

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - McMURDO P.

Judgment delivered 27 November 1998

  1. I have read and agree with the reasons and orders proposed by

    McPherson J.A. and would only add the following brief comments.

  2. Ordinarily, s. 68(2) of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) would cause to apply, in the absence of specific Commonwealth legislation, any relevant State legislation, such as s. 158A of the Justices Act 1886, to applications for costs on summary trials of Commonwealth offences. This position is altered by the enactment of s. 8ZN of the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) which is directly inconsistent with s. 158A of the Justices Act for the reasons stated by McPherson J.A.

  3. The finding that s. 8ZN of the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) is directly inconsistent with s. 158A of the Justices Act 1886 seems generally to accord with the approach taken by the High Court in Cheatle v. The Queen.[1] The Court there considered the different but in some ways analogous issue of whether s. 57 of the Juries Act 1927 (S.A.) was inconsistent with s. 80 of the Constitution insofar as it purported to apply to trials of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MacPherson v Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] QCA 396
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of MacPherson v Commissioner of Taxation involved the appellant, Graham MacPherson, who was charged with making false statements to a taxation officer, under section 8P(a) of the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth). The charges related to understating his income by failing to declare certain gross income received and omitting the value of benefits received. After a lengthy hearing, the prosecution was dismissed, leading to a dispute over whether MacPherson should be awarded his costs as a successful defendant. The magistrate ruled that neither party should receive their costs, and this decision was upheld in the District Court. MacPherson then sought leave to appeal to the higher court, which was granted.

The legal issues before the court were twofold: whether the magistrate had correctly exercised their discretion in deciding the appropriate order for costs, and whether the magistrate had applied the correct legal principles in making this decision. Specifically, the court needed to determine whether the magistrate had erred by considering the matters set out in section 158A of the Justices Act 1886 instead of adhering to the general principles set out in Latoudis v. Casey.

In resolving these issues, the court found that the magistrate had indeed acted wrongly by considering the wrong statutory provisions. The court held that the magistrate should have exercised their discretion in accordance with the general law as explained in Latoudis v. Casey. Consequently, the court had to exercise its discretion afresh in deciding the appropriate order for costs under section 8ZN of the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth). Given the circumstances, the court decided that MacPherson should not be awarded costs, despite his success at trial, due to the reasons outlined by McPherson J.A. The court concluded that this was one of those unusual cases where the appellant should not receive costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

PHERSON J
The trial magistrate therefore acted wrongly in considering the matters set out in s. 158A of the Justices Act 1886 instead of acting in accordance with the general principles set out in Latoudis v. Casey. It is then necessary for this Court to exercise its discretion afresh in deciding the appropriate order for costs under s. 8ZN of the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) in accordance with the general law as explained in Latoudis v. Casey. I am satisfied this is one of those unusual cases where the appellant should not be awarded costs, despite his success at trial, for the reasons given by McPherson J.A. REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - Mc A. Judgment delivered 27 November 1998 1 The appellant was charged in the magistrates court at Southport under the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) with three contraventions of s.8P(a) of that Act each consisting of making a statement to a taxation officer that was false in a material particular. In effect the offences charged were that he understated his income by failing to declare gross income received. After that complaint had been served, a second complaint, which has been described as an amended complaint, was issued in which the appellant was charged with omitting from his stated income the value of benefits received by him. 2 The hearing occupied several days. It ended in dismissal of the prosecution. A contest then followed over the question whether, as a successful defendant, the appellant should be awarded his costs. The magistrate took the view that he should not, and decided that none of the parties should receive their costs. On that issue an appeal was taken to a District Court judge. It was dismissed, but was followed by an application for leave to appeal to this Court. That application was granted, and the appeal or appeals (for there are two) have now been brought here. 3 For present purposes it is not necessary to examine in much detail the facts of which there was evidence at the hearing. Suffice to say that a Mr & Mrs McCurry, or their company Simuse Pty. Ltd., had been looking for investment opportunities in Queensland. They engaged the appellant Graham MacPherson to come to Queensland and purchase for them or their company a butcher’s shop at Lutwyche in Brisbane, which he then conducted on their or their company’s behalf. The terms of the appellant’s engagement by the McCurrys became a matter of dispute between them and him in the court proceedings that followed. At the time these complaints were issued in 1996 and 1997, that dispute had already been aired in criminal proceedings against the appellant on a previous occasion. He was originally found guilty at a trial in the District Court in 1994 on an indictment charging him with false accounting with intent to defraud contrary to s.441(b) of the Criminal Code. On appeal the conviction was quashed on the ground that Part III of the Taxation Administration Act (the Commonwealth Act) was an exhaustive statement of the law regulating the proscription and punishment of what was described as “conduct inimical to the implementation and enforcement of [Federal] tax legislation”, with the consequence that it was held that s.441(b) of the Code had no valid operation in relation to the conduct of the appellant with which he had been charged and convicted. See R. v. MacPherson [1996] 1 Qd.R. 656, 660-661.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: PHERSON J

Full text does not contain this section.