SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Civil: Application)
MACKS v TUCKER & ORS
Reasons of Judge Lunn a Master of the Supreme Court
20 May 2005
PROCEDURE
Application under R48.18(a) to strike out parts of a statement of claim as disclosing no cause of action and for summary judgment under R25.04 - applications in nature of demurrers - points not so plain and obvious that they should be dealt with under R46.18(a) or R25.04 - requirements of pleading statement of claim under R46A.03 - facts pleaded under R46A.03(b) which are not directed to a cause of action - applications dismissed.
MACKS v TUCKER & ORS
[2005] SASC 179Reasons on Applications of the First Defendant to Strike Out Parts of the Statement of Claim and of the Second Defendant for Summary Judgment.
JUDGE LUNN The plaintiff is the Trustee in Bankruptcy of the Estate of the late James McGregor who died on 11 December 1990. On 21 June 1991 probate of his estate was granted to his widow and Adrian McEwin. On 17 February 1997 the estate was declared bankrupt and the plaintiff is now the trustee of that bankrupt estate.
The first defendant is a solicitor who acted for the deceased and later for his estate. The second defendant is a company associated with the first defendant and was the trustee of his family trust.
The plaintiff instituted this action and filed his first statement of claim on 24 May 2004. On 29 July 2004 he filed an amended summons and statement of claim. That statement of claim contained 176 paragraphs and occupied 40 pages. It pleads a number of complicated transactions stretching over a long period of time. A defence has been filed by the second defendant but not by the other defendants.
On 29 November 2004 the first and second defendants took out separate notices for specific directions each seeking summary judgment or alternatively striking out various parts of the statement of claim. The hearings of these applications were held over and on 4 March 2005 the plaintiff filed an application for leave to file a further amended statement of claim which was the exhibit “RJF1” to the affidavit of Rebecca Field filed on that day. On 11 March the first defendant filed an amended notice for specific directions deleting its claim for summary judgment, but maintaining its claim to strike out parts of the statement of claim. On 22 April I heard the plaintiff’s application to amend, the first defendant’s amended application to strike out parts of the statement of claim and the second defendant’s application for summary judgment or to strike out parts of the statement of claim. It was agreed that I should treat the defendants’ applications to strike out the statement of claim as referring to the version which the plaintiff was seeking leave to file and not allow any parts of it which would be struck out pursuant to the defendants’ applications. The strike out applications were brought pursuant to R46.18 (a) and…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Macks v Tucker and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2005] SASC 179
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court included whether the second defendant owed any duty to the plaintiff, and if there was sufficient merit in the plaintiff's case to warrant a summary judgment. The second defendant argued that it did not owe any duty to the plaintiff at the time of any alleged breach, or at all. However, the court found that part of the claim against the second defendant related to it being a constructive trustee of assets received from, or through, the first defendant, which was enough to dismiss the application for summary judgment.
The court also dismissed the second defendant's application to strike out parts of the statement of claim, citing the same reasons as for the refusal of summary judgment. Consequently, the plaintiff was granted leave to file a further statement of claim in a specified form, subject to variations made by a letter dated 26 April 2005. The court indicated that it would hear from the parties regarding any additional orders that should be made.
In conclusion, the court found that the plaintiff's claim against the second defendant was sufficient to proceed, and thus denied both the summary judgment and the strike-out applications. The plaintiff was permitted to file an amended statement of claim, with the court reserving the right to make further orders as appropriate.
Background
Background to the litigation
The second defendant filed an application for summary judgment, which was ultimately denied. The second defendant contended that it did not owe any duty to the plaintiff at the time of any alleged breach or at all. Nevertheless, the court noted that part of the claim against the second defendant involves allegations that it acted as a constructive trustee of assets received from or through the first defendant, who is accused of breaching duties. This sufficient basis led to the dismissal of the summary judgment application. The court also rejected the second defendant's alternative application to strike out parts of the statement of claim, for reasons similar to those given for denying summary judgment.
The case proceeds with leave granted for the plaintiff to file a further statement of claim, as detailed in an affidavit and a letter from Rebecca Field. The court will address other necessary orders after hearing from the parties. The case's focus remains on the factual events and circumstances surrounding the transactions involving Anak and the allegations of breaches of duty by the defendants.
The matter of Macks v Tucker came before the court following an application by the Second Defendant for summary judgment. The application was dismissed by the court. The court noted that the Second Defendant's primary argument was that it did not owe any duty to the plaintiff at the time any alleged breach of duty occurred or at all. However, the court found that the proposed new version of the statement of claim clearly outlined that the Second Defendant was a constructive trustee of assets received from, or through, the First Defendant, knowing of the First Defendant's alleged breaches of duty. This was sufficient to justify the dismissal of the application for summary judgment. The court also dismissed the Second Defendant's alternative application to strike out the statement of claim, or parts of it, for the same reasons. The court granted leave to the plaintiff to file a further statement of claim, as varied by a letter dated 26 April 2005 from Rebecca Field. The court will hear the parties on what other orders should now be made.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court began its analysis by addressing the scope of the pleadings concerning the Anak transactions. The first defendant argued that the pleadings did not demonstrate that the bankrupt estate held any interest in Anak that could be adversely impacted by the numerous and intricate transactions. However, the Court found that the pleadings indeed encompassed at least some indirect interest in the Anak transactions. The Court further noted that much of what was alleged in the pleadings could be advanced under paragraph (b) of R46A.03, particularly in relation to the first plaintiff’s alleged conflict of interest and the claim for exemplary damages. This finding indicates that the Court considered the pleadings sufficient to warrant proceeding with the case on these grounds.
Turning to the application for Summary Judgment by the Second Defendant, the Court underscored that such judgment is only appropriate when it is evident that the action lacks merit, as established in Rogers v Legal Services Commission (1995) 64 SASR 572 at 588. The Court found that the proposed new version of the statement of claim did not meet the criterion for summary judgment, although it did not delve into the previous version of the statement of claim. The crux of the Second Defendant's argument was that it did not owe any duty to the plaintiff at the time of any alleged breach or at all. However, the Court highlighted that paragraphs 167A and 167B of the proposed new statement of claim clearly demonstrated that a substantial part of the claim against the Second Defendant pertained to it being a constructive trustee of assets received from or through the first defendant, knowing of the first defendant’s alleged breaches of duty. This sufficient basis justified the dismissal of the application for summary judgment.
The Court also addressed the second defendant’s alternative application to strike out the statement of claim, or parts of it. The Court dismissed this application for the same reasons that it refused the summary judgment. This decision aligns with the dismissal of similar applications by the first defendant. The Court’s rationale was grounded in the assertion that the claims against the second defendant were sufficiently substantiated, particularly regarding its role as a constructive trustee.
Furthermore, the Court granted leave to the plaintiff to file a further statement of claim in the form exhibited to the affidavit of Rebecca Field, as varied by her letter dated 26 April 2005. This decision indicates the Court’s willingness to allow the plaintiff to amend the statement of claim to better align with the legal standards and facts of the case. The Court concluded by scheduling a hearing to discuss any additional orders that should be made, reflecting its intent to manage the proceedings effectively and fairly.
In summary, the Court's decisions were rooted in its evaluation of the sufficiency of the pleadings and the claims presented against the defendants. The Court found the pleadings adequate to proceed with the case, dismissed the application for summary judgment, and refused the motion to strike out parts of the statement of claim. The binding legal principle, or ratio decidendi, established by the decision is that a party can proceed with a claim if the pleadings sufficiently demonstrate an indirect interest adversely affected by the transactions in question and if the claims are not devoid of merit. Additionally, the Court’s refusal of the summary judgment and the strike-out application underscores the importance of substantiated claims, particularly those involving constructive trusteeship and duty of care.